Final Results
Montanaro UK Smaller Companies Investment Trust PLC
Annual Report and Accounts 2008
The Montanaro UK Smaller Companies Investment Trust PLC
("MUSCIT") was launched in March 1995 and is listed on the London Stock
Exchange.
Investment Objective
MUSCIT's investment objective is capital appreciation
(rather than income) achieved by investing in small quoted companies listed on
the London Stock Exchange or traded on the Alternative Investment Market
("AIM") and to achieve relative outperformance of its benchmark, the FTSE
SmallCap (excluding investment companies) Index. No unquoted investments are
permitted.
Investment Policy
The Company looks to achieve its objective and to diversify
risk by investing in a portfolio of UK Smaller Companies. At the time of
initial investment, a potential investee company must be profitable and
smaller than the largest constituent of the HGSC Index, which represents the
smallest 10% of the UK Stock Market by value. At the start of 2008, this was
any company below £1.1 billion in size. The Manager looks to focus on the
smaller end of this Index.
In order to manage risk the Manager will limit any one
holding to a maximum of 5% of the Company's investments. The weightings for
every stock are closely monitored to ensure they reflect the underlying
liquidity of the particular company. The Company's AIM exposure is also
closely monitored by the Board and is limited to 30% of total investments with
Board approval required for exposure to be above 25%.
The Manager is focused on identifying high quality niche
companies operating in growth markets. This typically leads the Manager to
invest in companies that enjoy high barriers to entry, a sustainable
competitive advantage and strong management teams. The portfolio is therefore
constructed on a "bottom up" basis and there are no sectoral constraints
placed on the Manager. However, "top down" relative risk is regularly assessed
by reference to the benchmark's position.
The Board, in consultation with the Manager, is responsible
for determining the gearing strategy for the Company. Gearing is used to
enhance returns when the timing is considered appropriate. The Company
currently has a credit facility of £25 million through ING Bank. The Board has
agreed to limit borrowings to 25% of shareholders' funds.
The Board believes in the opportunities that UK Smaller
Companies present for long-term superior total returns. As a consequence of
this any material changes to the Company's existing investment objective and
policy will be subject to shareholder approval.
Highlights 2008
Results
Net Asset Value ("NAV") -16.9% (£102 million)
Gross assets -17.5% (£118 million)*
FTSE SmallCap (excluding investment companies) Index -30.9%
Share price -21.2%
As at 31 As at 31
March March
2008 2007
Revenue return on ordinary activities (£000) 1,358 1,041
Movement in capital reserve (£000) (23,586) 21,457
Revenue return per ordinary share 3.82p 2.92p
Dividend per ordinary share 3.65p 2.65p
Total return per ordinary share (62.48)p 63.18p
As at As at
31 March 31 March
2008 2007
Ordinary share price 245.00p 311.00p
NAV per ordinary share 304.52p 366.31p
*Over the year the Company bought stock into Treasury and
for cancellation, which accounted for a reduction of £4.89m in gross assets.
Chairman's Statement
"With a well defined and proven investment process that has delivered consistent
outperformance across both strong and weak markets, MUSCIT gives scope for
confidence going forward."
Highlights 2008
- In the year to 31 March 2008, the NAV of MUSCIT decreased
by 16.9% to 304.5p in comparison with a 30.9% loss by the SmallCap.
- Since launch, the NAV of MUSCIT has increased by 205% in
comparison with a gain of 60% by the Small Cap outperforming by 145%,
- The Board is responsible for the share buy back programme.
During the year 1,828,000 shares were bought into Treasury and 160,000 shares
were bought for cancellation.
Background
I am pleased to present the thirteenth annual report of the
Montanaro UK Smaller Companies Investment Trust (MUSCIT), which was launched
in March 1995. In 1996, the initial investment of £25 million was increased in
size through a £30 million "C" share issue. Net assets now stand at £102
million.
An investment trust is an attractive vehicle for
shareholders to invest in quoted UK Smaller Companies, which are less well
researched and more illiquid than larger, blue chip companies.
Performance
In the year to 31 March 2008, the NAV of MUSCIT decreased by
16.9% to 304.5p in comparison with a 30.9% fall by the FTSE SmallCap
(excluding investment companies) Index ("SmallCap").
Since launch, the NAV of MUSCIT has increased by 205% in
comparison with a gain of 60% by the SmallCap, outperforming by 145%.
Discount
The discount of MUSCIT's share price to NAV stood at 19.5%
on 31 March 2008 in comparison with a weighted sector average of 17.2%
(source: Wins Investment Trusts).
Share Buy Backs
The Board is responsible for the share buy back programme.
During the year 1,828,000 shares were bought back for
Treasury and 160,000 shares were bought back for cancellation at a cost of
£4,501,000 and £384,000 respectively.
Holding Shares in Treasury
As an alternative to cancellation, new regulations came into
force on 1 December 2003 that allow companies, including investment trusts, to
buy back shares and hold them in Treasury for re-issue at a later date. This
has the benefit of improving liquidity as well as retaining the opportunity to
enhance the net asset value.
The Board has actively and carefully considered the use of
Treasury Shares and has been among the sector's pioneers. Our policy is to
ensure that shareholders receive a tangible benefit above and beyond an
enhanced ability to manage the liquidity of the shares of MUSCIT. Shares held
in Treasury will only be re-issued at a lower discount than when they were
originally purchased and to produce a positive absolute return. Shares not
re-issued will be cancelled within one year from purchase.
This policy is in accordance with the recommendations of the
Association of Investment Companies in their paper "Treasury Shares - A Guide
to The Commercial and Technical Issues" dated 28 August 2003. Indeed, it goes
further than their recommendations in seeking both relative and absolute
returns for investors.
On 10 December 2007 the Company bought 1,828,000 ordinary
10p shares into Treasury, representing 5.44% of the issued capital, at a price
of £2.445 per share. The total cost of the purchase, including expenses, was
£4,501,000.
As at 31 March 2008, 1,828,000 shares were held in Treasury.
During the year the Company repurchased 160,000 ordinary 10p
shares for cancellation, representing 0.48% of the issued capital. The
breakdown of these purchases is detailed in Note 15. The total cost of the
purchases, including expenses was £384,000.
As at 31 March 2008 the Company had authority to repurchase
a further 3,349,857 ordinary 10p shares.
The above repurchases were undertaken in accordance with the
policies and risk management strategies outlined in the Business Review.
Gearing
The Board actively reviews the level of gearing considered
appropriate for the Company in discussion with the Manager. One of the
benefits of investment trusts is the ability to hold prudent levels of gearing
which can enhance investment returns.
During the course of the year a new increased facility was
arranged with ING Bank, which now provides a revolving credit facility of up
to £25 million. At 31 March 2008, £15 million was drawn down at a weighted
average interest rate of 6.1203%.
During the year, net gearing ranged from 3.8% to 11.3%. At
31 March 2008, net gearing was 3.8%
Dividend
MUSCIT's primary focus is on capital growth rather than
income. The Board's policy is to pay out by way of dividend a minimum of 90%
of net earnings. Accordingly, the Board proposes a final dividend of 3.65p per
ordinary share payable on 18 August 2008 to shareholders on the register at
the close of business on 13 June 2008.
Value Added Tax (VAT)
In 2004 the Association of Investment Companies (AIC) and
J.P.Morgan Claverhouse (Claverhouse) brought a case against HM Revenue &
Customs to challenge the VAT charge on management fees paid by investment
companies. The case was referred to the European Court of Justice and in a
ruling in June 2007 it upheld the AIC/Claverhouse claim. The immediate effect
is that invoices from the investment manager will no longer include VAT.
The MUSCIT Board is awaiting further clarification from HM
Revenue & Customs on the timetable and procedure for reclaiming VAT paid on
investment management fees since 1 January 2001. There may also be scope for
recovering certain VAT paid in relation to earlier periods. At the current
time the Board is not recognising the potential back claim in its results nor
its published NAV.
Corporate Governance
The Directors have thoroughly reviewed the recommendations
of the 2006 Combined Code on Corporate Governance (the "Code") and have
maintained procedures where appropriate, such as an annual evaluation of the
Board's performance. Consequently, MUSCIT has complied with the Code
throughout the year except where compliance would be inappropriate given the
size and nature of MUSCIT. Full disclosure of MUSCIT's compliance with the
Code is included in the Directors' Report.
Chairman's Comment
The past financial year will live long in the memory. A US
sub-prime problem rapidly escalated into a full-scale credit crisis with
international ramifications. Over the summer of 2007, the US housing market
deteriorated dramatically, placing considerable strain on the global banking
sector. The full consequences are as yet unknown but we have seen over $100
billion in worldwide losses related to the collapse of sub-prime mortgages,
the fire-sale of Bear Stearns and emergency rights issues at UBS and Lehman
Brothers.
Closer to home, inter-bank lending dried up as confidence
evaporated in the banking system. Ultimately this contributed to the first run
on a UK commercial bank since 1866 and the eventual nationalisation of
Northern Rock. In the wake of such fundamental banking problems the appetite
for risk has been reappraised. Essentially the era of cheap, easily accessible
credit is over. This will have serious implications for the outlook for UK
housing and heightens the likelihood that the problems that have beset the
financial sector will spill over into the real economy.
Given these tumultuous events, it can be of no surprise that
the bull market in equities came to a grinding halt during the summer of 2007.
Markets feed off confidence, be it consumer or macro-economic. Looking back
over the past 12 months, the prevailing economic climate has been one of
heightened uncertainty. Investors have become increasingly risk averse.
This change in investor sentiment has been particularly
visible at the smaller end of the equity markets. Over the course of the year
the FTSE SmallCap fell 30.9% in contrast to a fall of 10.8% in the FTSE
All-Share. When the problems that have beset the global economy in the last
year are put into a historic context, the extreme variance in annual returns
that were seen in 2007/08 become more understandable.
Research based on the FTSE All-Share and the Hoare Govett
Smaller Companies Index (HGSC), which represents the bottom 10% of the market
by value, shows that Smaller Companies have underperformed their larger peers
by more than 4% just 10 times in the last 52 years. The worst year was 1975
when they underperformed by 35%. This, of course, was the year of the oil
crisis. Interestingly, if you look at the other years of significant
underperformance, the theme of crisis is prevalent. With the credit crisis
taking such a firm hold on the British economy in the second half of the year,
it should be of little surprise that Smaller Companies have disappointed on
such a significant relative basis.
In such a challenging year there must be even greater
emphasis placed on stock picking skills. It is pleasing to see that MUSCIT's
stock selection has driven a year of strong relative outperformance. The
Manager's focus on profitable businesses, those that are ultimately in control of
their own destiny thanks to pricing power and a core competitive advantage, has
helped deliver impressive relative performance over the past year.
While it is impossible to forecast the scale and severity of
the current downturn, history illustrates that Smaller Companies do outperform
over the longer term. Indeed, the HGSC has outperformed the FTSE All-Share in
35 years out of the last 52 years. For this reason Smaller Companies should
not be neglected. Indeed, UK Smaller Companies do especially well in periods
of recovery.
One of the keys to successful equity investing is identifying a
company able to make a meaningful difference to investor returns. With a well
defined and proven investment process that has delivered consistent
outperformance across both strong and weak markets, MUSCIT gives scope for
confidence going forward.
DAVID GAMBLE
Chairman
30 May 2008
Manager's Report
We have taken the opportunity to add to existing positions
whose business models are familiar to us. Our experience shows that these
long-term holdings, where our knowledge and understanding is strongest, have
tended to deliver the best returns for us.
Highlights 2008
Heightened concentration within the portfolio has been a
strategic decision in a more challenging market.
The portfolio continued to see M&A with seven constituents
taken over, including MTL Instruments and Coda.
Portfolio Management
At 31 March 2008, the portfolio consisted of 66 companies,
compared with 71 companies a year earlier. The top ten holdings represent
26.0% of the total compared with 23.6% one year ago.
This heightened concentration within the portfolio has been
a strategic decision. In a more challenging market where profit warnings are
increasingly common, we believe that it is a case of "better the devil you
know". We have taken the opportunity to add to existing positions whose
business models are familiar to us and with management teams we believe are
capable of managing market expectations in more challenging periods, rather
than rush to add new holdings.
Our experience shows that these long-term holdings, where
our knowledge and understanding is strongest, have tended to deliver the best
returns for us. The past financial year has proved no exception and two of the
strongest performers have been held for many years.
Chloride, which specialises in power protection systems, has
benefited from global investment in infrastructure that has helped it
deliver a succession of earnings upgrades. We first invested in 1997.
Similarly Dechra Pharmaceuticals, a provider of veterinary products and
pharmaceuticals, delivered good growth as it expanded into Europe. We have
owned it since the company was listed in September 2000. We consider both to
be core holdings that can deliver further value to shareholders over coming
years.
On reflection, the past year has been just as much about
what we have not owned as what we have. Our underweight positions in General
Financials and Real Estate, two of the worst performing sectors, have been
rewarded. Equally, the focus we place on cash generation and healthy balance
sheets has also proved beneficial. In an environment where credit is becoming
both increasingly scarce and expensive, the market has taken a negative view
of highly geared companies that might have to renegotiate banking facilities.
In a year when absolute returns have been hard to achieve,
takeovers have proved a valuable source of performance. The portfolio has
historically seen more than its fair share of mergers and acquisitions and
this trend continued in 2007/08. The traits that attract us to our investments
make them enticing to predators. During the year we saw seven holdings taken
over. The most significant were the long-term holdings in MTL Instruments
(manufacturer of industrial safety devices), Coda (accounting software),
Foseco (supplier of consumable products for foundries) and Sondex (oil
services). All went out at healthy premiums. Unsurprisingly, given the recent
travails of the private equity sector, we saw a greater number of stocks fall
to trade buyers than in recent years.
As old holdings get taken over the team at Montanaro is
continually looking to identify the next generation of investments. This has
proved a particularly interesting exercise in volatile markets that present
pricing anomalies. At a time when there are question marks over the resilience
of the British economy, we have sought to identify companies with a global
focus operating in robust growth markets.
While retail may not seem immediately obvious, we believe
the recent acquisition of Early Learning Centre can help revitalise the
Mothercare brand. The company has a strong international franchise business
which accounts for almost half the company's profits and is delivering
double-digit like for like growth. In a similar vein Senior is also benefiting
from strong international growth, this time in the global aerospace industry.
It manufactures valuable parts for Boeing and Airbus, companies with order
books at record levels.
Annual Returns
The period under review has been one of the toughest for the
Smaller Companies sector in recent years. The Smaller Company market has been
particularly hard hit as investors moved to the perceived security and
liquidity of larger stocks. The past 12 months to 31 March 2008 have been the
worst in relative terms for the FTSE SmallCap Index against the FTSE All-Share
Index since the Company's inception.
We should not forget that Smaller Companies have enjoyed a
spectacular run in recent times. From its nadir in March 2003 the FTSE
SmallCap Index rose 150% through to early June 2007. This represents
outperformance of 33% against the FTSE All-Share. However, there is a degree
of inevitability that the Index has since responded in the way that it has.
The domestic focus of Smaller Companies and their exposure to the more
cyclical sectors such as Real Estate and General Financials leaves them more
vulnerable in times of economic uncertainty.
