Final Results - Part 1
BENCHMARK GROUP PLC
20 September 1999
Part 1
Year Ended 30 June 1999 Audited Results
Benchmark Group PLC ('Benchmark'), the specialist central London
property investment and development company, announces its Audited
Results for the year ended 30 June 1999.
Financial Highlights
* Net asset value per share up 11.1% to 270.5p (1998: 243.4p) -
net assets increased to £326.1m (1998: £293.4m)
* Investment properties revalued as at 30 June 1999 at £374.9m,
resulting in an increase of £24.1m - a 6.9% uplift
* Net rental income for the period £19.5m (1998: £21.5m) -
annualised net rental income (including sales and acquisitions
post the period end) now £23.4m
* Pre tax profit of £15.1m (1998: £19.7m); Post tax profit of
£13.2m (1998: £15.4m)
* Earnings per share of 10.9p (1998: 13.0p) - earnings per share
(excluding profits on disposal of trading and investment
properties) of 8.2p (1998: 8.8p)
* Final dividend of 2.0p recommended - making a total dividend
of 3.75p (1998: 3.5p), an increase of 7.1%
* Net gearing as at 30 June 1999 of 54% (1998: 57%) - net
borrowings £175.9m (1998: £165.8m)
Property Highlights
* £35.3m spent on acquisitions during the year with a further
£81.5m acquired since the year end
* Stated objective of disposing of non-core properties continued
with total sales of £85.9m during the year, providing a net
profit of 5% over book value - further £63.0m of sales since
the year end, providing 5.5% profit over book value at 30 June
1999
* Rent reviews and new lettings added £4.4m pa to the rent roll
* Principal residential development, The Panoramic, now 90% of
units sold with practical completion on target for the end of
September 1999
* Stirling Square - offices (95,000 sq ft) completed 1 September
1999 and now being marketed - 9,115 sq ft already let to KKR at
£65 per sq ft. Residential accommodation (15,500 sq ft) to be
ready by November 1999
* The Belgravia Estate - transport and environmental proposals to
be implemented shortly, listed building consent application to
convert the south side of the Halkin Arcade into a new food
store has been submitted - principal terms agreed to let to
Waitrose subject to listed building consent being obtained for
the conversion
* Nexus - two business centres in the City, totalling 53,500 sq
ft, to be opened in October 1999
* Letting campaign commenced at 33 Glasshouse Street and 16
Grosvenor Street
Tan Sri Quek Leng Chan, Chairman of Benchmark said: 'It is almost
three years now since the rebirth of Benchmark Group PLC as a
specialist Central London property company and we are delighted
with the progress made in achieving our then stated objectives. We
have formed an excellent base from which we can continue to grow
and to increase shareholder value whilst specialising in Central
London.'
For further information, please contact:
Nigel Kempner Jeremy Carey or Vikki Hennen
Benchmark Group PLC Tavistock Communications
Tel: 0171 287 6881 Tel: 0171 600 2288
CHAIRMAN'S STATEMENT
The year ended 30 June 1999 was another active year for the Group.
Despite some nervousness in autumn 1998 the Central London
property market remained strong in all sectors with office rentals
for modern space again showing good growth particularly in the
West End. Residential property prices showed healthy increases,
retail rents remained resilient and investment demand for
commercial property remained strong.
We have concentrated during the year on completing the
construction of our development programme and on achieving early
sales or lettings where our buildings are sufficiently advanced.
This has minimised the development risk, particularly at The
Panoramic, our residential development in Pimlico by the river,
and our office and residential development at Stirling Square in
St James's.
We have undertaken an active programme of sales during the year
and since the year end. In the current low inflationary
environment, we believe that property companies should attempt to
enhance shareholder value by actively working their portfolios to
transform unrealised valuation surpluses into realised profits,
and to acquire new properties to which management and development
skills can be applied to enhance returns in the future.
We have been prepared to participate in corporate transactions,
where we can acquire properties in our chosen area of
specialisation, Central London, and use our skills to improve the
properties and their return. Our participation in the acquisition
by Quintain Estates and Development PLC of Chesterfield Properties
PLC demonstrated this.
We have set up Nexus Estates PLC as a complementary serviced
offices company to improve our overall attraction to a wider base
of tenants. This will also provide greater flexibility to our
existing tenant base as we believe that it is now even more
important to work closely with our tenants, as business partners,
and seek to provide the full range of services and flexibility
they require.
RESULTS
The net asset value per share at 30 June 1999 was 270.5 pence
compared with 243.4 pence a year earlier, an increase of 11.1%.
Pre-tax profits for the year reduced to £15.1 million from £19.7
million in the previous year and post-tax profits for the year
reduced to £13.2 million from £15.4 million in the previous year.
