British American Tobacco PLC
30 September 2005
For immediate release: Friday 30 September 2005
British Columbia Decision
The following statement was issued by our Canadian subsidiary, Imperial Tobacco
Canada Ltd, yesterday, Thursday 29 September 2005:
"Montreal, September 29, 2005 - Today's Supreme Court of Canada's ruling
reassures Imperial Tobacco Canada that it can have a fair trial and bring
forward all the relevant information in any legal action undertaken by the B.C.
government under the Tobacco Damages and Health Care Recovery Act. The company
intends to vigorously defend itself in any trial initiated by that province.
It must be remembered that the decision rendered today does not in any way find
any tobacco company to be liable, but merely allows the action already taken by
the provincial government to continue.
"This case is not about tobacco and it's not about health, it's about abuse of
power and a grotesque cash grab by the government. The B.C. legislation is a
blueprint for any government in this country to facilitate a lawsuit against any
industry or any person or group of persons that a provincial government decides
to target," said Don McCarty, general counsel of Imperial Tobacco Canada. "This
decision essentially means that it is open season on any industry that any
government decides to take on for its own benefit. Industries such as fast food,
alcohol, gaming and others are all now fair game for a statute of this kind.
"Governments in Canada currently collect more than $9 billion a year in taxes
from the tobacco industry, which is more than 13 times the profit of Canadian
tobacco companies," he added. Since 1970 they have collected more than $130
billion in tax revenues on the sale of tobacco products, and the B.C. government
has directly collected more than $9 billion.
"We intend to fight for our right to a fair trial both before, during, and after
the trial pursued by the B.C. government. We are confident in the numerous
excellent and meritorious defences we intend to bring forward," McCarty said.
Inappropriate
This trial will take years to bring forward and to plead. Imperial Tobacco
Canada will ensure that the conduct of all parties in the history of tobacco in
this country is called to account, including the government itself, added
McCarty. The role of governments in the development and implementation of
tobacco policy will be relevant to this lawsuit and must be fully explored.
We now hope that the B.C. government will take time to think carefully before
deciding on a future course of action. The pursuit of a lawsuit to recover
health care costs will be a lengthy and expensive process. We estimate the
eight-year constitutional lawsuit has cost B.C. taxpayers well in excess of $20
million. And there will be no big pay out at the end of the day, even in the
doubtful event that the lawsuit is successful.
There is a better way. As a tobacco company we operate under the strict
regulation of both federal and provincial governments. We believe a more
co-operative, non-confrontational relationship between the regulator and the
regulated companies would serve everyone's interest.
Should this case proceed, we are confident that, when all the facts are brought
out, we will be successful in our defense."
The question as to whether the Act can be enforced against a number of
non-Canadian tobacco companies has still to be resolved. That issue will come
before the British Columbia Court of Appeal in February 2006. Meanwhile, the
claim is stayed against those companies pending the outcome of that appeal."
ENQUIRIES
British American Tobacco Press Office Investor Relations
David Betteridge/Teresa La Thangue /Emily Brand Ralph Edmondson/Rachael Cummins
+44 (0) 20 7845 2888 (24 hours) +44 (0) 20 7845 1180 or 1519
This information is provided by RNS
The company news service from the London Stock Exchange IIFSDAFIIVIE
*A Private Investor is a recipient of the information who meets all of the conditions set out below, the recipient:
Obtains access to the information in a personal capacity;
Is not required to be regulated or supervised by a body concerned with the regulation or supervision of investment or financial services;
Is not currently registered or qualified as a professional securities trader or investment adviser with any national or state exchange, regulatory authority, professional association or recognised professional body;
Does not currently act in any capacity as an investment adviser, whether or not they have at some time been qualified to do so;
Uses the information solely in relation to the management of their personal funds and not as a trader to the public or for the investment of corporate funds;
Does not distribute, republish or otherwise provide any information or derived works to any third party in any manner or use or process information or derived works for any commercial purposes.
Please note, this site uses cookies. Some of the cookies are essential for parts of the site to operate and have already been set. You may delete and block all cookies from this site, but if you do, parts of the site may not work. To find out more about the cookies used on Investegate and how you can manage them, see our Privacy and Cookie Policy
To continue using Investegate, please confirm that you are a private investor as well as agreeing to our Privacy and Cookie Policy & Terms.