There is little doubt that during this period these sectors
have entered bear markets. The Real Estate sector, for example, has
experienced a perfect storm. It underperformed the wider market as the period
of yield compression came to an end and the investment market stalled. Many of
these companies run highly leveraged balance sheets, leaving a deteriorating
gearing position as asset values decline.
While it is disappointing to report that the NAV fell over
the last year, we are pleased to have outperformed the benchmark by 14%. In
addition, the prevailing investment style has continued to deliver impressive
relative performance. We are convinced that high quality growth companies will
deliver long-term outperformance.
Market Outlook
While uncertainty remains over the full scale and location
of the sub-prime losses across the global financial system, it is hard to see
a near-term improvement in investor sentiment and stock market performance.
Last year's nervousness led to redemptions from UK SmallCap retail unit trusts
and OEICs totalling £366 million according to the Investment Management
Association. This only served to exacerbate last year's poor performance. In
tight, illiquid markets the presence of forced sellers often led to dramatic
and indiscriminate markdowns.
Clearly there are no quick fix solutions and we need a
period of consolidation to help restore confidence. The financial system may
require greater assistance from the UK regulatory authorities as banks need to
recapitalise. After all, banks with weak balance sheets will struggle to
finance the lending required to drive economic growth. Any reduction in
lending activity will only make the current situation worse.
Our experience tells us that just as valuations and market
sentiment get too high in periods of economic strength they are likely to fall
too far on the downside in the present environment. We are alert to
opportunities and will be prepared to utilise our borrowing facility
accordingly. However, while attractively valued stocks are now to be found in
abundance we firmly subscribe to the theory that "you get what you pay for."
We will continue to be happy to pay a little more for businesses where the
quality of the operation gives greater comfort in the earnings outlook.
This philosophy goes a long way to explaining why the
Company's portfolio trades at a small premium to its benchmark. At present the
forward P/E on the portfolio is 12x in contrast to the market on 10x. These
valuations are towards the low end of historic trading ranges and represent a
ratings compression of almost 40% over the last year. For the first time in
four years, Small and Large companies are trading at broadly the same level.
With a more realistic level of earnings growth forecasts in the market and
valuations at four year lows, we believe it is unlikely that Smaller Companies
will see the degree of underperformance witnessed in 2007.
Ultimately this will be another year for astute stock
picking. With economic growth set to slow over the course of the next 12
months and with further uncertainty surrounding the British housing market, we
will be proceeding with care. However, there remain strong pockets of global
growth and we aim to capitalise on them where we can. Additionally, some
sectors are experiencing beneficial tailwinds from Sterling's weakness against
the Euro which will support earnings. We also believe that if equity markets
fail to value companies fairly, predators in the form of trade buyers will be
prepared to do it for them.
I would like to record my thanks to the Chairman and the
Board of Directors for their help and support during the year and look forward
to the future with confidence. I am also very grateful for the extremely
valuable input I have received from our shareholders over the past 12 months.
Dan Harlow
Montanaro Investment Managers Limited
30 May 2008
Description of Thirty Largest Holdings
as at 31 March 2008
Fisher (James) & Sons PLC
Provider of specialist marine support services and operator
of tankships around UK coastal waters.
Dignity PLC
The UK's largest provider of funeral related services.
Genus PLC
A world leader in the application of genetics to animal
breeding.
Dechra Pharmaceuticals PLC
Manufacturer and distributor of veterinary products and
pharmaceuticals.
BPP Holdings PLC
The leading provider of training services to the legal,
accountancy and financial markets.
Scott Wilson Group PLC
An international consultancy offering integrated
professional services in the transportation, property, environmental and
natural resources sectors.
Chloride Group PLC
International electronics group, manufacturing products to
protect sensitive electrical equipment against power loss and power surges.
Ricardo PLC
The leading UK independent automotive consultancy.
Fenner PLC
A world leader in the field of reinforced polymer
engineering whose products are primarily sold into the mining, hydraulics and
energy industries.
Latchways PLC
World leader in the design, manufacture and sale of safety
systems for individuals working at height.
Wilmington Group PLC
Leading provider of information and training to business and
professional markets, with particular strength in the legal and regulatory
sectors.
WSP Group PLC
International consulting engineers with activities in the
UK, Scandinavia and United States.
Detica Group PLC
A business and technology consultancy strongly focused on
the National Security, Financial Services and Telecoms sectors.
Phoenix IT Group PLC
A provider of a range of IT support services, including
Business Continuity, hosting, service desks, and network and systems
management.
M.P. Evans Group PLC
A producer of Indonesian palm oil and Australian beef
cattle.
Hargreaves Services PLC
A leading provider of transport and support services to the
energy and waste sectors.
Hill & Smith Holdings PLC
One of the largest suppliers of galvanised steel to the UK
infrastructure, building and construction industries.
White Young Green PLC
Multi-disciplinary consultant providing engineering,
environmental, planning and management services to clients in the public and
private sector.
NCC Group PLC
A provider of Escrow Solutions, Assurance Testing and
Consultancy.
Domino Printing Sciences PLC
An international group providing total coding and printing
solutions to a wide portfolio of market sectors.
eaga PLC
The UK's leading provider of residential energy efficiency
solutions.
VP Group PLC
A specialist in the provision of rental equipment and
associated services to a range of market sectors.
RPS Group PLC
An international consultancy providing advice on the
development of natural resources, land and property, the management of the
environment, and health and safety.
Care UK PLC
An independent provider of health and social care service
solutions.
Croda International PLC
A manufacturer of speciality chemicals for the consumer care
and industrial markets.
The Stanley Gibbons Group PLC
The market leader in rare stamp and autograph investment.
Victrex PLC
The world's largest manufacturer of PEEK, a high performance
thermoplastic.
Hornby PLC
An international models and collectibles group.
Brammer PLC
A pan-European technical distributor of power transmission
components.
Domino's Pizza UK & IRL PLC
The UK and Ireland's leading pizza delivery company.
Fifty Largest Holdings
as at 31 March 2008
Market
Value % of Cap
Holding Sector £000 portfolio £m
Fisher (James) & Sons PLC Industrial Transportation 3,325 3.1 304
Dignity PLC General Retailers 3,074 2.9 487
Genus PLC Pharmeceuticals & Biotechnology 3,030 2.9 433
Dechra Pharmaceuticals PLC Pharmeceuticals & Biotechnology 2,900 2.7 237
BPP Holdings PLC Support Services 2,889 2.7 263
Scott Wilson Group PLC Support Services 2,613 2.5 182
Chloride Group PLC Electronic and Electrical Equipment 2,598 2.5 492
Ricardo PLC Support Services 2,468 2.3 179
Fenner PLC Industrial Engineering 2,350 2.2 411
Latchways PLC Support Services 2,321 2.2 93
Ten Largest Holdings 27,568 26.0
Wilmington Group PLC Media 2,265 2.1 146
WSP Group PLC Support Services 2,239 2.1 382
Detica Group PLC Software & Computer Services 2,121 2.0 289
Phoenix IT Group PLC Software & Computer Services 2,081 2.0 217
M.P. Evans Group PLC Food Producers 1,991 1.9 230
Hargreaves Services PLC Support Services 1,983 1.9 132
Hill & Smith Holdings PLC Industrial Engineering 1,982 1.8 251
White Young Green PLC Support Services 1,879 1.8 144
NCC Group PLC Software & Computer Services 1,875 1.7 113
Domino Printing Sciences PLC Electronic & Electrical Equipment 1,808 1.7 338
eaga PLC Support Services 1,800 1.7 465
VP Group PLC Support Services 1,765 1.7 142
RPS Group PLC Support Services 1,725 1.6 682
Care UK PLC Health Care Equipment & Services 1,719 1.6 227
Croda International PLC Chemicals 1,691 1.6 903
The Stanley Gibbons Group PLC General Retailers 1,662 1.6 47
Victrex PLC Chemicals 1,633 1.5 620
Hornby PLC Leisure Goods 1,604 1.5 72
Brammer PLC Support Services 1,602 1.5 149
Domino's Pizza UK & IRL PLC Travel & Leisure 1,572 1.5 325
Thirty Largest Holdings 64,565 60.8
Consort Medical PLC Health Care Equipment & Services 1,571 1.5 159
Holidaybreak PLC Travel & Leisure 1,564 1.5 268
BSS Group PLC Support Services 1,542 1.4 479
Superglass Holdings PLC Construction & Materials 1,479 1.4 80
Chemring Group PLC Aerospace & Defence 1,474 1.4 799
Foseco PLC Industrial Engineering 1,473 1.4 490
Primary Health Properties PLC Real Estate 1,471 1.4 105
Ultra Electronics Holdings PLC Aerospace & Defence 1,461 1.4 879
Brewin Dolphin PLC General Financials 1,451 1.4 290
Senior PLC Industrial Engineering 1,450 1.4 395
UTV Media PLC Media 1,398 1.3 136
Albemarle and Bond Holdings PLC General Financials 1,394 1.3 105
Lok'n Store Limited Support Services 1,380 1.3 47
Gooch & Housego PLC Industrial Engineering 1,331 1.2 54
Mothercare PLC General Retailers 1,309 1.2 357
Carclo PLC Chemicals 1,286 1.2 46
Synergy Energy Healthcare PLC Health Care Equipment & Services 1,269 1.2 345
IBS Open Systems PLC Software & Computer Services 1,244 1.2 44
London Capital Group Holdings PLC General Financials 1,222 1.2 129
Barr (AG) PLC Beverages 1,215 1.1 225
Fifty Largest Holdings 92,549 87.2
Analysis of Investment Portfolio by Industrial or Commercial
Sector
as at 31 March 2008
% of % of
Sector portfolio SmallCap
Oil and Gas Producers 2.1 2.1
Oil Equipment Services and Distribution 0.0 0.0
Oil and Gas Total 2.1 2.1
Chemicals 4.3 1.3
Mining 0.0 0.5
Basic Materials Total 4.3 1.8
Aerospace and Defence 2.8 1.1
Construction and Materials 2.3 3.8
Electronic and Electrical Equipment 6.4 2.7
General Industrials 0.0 0.8
Industrial Engineering 9.0 3.5
Industrial Transportation 3.1 4.3
Support Services 25.9 10.5
Industrials Total 49.5 26.7
Automobiles and Parts 0.0 0.0
Beverages 1.1 0.7
Food Producers 1.9 4.2
Household Goods 0.0 0.6
Leisure Goods 1.5 1.0
Personal Goods 0.0 0.0
Consumer Goods Total 4.5 6.5
Health-care Equipment and Services 4.3 3.1
Pharmaceuticals and Biotechnology 5.6 5.6
Health-care Total 9.9 8.7
Food and Drug Retailers 0.0 0.3
General Retailers 5.7 7.9
Media 3.4 5.0
Travel and Leisure 3.0 5.2
Consumer Services Total 12.1 18.4
Fixed Line Telecommunications 0.0 2.0
Telecommunications Total 0.0 2.0
General Financials 4.8 8.2
Life Insurance 0.0 1.2
Non-life Insurance 0.0 2.5
Real Estate 5.0 12.0
Financials Total 9.8 23.9
Software and Computer Services 7.8 7.8
Technology, Hardware and Equipment 0.0 2.1
Technology Total 7.8 9.9
The investment portfolio comprises 66 listed UK equity
holdings including 14 holdings totalling £18,259,000 (representing 17.2% of
the portfolio) traded on the Alternative Investment Market ("AIM").
Board of Directors
MUSCIT has a highly experienced Board of Directors with
extensive knowledge of investment management and investment trusts
David Gamble - Chairman (Aged 64)
David Gamble was appointed a Director on 19 November 2004
and became Chairman of MUSCIT on 28 January 2005. David is also chairman of
Hermes Property Unit Trust, a director of IBM Pension Trustees Limited, Barrie
& Hibbert PLC, Vencap International PLC, New Star Asset Management Limited,
Polar Capital Technology Trust PLC and Dunedin Enterprise Investment Trust
PLC. He retired as chief executive of British Airways Pension Investment
Management in 2004.
Antony Hardy (Aged 68)
Antony Hardy was appointed a Director on 17 July 2000. He is
a director of Perpetual Income and Growth Investment Trust plc, Sableknight
Limited and Lockfold Communications Limited and a director of several pension
fund trustee bodies. He is also an independent investment adviser to several
local authority pension schemes and endowed charities, YMCA England and a
number of private companies. He was previously investment manager for Church
Commissioners for England.
Christopher Jones (Aged 67)
Christopher Jones has over thirty years' investment
experience and was appointed a Director on 9 July 1999. From 1985 until 2004
he was head of investments at Merchant Investors Assurance Company Limited. He
is also a director of Schroder UK Mid and Smaller Cap Fund plc, Atlantis Japan
Growth Fund Limited, Ecofin Water & Power Opportunities PLC, Montanaro
European Smaller Companies PLC, Jupiter Second Enhanced Income Trust plc,
Cayenne Trust plc and Japan Accelerated Performance Fund PLC.
Michael Moule (Aged 62)
Michael Moule formerly specialised in managing investment
trusts for Henderson and Touche Remnant. Appointed a Director on 28 January
2005, he has extensive experience of UK and overseas equity markets having
worked with investment trusts since 1967. He is also a director of Foreign &
Colonial Eurotrust PLC, Lowland Investment Company plc and Polar Capital
Technology Trust PLC.
Laurence Petar (Aged 58)
Laurence Petar has been involved in the investment trust
sector for the past 30 years and was appointed a Director on 23 May 2003. He
was a partner at the stockbroking firm of Gilbert Elliott & Co until 1986. He
then spent 10 years as an executive director in charge of the investment trust
department at UBS Limited and most recently he was a consultant to HSBC
Securities. He is currently a director of Jupiter Asset Management Limited.
Advisers
Manager
Montanaro Investment Managers Limited
53 Threadneedle Street
London EC2R 8AR
Tel: 020 7448 8600
Fax: 020 7448 8601
www.montanaro.co.uk
info@montanaro.co.uk
Company Secretary, Administrator and Registered Office
CAPITA Sinclair Henderson Limited
Beaufort House
51 New North Road
Exeter EX4 4EP
Tel: 01392 412 122
Fax: 01392 253 282
Registrars
Capita Registrars
Shareholder Services Department
The Registry
34 Beckenham Road
Beckenham
Kent BR3 4TU
Tel: 0871 664 0300
(calls will cost 10p per minute plus network charges)
Fax: 020 639 2342
ssd@capitaregistrars.com
www.capitaregistrars.com
Bankers
HSBC International
PO Box 181
27-32 Poultry
London EC2P 2BX
ING Bank N.V.
London Branch
60 London Wall
London EC2M 5TQ
Auditor
KPMG Audit Plc
100 Temple Street
Bristol BS1 6AG
Solicitors
Norton Rose LLP
3 More London Riverside
London SE1 2AQ
Corporate Broker
Winterflood Securities Limited
The Atrium Building
Cannon Bridge
25 Dowgate Hill
London EC4R 2GA
Montanaro UK Smaller Companies Investment Trust PLC
Registered in England and Wales No. 3004101
An investment company as defined under Section 833 of the
Companies Act 2006.
Directors' Report
The Directors present their Annual Report and financial
statements for the year ended 31 March 2008.
Business Review
Introduction
Preparation of a Business Review is a recent development in
financial reporting and a mandatory requirement arising from Section 234ZZB of
the Companies Act 1985. A Business Review must contain a review of a company's
business, the principal risks and uncertainties it faces and an analysis of
its performance during the financial year and position at the year-end. To aid
understanding of these areas, your Board is required to include analysis using
appropriate Key Performance Indicators.