Earnings per share were 10.9 pence compared with 13.0 pence in the
previous year.
Normalised earnings per share, excluding profits on sales, reduced
by 7% from 8.8 pence to 8.2 pence.
Net rental income for the period reduced from £21.5 million to £19.5
million principally due to an increase in irrecoverable
property costs, which include letting fees, together with
disposals and rent-free periods given to tenants on new lettings.
Taking into account sales and acquisitions since the year end, net
rental income on an annualised basis at the date of this report is
now £23.4 million per annum.
DIVIDENDS
An interim dividend of 1.75 pence net per share was paid on 15
April 1999 and the Board now recommends the payment of a final
dividend of 2.0 pence net per share to be paid on 5 November 1999
to shareholders on the register at 1 October 1999. This
represents an increase of 7.1% over last year.
FINANCIAL
In July 1998 we successfully completed the raising of £49.1
million net by way of a Placing and Open Offer of 50 million units
of 5.75% Convertible Unsecured Loan Stock (CULS) 2013 at 100 pence
per unit. This lengthened the Group's average debt maturity.
Our net borrowings at the year end were £175.9 million
representing net gearing of 54%. This compared with 57% at 30
June 1998 and 52% at 31 December 1998.
The Group's net assets at 30 June 1999 were £326 million compared
with £293 million at 30 June 1998 and our gross assets were just
over £500 million.
ACQUISITIONS AND DISPOSALS
During the year we continued to progress our stated objective of
selling non-core assets. In addition, we sold those assets which
we considered had reached optimum values and used the proceeds for
new investments. Total sales were realised of £85.9 million at a
net profit of £4.1 million giving a surplus of 5% over book value.
Since the year end we have exchanged or completed further sales
totalling £62.95 million giving a surplus of 5.5% over book value.
In respect of acquisitions, during the year we spent £35.3 million
on the acquisition of properties in Central London and since the
year end we have spent £81.5 million on further acquisitions in
Central London but all located in the West End.
Following the disposals and acquisitions, at the date of this
statement, we now have a total portfolio of about 690,000 sq ft of
offices; 280,000 sq ft of retail and 40,000 sq ft of leisure
related space. Some 91% of the portfolio by value is in the West
End and 40 % by value is freehold.
VALUATIONS
Our investment properties were valued at 30 June 1999 by DTZ
Debenham Thorpe Chartered Surveyors. This revaluation showed a
net increase of £24.1 million representing a 6.9% uplift on the
investment properties (excluding development properties) still
held as at the year end.
OPERATIONS
Our development programme has progressed well and according to
plan and our development of Stirling Square at 5 Carlton Gardens
in the heart of St James's is being launched this month to provide
some 95,000 sq ft of prime, modern offices with car parking and
six residential units on the top two floors.
At our principal residential development, The Panoramic in
Pimlico, practical completion of the development will take place
at the end of this month and the first residential units will be
handed over to purchasers early in October. The progress of sales
and sales prices achieved has been most encouraging but in the
accounts for the period under review no account has been taken of
any anticipated profits.
Our office developments at 33 Glasshouse Street, and 16 Grosvenor
Street are ready for marketing. Further details of our
developments are included in the Review of Operations.
On our Belgravia Estate, we hope to implement shortly our
transport and environmental proposals to produce traffic calming
measures on Motcomb Street. We have submitted an application for
Listed Building Consent for our proposals to convert the south
side of the Halkin Arcade between Motcomb Street and Halkin Street
into a new food store of approximately 20,000 sq ft and we have
agreed principal terms to let the store to Waitrose Limited,
subject to obtaining Listed Building Consent. We are making good
progress in our negotiations with the Grosvenor Estate to
renegotiate the terms of our existing leases in the area and to
expand our holdings.
During the year we completed rent reviews and new lettings which
added £4.4 million per annum to the rent roll on an annualised
basis and our total net rental income on an annualised basis at
the date of this report is now £23.4 million per annum. We have
further rent reviews, lease renewals and new lettings to negotiate
over the next twelve months, which will see our net rental income
grow.
CORPORATE
We reviewed Benchmark's Articles of Association in the light of
current best practice and, in particular, having regard to the
'Combined Code' and other applicable corporate governance codes
and guidelines. Pursuant to this, Articles 88 and 89 relating to
retirement of Directors by rotation, including the Chairman and
Chief Executive, and Article 92 relating to retirement of
Directors on account of age, were amended by the Company at the
Extraordinary General Meeting held on 21 April 1999.
