Final Results
Grainger Trust PLC
06 December 2005
6 December 2005
GRAINGER TRUST plc:
PRELIMINARY ANNOUNCEMENT OF RESULTS
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2005
HIGHLIGHTS
• Core business operating contribution up by 7.6% to £88.2m.
• Grainger NAV up by 2.5% to 4.92p per share
• First acquisitions on Continental Europe announced
• Sales and distribution agreement with Norwich Union finalised
• £61m takeover of City North Group plc
• Total dividend up to 5.11p per share, an increase of 10%
• Portfolio continues to grow in asset value terms:
• Vacant Possession value now £2.067bn
• Investment value now £1.507bn
• Reversionary surplus stands at £560m
'This has been another year of significant progress at Grainger Trust. We have
continued to meet many of our strategic objectives - in particular, we have
consolidated our position as the UK's leading quoted residential investor and
trader' said Robert Dickinson, Chairman'
Contact:
Grainger Trust plc
Rupert Dickinson, Chief Executive 020 7795 4700
Andrew Cunningham, Deputy Chief Executive and Finance Director 020 7795 4700/
0191 261 1819
Baron Phillips Associates
Baron Phillips 020 7920 3161
07050 124119
Chairman's Statement
--------------------
I am pleased to report another year of significant progress at Grainger Trust.
Whilst we have not benefited from the exceptional market growth that has
characterised more recent results, we have concentrated on consolidating our
position as the UK's leading quoted residential investor and trader and have
worked to meet the strategic objectives we set ourselves 12 months ago.
Our focus remains on Grainger's core business - the acquisition, management and
sale on vacancy, of residential regulated tenancies. This business provides us
with a unique set of skills, asset base, cash flow and market knowledge that
allows us to examine residential based opportunities that have similar
management challenges or return characteristics.
During the year under review we have launched our equity release joint venture
programme with Norwich Union, expanded into Europe for the first time with two
joint venture developments, acquired a substantial land bank in Hampshire, and
commenced work on several mixed-use urban developments.
In addition we concluded a £61.3m agreed takeover of the central London-based
market rented residential investment company City North Group plc and a £70m
joint venture acquisition of a tenanted residential portfolio with Genesis
Housing Group, one of the country's leading Registered Social Landlords. We also
disposed of our last remaining major commercial property investments through an
asset swap.
Since the year end we have exchanged contracts on a €71.5m residential
investment portfolio in Germany comprising more than 1,400 units and generating
annual income of €4.5m. This acquisition will mark our first key investment
purchase within continental Europe and we continue to look for further similar
acquisitions where we can bring our deep and extensive knowledge of the sector
to generate superior returns for shareholders.
Shareholders will also be aware that we entered into preliminary discussions
with Parkdean Holidays to acquire its entire issued share capital. Although
these discussions were terminated, they demonstrate our willingness to examine a
wide range of less obvious opportunities where we believe we can bring our
residential and development skills to deliver long term reversionary returns.
Results
-------
Sales of tenanted residential property and net rental income from our core
portfolio continue to be the group's main profits drivers. Operating
contributions from our core business, increased by 7.6% over the year to £88.2m
from £81.9m. This included a contribution of £2.4m from City North. At the
pre-tax level, results for the 12 months to 30 September 2005 were impacted by
both a more normal contribution from our development and trading division of
£12.8m compared with £25.3m we recorded last year and higher interest charges of
£49.5m against £40.1m, resulting from our successful acquisition programme over
the period.
Accordingly pre-exceptional profits before tax were lower, but in line with
expectations at £42.1m compared with £59.6m for the same period a year ago. I am
also pleased to report that Grainger's net asset value continues to rise despite
the general perception of the residential market.
As shareholders appreciate, we consider the group's net asset position in three
ways: net asset value per share ('NAV'), diluted net asset value per share
('NNNAV'), which takes into account contingent tax and the market value of long
term debt and hedging, and the Grainger Net Asset Value, which adjusts for the
reversionary surplus within our portfolio. Our NAV has grown 2.0% to 558p from
547p, NNNAV has risen 3.5% to 385p from 372p, and the Grainger NAV is up 2.5% to
492p from 480p.
In line with the guidelines we established last year the Board is recommending a
final dividend of 3.41p per share which, together with the interim payment of
1.7p per share, will make a total for the year of 5.11p per share, an increase
of 10%. If approved, the final dividend will be paid on 8 March 2006 to the
shareholders on the register on 17 February 2006.
Strategy
--------
Long term exposure to the residential investment market has delivered annual
compound growth rates (as measured by the Halifax House Price Index) of 7%,
10.5% and 14.2% over the last 20, 10 and 5 years. There has been a more recent
slow down in growth -house prices rose by 3% over the 12 months to the end of
September 2005 - and the outlook over the coming 12 months is somewhat
uncertain.
Despite contradictory views of the market our own experience is that sales in
the first two months of the current financial year have been marginally ahead of
the end of September 2005 vacant possession values. We believe that over the
course of the current financial year overall house price inflation within our
portfolio will be muted.
However our business model is based on long term investment returns rather than
short term gains. Our interests are focused on market sectors where reversionary
potential is not entirely dependant on short term market growth, but also on
gains secured through tenure or use changes and by gaining planning consent.
These opportunities exist both in the UK and within continental Europe.