DEVELOPMENT, PERFORMANCE AND POSITION OF MUSCIT
Review of the Business of MUSCIT
A description of MUSCIT's activities during the year is
given in the Chairman's Statement and in the portfolio management section
of the Manager's Report.
MUSCIT is a closed-end investment trust listed on the London
Stock Exchange. Its affairs are managed so that it receives approval from HM
Revenue & Customs as an investment trust under s842 of the Income &
Corporation Taxes Act 1988 ("s842"). One of the criteria for compliance is
that at least 85% of MUSCIT's eligible investment income arising in an
accounting period is distributed to shareholders.
The Board considers that MUSCIT will continue to qualify as
an investment trust, which confers certain benefits such as exemption from the
payment of capital gains taxes arising on the sale of investments. MUSCIT has
most recently received approval under s842 for the year ended 31 March 2007
and an application will be made to HM Revenue & Customs for MUSCIT's status as
an investment trust in financial year 2007/08 to be confirmed. Further details
on the operation of investment trusts can be obtained from the Association of
Investment Companies on their website at www.theaic.co.uk.
MUSCIT is also an investment company as defined in s833 of
the Companies Act 2006. The current portfolio of MUSCIT is such that its
shares are eligible for inclusion in an ISA and PEPs up to the maximum annual
subscription limit and the Directors expect this eligibility to be maintained.
MUSCIT's investment objective is capital appreciation
(rather than income) achieved by investing in quoted companies listed on the
London Stock Exchange or traded on the Alternative Investment Market ("AIM").
No unquoted investments are permitted. The benchmark is the FTSE SmallCap
(excluding investment companies) Index.
At the time of initial investment, a potential investee
company must be profitable and smaller than the largest constituent of the
HGSC Index which represents the smallest 10% of the UK Stock Market by size.
At the start of 2008, this was any company below £1.1 billion in size.
The Manager of MUSCIT is Montanaro Investment Managers
Limited ("Montanaro"), a highly experienced specialist in UK and European
quoted small companies established in 1991. Montanaro has one of the largest
teams in the UK researching and investing exclusively in quoted small
companies.
They closely monitor all investments within the portfolio
and identify potential new investments. Although sector weightings of the
benchmark are monitored, the portfolio is a result of bottom-up stock picking
and may differ markedly from the index. Tracking error may be relatively high
reflecting a focus on research driven stock selection. Montanaro currently
manage over £700 million, mainly on behalf of leading financial institutions.
There are currently 35,449,458 ordinary 10p shares in issue
(2007: 35,609,458) of which 1,828,000 are held in Treasury (2007: nil).
Ordinary shareholders have unrestricted voting rights at all general meetings
of the Company. Details of the shares bought back during the year are
contained in the Chairman's Statement and Note 15.
Description of Principal Risks Associated with MUSCIT
The Board carefully considers the principal risks for MUSCIT
and seeks to mitigate these risks through continual and regular review, policy
setting, compliance with and enforcement of contractual obligations and active
communication with the Manager, the Administrator and shareholders.
The Board applies the principles detailed in the
recommendations of the AIC Code as described elsewhere in the Directors'
Report. Details of MUSCIT's internal controls may be found under Corporate
Governance below.
Mitigation of the principal risks is sought and achieved in
many ways as shown below:
Investment Manager: Montanaro has been the Manager of MUSCIT
since its launch in 1995. The success of MUSCIT and its strong performance is
largely attributable to Montanaro. Should the current Manager not be in a
position to continue its management of the Company, performance may be
impacted.
The Board holds board meetings which are attended by the
Manager. Montanaro have one of the largest specialist teams in the UK.
Succession planning within Montanaro and recruitment of personnel are closely
monitored.
Investment & Strategy: MUSCIT may underperform its benchmark
as a result of poor stock selection or sector allocation or as a result of
being geared in a falling market or ungeared in a rising market.
The Manager meets regularly with the Board to discuss
portfolio performance and strategy, and provides the Board and shareholders
with monthly reports. The portfolio is well diversified thereby reducing stock
specific risk. The Board receives and reviews monthly a report of all
transactions and, through the forum of its Management Engagement Committee,
formally reviews the performance of the Manager annually.
Gearing: one of the benefits of closed ended investment
trusts is the ability to use borrowings which can enhance returns in a rising
stock market. However, gearing exacerbates movements in the net asset value
both positively and negatively and will exaggerate declines in net asset value
when prices of quoted UK small companies are falling.
The Board monitors and discusses with the Manager the
appropriate level of gearing of MUSCIT at each Board meeting.
Portfolio Liquidity: as with all small company investment
trusts, there are times when the liquidity of the underlying portfolio is
poor, such as when small company trusts are out of favour or during periods of
adverse economic conditions. The Manager focuses on Smaller Companies where
the opportunities may be more attractive but this can increase overall
underlying illiquidity. This may result in the Manager being unable to buy or
sell individual holdings within the portfolio. In addition, this may impact
the discount of MUSCIT to the net asset value of the portfolio.
One of the benefits of a closed end trust is that the
Manager is not forced to buy or sell individual holdings at inopportune times.
The Manager constantly reviews the underlying liquidity of the portfolio,
which is well-diversified. Particular attention is paid to the AIM holdings,
with the Manager providing the Board with liquidity reports at every meeting.
Montanaro deal with a wide range of brokers to enhance their ability to
execute and minimise liquidity risk.
Liquidity of MUSCIT Shares: as with many small company
investment trusts, there are times when the liquidity of the shares of MUSCIT
is low. In the case of MUSCIT, many of the shareholders are large financial
institutions with a long-term investment horizon. Unlike other trusts where
private individuals form a larger part of the share register, this may result
in less shares being traded in MUSCIT on a daily basis and make it difficult
at times for investors to buy or sell shares of MUSCIT.
The Manager is encouraged by the Board to market the strong
investment story of MUSCIT to private client wealth managers and other
potential new investors. The goal is to widen the shareholder base to enhance
liquidity. In addition, the ability to buy back shares to be held in Treasury
for subsequent re-issue enhances the liquidity of MUSCIT shares.
Discount Volatility: as with all small company investment
trusts, discounts can fluctuate significantly both in absolute terms and
relative to their peer group.
The Board actively monitors and seeks to manage the discount
of MUSCIT and is responsible for share buy backs for cancellation or issuance
from Treasury. Share buy backs may help to reduce the discount.
During the year and up to the date of this report, MUSCIT
has made use of the authority granted at the Annual General Meeting held in
2007 to make market purchases of up to 5,337,857 ordinary shares. As at the
date of this report, 1,828,000 ordinary shares are held in Treasury. A further
160,000 Ordinary shares were bought back for cancellation.
The Board encourages the Manager to market MUSCIT to new
investors to increase demand for shares of MUSCIT, which may help to reduce
the discount.
Regulatory: a breach of s842 might lead to MUSCIT being
subject to capital gains tax; a breach of rules of the London Stock Exchange
might result in censure by the FSA and/or suspension of MUSCIT's listing on
the London Stock Exchange.
The Board has agreed a service level agreement with the
Administrator which includes active and regular review of
compliance with s842, and FSA and London Stock Exchange
Rules. This is reviewed at each Board meeting.
Operational: if the Administrator's operational procedures
proved deficient and its core accounting systems failed, accounting errors
might occur resulting in inaccurate net asset valuations and performance data
and possibly a qualified audit report and/or loss of s842 status.
The Board monitors operational issues monthly and reviews
them in detail at each Board meeting.
Financial: inappropriate accounting policies or failure to
comply with current or new Accounting Standards might lead to a breach of
regulations and/or loss of s842 status.
The Board monitors financial issues monthly and reviews them
in detail at each Board meeting.
Banking: a breach of MUSCIT's loan covenants might lead to
funding being summarily withdrawn.
The Board monitors compliance with banking covenants monthly
and reviews them with the Administrator and Manager.
Reputational: inadequate or deficient controls of the
Administrator or Manager or other third-party providers might result in
breaches of regulations and damage the trust and confidence of shareholders in
MUSCIT, leading to a widening of the discount.
The Board continually monitors and reviews issues that may
impact the standing of MUSCIT.
Reputational: Failure to keep current and potential
investors informed of the Trust's performance and development could result in
less shares being traded in MUSCIT on a daily basis and also lower investor
confidence.
The Board and Manager maintain clear and frequent
communication with shareholders and potential investors. The Board and Manager
are happy to meet with shareholders.
A description of MUSCIT's system for reviewing its
risk-environment is shown in the Directors' Report.
Analysis of Performance using Key Performance Indicators
Results and Dividends: the results for the year are as set
out in the Income Statement. The Directors recommend that a first and final
dividend of 3.65p (2007: 2.65p) per ordinary share (excluding any shares held
in Treasury), amounting to £1,227,000 (2007: £944,000), be paid on 18 August
2008 to shareholders on the share register at the close of business on 13 June
2008.
Net Asset Value: the NAV per ordinary share, including
revenue reserves, at 31 March 2008 was 304.52p (2007: 366.31p).
The Board and the Manager monitor the following Key
Performance Indicators:
- the NAV over one, three and five years and since launch
relative to the benchmark and peer group;
- the high, low and closing level of discount; and
- the Total Expense Ratio, which was 1.7% in 2007/08.
Future Developments and Events Subsequent to the Year End
At the Annual General Meeting held in 2005, shareholders
voted overwhelmingly for the continuation of MUSCIT. The next continuation
vote is due in 2010.
Section 992 Companies Act 2006
The following information is disclosed in accordance with
Section 992 of the Companies Act 2006.
The Company's capital structure and voting rights.
Details of the substantial shareholders in the Company.
The rules concerning the appointment and replacement of
Directors are contained in the Company's Articles of Association.
Amendment of the Company's Articles of Association and the
giving of powers to issue or buy back the Company's share require a special
resolution to be passed by shareholders and the Board's current powers to buy
back shares and proposals for their renewal.
There are: no restrictions concerning the transfer of
securities in the Company; no special rights with regard to control attached
to securities; no agreements between holders of securities regarding their
transfer known to the Company; and no agreements which the Company is party to
that might affect its control following a successful takeover bid.
There are no agreements between the Company and its
Directors concerning compensation for loss of office.
Management Agreement
The Company's investments are managed by Montanaro
Investment Managers Limited under a management agreement dated 30 June 1998,
amended on 10 June 1999 and 31 July 2001. The management fee comprises two
components: a fixed fee of 1/12 of 1% of the gross assets of MUSCIT, payable
monthly in arrears, and a performance fee of 0.1% of the gross assets of
MUSCIT for each 1% outperformance (or part thereof) of MUSCIT's NAV against
the SmallCap over the financial year, subject to a maximum of 0.5% of the
gross assets calculated at the end of the financial year. A performance fee is
only payable in respect of any financial year of MUSCIT in the event that the
NAV of MUSCIT as at the end of that financial year (as derived from the
audited financial statements of MUSCIT): (i) is not less than the NAV of
MUSCIT as at the end of the immediately preceding financial year in which the
Manager was entitled to a performance fee; and (ii) has outperformed MUSCIT's
benchmark during the year by at least 2%. (In such event, the performance fee
would be payable in respect of each 1% (or part thereof) outperformance of the
benchmark).
In the year to 31 March 2007 the Company achieved a new
"high on high" NAV of 366.31p. No performance fee is payable in respect of the
year ended 31 March 2008 (2007: £710,000+VAT).
On termination of the management agreement by MUSCIT, the
Manager is entitled to a termination fee of 1% of gross assets of MUSCIT as at
close of business on the last day of the calendar month immediately preceding
the effective date of termination of the agreement.
The Board keeps under review the performance of the Manager.
In the opinion of the Directors the continuing appointment of the Manager on
the terms agreed is in the interests of shareholders as a whole. Among the
reasons for this view are the satisfactory investment performance of MUSCIT
relative to that of the markets in which MUSCIT invests and because the
remuneration of the Manager is reasonable compared to that of the managers of
comparable investment companies.
Directors
The Directors in office at the year end, along with their
biographies, are shown above.
Directors' Beneficial and Family Interests
The interests of the Directors and their families in the
ordinary shares of MUSCIT are set out below:
As at As at
31 March 31 March
2008 2007
No. of shares No. of shares
David Gamble - Chairman 10,000 10,000
Antony Hardy 10,000 10,000
Christopher Jones 10,000 10,000
Michael Moule 7,000 7,000
Laurence Petar 10,000 10,000
There have been no changes to the above holdings between 31
March 2008 and the date of this Annual Report. None of the Directors nor any
persons connected with them had a material interest in any of MUSCIT's
transactions, arrangements or agreements during the year.
Corporate Governance
Compliance with the Provisions of the AIC Code of Corporate
Governance
The Board of MUSCIT has considered the principles and
recommendations of the AIC Code of Corporate Governance ("AIC Code") by
reference to the AIC Corporate Governance Guide for Investment Companies ("AIC
Guide"). The AIC Code, as explained by the AIC Guide, addresses all the
principles set out in Section 1 of the Combined Code, as well as setting out
additional principles and recommendations on issues that are of specific
relevance to MUSCIT.
The Board considers that reporting under the principles and
recommendations of the AIC Code, and by reference to the AIC Guide (which
incorporates the Combined Code), will provide better information to
shareholders.
The Company has complied with the recommendations of the AIC
Code and the relevant provisions of Section 1 of the Combined Code, except as
set out below.
The Combined Code includes provisions relating to:
the role of the chief executive;
executive directors' remuneration; and
the need for an internal audit function.
For the reasons set out in the AIC Guide, and in the
Preamble to the Combined Code, the Board considers that these provisions are
not relevant to the position of MUSCIT, being an externally managed investment
company. The Company has therefore not reported further in respect of these
provisions.
The AIC Code recommends that a full portfolio listing is
made available to shareholders at least once a year, and where it is not
contained in the Annual Report, a reference should be given explaining where
it can be found. The Company was not compliant as such disclosures were not
contained in the Annual Report for the year to 31 March 2007.
The Company discloses the top 50 holdings within its
portfolio, currently representing 87.2% of the portfolio. It is considered
that the remaining stocks are largely holdings in transition and not therefore
strictly representative of the portfolio.
Board Responsibilities
The Board comprises five non-executive Directors. The Board
has considered the independent status of each Director under the AIC Guide and
has determined that all are independent other than Christopher Jones for the
reasons set out on the following page. Mr Gamble and Mr Moule have a common
directorship of another investment trust but this is not considered to affect
their ability to act independently and each Director is deemed independent in
outlook and judgement. The Chairman is free from any conflicts of interest and
does not have any other significant commitments than those disclosed in his
biography above. The Board has formalised the arrangements under which
Directors, in the furtherance of their duties, may take independent
professional advice. The Company also maintains Directors' and Officers'
liability insurance.
The Company holds at least four Board meetings each year at
which the Directors review MUSCIT's investments and all other important issues
to ensure control is maintained over MUSCIT's affairs. During the year ended
31 March 2008, six Board meetings were held, one of which was a full-day
session devoted entirely to reviewing strategic matters.
None of the Directors has a contract of service with MUSCIT
nor has there been any contract or arrangement between MUSCIT and any Director
at any time during the year. The Company has neither executive directors nor
employees. However, the Board has engaged external companies to undertake the
investment management, administrative and custodial activities of MUSCIT.