It is almost three years now since the rebirth of Benchmark Group
PLC as a specialist Central London property company and we are
delighted with the progress made in achieving our then stated
objectives. I would like to thank my co-Directors and our
executive team for their valuable contributions. We have formed
an excellent base from which we can continue to grow and to
increase shareholder value whilst specialising in Central London.
Tan Sri Quek Leng Chan
Chairman 17 September 1999
REVIEW OF OPERATIONS
PROPERTY REVIEW
ACQUISITIONS
During the year, some £35.3 million was spent on acquisitions of
properties in Central London and since the year end, another £81.5
million has been spent. The principal transactions were:
* In December 1998, the long leasehold of 100 Regent Street, W1
was acquired from Aquascutum Group plc in a sale and partial
leaseback deal for £12.7 million;
* In March 1999, the freehold of 1 Cornhill, EC3 a landmark
building overlooking the Bank of England, Royal Exchange and
Mansion House was acquired for £14.35 million;
* In June 1999, the freehold of 37/38 Curzon Street, W1 was
acquired from Chesterfield Properties PLC for £8.25 million;
* In August 1999, we completed the acquisition of six properties
owned by subsidiaries of Chesterfield Properties PLC (which
were part of the conditional agreement with Quintain Estates &
Development PLC announced on 24 May 1999) for £19.51 million;
* In August 1999, the freehold interest in a portfolio of 13
properties, known as the Golden Square Estate, was acquired
from Taylor Clark Properties Limited for £22.5 million.
* In September 1999, the freehold of Buchanan House, 3 St James's
Square, SW1 was acquired from a pension fund for £38.0 million.
DISPOSALS
During the year, we continued to progress our stated objective of
disposing of non-core properties and total sales of £85.9 million
were achieved, giving a net profit of £4.1 million over book
value. The principal transactions were:
* In the first half (July to December 1998), 11 properties were
sold for a total consideration of £44.4 million and these
included Hugo House, Sloane Street, SW1; 15/18 Austin Friars,
EC2; 185/187 Brompton Road, SW3; 8-10 Storey's Gate, SW1;
167/169 Wardour Street, W1 and 16 Curzon Street, W1;
* In the second half (January to June 1999), six properties were
sold for a total consideration of £41.5 million and these
included Camden House in Birmingham; 187a/191 Brompton Road,
SW3; 11/12 Buckingham Gate, SW1; 156 Brompton Road, SW3; 110
Buckingham Palace Road, SW1 and 17-29 Maddox Street, W1.
* Subsequent to the year end, there were another £63.0 million of
disposals and they included: -
* In August 1999, a portfolio of six properties to Shaftesbury
PLC for £21.5 million;
* In August 1999, the freehold of Ibex House, Minories, EC3 for
£37.9 million.
DEVELOPMENTS
Some of the key properties undergoing refurbishment or
redevelopment works are as described below:
Stirling Square, Carlton Gardens, St James's, SW1
Works commenced on site in August 1997 with the demolition of Wool
House and new construction began in March 1998. Practical
completion of the 95,000 sq ft of offices was achieved on 1
September 1999, whilst the six residential units totalling 15,500
sq ft on the top two floors are expected to be ready by November
1999. In March 1999, we agreed to lease the fifth floor
comprising 9,115 sq ft to Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co Limited
(KKR) as their new European headquarters for a term of 20 years at
a rental level of £65 per sq ft.
The Panoramic, Grosvenor Road, Pimlico, SW1
Works commenced on the site in October 1997 to convert the
existing office space to form 90 apartments on 21 floors with 110
car spaces and practical completion is targeted for the end of
September 1999. Sales of the apartment units have exceeded our
expectation in terms of timing and, to date, we have exchanged
contracts for 81 apartments totalling £46.8 million, whilst
another 3 units totalling £1.2 million are under offer.
Ibex House, Minories, EC3
The freehold was acquired in July 1997 and at that time,
approximately 42% (80,000 sq ft) of the building was vacant. In
October 1997 we began a comprehensive rolling refurbishment
programme to create modern, air-conditioned offices with large,
open plan floor plates. By December 1998, 140,000 sq ft had been
refurbished, of which 100,000 sq ft had been pre-let to tenants
such as Claims Management Group, Aquascutum and Holmes Place.
Since the year end, we have completed the sale of this property to
a UK pension fund for £37.9 million and this generated a profit of
£8.3 million or 29.6% on historic cost. This transaction has
demonstrated our skills in transforming a half-empty, poorly
configured property at acquisition into an institutional quality
property and we are very pleased with the returns achieved.