At the same time we will continue to generate income through our asset and
property management skills, particularly when these can be used to help third
party investors maximise their returns from the residential market. Also we aim
to take full advantage of any market opportunities that may arise where our
strong financial base, long term outlook and experience will enable us to unlock
value.
We are pleased that the Chancellor has committed to introducing UK REITs
(Real Estate Investment Trusts), in the 2006 Finance Bill. We now hope that
the eventual legislation is not overly restrictive and that it will encourage
real new investment to the Residential Sector.
Board
-----
During the course of the year under review Bill Tudor John, former senior
partner at Allen & Overy and currently a Managing Director of Lehman Brothers,
joined the Board and has taken over the chairmanship of the Remuneration
Committee from Robert Hiscox.
People
------
As Grainger expands it is essential we have the right level of skills and
expertise to manage this growth. Although much of this comes from our core of
committed and dedicated professional senior executives, in the year we have been
able to augment this with a number of external high level appointments. It is
pleasing that Grainger is able to attract such highly qualified executives.
Outlook
-------
The way forward is clear. We will focus on our core regulated business but,
recognising that this stock is finite, we will continue to develop into areas
that capitalise on our existing skills and economic base and which offer
exposure to the residential market. The most significant of these will be equity
release, investment in Europe, residential development and residential fund and
property management.
Bearing these objectives in mind, together with our solid financial platform and
our asset and skills base, we believe we have the framework for continued long
term success.
Robert Dickinson
6 December 2005
Chief Executive's Review
------------------------
Last year we set out our objectives for Grainger Trust in our key business areas
and we have made significant progress in all of these.
Tenanted Residential
--------------------
This is our core business, providing us with a long term exposure to the
residential market and good levels of profit and cash generation. It is based on
our large and diverse portfolio - at 30 September 2005 its market value amounted
to £1.5 billion an increase of 10.8% in the year - our experience and expertise
at managing and trading property and our solid financial underpinning.
Despite sluggish market conditions throughout the last year this division has
continued to trade well, generating sales of £133m, only marginally down on
2004's figure of £135m. It has been pleasing that we have achieved these levels
without significantly reducing prices on sale. Margins on normal sales in 2005
(i.e when a property is sold on vacancy) were 48.5%; the equivalent figure in
2004 was 48.6%.
In valuation terms, our portfolio has risen in value by 2.6% and the average
vacant possession value of our properties at 30 September 2005 stood at
£173,000.The reversionary surplus in our portfolio (including our share of joint
ventures) is £560m (2004: £536m) or 433p per share. This figure represents the
difference between what we expect to sell our properties on vacancy for and what
we value them at in our market value balance sheet. The difference between the
vacant possession value of our residential portfolio and its original cost is
£967m (2004: £928m).
Just as important as annual trading performance and valuation uplifts is our
ability to replenish stock levels and to grow businesses offering long term
growth potential.
In our regulated business we have acquired 480 properties for £51m. We have also
purchased a highly reversionary portfolio of 455 London flats for £70m from the
Church Commissioners in a joint venture with the Genesis Housing Group. We are
delighted to have been successful in acquiring this portfolio as well as to be
working with Genesis and their property management subsidiary Pathmeads. We see
an interesting future for Grainger in working more closely with the Housing
Association Sector.
As has been announced previously we entered into an agreement with Norwich Union
enabling our home reversion products to be sold through their own in-house
advisors and IFA distribution network. Sales through this channel have been
slower than anticipated when we announced the initiative in March. This reflects
general market conditions in the equity release market and a slower than
expected start up, although recent figures for our originations and the home
reversion sector in general are more encouraging.
We are building our home reversion portfolio using three routes (Bridgewater,
Norwich Union and portfolio acquisitions) and we anticipate being able to
increase the total portfolio by at least £50m in the year ahead. As part of this
strategy, we have recently launched our own Bridgewater Flexible Reversion Plan,
and this has been well received by the market.
We are pleased with the progress we have made in our market rented and asset and
property management businesses. We believe that the key is to ally a good
portfolio with excellent property and asset management skills and appropriate
financing. The acquisition of City North Group plc combined with our existing
holdings has provided us with a critical mass of market rented properties -
close to £200m as at 30 September 2005. We are now well advanced in preparing a
fund structure to attract third party equity into this portfolio. This will
enable us to benefit from the rent and reversionary potential in market rented
housing directly as one of the fund participants and indirectly through the
receipt of management and performance fees.
Our management expertise is illustrated by the fact that we currently manage our
own portfolio of 12,382 properties and a further 1,185 properties for other
residential investors. These include Schroders Residential Property Unit Trust
(ResPUT) where we have increased our stake and are due to take on further
responsibilities including strategy and acquisitions in addition to our asset
and property management roles.
Grainger Europe
---------------
Our objective in mainland Europe has been to replicate certain key aspects of
the Grainger UK business. Consequently we have been reviewing opportunities in
reversionary residential portfolios and development.
Shortly after the year end we announced our first portfolio acquisition - a
total of 1,400 properties in the Metro Ruhr of Germany for a consideration of €
71.5m (£48.9m). This is due to complete by the end of 2005. The combination of
relatively high rental yields, low borrowing costs and potential for significant
gain over time, if the properties are sold to the owner occupier sector, make
this an attractive area for us. We are optimistic that this first acquisition
will provide a good platform for us to build on.