Clear, documented contractual arrangements are in place between MUSCIT and
these firms that define the areas where the Board has delegated functions to
them. Further details of the investment management agreement are given above.
A schedule of matters specifically reserved to the Board for
its decision has been adopted. These reserved matters include the approval of
annual and interim accounts, the approval of dividends, the approval of press
releases and circulars, Board appointments and removals and the membership of
Committees. Decisions regarding gearing and the capital structure of MUSCIT
(including share buy backs and Treasury share transactions) are also taken by
the Board, while the day-to-day investment of the portfolio is delegated to
the Manager.
Christopher Jones is the Senior Director of MUSCIT. While Mr
Jones is not deemed to be independent under the AIC Code or Listing Rules, due
to his being a director of more than one investment trust managed by the
Manager, the Board believes that his extensive knowledge of the interests of
shareholders of investment trusts enables him to effectively perform this
role.
Elections and Re-elections at the Annual General Meeting
In accordance with the Company's current Articles, one-third
of the Directors subject to retirement by rotation retire at each AGM. In so
far as the number of Directors retiring is less than one-third, those
Directors who have been longest in office shall retire. In accordance with the
Combined Code and AIC Code Directors will be subject to re-election by
shareholders at intervals of no more than three years. In divergence from the
AIC Code, Directors will not be subject to annual re-election once they have
served nine years on the Board since the date of first election.
The Board will consider the continuing independence of any
Director who has served on the Board for nine years or more, giving
consideration to:
(i) Employee relationships.
(ii) Material business relationships.
(iii) Family ties.
(iv) Cross-directorships.
(v) Shareholdings.
The tenure of the Chairman will be subject to the same
restrictions. A Chairman stepping down from that role will be capable of
continuing to serve as a Director.
In accordance with the Articles of Association, Antony Hardy
will retire by rotation at the Annual General Meeting and, being eligible,
will offer himself for re-election. His fellow Directors strongly recommend
the re-election of Antony Hardy who is Chairman of the Audit Committee and has
extensive experience as an independent investment adviser.
In accordance with the Combined Code and AIC Code, Michael
Moule and David Gamble will retire at the Annual General Meeting as a result
of it having been 3 years since their last election and, being eligible, will
offer themselves for re-election. David Gamble is Chairman of the Company and
has over 35 years experience within the asset management industry and
currently performs a number of non-executive and advisory roles. Michael Moule
has extensive experience of both UK and overseas equity markets and the
investment trust sector.
Their fellow Directors strongly recommend the re-election of
David Gamble and Michael Moule as they make a valuable contribution to the
knowledge and experience of the Board.
In accordance with Listing Rule 15.2.13A, Christopher Jones
will offer himself for re-election as a result of being a director of another
investment company managed by the Investment Manager.
His fellow Directors strongly recommend the re-election of
Christopher Jones who has significant experience both as a non-executive
Director and through a 30 year career in investment management.
Performance Evaluation
The Directors conduct an annual review of Board performance
and effectiveness. This process is comprised of three elements:
1. a factual report of Board Committee procedures from
MUSCIT's Secretary;
2. an assessment of the Board and a self-evaluation by each
Director against specific agreed criteria; and
3. an assessment of the Chairman by each Director against
specific agreed criteria.
Voting Policy and Socially Responsible Investment
The Company has given discretionary voting powers to the
Manager, Montanaro. AIC Code Principal 16 recommends that the Board should
agree a policy regarding voting rights exercised by Montanaro. However, the
Board has agreed that there is no need to set a written down policy with
Montanaro concerning key operational issues as the Board and Montanaro already
have a clear understanding of their respective responsibilities. The Board
encourages the Manager to give due consideration to environmental, social and
governance matters whilst recognising the overall investment policy and
objectives of the Company. Montanaro regularly reports to the Board on how the
Company's voting powers have been exercised. Montanaro votes against
resolutions it considers may damage shareholders' rights or economic
interests. Montanaro gives due weight to what they consider to be socially
responsible investment when making investment decisions, but its overriding
objective is to produce good investment returns for shareholders.
Board Committees
The Audit Committee comprises all members of the Board, with
Antony Hardy acting as Chairman, which the Board considers to be appropriate
in order to maximise the collective knowledge of the Committee. The Committee
meets at least twice a year in conjunction with the annual and interim results
of MUSCIT. It provides a forum through which MUSCIT's Auditor reports to the
Board; reviews the terms of appointment, remuneration, independence,
objectivity and effectiveness of the Auditor; reviews the annual and interim
reports of MUSCIT and monitors the internal controls of MUSCIT and its service
providers. The Committee has adopted formal written terms of reference.
The Remuneration Committee comprises all members of the
Board, with the Chairman of MUSCIT acting as its Chairman, which the Board
considers to be appropriate in order to maximise the collective knowledge of
the Committee. The Remuneration Committee meets as required for the purpose of
considering levels of remuneration paid to the Board. The Committee has
adopted written terms of reference.
The Board also uses a number of other committees, detailed
as follows, on which all Board members sit. Written terms of reference, which
may be obtained from the secretary on request, have been adopted in respect of
each committee, all of which are chaired by the Chairman of MUSCIT.
A Management Engagement Committee meets at least once a year
for the purpose of reviewing the terms of appointment and performance of the
Manager and other service providers. During the year this Committee held one
meeting.
The Nomination Committee meets as required for the purpose
of considering appointments to, and removals from, the Board. Appointments to
the Board are made according to a person's existing knowledge and expertise.
The Board is committed to a policy of succession planning. This Committee also
held one meeting.
Attendance
Management
Audit Remuneration Engagement Nomination
Board Committee Committee Committee Committee
Number
Number of Number of Number of Number of Number of Number of Number of Number of Number of of
meetings Meetings meetings Meetings meetings Meetings meetings Meetings meetings Meetings
held attended held attended held attended held attended held attended
David Gamble 6 6 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1
Antony Hardy 6 6 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1
Christopher Jones 6 6 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1
Michael Moule 6 6 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1
Laurence Petar 6 6 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1
Internal Control and Financial Reporting
The Board is responsible for establishing and maintaining
MUSCIT's system of internal control and for maintaining its effectiveness.
Internal control systems are designed to meet the particular needs of MUSCIT
and the risks to which it is exposed and by their very nature provide
reasonable but not absolute assurance against misstatement or loss. The
Directors have reviewed the effectiveness of the system of internal controls,
including financial, operational and compliance controls, and risk management.
The key procedures, which have been established to provide effective internal
control, are as follows:
Throughout the year under review and up to the date of this
Annual Report, there has been an ongoing process for identifying, evaluating
and managing the significant risks faced by MUSCIT, which accords with
guidance in the document entitled "Internal Control: Revised Guidance for
Directors on the Combined Code" and is reviewed on a regular basis by the
Board. The process involves reports from MUSCIT's Secretary and Manager as
described below. In addition, the Board receives internal control statements
from all the third parties to which it delegates functions.
In accordance with guidance issued to directors of listed
companies in October 2005 the Board has carried out a review of the system of
internal controls as it has operated since 1 April 2007.
Investment management is provided by the Manager, which is
regulated by the Financial Services Authority. The Board is responsible for
setting the overall investment policy and monitors the activity of the Manager
at regular Board meetings. The Manager provides reports at these meetings,
which cover investment performance and compliance issues.
Capita Sinclair Henderson Limited is responsible for the
provision of administration and company secretarial duties. It also reports to
the Board on risk control issues for MUSCIT as a whole.
Custody of assets is undertaken by independent third
parties.
The duties of investment management, accounting and the
custody of assets are segregated.
The procedures of the individual parties are designed to
complement one another.
The Board of MUSCIT clearly define the duties and
responsibilities of their agents and advisers in the terms of their contracts.
The appointment of agents and advisers is conducted by the Board after
consideration of the quality of the parties involved, and the Board monitors
their ongoing performance and contractual arrangements.
Mandates for authorisation of investment transactions and
expense payments are set by the Board.
The Board reviews financial information produced by MUSCIT's
Secretary in detail on a monthly basis.
Dialogue with Shareholders
The Directors are always available to enter into dialogue
with shareholders and have a policy of regularly inviting major shareholders
to meet with the Board.
All shareholders have the opportunity to attend and vote at
the Annual General Meeting during which the Board and Manager are available to
discuss issues affecting MUSCIT.
Substantial Shareholdings
As at the date of this report, MUSCIT has been informed of
the following notifiable interests in MUSCIT's voting rights:
% of
Beneficial owner Ordinary Shares shares in issue
Derbyshire County Council 2,925,000 8.70
East Riding of Yorkshire Council 2,675,000 7.96
Co-operative Insurance Society 2,500,000 7.44
Royal London Asset Management Limited 2,350,000 6.99
Reliance Mutual Insurance Society Limited 2,310,000 6.87
Newton Investment Management Limited 2,054,890 6.11
Jupiter Asset Management 1,875,000 5.58
Legal & General Group PLC 1,454,321 4.33
J O Hambro Investment Management Limited 1,359,600 4.04
Going Concern
The Directors, after due consideration, are of the opinion
that it is appropriate to presume that the Company will continue in business
for the foreseeable future and accordingly have adopted the going concern
basis in preparing the accounts.
Payment of Suppliers
It is MUSCIT's payment policy to obtain the best possible
terms for all business and therefore there is no consistent policy as to the
terms used. The Company agrees with its suppliers the terms on which business
will take place and it is MUSCIT's policy to abide by those terms. The Company
endeavours to pay suppliers' invoices by the end of the month in which they
are received. No invoices received by MUSCIT prior to the Balance Sheet date
(or 31 March 2007) were unpaid and, therefore, there were no trade creditors
at either year end.
Auditor
KPMG Audit Plc is willing to remain in office and Resolution
8 for its re-appointment will be proposed at the Annual General Meeting.
The Directors who held office at the date of approval of
this Directors' Report confirm that, so far as they are each aware, there is
no relevant audit information of which the Company's Auditors are unaware; and
each Director has taken all the steps that he ought to have taken as a
Director to make himself aware of any relevant audit information and to
establish that the Company's Auditors are aware of that information.
Special Business at the Annual General Meeting
A resolution to renew MUSCIT's authority to purchase (either
for cancellation or for placing into Treasury) up to 14.99% of MUSCIT's
ordinary shares in circulation for a further year will be put to shareholders
as Resolution 9 at the Annual General Meeting. Any shares held in Treasury for
a period in excess of 12 months will be cancelled.
Resolution number 10, if passed, will give the Directors the
general authority to allot ordinary shares (including issues out of Treasury)
up to an aggregate nominal amount of one-third of MUSCIT's issued ordinary
shares, in accordance with statutory pre-emption rights.
Resolution number 11, subject to the passing of Resolution
10, if passed, will give the Directors the general authority to allot ordinary
shares (including issues out of Treasury) for cash, up to an aggregate nominal
amount of 10% of the issued ordinary shares and at a price not less than the
net asset value per share, without having to offer such shares to existing
shareholders in proportion to their existing holdings.
Resolution number 12, subject to the passing of Resolution
number 10, if passed, will give the Directors the general authority to allot
shares held in Treasury at a discount to net asset value, up to the same
aggregate nominal amount of 10% of the issued ordinary shares. Any shares
placed into Treasury under this authority will only be re-issued at an
absolute profit and at a lower discount than when they were originally
purchased.
Any decisions regarding placing shares into Treasury, or
issuing shares from Treasury, will be taken by the Directors.
Resolution number 13, if passed, will amend the Company's
Articles of Association, primarily to reflect the provisions of the Companies
Act 2006 that came into force on or before 6 April 2008, and to reflect the
provisions of the Companies Act 2006 which are coming into force in October
2008. An explanation of the main changes between the proposed and existing
Articles of Association is set out in the note at the end of this report.
In addition, it is also proposed to increase the maximum
amount of the Directors' authorised aggregate annual remuneration from
£100,000 to £140,000 to allow for adequate succession planning which could
require the possible appointment of an additional Director if deemed to be
appropriate.
Full details of these resolutions are provided in the Notice
of Annual General Meeting.
By order of the Board
CAPITA SINCLAIR HENDERSON LIMITED
Company Secretary
30 May 2008
Directors' Remuneration Report
The Board has prepared this report, in accordance with the
requirements of the Directors' Remuneration Report Regulations 2002, in
respect of the year ended 31 March 2008. An Ordinary Resolution to receive
this report will be put to shareholders at the forthcoming Annual General
Meeting.
The law requires your Company's Auditor to audit certain
disclosures provided. Where disclosures have been audited, they are indicated
as such. The Auditor's opinion is included in its report.
Remuneration Committee
The Company currently has five non-executive Directors, all
of whom sit on the Remuneration Committee.
Policy on Directors' Fees
The Board's policy is that the remuneration of Directors
should reflect the experience of the Board as a whole, be fair and comparable
to that of other companies of a similar size and capital structure (ordinary
shares and bank borrowings) and that have a similar investment objective
(capital growth). It is intended that this policy will continue for the year
ending 31 March 2009.
The fees of the Directors are determined within the limits
set out in the Company's Articles of Association. Directors are not eligible
for bonuses, pension benefits, share options, long-term incentive schemes or
other benefits.
Directors' Service Contracts
It is the Board's policy that none of the Directors has a
service contract. The terms of their appointment provide that a Director shall
retire and be subject to election at the first Annual General Meeting after
his appointment, and at least every three years thereafter. The terms also
provide that a Director may be removed without notice and that compensation
will not be due on leaving office.
Your Company's Performance
The following graph compares the total return (assuming all
dividends are reinvested) over the past five years to ordinary shareholders to
the total shareholder return on a notional investment made up of shares of the
same kinds and number as those by reference to which the FTSE SmallCap
(ex.I.Cs) is calculated. The index was chosen for comparison purposes as it is
the benchmark used for investment performance measurement purposes.
Directors' Emoluments for the Year (Audited)
The Directors who served in the year received the following
emoluments in the form of fees:
Year to Year to
31 March 2008 31 March 2007
£ £
David Gamble 23,000 23,000
Antony Hardy 16,000 16,000
Christopher Jones 16,000 16,000
Michael Moule 15,000 15,000
Laurence Petar 15,000 15,000
Approval
The Directors' Remuneration Report was approved by the Board
of Directors on 30 May 2008.
DAVID GAMBLE
Chairman
Statement of Directors' Responsibilities
in Respect of the Annual Report and the Financial Statements
The Directors are responsible for preparing the Annual
Report and the financial statements in accordance with applicable law and
regulations.
Company law requires the Directors to prepare financial
statements for each financial year. Under that law they have elected to
prepare the financial statements in accordance with UK Accounting Standards
and applicable law (UK Generally Accepted Accounting Practice).
The financial statements are required by law to give a true
and fair view of the state of affairs of the Company and of the profit or loss
of the Company for that period.
In preparing these financial statements, the Directors are
required to:
select suitable accounting policies and then apply them
consistently;
make judgments and estimates that are reasonable and
prudent;
state whether applicable UK Accounting Standards have been
followed, subject to any material departures disclosed and explained in the
financial statements; and
prepare the financial statements on the going concern basis
unless it is inappropriate to presume that the Company will continue in
business.
