Final Results
TULLETT PREBON PLC
PRELIMINARY RESULTS - for the year ended 31 December 2009
Tullett Prebon plc today announced its preliminary results for the year ended
31 December 2009.
Financial Highlights
- Revenue £947.7m (2008: £943.6m)
- Operating profit £170.8m (2008: £175.1m) (1)
- Operating margin 18.0% (2008: 18.6%)(1)
- Adjusted Profit before tax £157.0m (2008: £155.4m)(2)
- Adjusted EPS 49.2p (2008: 47.1p)(3)
Notes
1. Operating profit and operating margin for 2008 are stated before
exceptional items
2. Adjusted Profit before Tax is stated before non cash gains and losses in
net finance income / (expense) and for 2008 is before exceptional items. A
reconciliation of Adjusted Profit before Tax to the Reported Profit before Tax
of £156.5m (2008: £137.0m) is shown in the Financial Review
3. Adjusted EPS is stated before non cash gains and losses in net finance
income / (expense) net of tax, prior year tax items, and for 2008 is before
exceptional items
Commenting on the results, Keith Hamill, Chairman of Tullett Prebon plc, said:
"The robust performance of the business during 2009 has been achieved despite
circumstances and events which have not always been helpful. It reflects the
value of the service that the business provides to participants in the world's
over-the-counter ("OTC") financial markets, the continuing underlying need for
those markets and the benefits of actions taken by management.
Revenue of £947.7m is slightly higher than reported for 2008. The operating
margin for 2009 is 18.0%, reflecting the active management of our front office
costs, the benefit of the actions taken at the end of 2008 to reduce fixed
support costs, the investments made in increasing the scale and breadth of the
business, and strong management control.
After lower financing costs, adjusted profit before tax of £157.0m compared
with £155.4m in 2008. With a reduction in the effective tax rate to 33.8%,
adjusted basic earnings per share were up 4% to 49.2p.
The business has low capital requirements and excellent cash flow
characteristics. Operating cash flow for the year was £137.9m and at the end
of the year net funds amounted to £9.0m (2008: net debt of £17.4m). Since the
return of £301.5m of capital to shareholders in early 2007 the business has
reported net cash flow before dividends and debt repayments of £250m and over
the same period has paid £76m of dividends to shareholders.
The Board recognises that dividends are an important element of shareholder
return and is recommending a final dividend of 10.0p per share, making the
total dividend for the year 15.0p, an increase of 18% on the 12.75p per share
paid for 2008. The final dividend will be payable on 20 May 2010 to
shareholders on the register on 30 April 2010."
Terry Smith, Chief Executive, added:
"Although the world's financial markets have remained unsettled, overall
activity in the markets slowed in the second half of 2009 in comparison to the
particularly volatile markets experienced in the autumn of 2008 and into the
first half of last year and, as expected, activity currently remains at this
more normal level.
The underlying revenue run rate in the first two months of the year is 5% lower
than a year ago at constant exchange rates. We expect this run rate against
prior year to improve, particularly in the second half. In addition, the net
effect of the broker defections in North America has been to reduce revenue by
6%. The benefit from the actions that we have taken to mitigate the impact of
the broker defections will increase during the year as the rebuilding programme
continues and the new brokers hired build up to their full run rate of revenue.
The eventual outcome of the regulatory debate about how to strengthen the
financial system remains uncertain, but we are confident that our role as an
intermediary in the OTC markets will continue to be vital and that our business
will continue to add significant value to our customers. We have a well
diversified and robust business, and we are well positioned to respond to and
to benefit from, changes in the way in which the OTC markets and our customers
operate and are regulated."
Enquiries:
Investors and analysts
Nigel Szembel, Head of Communications
Tullett Prebon plc
44 (0)207 200 7722
Press
Charlotte Kirkham
M:Communications
44 (0)207 920 2331
Further information on the Company and its activities is available on the
Company's website: www.tullettprebon.com
Overview
The strong financial results for 2009 reflect the robustness of the business
and the value of the service that it provides to participants in the world's
over-the-counter ("OTC") financial markets, as well as the benefits of the
investments made in increasing the scale and breadth of the business and the
actions taken to control costs.
Activity in many of the markets in which we operate was lower during 2009 than
2008, particularly in the second half when activity in 2008 was boosted by the
upheaval in financial markets following the collapse of Lehman Brothers.
Revenue of £947.7m is slightly higher than reported for 2008, with lower
underlying revenue due to reduced levels of market activity offset by more
favourable translation exchange rates for our North American and Asian
operations. Operating profit of £170.8m is £4.3m lower than for 2008,
reflecting a reduction in operating margin. Given that there is some
operational leverage in the business, operating margins are adversely affected
by lower levels of underlying revenue, but at 18.0% for 2009 are only a little
lower than the 18.6% for 2008. This reflects the active management of our
front office costs, the benefit of the actions taken at the end of 2008 to
reduce fixed support costs, and strong management control.
There has been significant structural change in the banking industry and
adjustments to the business models of many of our customers following the
unprecedented events in the world's financial markets during 2008, including a
reduction in risk appetite and financial sector leverage. This has resulted in
a move of capital away from more complex structured products towards the more
traditional 'flow' products, towards cash products rather than derivatives, and
towards first derivatives rather than complex secondary and tertiary
derivatives. Volumes in emerging markets products, volatility products and
equity related products have been particularly affected. The majority of our
business, however, is in the more traditional 'flow' products of foreign
exchange and interest rate swaps - although volumes were also generally lower
in these areas than in 2008 - and in government bonds and corporate bonds -
where the level of activity during the year was supported by high levels of
issuance.