During the year we also announced our participation in two development
opportunities. Firstly, an 81.6% stake in a mixed residential/retail scheme in
Zizkov in Prague, representing an investment of €6.7m and which we hope to take
through the planning process over the next 18 months. Secondly a €2.6m
investment representing a 45.7% stake in an 800 unit proposed residential
development in Tallinn, Estonia.
Development and Trading
-----------------------
Over the last few years we have moved away from pure commercial investment and
this process was substantially completed in the year.
We are now focussed on three areas: residential development, primarily mixed use
and residential schemes in London and the South East, urban and rural
regeneration schemes, including the acquisition of strategic land with
development potential, and Grainger Homes, our housebuilding arm based largely
in the North East of England.
After the exceptional year ended 2004, when several major schemes came to
fruition, the division this year has moved to a more normal level of trading,
producing an operating contribution of £12.8m on an asset base at the beginning
of the period of £109m.
The development of the former South London Hospital in Clapham comprising 77
units has gone well with 67 reserved or exchanged for a value of £20.3m. In
April we acquired 520 acres of land at West Waterlooville, Hampshire, which were
previously held under option. This has been included in the West of
Waterlooville Major Development Area and provisionally allocated 1,550
residential units with a further 1,000 in reserve.
A key element of our progress has been our ability and willingness to work with
partners. At Smiths Dock in North Tyneside we have formed a joint venture with
two local landowners to regenerate some 30 acres of waterfront land. We have
submitted an application for detailed planning permission for 1,250 units. We
have made progress on our schemes with Islington Borough Council having now
obtained planning consent for our 208 unit scheme at Hornsey Road and the 141
unit scheme in Barnsbury.
Grainger Homes has continued to develop, completing the sale of 84 units in the
year for a total of £11.3m, producing a trading contribution of £3.3m.
Operationally, therefore, we are pleased with the Group's performance in a year
in which market conditions have, as expected, proved testing.
People
------
As this Group continues to grow and operate in new market areas it is very
important to ensure that we have the personnel and management structure in place
to maximise the potential of both our existing asset base and new opportunities.
This year has been one of continued growth and change and we have made three
senior appointments Peter Couch, as Director of our Equity Release business,
Quinton Hill-Lines as Director of Corporate Development and, most recently,
Richard Exley who has joined as Director of Development and who is charged with
moving forward this division. In addition we have recently introduced a new
Senior Management Structure to ensure that each part of our business is run in
accordance with our stated strategy and that we take full advantage of the vast
range of knowledge and skills we have within the organisation.
Outlook
--------
We remain very confident in the outlook for Grainger. Our core portfolio is
geographically widespread, with a typical value near or below the UK average and
is generally un-modernised. These features help sustain demand in times of
market fragility. As importantly, the reversionary surplus in the portfolio of
over half a billion pounds acts as a potential reservoir for future gains. We
will focus on reversionary property for our core portfolio and continue to grow
our property and asset management skills so that we can make them more widely
available to external investors in the market rented sector.
We have put in place the products, distribution network and funding capability
to support high levels of growth in the home reversion market. Uncertainty
concerning the adequacy of pension provision and the widespread view that house
price inflation will be lower in the future should provide the impetus for
increased demand. Home reversion products fit well with other related sectors of
the market, for example second homes and retirement living and these may present
further opportunities for growth.
We look forward to completing our first German acquisition and are reviewing
several other opportunities that should help our European operation to become a
meaningful part of the Group's business.
We have continued to invest in the development division and have several schemes
in the pipeline that will produce attractive returns in the short to medium
term. We are growing this division and are confident that we can use our
understanding of local housing markets and management to ensure attractive
returns to our shareholders from a wide range of developments in the residential
sector.
In the coming year we will continue to progress in these main areas, whilst
exploring new opportunities to exploit our skills and asset base. I am confident
that the team we have is well placed to continue at the forefront of residential
investment and development in this country and in Europe. We are continuously
challenged by new legislation and regulations but we will look at these as
opportunities rather than threats.
Rupert Dickinson
6 December 2005
Operational Review
------------------
Tenanted residential
--------------------
Key performance statistics
--------------------------
2005 2004
No. £m No. £m
-------------- --------------
Properties sold on vacancy 720 109 783 111
Properties sold with tenants in
occupation 193 24 248 24
----- ----- ----- -----
Total sales 913 133 1,031 135
----- ----- ----- -----
Profits on sale* 61 58
Release of negative goodwill on
sales 6 6
----- -----
67 64
Net rental income and other income 23 20
Direct overhead costs (2) (2)
----- -----
Trading contribution 88 82
----- -----
* including gains on the sale of fixed assets
Trading and rental performance has held up well in the year. The acquisition of
City North Group contributed £2.4m to the years result. The overall return,
which includes the net valuation uplift, has been depressed in comparison to
last year by the slowing down in house price inflation. In 2005 the percentage
valuation uplift in our portfolio was 2.6%, in 2004 it was 12.4%. After taking
account of the elimination of revaluation surpluses realised on sales the
valuation movement in the year was £15.8m (2004: £121.3m).
Although the sales process has been more sluggish this year, as reflected by the
number of vacant properties at the year end (423 compared to 356 last year) we
have still experienced good levels of demand, helped by the geographic spread
and typical low value of individual units. Approximately 59% of our properties
by value are in London and the South East, 26% in the Midlands, East, South West
and Wales and 15% in the North and Scotland. Less than 22% of our properties by
value have vacant possession values in excess of £250,000 - the level at which
demand volatility becomes more marked.