The Directors are responsible for keeping proper accounting
records that disclose with reasonable accuracy at any time the financial
position of the Company and enable them to ensure that its financial
statements comply with the Companies Act 1985. They have general
responsibility for taking such steps as are reasonably open to them to
safeguard the assets of the Company and to prevent and detect fraud and other
irregularities.
Under applicable law and regulations, the Directors are also
responsible for preparing a Directors' Report, Directors' Remuneration Report
and Corporate Governance Statement that comply with that law and those
regulations.
The Directors are responsible for the maintenance and
integrity of the corporate and financial information included on the company's
website, www.montanarouksmaller.co.uk. Legislation in the UK governing the
preparation and dissemination of financial statements may differ from
legislation in other jurisdictions.
Responsibility statement of the Directors in respect of the
annual financial report
We confirm that to the best of our knowledge:
the financial statements, prepared in accordance with the
applicable set of accounting standards, give a true and fair view of the
assets, liabilities, financial position and profit or loss of the Company; and
the Directors' Report includes a fair review of the
development and performance of the business and the position of the issuer,
together with a description of the principal risks and uncertainties that they
face.
DAVID GAMBLE
Chairman
30 May 2008
Independent Auditor's Report
to the Members of Montanaro UK Smaller Companies Investment
Trust PLC
We have audited the financial statements of Montanaro UK
Smaller Companies Investment Trust PLC for the year ended 31 March 2008 which
comprise of the Income Statement, the Reconciliation of Movements in
Shareholders' Funds, the Balance Sheet, the Statement of Cash Flows and the
related notes. These financial statements have been prepared under the
accounting policies set out therein. We have also audited the information in
the Directors' Remuneration Report that is described as having been audited.
This report is made solely to the Company's members, as a
body, in accordance with section 235 of the Companies Act 1985. Our audit work
has been undertaken so that we might state to the Company's members those
matters we are required to state to them in an Auditor's report and for no
other purpose. To the fullest extent permitted by law, we do not accept or
assume responsibility to anyone other than the Company and the Company's
members as a body, for our audit work, for this report, or for the opinions we
have formed.
Respective responsibilities of directors and auditors
The Directors' responsibilities for preparing the Annual
Report, the Directors' Remuneration Report and the financial statements in
accordance with applicable law and UK Accounting Standards (UK Generally
Accepted Accounting Practice) are set out in the Statement of Directors'
Responsibilities above.
Our responsibility is to audit the financial statements and
the part of the Directors' Remuneration Report to be audited in accordance
with relevant legal and regulatory requirements and International Standards on
Auditing (UK and Ireland).
We report to you our opinion as to whether the financial
statements give a true and fair view and whether the financial statements and
the part of the Directors' Remuneration Report to be audited have been
properly prepared in accordance with the Companies Act 1985. We also report to
you whether in our opinion the information given in the Directors' Report is
consistent with the financial statements.
In addition we report to you if, in our opinion, the Company
has not kept proper accounting records, if we have not received all the
information and explanations we require for our audit, or if information
specified by law regarding Directors' remuneration and other transactions is
not disclosed.
We review whether the Corporate Governance Statement
reflects the company's compliance with the nine provisions of the 2006
Combined Code specified for our review by the Listing Rules of the Financial
Services Authority, and we report if it does not. We are not required to
consider whether the Board's statements on internal control cover all risks
and controls, or form an opinion on the effectiveness of the Company's
corporate governance procedures or its risk and control procedures.
We read the other information contained in the Annual Report
and consider whether it is consistent with the audited financial statements.
We consider the implications for our report if we become aware of any apparent
misstatements or material inconsistencies with the financial statements. Our
responsibilities do not extend to any other information.
Basis of audit opinion
We conducted our audit in accordance with International
Standards on Auditing (UK and Ireland) issued by the Auditing Practices Board.
An audit includes examination, on a test basis, of evidence relevant to the
amounts and disclosures in the financial statements and the part of the
Directors' Remuneration Report to be audited. It also includes an assessment
of the significant estimates and judgments made by the Directors in the
preparation of the financial statements, and of whether the accounting
policies are appropriate to the Company's circumstances, consistently applied
and adequately disclosed.
We planned and performed our audit so as to obtain all the
information and explanations which we considered necessary in order to provide
us with sufficient evidence to give reasonable assurance that the financial
statements and the part of the Directors' Remuneration Report to be audited
are free from material misstatement, whether caused by fraud or other
irregularity or error. In forming our opinion we also evaluated the overall
adequacy of the presentation of information in the financial statements and
the part of the Directors' Remuneration Report to be audited.
Opinion
In our opinion:
the financial statements give a true and fair view, in
accordance with UK Generally Accepted Accounting Practice, of the state of the
Company's affairs as at 31 March 2008 and of its loss for the year then ended;
the financial statements and the part of the Directors'
Remuneration Report to be audited have been properly prepared in accordance
with the Companies Act 1985; and
the information given in the Directors' Report is consistent
with the financial statements.
KPMG Audit Plc
CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS
REGISTERED AUDITOR
30 May 2008
Income Statement
for the year to 31 March 2008
Year to 31 Year to 31
March 2008 March 2007
Revenue Capital Total Revenue Capital Total
Notes £000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000
(Losses)/gains on investments designated
as fair value through profit or loss 10 - (22,427) (22,427) - 23,331 23,331
Dividends and interest 2 2,823 - 2,823 2,423 - 2,423
Management fee 3 (716) (717) (1,433) (736) (736) (1,472)
Management performance fee 3 - - - - (834) (834)
Other income 2 5 - 5 3 - 3
Other expenses 4 (312) - (312) (342) - (342)
Net return before finance costs and
taxation 1,800 (23,144) (21,344) 1,348 21,761 23,109
Interest payable and similar charges 6 (442) (442) (884) (304) (304) (608)
Net return before taxation 1,358 (23,586) (22,228) 1,044 21,457 22,501
Taxation 7 - - - (3) - (3)
Net return after taxation 1,358 (23,586) (22,228) 1,041 21,457 22,498
Return per ordinary share 9 3.82p (66.30p) (62.48p) 2.92p 60.26p 63.18p
The total column of this statement is the profit and loss
account of the Company.
All revenue and capital items in the above statement derive
from continuing operations.
No Statement of Total Recognised Gains and Losses has been
prepared as all such gains and losses are shown in the Income Statement.
No operations were acquired or discontinued in the year.
The notes below form part of these financial statements.
Reconciliation of Movements in Shareholders' Funds
for the year to 31 March 2008
Called- Own Total
up Share Capital Capital Capital shares equity
Share-
share premium redemption Special reserve reserve Revenue held in holders'
capital account reserve reserve - realised - unrealised reserve Treasury funds
Year to 31 March 2008 Notes £000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000
As at 31 March 2007 3,561 19,307 1,149 9,835 46,505 48,250 1,833 - 130,440
Transfer between reserves - - - - 46,384 (46,384) - - -
Fair value movement of
investments 10 - - - - (16,362) (6,065) - - (22,427)
Costs allocated to capital - - - - (1,159) - - - (1,159)
Dividends paid in the year 8 - - - - - - (944) - (944)
Shares purchased for
cancellation (16) - 16 (384) - - - - (384)
Shares purchased for
Treasury - - - - - - - (4,501) (4,501)
Net revenue for the year - - - - - - 1,358 - 1,358
As at 31 March 2008 3,545 19,307 1,165 9,451 75,368 (4,199) 2,247 (4,501) 102,383
Own Total
Called-up Share Capital Capital Capital shares equity
Share-
share premium redemption Special Reserve reserve Revenue held in holders'
capital account reserve reserve - realised - unrealised reserve Treasury funds
Year to 31 March 2007 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000
As at 31 March 2006 3,561 19,307 1,149 9,835 42,022 31,276 1,611 - 108,761
Net gains on realisation of i
nvestments 10 - - - - 6,357 - - 6,357
Unrealised appreciation on
investments before transfer
on disposal 10 - - - - - 16,974 - - 16,974
Costs allocated to capital - - - - (1,874) - - - (1,874)
Dividends paid in the year 8 - - - - - - (819) - (819)
Net revenue for the year - - - - - - 1,041 - 1,041
As at 31 March 2007 3,561 19,307 1,149 9,835 46,505 48,250 1,833 - 130,440
The notes below form part of these financial statements.
With effect from 1 April 2007, changes in fair value of
investments which are readily convertible to cash, without accepting adverse
terms at the balance sheet date are included in realised, rather than
unrealised, capital reserves. The balances on both reserves at 1 April 2007
have been amended by a reserve transfer to reflect this change.
In accordance with TECH 01/08, gains and losses arising from
changes in the fair value of investments are considered to be realised to the
extent that they are readily convertible to cash, without accepting adverse
terms, at the balance sheet date. Fair value gains on unlisted investments are
not considered to be readily convertible to cash and therefore treated as
unrealised. The treatment of listed investments is dependent upon the
individual circumstances of each holding.
Balance Sheet
as at 31 March 2008
31 March 31 March
2008 2007
Notes £000 £000 £000 £000
Fixed assets
Investments designated at
fair value through profit or
loss 10 106,154 137,442
Current assets
Debtors 12 460 969
Cash at bank 20 11,243 4,360
11,703 5,329
Creditors: amounts falling
due within one year
Other creditors 13 (474) (1,831)
Revolving credit facility 14 (15,000) (10,500)
(15,474) (12,331)
Net current liabilities (3,771) (7,002)
Total assets less current
liabilities 102,383 130,440
Net assets 102,383 130,440
Share capital and reserves
Called-up share capital 15 3,545 3,561
Share premium account 19,307 19,307
Capital redemption reserve 1,165 1,149
Special reserve 9,451 9,835
Capital reserve
- realised  75,368 46,505
- unrealised (4,199) 48,250
Revenue reserve 2,247 1,833
Own shares held in Treasury (4,501) -
Total equity shareholders'
funds 102,383 130,440
Net asset value per
ordinary share 18 304.52p 366.31p
These financial statements were approved by the Board of
Directors on 30 May 2008.
DAVID GAMBLE, ANTONY HARDY
The notes below form part of these financial statements.
Statement of Cash Flows
for the year to 31 March 2008
31 March 31 March
2008 2007
Notes £000 £000 £000 £000
Operating activities
Investment income received 2,604 2,147
Deposit interest received 177 125
Management fees paid (2,059) (1,832)
Company secretarial fees paid (63) (54)
Other cash expenses (529) (598)
Net cash inflow/(outflow) from operating
activities 19 130 (212)
Servicing of finance
Interest and similar charges paid (802) (612)
Net cash outflow from servicing of finance (802) (612)
Taxation
Taxation paid - (3)
Net cash outflow from taxation - (3)
Capital expenditure and financial investment
Purchases of investments (28,763) (34,074)
Sales of investments 37,647 35,675
Net cash inflow from investing activities 8,884 1,601
Equity dividends paid (944) (819)
Net cash inflow/(outflow) before financing 7,268 (45)
Financing
Proceeds of short-term credit facility 4,500 10,500
Repayment of short-term credit facility - (10,000)
Ordinary shares purchased for cancellation (384) -
Ordinary shares purchased for Treasury (4,501) -
Net cash (outflow)/inflow from financing (385) 500
Increase in cash 20 6,883 455
The notes below form part of these financial statements.
Notes to the Financial Statements at 31 March 2008
1 Accounting Policies
Accounting Convention
The financial statements are prepared under the historical
cost convention as modified by the revaluation of fixed asset investments and
in accordance with applicable accounting standards and the Statement of
Recommended Practice regarding the Financial Statements of Investment Trust
Companies ("SORP") issued in January 2003 (revised December 2005). All the
Company's activities are continuing.
A resolution regarding the continuation of the Company as an
investment trust beyond 2011 will be put to shareholders at the 2010 Annual
General Meeting, as required by the Articles of Association. Therefore, the
Directors believe that it is appropriate for the financial statements to be
prepared on a going concern basis.
Income Recognition
UK dividend income is included in the financial statements
when the investments concerned are quoted ex-dividend and shown net of any
associated tax credit.
Deposit interest and underwriting commissions receivable are
included on an accruals basis.
Management Expenses and Finance Costs
Management fees and finance costs are allocated 50% to the
capital reserve - realised and 50% to the revenue account. This is in line
with the Board's expectations of long-term returns from the investment
portfolio of the Company. Performance fees are charged 100% to capital.
Costs arising on early settlement of debt are allocated 100%
to capital, in accordance with the requirements of the SORP.
All other expenses are allocated in full to the revenue
account.
Investments
Investments are recognised and derecognised on the trade
date where a purchase or sale is under a contract whose terms require delivery
within the time frame established by the market concerned, and are initially
measured at fair value.
All investments held by the Company are classified as at
"fair value through profit or loss". Investments are initially recognised at
cost, being the fair value of the consideration given. After initial
recognition investments are measured at fair value, with unrealised gains and
losses on investments and impairment of investments recognised in the Income
Statement and allocated to capital.
For investments actively traded in organised financial
markets, fair value is generally determined by reference to Stock Exchange
quoted market bid prices at the close of business on the balance sheet date,
without adjustment for transaction costs necessary to realise the asset.
In accordance with TECH 01/08, gains and losses arising from
changes in the fair value of investments are considered to be realised to the
extent that they are readily convertible to cash, without accepting adverse
terms, at the balance sheet date. Fair value gains on unlisted investments are
not considered to be readily convertible to cash and therefore treated as
unrealised. The treatment of listed investments is dependent upon the
individual circumstances of each holding.
Treasury Shares
The consideration paid for shares held in Treasury is
presented as a deduction from equity shareholders' funds, in accordance with
FRS 25: "Financial Instruments: Disclosure and Presentation". Any profit on
the sale of shares out of Treasury is credited to the share premium account in
full.
Taxation
The charge for taxation is based on the net revenue for the
year. Deferred taxation is provided in accordance with FRS 19: Deferred
Taxation, on all timing differences that have originated but not reversed by
the balance sheet date. Deferred taxation assets are only being recognised to
the extent that they are regarded as recoverable.
Dividends Payable to Shareholders
In accordance with FRS 21: "Events after the Balance Sheet
date", dividends to shareholders are recognised as a liability in the period
in which they have been declared. Therefore, any interim dividends are not
accounted for until paid, and final dividends are accounted for when approved
by shareholders at an annual general meeting.
Bank loans and borrowings
All bank loans and borrowings are initially recognised at
cost, being the fair value of the consideration received, less issue costs
where applicable. After initial recognition, all interest bearing loans and
borrowings are subsequently measured at amortised cost. Any differences
between cost and redemption value is recognised in the Income Statement over
the period of the borrowings on an effective interest basis.
CAPITAL RESERVES
i) Capital Reserve - Realised:
Gains and losses on realisation of investments and changes
in fair value of instruments which are readily convertible to cash, without
accepting adverse terms, are dealt with in this reserve. This reserve is also
used for the purchases of the Company's own shares for cancellation. 50% of
the management fees, including any related VAT, and 50% of finance costs in
accordance with the Company's objectives are allocated to this reserve.
(ii) Capital Reserve - Unrealised:
Changes in fair value of investments which are not readily
convertible to cash, without accepting adverse terms, are dealt with in this
reserve.
2 Income
Year to Year to
March 2008 March 2008
£000 £000
Income from investments 2,628 2,248
UK dividend income 2,628 2,248
Other income
Bank interest 195 175
Underwriting commission 5 3
Total income 2,828 2,426
Total income comprises
Dividends from financial assets designated at fair value
through profit or loss 2,628 2,248
Interest from financial assets designated at fair value
through profit or loss 195 175
Other income not from financial assets 5 3
2,828 2,426
All investment income has been obtained from investments
listed in the UK.