The wholesale OTC markets are critical to the effective functioning of the
world's financial system. Tullett Prebon, as the world's second largest
inter-dealer broker ("IDB"), has a vital role in facilitating trading in these
markets by finding and creating liquidity through price and volume discovery,
and by providing clients with anonymity in their trading activities.
Politicians and regulators continue to debate the various proposals put forward
in both the US and Europe to improve the efficiency and robustness of OTC
derivatives markets - our own views on these matters are articulated below. We
believe that the effective and efficient operation of OTC markets will continue
to rely on intermediaries to provide liquidity and appropriate infrastructure
to facilitate trading and risk management, and our expertise and depth of
liquidity pools make us well positioned to continue to provide valuable support
to our clients and to take advantage of opportunities that these proposals
create.
Our strategy is to continue to focus on providing services as an intermediary
in wholesale OTC markets, and to continue to build a business with the scale
and breadth to deliver superior performance and returns, whilst maintaining
strong financial management disciplines.
The business is well diversified across both products and geographies and our
performance in 2009 has benefited from the investments made in the last two
years in increasing the scale and breadth of the business. In particular, our
business in Europe has benefited from the investments made in Credit through
both broker hires and the launch of an electronic broking platform, and in
Energy through the acquisitions of Primex and Aspen. Some of the emerging
markets offer significant opportunities as their wholesale financial markets
continue to develop and in October 2009 we announced that we had reached
agreement to acquire Convencao, one of the leading and most well respected
interdealer brokers in Brazil, marking our entry to the on-shore Latin American
market. The acquisition is conditional on approval from the Brazilian
authorities, including the Central Bank of Brazil, and is expected to complete
in the second quarter of 2010.
We have continued to develop our electronic capabilities and market share. Our
focus is on the 'hybrid' model under which electronic platforms build upon and
support the business' excellent voice broking franchise and high level
technology to create a set of tools that enable our brokers to provide a full
broking service to meet client demand. We have a growing suite of efficient
and stable electronic platforms which are competitive with similar platforms
provided by our peers.
In addition, we are developing our post trade risk management services. In
response to client demand we have extended the coverage of TP Match, our FRA
matching platform, to all major currencies in multiple tenors, enabling clients
in all three regions to reduce their interest rate risk. The recently
announced acquisition of OTC Valuations will complement our Information Sales
business and will allow us to meet the increasing demand for independent
valuation services. Revenues from our established Information Sales activities
together with 'hybrid' revenues from products that have established electronic
execution capability now represent approximately one-sixth of the group's total
revenue.
Between August and December 2009, 77 brokers on certain desks in our North
American business resigned following a raid on the business by BGC. Although
these brokers did generate substantial revenue, actions are being taken to
strengthen the management and organisation of our North American business,
including replacing staff. We have hired new senior management to lead our
credit and mortgage backed securities activities and are making progress in
recruiting brokers in these and other affected areas. Legal action is being
taken against BGC and former employees in the US and also in London, and
against former employees in Hong Kong who have unlawfully terminated their
employment with us in order to join BGC, following raids earlier in the year on
our London and Hong Kong businesses.
Our key financial and performance indicators for 2009 compared with those for
2008 are summarised in the table below.
Change
2009 2008
Constant
Reported Exchange
Rates
Revenue £947.7m £943.6m + 0% -9%
Operating profit £170.8m £175.1m -2% -11%
Operating margin 18.0% 18.6% -0.6% points
Broker headcount (year end) 1,612 1,653 -2%
Average revenue per broker (£'000) 565 548 + 3% -7%
Broker employment costs : broking 58.0% 57.5% + 0.5% points
revenue
Non-broker headcount (year end) 824 889 -7%
Reported revenue in 2009 of £947.7m was slightly higher than 2008, and was 9%
lower at constant exchange rates. Year end broker headcount was 2% lower, and
average revenue per broker at £565k was 7% lower at constant exchange rates.
The reduction in broker headcount reflects the impact of the cost reduction
action taken at the end of 2008 and the decline in headcount in North America
due to the defection of the brokers in the second half of the year, which has
offset increased headcount in Europe and Asia Pacific.
Reported operating profit for 2009 of £170.8m is 2% lower than in 2008 and is
11% lower at constant exchange rates. The operating margin has reduced by 0.6%
points to 18.0%. The objectives of the cost reduction action undertaken
towards the end of 2008 to increase flexibility in front office costs and to
reduce absolute support costs have been delivered. Broker compensation as a
percentage of broking revenue has, however, increased by 0.5% points to 58.0%,
driven by increases in North America and Asia due to inefficiencies in certain
desks as a result of revenue declines, and generally increased costs of
employment across the business as a result of competitive pressures. Support
costs have been significantly reduced, driven by reductions in headcount.
Non-broker headcount of 824 at the end of 2009 is 7% lower than at the end of
2008 and 13% lower than at June 2008.
Operating Review
The tables below analyse revenue and operating profit for 2009 compared with
2008. A significant proportion of the group's activity is conducted outside
the UK and the reported results are therefore impacted by the movement in the
foreign exchange rates used to translate the results of non-UK operations. In
order to give a more meaningful analysis of performance, revenue and operating
profit growth rates for 2009 shown below are presented both as reported, and
calculated using translation exchange rates for 2008 consistent with those used
for 2009. The commentary below refers to growth rates at constant exchange
rates.
Revenue by product group
Change
Constant
2009 2008 Reported Exchange
£m £m Rates
Treasury Products 238.9 246.1 -3% -12%
Interest Rate Derivatives 192.0 220.9 -13% -22%
Fixed Income 317.1 282.1 +12% +2%
Equities 74.0 94.2 -21% -29%
Energy 100.6 81.5 +23% +13%
Information Sales and Risk Management 25.1 18.8 +34% +32%
Services
947.7 943.6 +0% -9%
Revenue in many product areas was lower in 2009 than in 2008, reflecting the
lower activity in the markets, particularly during the second half, when
revenue in 2008 was boosted by the exceptional levels of volatility during the
height of the financial crisis.