The average vacant possession values in our three key portfolios are:-
£K
-----
Regulated 165
Market rented 191
Home reversion 190
-----
Overall (excluding other interests) 173
-----
This compares to the Halifax All House figure at 30 September of £166,000.
We have continued to grow our portfolio in both number and asset value terms.
The vacant possession value (including our share of joint ventures) is £2,067m
and the investment value is £1,507m giving us a reversionary surplus of £560m.
This is the gain over and above the market value of the properties we would
achieve if we sold the properties on vacancy at today's values. The surplus
above original cost is £967m.
We have acquired a total of 1,254 units in the year for a cost of £184m
(including properties acquired in the City North portfolio).
During the year we increased our stake in the Schroders Residential Property
Unit Trust ('ResPUT') to 19.5%. We provide asset and property management
services to this fund and the fee income that we received from this and from
other similar services for other customers amounted to £1.1m.
Development and Trading
-----------------------
Key performance statistics
--------------------------
2005 2004
£m £m
----- -----
Trading profits 11.7 13.5
Profits on sale of fixed assets 0.5 3.5
Net rental income less overheads - 0.4
Other net income (2004 Pimlico flats) 0.6 7.9
----- -----
Trading contribution 12.8 25.3
----- -----
The results for 2004 included profits achieved on sales of the commercial
portfolio, of the last major housing allocated land site at Kennel Farm and
receipts relating to the Pimlico development, totalling £22.1m. These were
largely one-off transactions and the division has now moved to more normal
trading levels.
The movement on revaluation in the year was a deficit of £12.0m (2004: deficit
of £3.8m); this represents the net effect of the elimination of revaluation
surpluses realised on sales in the year together with the impact of year end
valuations.
Major contributions to trading profits in the year have come from Kennel Farm
(£3.5m) Grainger Homes (£3.3m) and the sale of Landmark Place, Slough (£2.3m).
Opportunities for future income from Kennel Farm relate primarily to
approximately 5 acres of land currently allocated for business use and the local
centre.
During the year Grainger Homes sold 84 units for £11.3m. Much effort has gone
into creating a sustainable land bank at this division and over the next three
years we hope to achieve average annual sales of up to 200 units.
Other projects in this division are making satisfactory progress and their
status is shown in table 7 in the attached appendix.
Financial Review
----------------
Results
--------
Group profit before interest and tax has fallen from £99.7m to £91.6m. Net
residential rents and other income have increased by £3.5m to £23.2m, including
£2.4m from City North Group, and trading profits on residential sales including
negative goodwill released and profits on sale of fixed assets have improved by
4.3% from £64.4m to £67.1m. However, these have been more than offset by a
decrease in the contribution from the development and trading division which
fell from £25.3m to £12.8m.
Interest payable
----------------
Group pre-exceptional interest has increased from £40.1m to £49.1m. This is a
combination of higher average debt levels (up by approximately £100m over the
previous year) and higher borrowing costs. The average base rate in 2005 was
4.7% in 2004, 4.1%. This impacted on the proportion of our debt that is variable
or is hedged through caps. Our average interest rate in the year was 5.9% (2004:
5.8%).
Interest is covered 1.9 times by profit before interest and tax (2004: 2.5
times). Net cashflow (being all group receipts less expenses and taxation)
covered interest 3.8 times (2004: 5.1 times).
Taxation
---------
Our annual tax charge is significantly affected by FRS 19, the accounting
standard preventing the provision of deferred tax on revaluation gains when
companies are acquired. This serves to increase our effective tax rate above the
standard corporation tax rate of 30%. This year, it has been 37.1% (2004:
39.1%).
Major items affecting the tax charge are:-
£m
-----
Group profit before tax 42.1
-----
Tax at 30% 12.6
Adjusted for:
Additional tax on the difference between book and tax base costs
of trading property sales 7.4
Negative goodwill (not taxable) (1.8)
Other including adjustments to tax in prior periods (2.6)
-----
Actual tax charge 15.6
-----
Earnings per share and dividends
--------------------------------
Earnings per share before exceptional items have fallen to 21.2p from 29.9p.
Dividends have increased by 10% and are covered 4.0 times by profit after
taxation but before exceptional items (2004: 6.5 times).
Financial Position
------------------
General
-------
Most of our properties are held as trading stock and are therefore shown in the
statutory balance sheet at cost. This does not reflect the true worth of
Grainger's assets and therefore we set out in the notes to this statement our
net assets with the properties restated to market value.
Fixed assets
------------
Fixed assets properties in the balance sheet comprise £202.2m tenanted
residential and £20.3m development totalling £222.5m (2004: £97.0m, £8.4m and
£105.4m respectively). The major change relates to the acquisition of the City
North portfolio in the year.
Investments and intangible assets
---------------------------------
Investments relate to our investment in Schroders ResPUT and in joint ventures
and associates. We invested a further £8.4m in the ResPUT this year and now own
19.5% of the units issued. The market value at 30 September 2005 was £18.2m and
the cost £15.4m.