3 Management Fee
Year to 31 Year to 31
March 2008 March 2007
Revenue Capital Total Revenue Capital Total
£000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000
Management fee 664 664 1,328 626 626 1,252
Irrecoverable VAT
thereon 52 53 105 110 110 220
Performance fee - - - - 710 710
Irrecoverable VAT
thereon - - - - 124 124
716 717 1,433 736 1,570 2,306
The Manager receives a monthly fee equivalent to 1/12 of
1.0% of the gross assets of the Company valued at the close of business on the
last business day of each month and is entitled to a performance fee
calculated as described in the Directors' Report above.
At 31 March 2008, £98,000 (2007: £829,000) excluding VAT was
due for payment to the Manager.
The Company ceased to pay VAT on its Manager's fees from 10
October 2007 as a result of the AIC/Claverhouse ruling.
4 Other Expenses
Year to Year to
31 March 31 March
2008 2007
£000 £000
Administration and company secretarial fees 63 59
Auditor's remuneration (also see * below) for:
- audit 20 22
- other services to the Company 3 3
Other expenses (including Directors' remuneration and VAT) 226 258
312 342
* Total fees paid to the Auditor for the year, all of which were charged to revenue, comprised:
Audit services
- statutory audit 20 22
Tax services
- compliance services 3 3
23 25
The Directors do not consider that the provision of
non-audit work to the Company affects the independence of the Auditor.
5 Directors' Remuneration
Year to Year to
31 March 2008 31 March 2007
£000 £000
Total fees 85 85
A breakdown of the Directors' remuneration is set out in the Directors' Remuneration Report above.
The Company has no employees.
6 Interest Payable and Similar Charges
Year to 31 Year to 31
March 2008 March 2007
Revenue Capital Total Revenue Capital Total
£000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000
Financial liabilities not at fair
value through profit or loss
Interest payable on loan 442 442 884 304 304 608
442 442 884 304 304 608
7 Taxation
The current taxation for the year is lower than the standard
rate of corporation tax in the UK of 30% (2007: 30%). A reconciliation is
provided below:
Year to Year to
31 March 2008 31 March 2007
£000 £000
Return on ordinary activities before taxation - revenue 1,358 1,044
Theoretical corporation tax at 30% 407 313
Effects of:
- UK dividend income not liable to corporation tax (788) (669)
- expenses disallowed for taxation purposes 6 16
- excess management expenses 375 340
- irrecoverable overseas tax - 3
Current taxation charge - 3
Capital returns are not included in the above analysis
since, as an investment trust, the Company's capital gains are not taxable.
At 31 March 2008, the Company had surplus management
expenses and non-trade losses of £20,383,984 (2007: £17,970,720), which have
not been recognised as a deferred taxation asset. This is because the Company
is not expected to generate taxable income in future periods in excess of the
deductible expenses of those future periods and, accordingly, it is unlikely
that the Company will be able to reduce future taxation through the use of
existing surplus expenses.
Due to the Company's status as an Investment Trust and the
intention to continue meeting the conditions required to obtain approval in
the foreseeable future, the Company has not provided deferred tax on any
capital gains and losses arising on the revaluation or disposal of
investments.
8 Dividends
Year to Year to
31 March 2008 31 March 2007
£000 £000
Paid
2007 Final dividend of 2.65p (2006: 2.30p)
per ordinary share 944 819
Proposed
2008 Final dividend of 3.65p (2007: 2.65p)
per ordinary share 1,227 944
9 Return per Share
Year to 31 Year to 31
March 2008 March 2007
Revenue Capital Total Revenue Capital Total
Ordinary share 3.82p (66.30p) (62.48p) 2.92p 60.26p 63.18p
Revenue return per ordinary share is based on the net
revenue after taxation of £1,358,000 (2007: £1,041,000) and 35,576,425 (2007:
35,609,458) ordinary shares, being the weighted average number of ordinary
shares, excluding shares held in Treasury.
Capital return per ordinary share is based on net capital
losses for the year of £23,586,000 (2007: gains £21,457,000), and on
35,576,425 (2007: 35,609,458) ordinary shares, being the weighted average
number of ordinary shares, excluding shares held in Treasury.
10 Investments
Year to 31 Year to 31
March 2008 March 2007
£000 £000
Total investments at fair value 106,154 137,442
The investment portfolio comprises 66 listed UK equity
holdings including 14 holdings totalling £18,259,000 (representing 17.2% of
the portfolio) traded on the Alternative Investment Market ("AIM").
Year Year to
to 31 March 2008 31 March 2007
£000 £000
Opening book cost 89,192 84,662
Opening fair value adjustment 48,250 31,276
Opening valuation 137,442 115,938
Movements in the year
Purchases at cost 28,234 34,432
Sales - proceeds (37,095) (36,259)
Sales - gains on sales 10,072 6,357
Changes in fair value (32,499) 16,974
Closing valuation 106,154 137,442
Closing book cost 90,403 89,192
Closing fair value adjustment 15,751 48,250
106,154 137,442
TRANSACTION COSTS
During the year, the Company incurred transaction costs of
£183,000 (2007: £261,000) and £59,000 (2007: £65,000) on purchases and sales
of investments, respectively. These amounts are deducted in determining gains
on investments at fair value as disclosed in the Income Statement.
With effect from 1 April 2007, changes in fair value of
investments which are readily convertible to cash, without accepting adverse
terms, at the balance sheet date are considered to be realised. Fair value
gains on unlisted investments are not treated as readily convertible to cash,
whereas the treatment of gains on listed investments depends on the individual
circumstances of each investment.
31 March 2008 31 March 2007
Realised Unrealised Total Realised Unrealised Total
`000 `000 `000 `000 `000 `000
Net gains on
investments at
fair value though
profit or loss
Gains on sales 10,072 - 10,072 6,357 - 6,357
Changes in fair (26,434) (6,065) (32,499) - 16,974 16,974
value
(16,362) (6,065) (22,427) 6,357 16,974 23,331
A list of the top 50 investments by market value and an
analysis of the investment portfolio by industrial or commercial sector are
set out above.
11 Significant Holdings
The Company has a holding of 3% or more of the voting rights
attached to shares that is material in the context of the accounts in the
following investments:
% of
Voting
Security rights
Zytronic 3.9
The Stanley Gibbons Group PLC 3.6
12 Debtors
31 March 2008 31 March 2007
£000 £000
Prepayments and accrued income 114 647
Dividends receivable 346 322
460 969
The carrying amount for prepayments, accrued income and
dividends receivable disclosed above reasonably approximates to its fair value
at the year end and is expected to be realised within a year from the balance
sheet date.
13 Other Creditors
31 March 2008 31 March 2007
£000 £000
Accruals and deferred income 474 1,831
474 1,831
The carrying amount for accruals and deferred income
disclosed above reasonably approximates to its fair value at the year end and
is expected to be realised within a year from the balance sheet date.
14 Revolving Credit Facility
31 March 2008 31 March 2007
£000 £000
Falling due within one year 15,000 10,500
Falling due after more than one year - -
15,000 10,500
The Company has a £25,000,000 Revolving Credit Facility with
ING Bank N.V.
As at 31 March 2008, £15,000,000 was drawn down (31 March
2007: £10,500,000), all of which has a fixed interest rate of 6.1203%* and is
repayable on 1 August 2008. The remaining £10,000,000 remains undrawn.
* Including margin and mandatory costs.
15 Share Capital
31 March 2008 31 March 2007
£000 £000
Authorised:
82,101,048 (2007: 82,101,048)
ordinary shares of 10p each 8,210 8,210
Allotted, called-up and fully paid:
35,449,458 (2007: 35,609,458)
ordinary shares of 10p each 3,545 3,561
Voting rights
Ordinary shareholders have unrestricted voting rights at all
general meetings of the Company.
At the Annual General Meeting on 27 July 2007 the Company
was granted the authority to repurchase 5,337,857 ordinary shares. As at 31
March 2008 the Company had the authority to repurchase 3,349,857 ordinary
shares. This authority is due to expire at the conclusion of the next Annual
General Meeting to be held on 18 July 2008.
During the year the following shares were purchased for
cancellation:
Number of Total cost of purchase
Ordinary shares purchased including expenses
Date £000
17/12/2007 25,000 58
18/12/2007 10,000 23
09/01/2008 50,000 121
16/01/2008 20,000 48
21/01/2008 30,000 71
07/03/2008 20,000 50
14/03/2008 5,000 13
160,000 384
During the year the following shares were purchased for
Treasury:
Number of Ordinary shares purchased Total cost of purchase including expenses
Date £000
10/12/2007 1,828,000 4,501
The Company does not have any externally imposed capital
requirements. The Capital of the Company is managed in accordance with its
investment policy in pursuit of its investment objective, both of which are
detailed above.
16 Duration of the Company
The Articles of Association prescribe that shareholders
should have the opportunity to consider the future of the Company at regular
intervals. At the Annual General Meeting to be held in 2010 an Ordinary
Resolution will be proposed to release the Directors from the obligation to
convene an EGM during 2011 for the purpose of voluntarily winding up the
Company, as provided for in the Company's Articles of Association. If the
Company is not wound up, such resolution will be proposed at an EGM every five
years thereafter unless, at any AGM held within, and not more than, 18 months
prior to the expiry of the relevant period of five years, an ordinary
resolution is passed releasing the Directors from the obligation to convene
such an EGM.
17 Own Shares Held in Treasury
The Company has taken advantage of the regulations which
came into force on 1 December 2003 to allow companies, including investment
trusts, to buy shares and hold them in Treasury for re-issue at a later date.
In accordance with FRS 25: "Financial Instruments: Presentation and
Disclosure", the consideration paid for shares held in Treasury is presented
as a deduction from shareholders' funds.
Year to 31 March 2008 Year to 31 March 2007
Own shares Premium on Own shares Premium on
held in Treasury disposal held in Treasury disposal
SUMMARY Number £000 £000 Number £000 £000
At 1 April - - - - - -
Additions 1,828,000 4,501 - - - -
Cancellation - book cost - - - - - -
Disposals - book cost - - - - - -
At 31 March 1,828,000 4,501 - - - -
18 Net Asset Value per Ordinary Share
Net asset value per ordinary share is based on net assets of
£102,383,000 (2007: £130,440,000) and on 33,621,458 (2007: 35,609,458)
ordinary shares being the number of ordinary shares in issue at the year end.
19 Reconciliation of Net Revenue Before Finance Costs and
Taxation to Net Cash Inflow/(Outflow) from Operating Activities
Year to Year to
31 March 2008 31 March 2007
£000 £000
Net revenue before finance costs and taxation 1,800 1,348
Management fee charged to capital (717) (1,570)
(Decrease)/increase in creditors (910) 163
Decrease in prepayments and accrued income (43) (153)
Net cash inflow/(outflow) from operating activities 130 (212)
20 Reconciliation of Net Cash Flows to Movements in Net Debt
Year to Year to
31 March 2008 31 March 2007
£000 £000
Increase in cash in year 6,883 455
Proceeds of credit facility (4,500) (10,500)
Repayment of credit facility - 10,000
Movement in net funds 2,383 (45)
Net debt at beginning of year (6,140) (6,095)
Net debt at end of year (3,757) (6,140)
ANALYSIS OF NET DEBT
1 April 2007 Cash flows 31 March 2008
£000 £000 £000
Cash at bank 4,360 6,883 11,243
Debt due in less than one year (10,500) (4,500) (15,000)
Debt due after one year - - -
(6,140) 2,383 (3,757)
21 Analysis of Financial Assets and Liabilities
As required by FRS 29: "Financial Instruments: Disclosures",
an analysis of financial assets and liabilities, which identifies the risk to
the Company of holding such items, is given below.
BACKGROUND
The Company's financial instruments comprise securities,
cash balances and debtors and creditors that arise from its operations, for
example, in respect of sales and purchases awaiting settlement and debtors for
accrued income.
The risk management policies and procedures outlined in this
note have not changed substantially from the previous accounting period.
The Company has little or no exposure to cash flow or
foreign currency risk.
The principal risks the Company faces in its portfolio
management activities are:
credit risk;
market price risks, i.e. movements in the value of
investment holdings caused by factors other than interest rate or currency
movement;
interest rate risk;
liquidity risk i.e. the risk that the Company has difficulty
in realising assets or otherwise raising funds to meet commitments associated
with financial instruments; and
gearing.
The Manager monitors the financial risks affecting the
Company on a daily basis. The Directors receive financial information on a
monthly basis which is used to identify and monitor risk.
(i) Credit Risk
Credit risk is the risk of financial loss to the Company if
the contractual party to a financial instrument fails to meet its contractual
obligations.
The carrying amounts of financial assets best represent the
maximum credit risk exposure at the balance sheet date.
The Company's listed investments are held on its behalf by
HSBC acting as agent, the Company's custodian. Bankruptcy or insolvency of the
custodian may cause the Company's rights with respect to securities held by
the custodian to be delayed. The Board monitors the Company's risk by
reviewing the custodian's internal controls reports.
Investment transactions are carried out with a large number
of brokers whose creditworthiness is reviewed by the Investment Manager.
Transactions are ordinarily undertaken on a delivery versus payment basis
whereby the Company's custodian bank ensures that the counterparty to any
transaction entered into by the Company has delivered in its obligations
before any transfer of cash or securities away from the Company is completed.
Cash is only held at banks that have been identified by the
Board as reputable and of high credit quality.
The maximum exposure to credit risk at 31 March 2008 was:
31 March 2008 31 March 2007
£000 £000
Cash at bank 11,243 4,360
Debtors and prepayments 460 969
11,703 5,329
None of the Company's assets are past due or impaired.
(ii) Market Price Risk
Market price risk arises mainly from uncertainty about
future prices of financial instruments. The value of shares and the income
from them may fall as well as rise and shareholders may not get back the full
amount invested. The Manager continues to monitor the prices of financial
instruments held by the Company on a real time basis. Adherence to the
Company's investment objectives shown on the inside front cover mitigates the
risk of excessive exposure to one issuer or sector.
The Board manages the market price risks inherent in the
investment portfolio by ensuring full and timely access to relevant
information from the Investment Manager. The Board meets regularly and each
meeting reviews the investment performance, the investment portfolio and the
rationale for the current investment positioning to ensure consistency with
the Company's objectives and investment policies. The portfolio does not seek
to reproduce the index, investments are selected based upon the merit of
individual companies and therefore the portfolio may well diverge from the
short term fluctuations of the benchmark.
Fixed asset investments are valued at their bid price which
equates to their fair value. A list of the Company's 50 largest equity
investments is given above. In addition, an analysis of the investment
portfolio by broad industrial and commercial sector, an analysis of the
portfolio by market capitalisation of holdings and a list of the 30 largest
equity investments are contained in the Managers' Review section.
The maximum exposure to market price risk is the fair value
of investments of £106,154,000 (2007: £137,442,000).
If the investment portfolio valuation fell by 1% from the
amount detailed in the financial statements as at 31 March 2008 it would have
the effect, with all other variables held constant, of reducing the net
capital return before taxation by £1,062,000 (2007: £1,374,000). An increase
of 1% in the investment portfolio valuation would have an equal and opposite
effect on the net capital return before taxation.