Within Treasury Products, which covers FX and cash, the reduction in revenue is
most marked in FX options and in emerging market FX forwards, including
non-deliverable forwards, reflecting the reduction in risk appetite and capital
deployed in those areas.
Similarly, within Interest Rate Derivatives, the reduction in market activity
in the product areas of interest rate options and emerging market interest rate
swaps was more marked than the reduction in G7 currency interest rate swaps.
The growth in revenue in Fixed Income reflects the strength of our franchise in
this area, and the high volume of activity in government and corporate bonds in
both Europe and North America, especially in the first half. Activity in credit
derivatives in both regions has suffered due to regulatory uncertainty, and in
North America revenue in the last quarter was affected by the broker
departures.
In Equities, revenue from both equity derivatives and cash equities was lower
reflecting lower equity market values and lower activity.
Commodity markets have continued to be volatile and our Energy business has
benefited from this and from the increased depth and breadth of the business
from the acquisitions of Primex and Aspen enhancing our presence and liquidity
in a wide range of oil products.
Our Information Sales business has continued to benefit from increasing
customer demand for both real time and end of day data and from an expansion of
the customer base. In addition, our post trade Risk Management Services have
grown strongly following the extension of the product and geographic coverage
of TP Match.
Revenue by region
Change
Constant
2009 2008 Reported Exchange
£m £m Rates
Europe 542.6 504.1 +8% +7%
North America 318.0 339.6 -6% -23%
Asia Pacific 87.1 99.9 -13% -30%
947.7 943.6 +0% -9%
Europe
Revenue in Europe has increased by 7%. Broker headcount in Europe at 788 is 4%
higher than a year ago and average revenue per broker has increased by 3%. The
business has delivered strong growth in revenue in Fixed Income and Energy,
benefiting from buoyant markets and the investments made in these areas over
the last two years. Revenue in Treasury Products and Interest Rate Derivatives
has been affected by lower activity in emerging market products. The Equities
business, which is the smallest product group in Europe, is mainly focused on
equity derivatives which have suffered from both lower equity market values and
lower volumes.
In Fixed Income we have maintained our leading position in government bonds and
have re-established our presence and gained market share in corporate bonds and
credit derivatives following the actions taken in 2008, including the highly
successful launch of tpCREDITDEAL, our electronic platform. The region's
Energy business has benefited from the expansion of coverage of a wide range of
oil products through the acquisitions in 2008 of Primex and Aspen, and from the
investments made in establishing a presence in new products including
emissions, bio-fuels and coal.
North America
In North America, revenue fell by 23%. Year end broker headcount at 468 is 14%
lower than at the end of 2008 due to the rationalisation and closure of
marginal desks during the year and the broker departures in the last quarter.
Average revenue per broker has also fallen compared with 2008 due to the
generally lower levels of activity in most products, with the reduction in
activity most marked in emerging market products, volatility products and cash
equities.
Fixed Income continues to be the largest product group in the region and
revenue in this area slowed significantly in the second half following a
buoyant start to the year, with the market in credit derivatives particularly
hit. In most other product areas the performance relative to 2008 was stronger
in the second half than in the first half.
Asia
Our business in Asia is predominantly focused on Treasury Products and Interest
Rate Derivatives, which account for 90% of the region's revenue. We have
maintained our market share in our major products across the region but market
activity was low throughout the year and revenue fell by 30%, with average
revenue per broker 25% lower and average broker headcount also down. Revenue
run rates began to stabilise during the second half and revenue in the last two
months of the year was higher than in 2008.
Although the three largest centres in the region, Singapore, Hong Kong and
Tokyo, continue to account for over 80% of the region's revenue, we have well
established businesses in several other Asia Pacific financial centres,
including our joint venture in Shanghai. The Energy business in the region has
increased in scale with the addition of Aspen's Singapore based team, and we
have established a securities business in Tokyo to provide brokerage services,
initially in equity derivatives, which was granted its license and commenced
operations in February 2010. Year end broker headcount in Asia at 356 is 2%
higher than at the end of 2008. We are well positioned to benefit from the
region's return to growth.
Operating profit by region (1)
Change
Constant
2009 2008 Reported Exchange
£m £m Rates
Europe 123.2 108.1 +14% +13%
North America 44.4 57.8 -23% -37%
Asia Pacific 3.2 9.2 -65% -72%
Reported 170.8 175.1 -2% -11%
Operating margin by region (1) 2009 2008
Europe 22.7% 21.4%
North America 14.0% 17.0%
Asia Pacific 3.7% 9.2%
18.0% 18.6%
Note 1. Operating profit and operating margin for 2008 are stated before
exceptional items.
Operating profit in Europe has increased by 13%, with the operating margin
increasing to 22.7%. The increased operating margin in Europe primarily
reflects the increased scale of the business and the actions taken to reduce
both front office and support costs. Broker employment costs as a percentage
of revenue have reduced compared with 2008 reflecting the benefit from the
actions taken at the end of that year, and the elimination of the
inefficiencies experienced during 2008 resulting from the large number of
brokers who joined the business building up to their full run rate of revenues.
Operating profit in North America has reduced by 37% and the operating margin
has fallen to 14.0% mainly due to the reduction in revenue. Support costs have
been reduced, but represent a higher percentage of revenue in 2009 than in
2008. Broker employment costs as a percentage of revenue also increased during
the year due to inefficiencies in certain desks as a result of revenue
declines, together with increased costs of employment in the light of
competitor action.