Our main joint venture interests are a 33% stake in a limited liability
partnership to develop Smiths Dock in North Tyneside of £4.1m including
goodwill, (2004: £3.3m) a 50% stake in a similar structure with Genesis Housing
Group of £8.8m which was established to acquire a portfolio of properties from
the Church Commissioners which had a year end value of £72.6m and a 50% stake in
a joint venture with Grange Prescot Limited to develop land at Prescot Street,
London. E1 with a value of £5m.
The negative intangible asset of £81.3m (2004: £84.8m) principally reflects
goodwill arising on the acquisition of Bromley, the acquisition vehicle used to
acquire the BPT group. It is being released to the profit and loss account in
line with property sales from that business.
Trading properties
-------------------
30 Sept 2005 30 Sept 2004
£m £m
Statutory Balance Sheet
-----------------------
Tenanted residential 870 843
Development and trading 92 76
----- -----
962 919
----- -----
Market value balance sheet
--------------------------
Tenanted residential 1,271 1,232
Development and trading 104 101
------ ------
1,375 1,333
------ ------
The cost of our tenanted residential stock has increased from £843m to £870m,
being stock purchases of £85m, capitalised improvement costs of £6m less sales
and transfers of £64m. Market value figures have risen to £1,271m from £1,232m.
Valuation uplifts account for £48m and this is reduced by the elimination on
sale of previously recognised surpluses of £36m. The balance of £27m relates to
the net effect of sales, acquisitions and transfers.
The market value of all our tenanted residential property at 30 September 2005
is £1,473m (2004: £1,329m).
The group's development and trading assets held as stock increased in cost terms
to £92m and in market terms to £104m (2004: £76m and £101m respectively), the
major movements being expenditure on West Waterlooville amounting to £21.5m, net
investment at Grainger Homes of £11.4m, and the sale of Landmark Place, Slough
which eliminated £20.0m of cost.
The total market value of all of the Group's development and trading assets at
30 September 2005 was £123.8m (2004: £109.0m)
Proforma net assets
-------------------
Market
Statutory Market value Conti- NNNAV
balance value balance ngent balance
sheet adjustments sheet FRS 13 tax sheet
£m £m £m £m £m £m
-------------------------------------------------------------
Properties:-
Tenanted residential 1,072 401 1,473 - - 1,473
Development and trading 112 12 124 - - 124
----- ----- ----- ----- ----- -----
Total properties 1,184 413 1,597 - - 1,597
Investment/others
assets/cash 87 8 95 - - 95
Negative goodwill (80) 80 - - - -
------ ----- ----- ----- ----- -----
Total assets 1,191 501 1,692 - - 1,692
------ ----- ----- ----- ----- -----
Borrowings and creditors (922) - (922) (18) - (940)
Net current liabilities (39) - (39) - - (39)
Provisions/contingent tax (6) (1) (7) 7 (213) (213)
Minority interest - (2) (2) - - (2)
----- ----- ----- ----- ----- -----
Total liabilities (967) (3) (970) (11) (213) (1,194)
----- ----- ----- ----- ----- -----
Net assets 30 September 2005 224 498 722 (11) (213) 498
----- ----- ----- ----- ----- -----
Net assets pence per share 173 385 558 (8) (165) 385
----- ----- ----- ----- ----- -----
Other assets and liabilities
----------------------------
Other net liabilities excluding cash balances and current debt instalments have
fallen from £77.0m to £45.4m. Two major items contribute to this. Firstly the
acquisition of a major portfolio of equity release properties (£19.5m) and
secondly the payment of the final instalment of the purchase price for Deutsche
Bank's stake in the Bromley joint venture (£10.0m) - both of these were included
in creditors in the September 2004 balance sheet and were paid shortly
thereafter.
Net assets
----------
Net assets at market value have increased from £678m to £722m:-
Reflected in Not reflected
the accounts in the Total
accounts
£m £m £m
Net assets at 1 October 2004 178 500 678
Retained profits 20 (6) 14
Revaluation surpluses:-
Tenanted residential 5 12 17
Development and trading 1 (13) (12)
Investments - 4 4
Goodwill movements - 1 1
Shares issued on acquisition of
City North Group 20 - 20
----- ----- -----
Net assets at 30 September 2005 224 498 722
===== ===== =====
Diluted NAV (or NNNAV) is computed by adjusting NAV for the market value of long
term debt and derivatives and for contingent tax.
These two adjustments amount to 8p and 165p per share respectively (2004: 0p and
174p respectively).
The FRS 13 adjustment has increased because of the current low 5 year swap rate.
At 30 September 2005 this was 4.535%, compared to 5.122% in 2004. This has
resulted in some of our hedging instruments moving out of the money.
Contingent tax, which will only crystallise on the realisation of the assets and
is therefore payable sometime in the future, has stayed relatively constant
because of the low level of movement in the revaluation surplus in the year.
As in previous years we also present Grainger NAV. This reflects our estimate of
the present value of the reversionary surplus in our regulated and equity
release portfolios. In gross terms this is the difference between what we would
achieve on sale of our properties on vacancy and the value attributed to them in
the market value balance sheet. We have calculated the after tax present value
of that surplus by discounting it back over its expected average period of
realisation at the discount rate of 8.6% (our weighted average cost of capital
plus a risk premium of 3% (2004: 8.6%). The adjustment increases NNNAV by 107p
per share to give Grainger NAV of 492p (2004: 480p).