(iii) Interest Rate Risk
Changes in interest rates may cause fluctuations
in the income and expenses of the Company. The revolving credit facility with
ING Bank.NV is a fixed rate facility (see note 14). The amount of such
borrowings and the approved levels are monitored and reviewed regularly by the
Board. The Company mitigates the risk by fixing the interest rates of the
facility for six months at a time.
The Company receives interest on the cash
deposits at a rate of 0.5% below the bank base rate. The interest received in
the year amounted to £195,000 (2007:£175,000).
The interest risk profile of the Company is given below.
If interest rates had reduced by 1% from those paid as at 31
March 2008 it would have the effect, with all other variables held constant,
of increasing the net revenue return before taxation on an annualised basis by
£150,000 (2007: £105,000). If there was an increase in interest rates of 1%
there would have been an equal and opposite effect in the net revenue return
before taxation. The calculations are based on cash at bank and short-term
deposits as at 31 March 2008 and these may not be representative of the year
as a whole.
Due to the short-term nature of the loan facility, changes
in interest rates would not have an effect on the fair value of the loan.
(iv) Liquidity Risk
Liquidity is the risk that the Company will encounter
difficulty in meeting obligations associated with financial liabilities. The
Manager does not invest in unlisted securities on behalf of the Company.
However, the investments held by the Company consist of UK quoted small
companies which are inherently less liquid than quoted large companies.
Short-term flexibility is achieved through the use of bank borrowings.
Liquidity risk is mitigated by the fact that the Company has £11.2 million
cash at bank which can satisfy its creditors and that as a closed end fund
assets do not need to be liquidated to meet redemptions. The Board has deemed
that the funds listed investments with a market capitalisation of over £100
million are readily realisable to cash. Exposure to listed investments with a
market capitalisation of less than £100 million is £17,198,000.
(v) Gearing
Gearing can have amplified effects on the net asset value of
the Company. It can be positive for a company's performance, although it can
have negative effects on performance in falling markets. It is the Company's
policy to determine the adequate level of gearing appropriate to its own risk
profile.
(vi) Use of Derivatives
It is not the Company's policy to enter into derivative
contracts.
FINANCIAL ASSETS
The majority of the Company's financial assets are listed
equity shares which neither pay interest nor have a maturity date. No fixed
interest assets were held at 31 March 2008 nor during the year.
All financial assets are in sterling and disclosed at fair
value through profit or loss.
FINANCIAL LIABILITIES
The Company finances its operations through equity, retained
profits and bank borrowings (see note 14). The change in the fair value of
financial liabilities during the year was not related to the credit risk
profile. The interest rate risk profile of the financial liabilities of the
Company as at 31 March 2008 is as follows:
Weighted average Period until
Total interest rate maturity
£000 % Years
Amounts drawn down under fixed revolving credit facility £15.0m 15,000 6.1203 0.33
Financial liabilities upon which no interest is paid 474 - -
The interest rate risk profile of the financial liabilities
of the Company as at 31 March 2007 was as follows:
Weighted average Period until
Total interest rate maturity
£000 % Years
Amounts drawn down under fixed revolving credit facility £7.5m 7, 500 5.7349 0.33
£3.0m 3,000 6.1453 0.25
Financial liabilities upon which no
interest is paid 1,831 - -
The maturity profile of the Company's financial liabilities
is as follows:
As at As at
31 March 2008 31 March 2007
£000 £000
In one year or less 15,474 12,331
In more than one but not more than two years - -
In more than two years but not more than five years - -
15,474 12,331
The Company had £10,000,000 undrawn under the fixed
Revolving Credit Facility at 31 March 2008 (2007: £4,500,000).
The Company's fixed revolving credit facility is measured at
cost and denominated in sterling. All other financial liabilities are in
sterling and disclosed at fair value. It is considered that, because of the
short term nature of the facility, cost approximates to fair value.
22 Previous Commitments and Contingent Liabilities
At 31 March 2008, there were no capital commitments (2007: nil).
23 Related Party Transactions
Under the Listing Rules the Manager is regarded as a related
party of the Company. The amounts paid to the Manager are disclosed in note 3.
However, the existence of an independent Board of Directors demonstrates that
the Company is free to pursue its own financial and operating policies, and
therefore, in terms of FRS 8: "Related Party Transactions", the Manager is not
considered a related party. The relationship between the Company, its
Directors and the Manager is disclosed in the Directors' Report.
Company Summary
Investment Objective
MUSCIT's investment objective is capital appreciation
(rather than income) achieved by investing in small quoted companies listed on
the London Stock Exchange or traded on the Alternative Investment Market
("AIM") and to achieve relative outperformance of its benchmark, the FTSE
SmallCap (excluding investment companies) Index. No unquoted investments are
permitted.
Investment Policy
The Company looks to achieve its objective and to diversify
risk by investing in a portfolio of UK Smaller Companies. At the time of
initial investment, a potential investee company must be profitable and
smaller than the largest constituent of the HGSC Index, which represents the
smallest 10% of the UK Stock Market by value. At the start of 2008, this was
any company below £1.1 billion in size. The Manager looks to focus on the
smaller end of this Index.
In order to manage risk the Manager will limit any one
holding to a maximum of 5% of the Company's investments. The weightings for
every stock are closely monitored to ensure they reflect the underlying
liquidity of the particular company. The Company's AIM exposure is also
closely monitored by the Board and is limited to 30% of total investments with
Board approval required for exposure to be above 25%.
The Manager is focused on identifying high quality niche
companies operating in growth markets. This typically leads the Manager to
invest in companies that enjoy high barriers to entry, a sustainable
competitive advantage and strong management teams. The portfolio is therefore
constructed on a "bottom up" basis and there are no sectoral constraints
placed on the Manager. However, "top down" relative risk is regularly assessed
by reference to the benchmark's position.
The Board, in consultation with the Manager, is responsible
for determining the gearing strategy for the Company. Gearing is used to
enhance returns when the timing is considered appropriate. The Company
currently has a credit facility of £25 million through ING Bank. The Board has
agreed to limit borrowings to 25% of Shareholders' funds.
The Board believes in the opportunities that UK Smaller
Companies present for long-term superior total returns. As a consequence of
this any material changes to the Company's existing investment objective and
policy will be subject to Shareholder approval.
Benchmark
FTSE SmallCap (excluding investment companies) Index ("SmallCap").
Gross Assets
£117,857,000 as at 31 March 2008.
Shareholders' Funds
£102,383,000 as at 31 March 2008.
Market Capitalisation
£82,373,000 as at 31 March 2008.
Capital Structure
As at 31 March 2008 and at the date of this report, the
Company had 35,449,458 ordinary shares of 10p each in issue (of which
1,828,000 were held in Treasury).
Wind up Date
In accordance with the Articles of Association, a resolution
will to be put to shareholders at the Annual General Meeting to be held in
2010 to release the Directors from the obligation to convene an EGM in 2011
for the purpose of winding up the Company.
Management Fee
The management fee comprises two components: a fixed fee of
1/12 of 1% of the gross assets of the Company, payable monthly in arrears, and
a performance fee of 0.1% of the gross assets of the Company for each 1%
outperformance (or part thereof) of the Company's NAV against the SmallCap
over the financial year, subject to a maximum of 0.5% of the gross assets
calculated at the end of the financial year. For further details above.
Administration and Company Secretarial Fees
The Company Secretary receives an annual fee of £63,000 plus
VAT, which is subject to an annual RPI uplift.
Sources of Information
All information contained within the Chairman's Statement
and the Manager's Report has been provided by Montanaro Investment Managers
Limited unless otherwise noted.
Glossary of Terms
Nav
NAV stands for Net Asset Value and represents shareholders'
funds expressed as an amount per individual share. Shareholders' funds are the
total value of a company's assets at current market value less its
liabilities.
Discount
If the share price of an investment trust is lower than the
NAV per share, the shares are said to be trading at a discount. The size of
the discount is calculated by subtracting the share price from the NAV per
share and is usually expressed as a percentage of the NAV per share. If the
share price is higher than the NAV per share, the shares are said to be
trading at a premium.
Gearing
Gearing is the process whereby growth or decline in the
total assets of a company has an exaggerated effect on the NAV of that
company's ordinary shares due to the presence of borrowings or share classes
with a prior ranking entitlement to capital.
Net Gearing
Net gearing is the total debt, net of cash and equivalents
as a percentage of the total shareholders' funds.
Gross Assets
Gross assets are the sum of both fixed and current assets
with no deductions.
Shareholder Information
Sources of Further Information
The Company's share price is listed in the Financial Times
under "Investment Companies".
Information on the Company is available on the Company's website,
www.montanarouksmaller.co.uk, and the Manager's website: www.montanaro.co.uk.
Key Dates
31 March 2008 Company year end
30 May 2008 Annual results
11 June 2008 Ex-dividend
18 July 2008 Annual General Meeting
18 August 2008 Dividend payable
November 2008 Interim results
Frequency of Nav Publication
The Company's NAV is released to the London Stock Exchange
on a daily basis.
PEP/ISA Status
The Company is fully eligible for inclusion in ISAs and
transfers into existing PEPs.
AIC
The Company is a member of the Association of Investment
Companies.
Explanatory Notes of Principal Changes to the Company's
Articles of Association
We are asking shareholders to approve a number of amendments
to our Articles of Association, primarily to reflect the provisions of the
Companies Act 2006 that came into force on or before 6 April 2008, and to
reflect the provisions of the Companies Act 2006 which are coming into force
in October 2008. An explanation of the main changes between the proposed and
existing articles of association is set out below. In addition, it is also
proposed to increase the maximum amount of the Directors' authorised aggregate
annual remuneration from £100,000 to £140,000.
The remaining provisions of the Companies Act 2006 are
expected to come into force in October 2009. In addition, various regulations
that relate to certain of these provisions have yet to be finalised.
Consequently, it will be necessary for the Company to undertake a further
review of its Articles of Association in due course in order to reflect these
other provisions. As these further changes to the Articles of Association will
be reasonably substantial in number, it is anticipated that the Company will
adopt new Articles of Association at its next Annual General Meeting.
It is proposed to adopt new Articles of Association (the
"New Articles") in order to update the Company's current Articles of
Association (the "Current Articles") primarily to take account of changes in
English company law brought about by the Companies Act 2006 that came into
force on or before 6 April 2008, and are coming into force in October 2008.
The principal changes introduced in the New Articles are summarised below.
Other changes, which are of a minor, technical or clarifying nature and also
some more minor changes which merely reflect changes made by the Companies Act
2006 have not been noted in this Appendix. The New Articles showing all the
changes to the Current Articles are available for inspection at the offices of
Montanaro Investment Managers Limited, 53 Threadneedle Street, London EC2R 8AR
from 10am on 16 July 2008 until the close of the Annual General Meeting on 18
July 2008.
1 Uncertificated shares
The Current Articles currently grant the Company power to
refuse to register a transfer of shares if a restriction notice served in
relation to those shares has not been complied with. This empowers a public
company to investigate interests in its share capital. The Company may serve a
restriction notice on any person whom it reasonably believes is or has been
(at any time during the three years immediately preceding the issue of the
notice) interested in the Company's shares. However, under the Uncertificated
Securities Regulations 2001 (the "Regulations"), Euroclear UK & Ireland
Limited ("Euroclear") maintains the register in relation to those members who
hold uncertificated shares in the Company and automatically registers
transfers of title of uncertificated shares on settlement of transactions.
Accordingly, if the shares in respect of which a restriction notice has been
served are in uncertificated form, it would not be possible for the Company to
exercise its power to refuse to register a transfer of those shares.
Therefore, the Regulations permit the Company to give Euroclear notice
requiring the shares to be converted into certificated form, provided that the
conversion is in accordance with provisions in the Company's Articles of
Association.
It is therefore proposed that the Company includes in its
New Articles a provision enabling it to force the conversion of the relevant
shares to certificated form on a failure to respond to a restriction notice,
it will then be able to serve a notice on Euroclear to that effect and
subsequently impose the restrictions on transfer that are available in respect
of certificated shares.
2 Treasury shares
Under the Companies (Acquisition of Own Shares) (Treasury
Shares) Regulations 2003, the Company is allowed to hold up to 10% of its own
shares in treasury following a buy back, instead of cancelling them as
previously required. This gives the Company the ability to re-issue treasury
shares quickly and cost-effectively and provides the Company with additional
flexibility in the management of its capital base. Such shares may be resold
for cash but all rights attaching to them, including voting rights and any
right to receive dividends are suspended whilst they are held in treasury. If
the Board exercises the authority to purchase the Company's own shares, the
Company will have the option of either holding in treasury or of cancelling
any of its own shares purchased pursuant to this authority and will decide at
the time of purchase which option to pursue.
3 Form of resolution
The Current Articles of the Company contain a provision
that, where for any purpose an ordinary resolution is required, a special or
extraordinary resolution is also effective. This provision is being amended as
the concept of extraordinary resolutions has not been retained under the
Companies Act 2006.
The Current Articles enable members to act by written
resolution. Under the Companies Act 2006 public companies can no longer pass
written resolutions. These provisions have therefore been removed in the New
Articles.
4 Convening extraordinary and annual general meetings
The provisions in the Current Articles dealing with the
convening of general meetings and the length of notice required to convene
general meetings are being amended to conform to new provisions in the
Companies Act 2006. In particular an extraordinary general meeting to consider
a special resolution can be convened on 14 days' notice whereas previously 21
days' notice was required.
5 Variation of class rights
The Current Articles contain provisions regarding the
variation of class rights. The proceedings and specific quorum requirements
for a meeting convened to vary class rights are contained in the Companies Act
2006. The relevant provisions have therefore been amended in the New Articles.
6 Votes of members
Under the Companies Act 2006 proxies are entitled to vote on
a show of hands whereas under the Current Articles proxies are only entitled
to vote on a poll. The time limits for the appointment or termination of a
proxy appointment have been altered by the Companies Act 2006 so that the
articles cannot provide that they should be received more than 48 hours before
the meeting or in the case of a poll taken more than 48 hours after the
meeting, more than 24 hours before the time for the taking of a poll, with
weekends and bank holidays being permitted to be excluded for this purpose.
Multiple proxies may be appointed provided that each proxy is appointed to
exercise the rights attached to a different share held by the shareholder. The
New Articles reflect all of these new provisions.
7 Age of directors on appointment
The Current Articles contain a provision stating that a
person is not incapable of being appointed a Director by reason of his having
attained the age of 70. Such provision is now unnecessary due to the
Employment Equality (Age) Regulations 2006 and so has been removed from the
New Articles.
8 Provision for employees on cessation of business
The Companies Act 2006 provides that the powers of the
directors to make provision for a person employed or formerly employed by the
Company in connection with the cessation or transfer to any person of the
whole or part of the undertaking of the Company, may be exercised by the
directors or by the Company in general meeting. However, if the power is to be
exercised by the directors, the articles of association must include a
provision to this effect. The New Articles provide that the directors may
exercise this power.