The business in Asia Pacific has a higher level of operational gearing than the
other two regions due to the relatively high level of fixed support costs
incurred in maintaining a presence across a number of centres. Operating
profit in Asia has been driven lower by the reduction in revenue with the
operating margin falling to 3.7%. Broker employment costs as a percentage of
revenue have increased due to the combination of revenue declines and
increasing competition.
Financial Review
The results for 2009 compared with those for 2008 are shown in the table below.
2009 2008
£m £m
Revenue 947.7 943.6
Operating profit (1) 170.8 175.1
Cash finance expense (13.8) (19.7)
Adjusted Profit before tax (2) 157.0 155.4
Tax (53.0) (56.0)
Associates 1.8 1.3
Minority interests (0.6) (0.5)
Adjusted Earnings (3) 105.2 100.2
Weighted average number of shares 213.9m 212.8m
Adjusted Earnings per share 49.2p 47.1p
Note 1. Operating profit for 2008 is stated before exceptional items
Note 2. Adjusted PBT reconciles to reported PBT as follows: 2009 2008
£m £m
Adjusted Profit before tax 157.0 155.4
Exceptional items - (19.5)
Non cash finance (expense)/income (0.5) 1.1
Reported Profit before tax 156.5 137.0
Note 3. Adjusted Earnings reconciles to reported Earnings 2009 2008
as follows:
£m £m
Adjusted Earnings 105.2 100.2
Exceptional items - (19.5)
Tax relief on exceptional items - 5.8
Non cash finance (expense)/income (0.5) 1.1
Deferred tax on non cash finance (expense)/income 0.2 (0.4)
Prior year tax items 5.9 7.3
Reported Earnings 110.8 94.5
Finance Income/(Expense)
The cash finance expense primarily comprises the interest payable on the fixed
rate bonds and the floating rate bank debt, partly offset by the interest
income on cash deposits. The reduction in cash finance expense in 2009
compared to 2008 reflects the lower average amount of bank debt outstanding and
the net benefit of lower interest rates, with the reduction in interest payable
on the bank debt greater than the reduction in yield on the cash balances.
Non cash finance income/(expense) items are excluded from adjusted profit
before tax and adjusted earnings. These items comprise the mark to market
movements on derivative financial instruments held at fair value through profit
and loss, the amortisation of discount on deferred consideration and the
expected return and interest on pension scheme assets and liabilities. In 2008
the pension related items netted to a credit of £1.6m, in 2009 these items
netted to a charge of £0.5m.
Tax
The effective rate of tax on adjusted profit before tax is 33.8% (2008:
36.0%). The reduction in the effective rate compared with 2008 results
primarily from the increase in the proportion of taxable profits generated in
the UK relative to the US, together with the full year benefit of last year's
reduction in the UK statutory rate.
Tax charges and credits arising on non cash finance income/(expense) items and
prior year tax items are excluded from the calculation of the effective tax
rate on adjusted profit before tax. Prior year tax items primarily reflect the
release of tax provisions made in previous years as tax matters are settled,
and do not relate to current trading.
Adjusted Basic EPS
Adjusted Basic EPS is calculated using adjusted earnings shown in the table
above and the undiluted weighted average number of shares in issue of 213.9m
(2008: 212.8m).
Exchange and Hedging
The income statements of the group's non-UK operations are translated into
sterling at average exchange rates. The most significant exchange rates for
the group are the US dollar, the Euro, the Singapore dollar and the Japanese
Yen. The group's current policy is not to hedge income statement translation
exposure.
The balance sheets of the group's non-UK operations are translated into
sterling using year end exchange rates. The major balance sheet translation
exposure is to the US dollar. Until October 2008, the group had designated a
cross currency interest rate swap as a net investment hedge of US$117m of the
US dollar denominated net assets. At that time the group decided to
discontinue the hedging of this balance sheet translation exposure. The swap
was therefore de-designated as a net investment hedge and a forward FX contract
was executed to close out the FX position inherent in the swap. Both the cross
currency interest rate swap and the forward FX contract matured in August
2009.
Average and year end exchange rates used in the preparation of the financial
statements are shown below.
Average Year End
2009 2008 2009 2008
US dollar $1.55 $1.89 $1.61 $1.44
Euro €1.12 €1.28 €1.13 €1.03
Singapore dollar S$2.26 S$2.65 S$2.27 S$2.08
Japanese Yen ¥145 ¥198 ¥150 ¥130
Cash flow and financing
Cash flow before dividends and debt repayments and draw downs is summarised in
the table below.
2009 2008
£m £m
Operating profit (1) 170.8 175.1
Share based compensation (0.4) 4.9
Depreciation and amortisation 8.2 7.8
EBITDA 178.6 187.8
Capital expenditure (net of disposals) (9.4) (14.9)
Working capital (31.3) 20.2
Operating cash flow 137.9 193.1
Exceptional items - restructuring cash payments (6.8) (1.4)
Interest (11.7) (18.8)
Maturity of derivative financial instruments (10.0) -
Taxation (30.4) (39.1)
Defined benefit pension scheme funding (8.1) (3.2)
ESOT transactions 1.5 -
Dividends received from associates/(paid) to minorities 1.2 (0.5)
Acquisitions/investments (3.5) (3.9)
Cash flow 70.1 126.2
Note 1. Operating profit for 2008 is stated before exceptional items
In 2009 the group has delivered a substantial operating cash flow, representing
more than 80% of operating profit. The working capital outflow of £31.3m in
2009 reflects the unwind of the inflow in 2008 which was due to the unusually
high levels of bonus accruals at the end of that year as a result of the high
level of activity in the second half, and an increase in the broker sign-on
prepayment balance. Net capital expenditure of £9.4m mainly relates to
investment in electronic platforms and office fit-out work, including a new
data centre in New Jersey, and was slightly higher than depreciation and
amortisation.