It should be stressed that this calculation is based on current house prices and
assumes no future house price inflation. An annual increase in house prices of
4% would increase the adjustment to 177p and give a Grainger NAV of 562p.
Cash and Debt
-------------
Cash balances at the year end amounted to £53m, representing 3.1% of our total
market value gross assets. Of this £26m, (2004:£30m) represents deposits
received or acts as security for cash backed loan notes.
Group borrowings have increased from £757m to £921m, including capitalised loan
costs of £7m (2004: £7m). These will be written off over the period of the loan.
The increase in borrowings has principally arisen from the acquisition of City
North and West Waterlooville.
The total of our net borrowings expressed as a percentage of the market value of
our gross property assets ('loan to value ratio') at 30 September 2005 was 54%
(2004: 49%) and gearing was 120% (2004: 103%).
Financing
---------
During the year the group extended its core borrowing facility by £400m to
£1,300m and in so doing reduced the blended margin on the facility by 7 basis
points. At 30 September 2005, the Group had headroom in its borrowing capacity
of £450m.
Capital Management
------------------
The group finances its operations through a combination of shareholders funds
and borrowings with the objective of optimising weighted average cost of capital
('WACC') whilst retaining funding flexibility. At 30 September 2005 our estimate
of WACC was 5.58% (2004: 5.64%).
The group does not take trading positions in financial instruments but holds
them to minimise the risk of exposure to fluctuating interest rates. The
majority of our debt is subject to protective swaps, caps or collars or is
maintained at fixed rates of interest. At 30 September 2005, £658m or 76% of the
groups net debt was either fixed to termination, or for over one year, or was
protected by financial instruments (2004: 71%).
A combination of interest rate swaps and financial caps is used to provide a
degree of certainty over future interest rate costs whilst enabling the group to
take advantage of favourable short term rates. At 30 September 2005 the group
held £347m of swap contracts at an average pre margin rate of 5.4% maturing
between 2006 and 2014 (2004: £223m @ 5.4%). There were also financial caps in
place of £265m at an average capped rate of 6.1% expiring between 2006 and 2009
(2004: £233m @ 6.1%). A summary of our gross borrowings is:-
Interest
Principal rate % Terminating
--------- --------- -----------
Fixed to termination 45 6.3 2006-32
Hedged by swap contracts 347 6.3 2006-14
Hedged by financial caps 265 5.6 2006-09
Variable/fixed under one year 264 5.4 2006-14
----- ----- -------
Total debt 921 5.9
Less: cash (53)
-----
Net debt 868
-----
The effect of the fair value adjustment of marking the group's fixed rate debt
and derivatives to current market rates ('FRS 13 adjustments') would be to
produce a notional 'liability' after tax of £10.6m or 8p per share (2004: 0p).
This adjustment represents approximately 1.1% of group borrowings at 30
September 2005 and will not be recognised in the accounts until the position
matures or is terminated.
The group also maintains a range of borrowing maturities to enable it to balance
continuity of funding with flexibility. At 30 September 2005 the average
duration of the group debt was 5.1 years (2004: 6.4 years).
International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS)
-------------------------------------------------
IFRS are mandatory for the main UK listed companies for accounting periods
ending on or after 31 December 2005 and so will affect Grainger's financial
statements for the first time next year. As with most property companies, we
expect the main changes will arise in the areas of deferred taxation, financial
instruments, valuation movements and treatment of goodwill. In particular, the
FRS13 adjustment and part of the contingent tax adjustment we currently make to
NAV to arrive at NNNAV will form a part of the statutory balance sheet. The
difference between NAV and NNNAV will therefore represent the contingent tax on
the uplift of trading properties from book value to market value. We anticipate
that, along with other companies with significant investment property assets,
our income and expenditure account will become more volatile as valuation
surpluses and deficits will be recognised therein. In line with other FTSE
companies, we will announce the restatement of prior year figures and the
qualitative impacts on our accounts prior to our half year in March 2006.
Andrew Cunningham
6 December 2005
Consolidated Profit and Loss Account
For the year ended 30 September 2005
-------------------------------------
Year Ended Year Ended
30.09.2005 30.09.2004
(unaudited) (audited)
Note £m £m
--------------------------------
Turnover (2005: including share of joint
ventures and associates) 226.9 217.4
Less: Share of turnover of joint ventures
and associates (0.6) -
------ ------
Group turnover 226.3 217.4
------ ------
Gross rentals 45.5 41.0
Trading profits 74.8 72.6
Other income 2.9 9.8
------ ------
123.2 123.4
Less:
Property expenses (24.3) (22.7)
Administrative expenses (9.4) (7.5)
------ ------
Operating profit - group and share of joint
ventures and associates 89.5 93.2
------ ------
Net profit on disposal of and provisions against
fixed assets
- Group 2.1 6.5
------ ------
Profit on ordinary activities before interest and taxation 91.6 99.7
Net interest payable and similar charges
---------------------
- Group normal (49.1) (40.1)
- Group exceptional - (5.4)
- Joint venture (0.4) -
---------------------
(49.5) (45.5)
------ ------
Profit on ordinary activities before taxation 42.1 54.2
Tax on profit on ordinary activities 2 (15.6) (21.2)
------ ------
Profit on ordinary activities after taxation 26.5 33.0
------ ------
Dividends 3 (6.6) (5.7)
------ ------
Retained profit for the group 19.9 27.3
------ ------
Basic earnings per share 1 21.2p 26.8
Diluted earnings per share 1 20.9p 26.7
Basic earnings per share before exceptional items 1 21.2p 29.9
All results relate to continuing operations.