33 Glasshouse Street, W1
This is the office element of our long leasehold interest in 100
Regent Street, W1 that we acquired in a sale and partial leaseback
from Aquascutum Group Plc. Aquascutum will continue to occupy the
basement to second floors, totalling some 27,000 sq ft as its
flagship London store whilst moving its head office to another of
our properties, Ibex House, where it has taken a 10-year lease on
16,400 sq ft. At 33 Glasshouse Street, we have refurbished the
upper five floors to create 25,500 sq ft of modern air-conditioned
offices with a new entrance on Glasshouse Street. The works were
completed in September 1999 and the space is currently being
marketed. This transaction has demonstrated Benchmark's special
skills in working with owner-occupiers on their occupational
requirements in order to enable them to release capital invested
in their properties.
15 & 16 Grosvenor Street and 15/16 Brook's Mews, W1
Number 15 is one of the few freehold interests on Grosvenor
Street, not owned by the Grosvenor Estate, and is being rebuilt
behind the existing period facade to offer about 12,000 sq ft of
offices which would be ready by December 1999. The refurbishment
of Number 16 is completed and it offers a mixture of period
accommodation at the front with modern open plan offices totalling
16,000 sq ft. The refurbishment of 15/16 Brooks Mews has been
completed and only 3,300 sq ft remains to be let.
40/43 Old Bond Street and 3/4 Albermarle Street, W1
This is the joint venture with Thos. Agnew & Sons where we hold a
25% stake in the freehold property. We have just completed the
letting of the retail unit at 40/41 Old Bond Street to Cartier
Ltd. We have also let 12,000 sq ft of offices in 3/4 Albermarle
Street to Gooch Webster. Planning consent has been received for
the creation of a separate 1,000 sq ft retail unit on Albemarle
Street.
Belgravia Estate, SW1
On our Belgravia Estate, we hope to implement shortly our
transport and environmental proposals to produce traffic calming
measures on Motcomb Street. We have submitted an application for
Listed Building Consent for our proposals to convert the south
side of the Halkin Arcade between Motcomb Street and Halkin Street
into a new food store of approximately 20,000 sq ft and we have
agreed principal terms to let the store to Waitrose Limited,
subject to obtaining Listed Building Consent. We are making good
progress in our negotiations with the Grosvenor Estate to
renegotiate the terms of our existing leases in the area and to
expand our holdings.
Nexus Estates
In March 1999, we formed a new subsidiary called Nexus Estates
Limited whose main activity will be the operation of serviced
business centres. This activity will complement our existing
tenant base by offering flexible leases with added value services
included. We acquired the freehold of 1 Cornhill, EC3, a prime
landmark building of around 40,000 sq ft in the City core for
£14.35 million in March and it will be the flagship centre in the
City for Nexus. In addition, Nexus has converted 13,500 sq ft at
148 Leadenhall Street, EC3, where we completed the refurbishment
early this year, into a business centre targeted towards the
insurance sector. The two centres are expected to be fully
operational in October 1999.
PROPERTY MANAGEMENT
During the financial year, new lettings, rent reviews and lease
renewals were completed to produce an annualised rent of £4.4
million per annum. Following the property disposals and
acquisitions after the year end, the total net rental income on an
annualised basis is now £23.4 million per annum.
PORTFOLIO BALANCE
The analysis takes into account all acquisitions and disposals
made after the year end but excludes any development properties
such as Stirling Square.
* Lease profile
42% of our annual net rental income continues after 10 years.
Lease Profile %
Less than 5 years 28.0
5-10 years 30.4
11-15 years 24.8
More than 15 years 16.8
* Location
Approximately 91% by value of our properties are in the West
End.
Location %
West End 90.6
City 7.9
Mid-Town 1.5
* Use
67% of the annual net rental income is derived from offices and
26% from retail use. The 'other' categories include leisure,
restaurant/bar and residential use.
Use %
Office 66.7
Retail 26.2
Others 7.1
* Tenure
Despite our concentration in the West End where many properties
are leasehold, we have 58% by value of our properties on a
freehold basis or on leases exceeding 100 years.
Tenure %
Less than 25 years 0.5
25-49 years 5.0
50-74 years 9.8
75-100 years 26.6
More than 100 years 17.7
Freehold 40.4
* Tenant Profile
20% of our gross annual income comes from major retailers while
tenants in the financial services sector contribute 15%.
Tenant Profile %
Banks 4
Government 1
Oil Companies 2
Financial Services 15
U.K. Corporates 13
Chartered Surveyors 4
Major Retailers 20
Computer Companies 4
Media companies 6
Others 31
* Type
The breakdown into investment, non-income producing development
and trading properties is shown as below:
Type %
Investment 73.9
Development 24.9
Trading 1.2
MORE TO FOLLOW
FR ABAKKKOKKAAR