The exceptional items cash payments of £6.8m in 2009 represent the completion
of the cash outflows arising from the cost reduction actions taken at the end
of 2008.
Interest payments in 2009 were lower than in 2008, in line with the lower
profit and loss charge.
The maturity of derivative financial instruments, primarily the cross currency
interest rate swap and the forward FX contract executed to close out the FX
position inherent in the swap, resulted in a net cash outflow of £10.0m.
Tax payments in 2009 were lower than in 2008 mainly due to the increase in the
proportion of the 2009 tax charge arising in the UK, where half of the
liability is paid in the following year.
The group makes regular contributions to its defined benefit pension schemes to
match the benefits paid and scheme expenses, and in January 2009 paid an
additional £4.5m of contributions under agreements with the trustees of the
schemes aimed at eliminating the actuarial deficits by 31 December 2010.
Additional contributions of £4.5m have also been made in January 2010.
Expenditure on acquisitions and investments in 2009 mainly comprises deferred
consideration payments relating to Chapdelaine and Primex.
The movement in cash and debt is summarised below.
£m Cash Debt Net
At 31 December 2008 405.2 (422.6) (17.4)
Cash flow 70.1 - 70.1
Dividends (27.8) - (27.8)
Debt repayments / draw downs (33.6) 33.6 -
Debt issue costs (2.5) 2.5 -
Effect of movement in exchange rates (15.2) 0.3 (14.9)
Movements in fair value / amortisation of - (1.0) (1.0)
costs
At 31 December 2009 396.2 (387.2) 9.0
At 31 December 2009 the group held cash, cash equivalents and other financial
assets of £396.2m which exceeded the debt outstanding by £9.0m.
On 6 July 2009 holders of £141.1m of the group's Eurobond due August 2014
exchanged their holdings for the same amount of new notes due July 2016. The
group's borrowings at 31 December 2009 comprised these new notes, the remaining
£8.8m of the Eurobond due August 2014, £240m drawn under the amortising bank
term loan facility, and a small amount of finance leases. The term loan is
subject to repayments of £30m in each of January 2010 and January 2011, with £
180m maturing in January 2012.
Pensions
The group has two defined benefit pension schemes in the UK which were acquired
with Tullett and Prebon, both of which are closed to new members and future
accrual.
The combined deficit of these schemes under IAS19 has reduced to £1.3m at 31
December 2009 (2008: £8.5m). During 2009 the schemes' assets have increased
from £106.9m to £137.7m reflecting strong investment returns and the additional
contributions, and the schemes' liabilities have increased from £115.4m to £
139.0m mainly reflecting a reduction in the discount rate applied to the
schemes' liabilities.
Return on capital employed
The return on capital employed in 2009 was 47% (2008: 50%) which has been
calculated as operating profit divided by average shareholders' funds less net
funds or plus net debt as appropriate, and adding back cumulative amortised
goodwill and post tax reorganisation costs and exceptional items.
Regulatory Developments
Various proposals aimed at strengthening the financial system generally, and
the operation of the OTC derivatives markets specifically, continue to be
debated by regulators and politicians in both the United States and Europe.
There are three common objectives of the proposals directed at the OTC
derivatives markets:
- A reduction in operational risk through increased standardisation of contracts
and increased use of electronic post trade processing,
- A reduction in counterparty risk through increased use of central
counterparties (CCPs) and higher collateralisation and capital charges for
bilateral contracts, and
- An increase in transparency through increased use of electronic trading
platforms and increased pre and post trade reporting and use of trade
repositories.
The proposals directed at reducing the systemic risk of individual financial
institutions seek to do so through, amongst other matters, introducing
increased capital and liquidity requirements, specific tax disincentives or
levies, and restrictions on activities.
It is difficult at this stage to accurately judge how or when these proposals
will be implemented or to estimate the effect that these proposals will have on
the level of overall activity in the OTC markets. We are, however, confident
that vibrant OTC markets will remain essential to the effective operation of
the world's financial system, and that the role of intermediaries in those
markets, creating liquidity and facilitating efficient trading and risk
management, will be of increasing importance.
There remain a number of misconceptions about the proposals and their potential
impact on OTC markets, how trading is undertaken, and how well positioned
individual inter-dealer brokers and other trading venues are to respond and
benefit. We put forward the following views.
It is neither practical nor desirable for all OTC derivatives to become
standardised. One of the primary reasons that OTC markets exist is because of
the need for financial institutions and end-users to manage their risks through
bespoke contracts. Restricting the range of products that are available to
manage risk positions would be counter productive to improving the strength of
the financial system or the economy.
Those OTC derivatives that are deemed to be standard will not all migrate to
trading on exchanges. The proposals in both Europe and the US allow for
standardised OTC derivatives to be traded on venues other than exchanges,
including Multilateral Trading Facilities in Europe (which our existing
electronic platforms in the region are registered as), and Alternative Swap
Execution Facilities in the US, the current definition of which covers our
operations. In addition it is not universally accepted that mandating trading
on organised markets is appropriate. In the UK the FSA argue that such a move
would be detrimental and that the regulatory objectives can be achieved by
other means.
It is inconceivable that OTC derivatives trading will all move onto pure
electronic platforms. Pure electronic platforms, without intervention or
support from brokers, are suitable only for the very few highly liquid and
highly standardised OTC products, and these are already transacted on such
platforms. The role of voice broking in providing liquidity will continue to
be required in all but the most standardised of products. The hybrid model in
electronic broking, under which electronic solutions operate together with and
alongside voice brokers, is much more suitable for the majority of OTC
derivatives products. Hybrid platforms have evolved from voice broking and the
provision of pricing and volume data into execution platforms and we believe
that the process of "electronification" in OTC derivatives markets will
continue to be evolutionary.