9 Conflicts of interest
The Companies Act 2006 sets out directors general duties
which largely codify the existing law but with some changes. Under the
Companies Act 2006, from 1 October 2008 a director must avoid a situation
where he has, or can have, a direct or indirect interest that conflicts, or
possibly may conflict with the Company's interests. The requirement is very
broad and could apply, for example, if a director becomes a director of
another company or a trustee of another organisation. The Companies Act 2006
allows directors of public companies to authorise conflicts and potential
conflicts, where appropriate, where the articles of association contain a
provision to this effect. The Companies Act 2006 also allows the articles of
association to contain other provisions for dealing with directors' conflicts
of interest to avoid a breach of duty. The New Articles give the directors
authority to approve such situations and to include other provisions to allow
conflicts of interest to be dealt with in a similar way to the current
position.
There are safeguards which will apply when directors decide
whether to authorise a conflict or potential conflict. First, only directors
who have no interest in the matter being considered will be able to take the
relevant decision, and secondly, in taking the decision the directors must act
in a way they consider, in good faith, will be most likely to promote the
Company's success. The directors will be able to impose limits or conditions
when giving authorisation if they think this is appropriate.
The New Articles also contain provisions relating to
confidential information, attendance at board meetings and availability of
board papers to protect a director being in breach of duty if a conflict of
interest or potential conflict of interest arises. These provisions will only
apply where the position giving rise to the potential conflict has previously
been authorised by the directors. It is the Board's intention to report
annually on the Company's procedures for ensuring that the Board's powers to
authorise conflicts are operated effectively.
The New Articles will also apply to alternate directors.
10 Notice of board meetings
Under the Current Articles, when a director is abroad he can
request that notice of directors' meetings are sent to him at a specified
address and if he does not do so he is not entitled to receive notice while he
is away. This provision has been removed, as modern communications mean that
there may be no particular obstacle to giving notice to a director who is
abroad. It has been replaced with a more general provision that a director is
treated as having waived his entitlement to notice, unless he supplies the
Company with the information necessary to ensure that he receives notice of a
meeting before it takes place.
11 Electronic and web communications
Provisions of the Companies Act 2006 which came into force
in January 2007 enable companies to communicate with members by electronic
and/or website communications. The New Articles continue to allow
communications to members in electronic form and, in addition, they also
permit the Company to take advantage of the new provisions relating to website
communications. Before the Company can communicate with a member by means of
website communication, the relevant member must be asked individually by the
Company to agree that the Company may send or supply documents or information
to him by means of a website, and the Company must either have received a
positive response or have received no response within the period of 28 days
beginning with the date on which the request was sent. The Company will notify
the member (either in writing, or by other permitted means) when a relevant
document or information is placed on the website and a member can always
request a hard copy version of the document or information.
12 Directors' indemnities and loans to fund expenditure
The Companies Act 2006 has in some areas widened the scope
of the powers of a company to indemnify directors and to fund expenditure
incurred in connection with certain actions against directors. In particular,
a company that is a trustee of an occupational pension scheme can now
indemnify a director against liability incurred in connection with the
company's activities as trustee of the scheme. In addition, the existing
exemption allowing a company to provide money for the purpose of funding a
director's defence in court proceedings now expressly covers regulatory
proceedings and applies to associated companies.
13 Duration of the Company
At the Annual General Meeting of the Company held on 15 July
2005 the Company's shareholders resolved to release the directors from
convening a General Meeting in 2006 to propose a Special Resolution for the
winding up of the Company. As a consequence of that resolution, the directors
are next obliged to convene a General Meeting to propose a Special Resolution
for the winding up of the Company in 2010, unless at the Company's 2009 Annual
General Meeting an Ordinary Resolution is passed releasing the directors from
the obligation to convene such General Meeting.
14 Directors' fees
It is proposed to increase the maximum amount of the
Directors' authorised aggregate annual remuneration from £100,000 to £140,000.
15 Entitlement to Attend and Speak
It is proposed to include a provision entitling directors to
attend and speak at any meeting of the Company, and to allow the Chairman to
invite any person to attend and speak at any meeting where this will assist in
the deliberations of the meeting.
16 Execution of Deeds
It is now possible for a witness to attest a Director's
signature when executing a deed. This applies both when affixing the Company
seal and when executing a deed without the seal.
17 General
The New Articles include some other more minor changes. The
opportunity has also been taken to bring clearer language into the New
Articles and in some areas to conform the language of the New Articles.
Notice of Annual General Meeting
Notice is hereby given that the Thirteenth Annual General
Meeting of the Company will be held at the offices of Montanaro Investment
Managers Limited, 53 Threadneedle Street, London EC2R 8AR on Friday, 18 July
2008 at 12 noon for the following purposes:
Ordinary Business
RESOLUTION 1 - ORDINARY RESOLUTION
To receive and, if thought fit, to accept the Reports of the
Directors and the Auditor and the audited financial statements for the year
ended 31 March 2008.
RESOLUTION 2 - ORDINARY RESOLUTION
To receive and, if thought fit, to accept the Directors'
Remuneration Report for the year ended 31 March 2008.
RESOLUTION 3 - ORDINARY RESOLUTION
To declare a first and final dividend of 3.65p per ordinary
10p share for the year ended 31 March 2008.
RESOLUTION 4 - ORDINARY RESOLUTION
To re-elect Christopher Jones a Director of the Company.
RESOLUTION 5 - ORDINARY RESOLUTION
To re-elect David Gamble a Director of the Company.
RESOLUTION 6 - ORDINARY RESOLUTION
To re-elect Michael Moule a Director of the Company.
RESOLUTION 7 - ORDINARY RESOLUTION
To re-elect Antony Hardy a Director of the Company.
RESOLUTION 8 - ORDINARY RESOLUTION
To re-appoint KPMG Audit Plc as Auditor to the Company to
hold office from the conclusion of this meeting until the conclusion of the
next general meeting at which financial statements are laid and to authorise
the Directors to determine their remuneration.
Special Business
RESOLUTION 9 - SPECIAL RESOLUTION
That the Company be and is hereby generally and
unconditionally authorised in accordance with Section 166 of the Companies Act
1985 ("the Act") to make market purchases (within the meaning of Section 163
of the Act) of ordinary shares of 10p each in the capital of the Company
("ordinary shares"), provided that:
(i) the maximum number of ordinary shares hereby authorised
to be purchased shall be 5,313,874, or if less, 14.99% of the number of shares
in issue immediately following the passing of this resolution;
(ii) the minimum price which may be paid for each ordinary
share is 10p;
(iii) the maximum price payable by the Company for each
Ordinary 10p share is the higher of (i) 105 per cent. of the average of the
mid-market value of the Ordinary 10p shares in the Company for the 5 business
days prior to the date of the market purchase and (ii) the higher of the price
of the last independent trade and the highest current bid as stipulated by
Article 5(1) of Commission Regulation (EC) 22 December 2003 implementing the
Market Abuse Directive as regards exemptions for buyback programmes and
stabilisation of financial instruments (No.2233/2003);
(iv) the authority hereby conferred shall expire at the
conclusion of the next Annual General Meeting of the Company in 2009 or, if
earlier, on the expiry of 15 months from the passing of this Resolution,
unless such authority is renewed prior to such time;
(v) the Company may make a contract to purchase ordinary
shares under the authority hereby conferred prior to the expiry of such
authority which will or may be executed wholly or partly after the expiration
of such authority and may make a purchase of ordinary shares pursuant to any
such contract; and
(vi) any shares purchased under the authority hereby
conferred and held in Treasury by the Company shall, if not issued out of
Treasury within 12 months following such purchase, be cancelled.
RESOLUTION 10 - ORDINARY RESOLUTION
That the Directors of the Company be and they are hereby
generally and unconditionally authorised (in substitution for any authorities
previously granted to the Directors), pursuant to Section 80 of the Companies
Act 1985 ("the Act"), to exercise all the powers of the Company to allot
relevant securities, including any issue of shares out of Treasury (within the
meaning of Section 80(2) of the Act) up to an aggregate nominal amount of
£1,181,648, being one third of the total issued ordinary share capital as at
31 March 2008, provided that this authority shall expire on the earlier of the
date of the next Annual General Meeting of the Company to be held in 2009, or
15 months after the date of passing this resolution, save that the Company may
before such expiry make offers, agreements or arrangements which would or
might require relevant securities to be allotted after such expiry and so that
the Directors of the Company may allot relevant securities in pursuance of
such offers, agreements or arrangements as if the authority conferred hereby
had not expired.
RESOLUTION 11 - SPECIAL RESOLUTION
That, subject to the passing of Resolution 10 set out above,
the Directors of the Company be and they are hereby empowered pursuant to
Section 95(1) of the Act to allot equity securities, including any issue of
shares out of Treasury (within the meaning of Section 94 of the Act) pursuant
to the authority conferred by Resolution 7 as if Section 89(1) of the Act did
not apply to any such allotment, provided that this power shall be limited to
the allotment of equity securities for cash up to an aggregate nominal amount
of £354,495 being 10% of the issued share capital as at 31 March 2008, at a
price of not less than the Net Asset Value per share and shall expire on the
earlier of the date of the next Annual General Meeting of the Company to be
held in 2009, or 15 months after the date of passing this resolution, save
that the Company may before such expiry make offers, agreements or
arrangements which would or might require equity securities to be allotted
after such expiry and so that the Directors of the Company may allot equity
securities in pursuance of such offers, agreements or arrangements as if the
power conferred hereby had not expired.
RESOLUTION 12 - SPECIAL RESOLUTION
That, subject to the passing of Resolution 10 set out above,
the Directors of the Company be and are hereby authorised, for the purposes of
paragraph 15.4.23 of the Listing Rules of the United Kingdom Listing
Authority, to issue ordinary shares of 10p each in the capital of the Company
at a price below the net asset value per share of the existing ordinary shares
in issue, provided always that such issue will be limited to:
(i) up to an aggregate nominal amount of £354,495, being 10%
of the ordinary shares in issue as at the date of this report;
(ii) the sale of shares which, immediately before such sale,
were held by the Company as Treasury shares; and
(iii) in the event of a sale of shares which, immediately
before such sale, were held by the Company as Treasury shares, such shares
shall be issued at a higher price and at a lower discount to net asset value
than when purchased by the Company in accordance with Resolution 9 set out
above.
RESOLUTION 13 - SPECIAL RESOLUTION
THAT the new Articles of Association, a copy of which was
produced to the meeting and initialled by the Chairman of the meeting for the
purpose of identification, be hereby approved and adopted as the new Articles
of Association of the Company in substitution for, and to the exclusion of,
the existing Articles of Association.
By Order of the Board
CAPITA SINCLAIR HENDERSON LIMITED
Company Secretary
30 May 2008
Note 1: A member entitled to attend and vote at this meeting
may appoint one or more persons as his/her proxy to attend, speak and vote on
his/her behalf at the meeting. A proxy need not be a member of the Company. If
multiple proxies are appointed they must not be appointed in respect of the
same shares. To be effective, the enclosed form of proxy, together with any
power of attorney or other authority under which it is signed or a certified
copy thereof, should be lodged at the office of the Company's Registrar,
Capita Registrars, Proxy Department, 34 Beckenham Road, Beckenham, Kent, BR3
4TU not later than 48 hours before the time of the meeting. The appointment of
a proxy will not prevent a member from attending the meeting and voting in
person if he/she so wishes. A member present in person or by proxy shall have
one vote on a show of hands and on a poll every member present in person or by
proxy shall have one vote for every ordinary share of which he is the holder.
Note 2: A person to whom this notice is sent who is a person
nominated under Section 146 of the Companies Act 2006 to enjoy information
rights (a "Nominated Person") may, under an agreement between him/her and the
Shareholder by whom he/she was nominated, have a right to be appointed (or to
have someone else appointed) as a proxy for the Annual General Meeting. If a
Nominated Person has no such proxy appointment right or does not wish to
exercise it, he/she may, under any such agreement, have a right to give
instructions to the Shareholder as to the exercise of voting rights. The
statements of the rights of members in relation to the appointment of proxies
in Note 1 above does not apply to a Nominated Person. The rights described in
those Notes can only be exercised by registered members of the Company.
Note 3: As at 29 May 2008 (being the last business day prior
to the publication of this notice) the Company's issued share capital and
total voting rights amounted to 35,449,458 ordinary shares carrying one vote
each.
Note 4: Pursuant to Regulation 41 of the Uncertificated
Securities Regulations 2001, the Company specifies that only those
Shareholders registered on the Register of Members of the Company as at 12pm
on 16 July 2008 (or in the event that the meeting is adjourned, only those
Shareholders registered on the Register of Members of the Company as at 12pm
on the day which is two days prior to the adjourned meeting) shall be entitled
to attend in person or by proxy and vote at the Annual General Meeting in
respect of the number of shares registered in their name at that time. Changes
to entries on the Register of Members after that time shall be disregarded in
determining the rights of any person to attend or vote at the meeting.
Note 5: In order to facilitate voting by corporate
representatives at the Annual General Meeting, arrangements will be put in
place at the meeting so that:
(i) if a corporate Shareholder has appointed the Chairman of
the meeting as its corporate representative with instructions to vote on a
poll in accordance with the directions of all of the other corporate
representatives for that corporate Shareholder present at the meeting then, on
a poll, those corporate representatives will give voting directions to the
Chairman of the meeting and the Chairman will vote (or withhold a vote) as
corporate representative in accordance with those directions; and
(ii) if more than one corporate representative for the same
corporate Shareholder attends the meeting but the corporate Shareholder has
not appointed the Chairman of the meeting as its corporate representative, a
designated corporate representative will be nominated from those corporate
representatives in attendance on behalf of the corporate Shareholder who will
vote on a poll and the other corporate representatives will give voting
directions to that designated corporate representative. Corporate Shareholders
are referred to the guidance issued by the Institute of Chartered Secretaries
and Administrators on proxies and corporate representatives - www.icsa.org.uk
- for further details of this procedure. The guidance includes a sample form
of representation letter if the Chairman is being appointed as described in
paragraph (i) of this Note 5.
Note 6: Shareholders should note that it is possible that,
pursuant to requests made by shareholders of the Company under section 527 of
the Companies Act 2006, the Company may be required to publish on a website a
statement setting out any matter relating to: (i) the audit of the Company's
accounts (including the auditor's report and the conduct of the audit) that
are to be laid before the Annual General Meeting; or (ii) any circumstances
connected with an auditor of the Company ceasing to hold office since the
previous meeting at which annual accounts and reports were laid in accordance
with section 437 of the Companies Act 2006. The Company may not require the
shareholders requesting any such website publication to pay its expenses in
complying with sections 527 or 528 of the Companies Act 2006. Where the
Company is required to place a statement on a website under section 527 of the
Companies Act 2006, it must forward the statement to the Company's auditor not
later than the time when it makes the statement available on the website. The
business which may be dealt with at the Annual General Meeting includes any
statement that the Company has been required under section 527 of the
Companies Act 2006 to publish on a website.
Note 7: The following documents will be available for
inspection at the registered office of the Company during normal business
hours on any weekday (Saturdays, Sundays and public holidays excepted) from
the date of this notice until the conclusion of the Annual General Meeting and
on the date of the Annual General Meeting at the offices of Montanaro
Investment Managers Limited, 53 Threadneedle Street, London EC2R 8AR from
11:45am until the conclusion of the meeting:
a) Copies of the letters of appointment of the Chairman and
the Non-executive Directors of the Company.
b) A copy of the Articles of Association of the Company.
Registered in England and Wales No. 3004101.
A copy of MUSCIT's Annual Report for the year ended 31 March
2008 can be found on the Company's website, www.montanarouksmaller.co.uk
END