Statement of Group Total Recognised Gains and Losses
For the year ended 30 September 2005
------------------------------------
Year Ended Year Ended
30.09.2005 30.09.2004
(unaudited) (audited)
£m £m
--------------------------------
Profit for the period attributable to shareholders 26.5 33.0
Taxation on realisation of property revaluation gains
of previous years - (0.4)
Unrealised surplus on revaluation of properties 5.4 4.3
------ ------
Total gains and losses recognised since the last
annual report - group 31.9 36.9
------ ------
Consolidated Balance Sheet
at 30 September 2005
--------------------
30.09.2005 30.09.2004
(unaudited) (audited)
Note £m £m
--------------------------------
Fixed assets
Intangible assets (81.3) (84.8)
Tangible assets 224.4 106.7
Investments in joint ventures:
-----------------------
Share of gross assets 44.7 -
Share of gross liabilities (28.3) -
Goodwill 1.5 -
-----------------------
17.9 -
Investment in associates 0.1 -
Other Investments 15.4 10.3
------ ------
176.5 32.2
------ ------
Current assets
Stocks 961.5 918.6
Debtors: amounts falling due within one year 4 12.9 10.6
Cash at bank and in hand 53.3 53.8
------ ------
1,027.7 983.0
-------- ------
Creditors: amounts falling due within one year 5 (76.2) (109.0)
------ ------
Net current assets 951.5 874.0
------ ------
Total assets less current liabilities 1,128.0 906.2
-------- ------
Creditors: amounts falling due after more
than one year 5 (895.9) (717.9)
Provisions for liabilities and charges (8.5) (10.4)
-------- ------
Net assets 223.6 177.9
-------- ------
Capital and reserves
Called-up equity share capital 6.5 6.2
Share premium account 21.6 21.5
Revaluation reserve 17.7 13.9
Merger reserve 20.1 -
Capital redemption reserve 0.2 0.2
Profit and loss account 157.5 136.1
-------- ------
Equity shareholders' funds 223.6 177.9
-------- ------
Consolidated Cashflow Statement
For the year ended 30 September 2005
------------------------------------
30.09.2005 30.09.2004
(unaudited) (audited)
£m £m
-------------------------
Net cash inflow from operating activities 19.3 56.7
------ ------
Returns on investments and servicing of finance
Interest received 2.2 3.3
Interest paid - normal (49.9) (42.2)
- exceptional - (5.4)
Dividends received 0.1 0.2
------ ------
(47.6) (44.1)
------ ------
Taxation
UK corporation tax paid (16.6) (24.1)
------ ------
Capital expenditure and financial investment
Purchase of fixed asset investments (8.4) (4.5)
Purchase of tangible fixed assets (18.8) (29.8)
Sale of fixed asset investments - 1.2
Sale of tangible fixed assets 13.3 41.1
------ ------
(13.9) 8.0
------ ------
Acquisitions and disposals
Purchase of subsidiaries (39.8) (2.3)
Costs on purchase of subsidiaries (1.5) -
(Overdraft)/cash acquired on purchase of subsidiaries (0.3) 0.2
Investment in associates and joint ventures (11.1) -
------ ------
(52.7) (2.1)
------ ------
Equity dividends paid (6.9) (4.2)
------ ------
Cash outflow before financing (118.4) (9.8)
------ ------
Financing
New loans raised 170.0 726.1
Repayment of loans (52.2) (743.7)
Purchase of shares - (0.6)
Issue of shares 0.1 0.1
------ ------
Net cash inflow/(outflow) from financing 117.9 (18.1)
------ ------
Decrease in cash in the year (0.5) (27.9)
------ ------
30.09.2005 30.09.2004
(unaudited) (audited)
£m £m
-------------------------
Reconciliation of operating profit to net cash inflow f
rom operating activities
Operating profit 89.5 93.2
Depreciation 0.4 0.4
Movement in provisions for liabilities and charges (0.2) (0.2)
Provision against investment 0.9 -
Amortisation of goodwill (5.3) (6.1)
Decrease/(increase) in debtors 0.9 (2.0)
(Decrease)/increase in creditors (24.3) 1.7
Increase in stocks (42.6) (30.3)
------ ------
Net cash inflow from operating activities 19.3 56.7
------ ------
NOTES TO THE PRELIMINARY ANNOUNCEMENT OF RESULTS
1 Earnings Per Share
The calculation of basic, diluted and adjusted earnings per share is based on the
following earnings and number of shares:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Year ended 30 September 2005 Year ended 30 September 2004
Weighted Weighted
Profit average Profit average
for the number Earnings for the number Earnings
Year of shares per share year of shares per share
£m (thousands) pence £m (thousands) pence
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Basic earnings per share
Profit attributable
to shareholders 26.5 125,077 21.2 33.0 122,815 26.8
Exceptional item less tax - - 3.8 3.1
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Adjusted earnings 26.5 125,077 21.2 36.8 122,815 29.9
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Effect of potentially
dilutive securities
Options and shares - 1,770 (0.3) - 720 (0.1)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diluted earnings per share
Profit attributable
to shareholders 26.5 126,847 20.9 33.0 123,535 26.7
Exceptional item less tax - - 3.8 3.1
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Adjusted earnings 26.5 126,847 20.9 36.8 123,535 29.8
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The adjusted earnings per share is presented as, in the opinion of the
directors, it gives a better picture of the underlying performance of the
business.