It is not plausible that all OTC derivatives will move to being cleared through
a CCP. Moves to central counterparty clearing transfer rather than eliminate
risk, and it is essential that CCPs are able to manage the risks effectively.
Some products are unsuitable for central counterparty clearing and we agree
with the FSA that CCPs should not be forced to clear a product if they are
unable to manage the risks of doing so. Nor does it follow that if an OTC
derivative product is cleared by a CCP it will no longer be voice brokered.
Interest rate swaps in the inter bank market have been successfully cleared
through SwapClear since 1999 with over 60% of all inter-dealer swap volumes now
cleared through this facility. Interest rate swaps remain one of the largest
voice brokered OTC products.
The OTC markets and the inter-dealer broker sector are not synonymous. The
majority of OTC transactions are undertaken directly between banks and other
counterparties. The proportion of the total market volume that is transacted
through IDBs appears to be increasing. We believe that this trend is likely to
continue as banks seek to gain the benefits of accessing deep liquidity and
trading anonymously, as well as facilitating reductions in their fixed costs,
that are achieved by executing trades through IDBs.
Outlook
Although the world's financial markets have remained unsettled, overall
activity in the markets slowed in the second half of 2009 in comparison to the
particularly volatile markets experienced in the autumn of 2008 and into the
first half of last year and, as expected, activity currently remains at this
more normal level.
The underlying revenue run rate in the first two months of the year is 5% lower
than a year ago at constant exchange rates. We expect this run rate against
prior year to improve, particularly in the second half. In addition, the net
effect of the broker defections in North America has been to reduce revenue by
6%. The benefit from the actions that we have taken to mitigate the impact of
the broker defections will increase during the year as the rebuilding programme
continues and the new brokers hired build up to their full run rate of revenue.
The eventual outcome of the regulatory debate about how to strengthen the
financial system remains uncertain, but we are confident that our role as an
intermediary in the OTC markets will continue to be vital and that our business
will continue to add significant value to our customers. We have a well
diversified and robust business, and we are well positioned to respond to and
to benefit from, changes in the way in which the OTC markets and our customers
operate and are regulated.
Consolidated Income Statement
for the year ended 31 December 2009
Notes 2009 2008
£m £m
Revenue 3 947.7 943.6
Administrative expenses (781.2) (774.1)
Other operating income 4 4.3 5.6
Exceptional items 5 - (19.5)
Operating profit 170.8 155.6
Finance income 6 20.2 24.8
Finance costs 7 (34.5) (43.4)
Profit before tax 156.5 137.0
Taxation (46.9) (43.3)
Profit of consolidated companies 109.6 93.7
Share of results of associates 1.8 1.3
Profit for the year 111.4 95.0
Attributable to:
Equity holders of the parent 110.8 94.5
Minority interests 0.6 0.5
111.4 95.0
Earnings per share
Basic 8 51.8p 44.4p
Diluted 8 51.2p 44.0p
Adjusted earnings per share is disclosed in note 8
Consolidated Statement of Comprehensive Income
for the year ended 31 December 2009
2009 2008
£m £m
Profit for the year 111.4 95.0
Other comprehensive income:
Revaluation of available-for-sale assets 0.9 0.5
Gain/(loss) on net investment hedge 2.5 (17.2)
Effect of changes in exchange rates on translation of (17.2) 46.5
foreign operations
Actuarial losses on defined benefit pension schemes (0.5) (9.4)
Taxation (charge)/credit on components of other (1.9) 9.7
comprehensive income
Other comprehensive income for the year (16.2) 30.1
Total comprehensive income for the year 95.2 125.1
Attributable to:
Equity holders of the parent 94.9 123.6
Minority interests 0.3 1.5
95.2 125.1
Consolidated Balance Sheet
as at 31 December 2009
2009 2008
£m £m
Non-current assets
Goodwill 373.5 387.7
Other intangible assets 7.4 5.8
Property, plant and equipment 25.6 27.6
Interest in associates 3.5 3.5
Other financial assets 4.8 4.7
Deferred tax assets 13.7 18.0
428.5 447.3
Current assets
Trade and other receivables 5,765.0 13,547.6
Other financial assets 30.1 30.2
Cash and cash equivalents 366.1 375.0
Derivative financial instruments - 4.6
6,161.2 13,957.4
Total assets 6,589.7 14,404.7
Current liabilities
Trade and other payables (5,825.5) (13,648.5)
Interest bearing loans and borrowings (30.2) (30.6)
Derivative financial instruments - (14.3)
Current tax liabilities (36.7) (28.9)
Short term provisions (1.5) (2.2)
(5,893.9) (13,724.5)
Net current assets 267.3 232.9
Non-current liabilities
Interest bearing loans and borrowings (357.0) (392.0)
Retirement benefit obligations (1.3) (8.5)
Deferred tax liabilities (8.1) (0.6)
Long term provisions (7.8) (9.7)
Other long term payables (9.1) (24.9)
(383.3) (435.7)
Total liabilities (6,277.2) (14,160.2)
Net assets 312.5 244.5
Equity
Share capital 53.8 53.8
Share premium 9.9 9.9
Reverse acquisition reserve (1,182.3) (1,182.3)
Other reserves 128.6 139.9
Retained earnings 1,300.3 1,220.8
Equity attributable to equity holders of the parent 310.3 242.1
Minority interests 2.2 2.4
Total equity 312.5 244.5
Consolidated Statement of Changes in Equity
for the year ended 31 December 2009
Equity attributable to equity holders of the parent
Share Reverse Re- Hedging
Share premium acquisition valuation Merger and Own Retained Minority Total
capital account reserve reserve reserve translation shares earnings Total interests equity
£m £m £m £m £m £m £m £m £m £m £m
Balance at
1 January
2009 53.8 9.9 (1,182.3) 1.4 121.5 23.9 (6.9) 1,220.8 242.1 2.4 244.5
Profit for
the year 110.8 110.8 0.6 111.4
Other
comprehensive
income for
the year 0.9 (16.3) (0.5) (15.9) (0.3) (16.2)
Total
comprehensive
income - - - 0.9 - (16.3) - 110.3 94.9 0.3 95.2
Dividends
paid in the
year (27.8) (27.8) (0.7) (28.5)
Sale of own
shares 2.6 (1.1) 1.5 1.5
Shares used
to meet share
award
exercises 1.5 (1.5) - -
Increase in
minorities'
equity
interests - 0.2 0.2
Debit arising
on
share-based
payment
awards (0.4) (0.4) (0.4)
Balance at
31 December
2009 53.8 9.9 (1,182.3) 2.3 121.5 7.6 (2.8) 1,300.3 310.3 2.2 312.5
Balance at
1 January
2008 53.2 - (1,182.3) 0.9 121.5 (4.4) (20.7) 1,162.1 130.3 2.1 132.4
Profit for
the year 94.5 94.5 0.5 95.0
Other
comprehensive
income for
the year 0.5 28.3 0.3 29.1 1.0 30.1
Total
comprehensive
income - - - 0.5 - 28.3 - 94.8 123.6 1.5 125.1
Issue of
share capital 0.6 9.9 10.5 10.5
Dividends
paid in the
year (27.2) (27.2) (1.2) (28.4)
Shares used
to meet share
award
exercises 13.8 (13.8) - -
Credit
arising on
share-based
payment
awards 4.9 4.9 4.9
Balance at
31 December
2008 53.8 9.9 (1,182.3) 1.4 121.5 23.9 (6.9) 1,220.8 242.1 2.4 244.5
Consolidated Cash Flow Statement
for the year ended 31 December 2009
Notes 2009 2008
£m £m
Net cash from operating activities 10(a) 85.3 136.0
Investing activities
(Purchase)/sale of other financial assets (0.8) 0.9
Interest received 5.0 11.5
Dividends from associates 1.9 0.5
Purchase of available-for-sale assets (0.1) (0.1)
Purchase of intangible fixed assets (4.1) (3.4)
Purchase of property, plant and equipment (5.2) (13.2)
Proceeds on disposal of property, plant and equipment 0.2 -
Investment in subsidiaries (3.4) (3.8)
Net cash used in investment activities (6.5) (7.6)
Financing activities
Dividends paid 9 (27.8) (27.2)
Dividends paid to minority interests (0.7) (1.0)
Sale of own shares 1.5 -
Repayment of debt (30.1) (30.1)
Repayment of obligations under finance leases (3.7) (0.3)
Eurobond issue costs (2.5) -
Payments relating to net investment hedges (12.5) -
Receipts relating to net investment hedges 2.5 -
Net cash used in financing activities (73.3) (58.6)
Net increase in cash and cash equivalents 5.5 69.8
Net cash and cash equivalents at the beginning of the
year 374.9 262.1
Effect of foreign exchange rate changes (14.3) 43.0
Net cash and cash equivalents at the end of the year 366.1 374.9
Cash and cash equivalents 366.1 375.0
Overdrafts - (0.1)
Net cash and cash equivalents 366.1 374.9
Notes to the Consolidated Financial Statements
for the year ended 31 December 2009
1. General information
Tullett Prebon plc is a company incorporated in England and Wales under the
Companies Act.
2. Basis of preparation of accounts
Basis of accounting
The financial information included in this document does not constitute the
Group's statutory accounts for the years ended 31 December 2009 or 2008, but is
derived from those accounts. Statutory accounts for 2008 have been delivered to
the Registrar of Companies and those for 2009 will be delivered following the
Company's annual general meeting. The auditors have reported on those accounts;
their reports were unqualified and did not contain statements under sections
237(2) or 237(3) of the Companies Act 1985 nor sections 498(2) or 498(3) of the
Companies Act 2006.
The financial statements have been prepared on the historical cost basis,
except for the revaluation of certain financial instruments.
The Directors have a reasonable expectation that the Group has adequate
resources to continue in operational existence for the foreseeable future.
Accordingly, these financial statements continue to be prepared on the going
concern basis.
Basis of consolidation
The consolidated financial statements incorporate the financial statements of
the Company and entities controlled by the Company made up to 31 December each
year. Control is achieved where the Company has the power to govern the
financial and operating policies of an investee enterprise so as to obtain
benefits from its activities.
3. Segmental analysis
Analysis by geographical segment
2009 2008
£m £m
Revenue
Europe 542.6 504.1
North America 318.0 339.6
Asia Pacific 87.1 99.9
947.7 943.6
Operating profit
Europe 123.2 108.1
North America 44.4 57.8
Asia Pacific 3.2 9.2
Operating profit before exceptional items 170.8 175.1
Exceptional items (note 5) - (19.5)
Reported operating profit 170.8 155.6
Finance income 20.2 24.8
Finance costs (34.5) (43.4)
Profit before tax 156.5 137.0
Taxation (46.9) (43.3)
Profit of consolidated companies 109.6 93.7
Share of results of associates 1.8 1.3
Profit for the year 111.4 95.0
There are no inter-segment sales included in segment revenue.
4. Other operating income
Other operating income represents receipts such as rental income, royalties,
insurance proceeds, settlements from competitors, profit on asset disposals and
business relocation grants. Costs associated with such items are included in
administrative expenses.
5. Exceptional items
The exceptional items in 2008 reflected the cost of actions taken to reduce
operating costs, including the costs of desk closures, redundancies and the
write down of sign-on payments which were considered to be impaired.