2 Taxation
Tax on profit on ordinary activities: 30 September 30 September
2005 2004
£m £m
------------------------------
Group:
Normal 15.6 22.8
Exceptional - (1.6)
------ ------
15.6 21.2
------ ------
3 Dividends
Interim of 1.70p per share (2004: 0.81p) 2.2 1.0
Final of 3.41p per share (2004: 3.84p) 4.4 4.7
------ ------
6.6 5.7
4 Debtors
Trade debtors 1.9 5.8
Other debtors 4.8 0.5
Prepayments and accrued income 3.8 2.9
Deferred tax 2.4 1.4
------ ------
12.9 10.6
------ ------
5 Creditors
Amounts falling due within one year:
Loan notes 26.4 31.8
Deposits received 1.1 0.8
Trade creditors 6.7 22.2
Corporation tax payable 22.0 20.5
Other taxation and social security 1.5 3.2
Accruals and deferred income 14.1 25.8
Dividends payable 4.4 4.7
------ ------
76.2 109.0
------ ------
Amounts falling due after more than one year:
Bank loans 887.9 717.9
Other Creditors 8.0 -
------- ------
895.9 717.9
------- ------
6 This announcement does not constitute statutory accounts within the meaning of
Section 240 of the Companies Act 1985. Statutory accounts for the year ended 30
September 2004 have been filed with the Registrar of Companies. The auditors
have reported on those accounts; their report was unqualified and did not
contain any statement under Section 237(2) or (3) of the Companies Act 1985.
7 Copies of the statement may be obtained from the Company's registered office,
Citygate, St. James' Boulevard, Newcastle upon Tyne, NE1 4JE. Further details of
this announcement can be found on our website, www.graingertrust.co.uk.
8 The Board of Directors approved this preliminary announcement on 6 December 2005
Appendices
1. Analysis of tenanted residential portfolio by tenure
----------------------------------------------------
Vacant % Vacant
No of Possession Investment possession
properties value £m value £m value
-------------------------------------------------
Regulated 8,161 1,349 984 73
Assured 1,102 210 188 90
Vacant 423 65 58 89
Equity Release 2,663 354 196 55
Hotel complex - short term
lettings 33 5 5 100
Other interests - 41 42 97
Share of joint ventures 43 34 80
------ ----- ----- -----
30 September 2005 12,382 2,067 1,507 73
------ ----- ----- -----
30 September 2004 12,041 1,865 1,329 71
------ ----- ----- -----
2. Range of vacant possession values (excluding other interests and share of
joint ventures)
---------------
Vacant
No of possession
properties value £m
----------------------------
> £500K 71 56
£250K - £500K 1,167 385
£175K - £250K 2,809 587
£100K - £175K 4,943 690
<£100K 3,392 257
------ ------
12,382 1,975
------ ------
3. Geographic distribution of residential portfolio Investment
value £m % of assets £m
--------------------------
London 636 43
South East 237 16
South West 83 6
East 94 6
East Midlands 61 4
West Midlands 134 9
Wales 11 1
Yorkshire 56 4
North West 127 9
North East 23 1
Scotland 11 1
Northern Ireland - -
------ ------
1,473 100
Share of joint ventures 34
------ ------
1,507
------
4. Analysis of acquisitions in the year (excluding JV but including City North)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Vacant
possession
No. Cost value £m
-----------------------
Regulated (including APT) 480 51 73
Assured 584 110 125
Vacant 30 4 5
Equity Release 156 18 36
Other 4 1 3
------ ----- -----
1,254 184 242
------ ----- -----
5. Market value analysis of property assets
----------------------------------------
Held Market Fixed
as stock value Market assets at
at cost adjustment value valuation Total
£m £m £m £m £m
-----------------------------------------------------
Residential 870 401 1,271 202 1,473
Development and trading 92 12 104 20 124
----- ----- ----- ----- -----
Total 962 413 1,375 222 1,597
----- ----- ----- ----- -----
6. Analysis of residential sales in the year (from stock and fixed assets)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Trading
profit/
profit
on
Sales disposal
No proceeds £m
--------------------------
Regulated 600 86 43
Assured 99 11 2
Vacant 145 24 9
Equity Release 69 7 4
Other - 5 3
------ ----- -----
Total 913 133 61
------ ----- -----
7. Major development projects
--------------------------
Project Description Status Income expected from
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
West 520 acres of Planning 2008
Waterlooville greenfield land in application for
Hampshire 1,550 units due
to be submitted
in 2006
Macaulay Road 110,00 sq. ft. Planning decision 2008/9
mixed use scheme expected by mid 2006
in Clapham
South London 77 residential Completion of 2006
Hospital units above Tesco project due by
store in Clapham Spring 2006
Hornsey Road, Public/private Planning consent 2008/9
Barnsbury partnership mixed granted in October 2005.
Complex use scheme of 350
residential units,
43,000 sq. ft.
council office
facilities and
community
Smiths Dock, Joint venture to Planning decision 2007
North Shields regenerate 30 for 1,250 units
acres at former due early 2006
dry docks
This information is provided by RNS
The company news service from the London Stock Exchange