6. Finance income
2009 2008
£m £m
Interest receivable and similar income 3.4 11.5
Fair value gain on derivative instruments 9.0 4.6
Expected return on pension schemes' assets 6.5 8.7
Amortisation of discount on deferred consideration 1.3 -
20.2 24.8
7. Finance costs
2009 2008
£m £m
Interest payable on bank loans 4.6 17.2
Interest payable on Eurobond 11.5 12.4
Other interest payable 0.2 0.3
Amortisation of debt issue costs 0.9 1.4
Total borrowing costs 17.2 31.3
Amortisation of discount on deferred consideration - 0.5
Fair value loss on derivative instruments 10.3 4.5
Interest cost on pension schemes' liabilities 7.0 7.1
34.5 43.4
8. Earnings per share
2009 2008
Adjusted basic 49.2p 47.1p
Basic 51.8p 44.4p
Diluted 51.2p 44.0p
The calculation of basic and diluted earnings per share is based on the
following number of shares in issue:
2009 2008
No. No.
(m) (m)
Weighted average shares in issue used for
calculating basic and adjusted basic earnings
per share 213.9 212.8
Contingently issuable shares 1.8 0.6
Issuable on exercise of options 0.7 1.3
Diluted weighted average shares in issue 216.4 214.7
The earnings used in the calculation of adjusted, basic and diluted earnings
per share, are as described below:
2009 2008
£m £m
Earnings 111.4 95.0
Minority interests (0.6) (0.5)
Earnings for calculating basic and diluted earnings per share 110.8 94.5
Exceptional items - 19.5
Expected return on pension schemes' assets (6.5) (8.7)
Interest cost on pension schemes' liabilities 7.0 7.1
Amortisation of discount on deferred consideration (1.3) 0.5
Fair value movement on derivative financial instruments 1.3 -
Tax on above items (0.2) (5.4)
Prior year tax (5.9) (7.3)
Adjusted earnings for calculating adjusted basic
earnings per share 105.2 100.2
9. Dividends
2009 2008
£m £m
Amounts recognised as distributions to equity holders in the
year:
Interim dividend for the year ended 31 December 2009 of 5.0p per 10.7 -
share
Final dividend for the year ended 31 December 2008 of 8.0p per 17.1 -
share
Interim dividend for the year ended 31 December 2008 of 4.75p - 10.2
per share
Final dividend for the year ended 31 December 2007 of 8.0p per - 17.0
share
27.8 27.2
In respect of the current year, the directors propose that the final dividend
of 10.0p per share amounting to £21.4m will be paid on 20 May 2010 to all
shareholders on the Register of Members on 30 April 2010. This dividend is
subject to approval by shareholders at the AGM and has not been included as a
liability in these financial statements.
The trustees of the Tullett Prebon plc Employee Share Ownership Trust and the
trustees of Tullett Prebon plc Employee Benefit Trust 2007 have waived their
rights to dividends.
10. Notes to the cash flow statement
(a) Reconciliation of operating profit to net cash from operating activities
2009 2008
£m £m
Operating profit 170.8 155.6
Adjustments for:
Share-based compensation (0.4) 4.9
Profit on sale of other non-current financial assets - (1.3)
Loss on sale of property, plant and equipment - 2.0
Depreciation of property, plant and equipment 6.1 6.5
Amortisation of intangible assets 2.1 1.3
Decrease in provisions for liabilities and charges (1.8) (5.4)
Outflow from retirement benefit obligations (8.1) (3.2)
Increase in non-current liabilities 0.7 0.7
Operating cash flows before movement in working capital 169.4 161.1
Decrease in trade and other receivables 4.4 13.1
(Increase) / decrease in net settlement balances (0.2) 5.1
(Decrease) / increase in trade and other payables (41.2) 26.1
Cash generated from operations 132.4 205.4
Income taxes paid (30.4) (39.1)
Interest paid (16.7) (30.3)
Net cash from operating activities 85.3 136.0
(b) Cash and cash equivalents
Cash and cash equivalents comprise cash at bank and other short term highly
liquid investments with maturity of three months or less. Cash at bank earns
interest at floating rates based on daily bank deposit rates. Short term
deposits are made for varying periods of between one day and one week depending
on the immediate cash requirements of the Group, and earn interest at the
respective short term deposit rates.
For the purposes of the consolidated cash flow statement, cash and cash
equivalents comprise the following at 31 December:
2009 2008
£m £m
Cash and cash equivalents 366.1 375.0
Bank overdrafts - (0.1)
366.1 374.9
11. Analysis of net funds
At 1 Cash Non-cash Exchange At 31
January flow items differences December
2009 2009
£m £m £m £m £m
Cash 229.6 (27.2) - (12.7) 189.7
Cash equivalents 142.7 32.5 - (1.6) 173.6
Client settlement money 2.7 0.1 - - 2.8
Cash and cash equivalents 375.0 5.4 - (14.3) 366.1
Other current financial 30.2 0.8 - (0.9) 30.1
assets
Total funds 405.2 6.2 - (15.2) 396.2
Overdraft (0.1) 0.1 - - -
Bank loans within one year (30.0) 30.0 (30.0) - (30.0)
Bank loans after one year (238.5) - 29.4 - (209.1)
Loans due after one year (149.8) 2.6 (0.4) - (147.6)
Finance leases (4.2) 3.7 (0.3) 0.3 (0.5)
(422.6) 36.4 (1.3) 0.3 (387.2)
Total net funds (17.4) 42.6 (1.3) (14.9) 9.0
OTHER INFORMATION
The Annual General Meeting of Tullett Prebon plc will be held at Level 37,
Tower 42, 25 Old Broad Street, London EC2N 1HQ on 13 May 2010 at 2.30pm.