Final Results
UK Coal PLC
02 March 2006
UK COAL PLC
Preliminary Announcement
UK COAL PLC, the coal mining and property group, today announces its preliminary
audited results for the year ended 31 December 2005.
Financial Overview
• Return to profitability in the final quarter
• Full year operating loss before Exceptional Items £21.9 million (2004:
£27.0 million)
• Exceptional Items relating to closure, reorganisation and
rationalisation, net of Investment Aid receivable £31.4 million (2004: £10.1
million)
• Loss for the year £62.2 million (2004: £33.5 million)
• Debt at 31 December 2005 £95.5 million including leasing but excluding
cash held in respect of insurance and surface damage liabilities (31 December
2004: £48.0 million)
• £58.8 million increase in the value of the property portfolio (excluding
investment properties), to £181.5 million in excess of book value
• Value of investment properties increased to £17.8 million (31 December
2004: £6.7 million)
• Prices increasing reflecting improved market conditions. Selling price
per Gigajoule £1.35 (2004: £1.18)
• Deep mine cost per Gigajoule before Exceptional Items £1.49 (2004:
£1.34)
• Surface mine cost per Gigajoule before Exceptional Items £1.31 (2004:
£1.10)
Operational Summary
• Market conditions remain strong, proportion of non contracted output
increased
• Progress made reorganising deep mines and improving productivity
• Total deep mine production at 9.0 million tonnes reflects closure of
Selby complex in 2004 (2004: 12.0 million tonnes)
• Surface mine planning consent received for 2 sites totalling 1.2 million
tonnes*
• Surface mine production at 1.0 million tonnes reflects lack of planning
consents (2004: 2.0 million tonnes)
• Property occupancy increased and rental income grown to £4.8 million
(2004: £3.9 million)
• Property proceeds of £15.0 million (2004: £4.3 million) from sale of
land where value has been obtained, generating profits of £9.6 million (2004:
£2.8 million)
• Planning application for first wind farm approved. Progressing
applications in respect of a further eight wind farms
On commenting on the results, David Jones, Chairman, said '2005 has been an
important year for UK COAL. The Group is now well placed for the coming year,
having returned to profitability in the final quarter of 2005. The outcome of
the energy review, which we expect will recognise the importance of indigenous
coal supply in a balanced energy portfolio, will be important for UK COAL.'
* includes 987,000 tonnes obtained in February 2006
For further information, please contact:
Financial: Ken Cronin/Michael Turner
(Gavin Anderson & Company) Tel: 020 7554 1400
Operational: Stuart Oliver
Tel: 01525 381759
Mob: 07774 231178
Chairman's Statement
Operations
As expected, 2005 proved to be a transitional year for UK COAL, especially in
the deep mine business, where the mining conditions required the Group to
announce the closure or mothballing of three collieries, although options are
being reviewed to continue mining at Harworth. Geological problems elsewhere,
especially at Daw Mill, caused lower than expected production. I am confident
that the actions taken in the year to address these issues were the correct ones
to secure the Group's future. In the final quarter of 2005, it was demonstrated
that the deep mines could produce coal economically over an extended period and
this, together with the profitability of our other businesses, makes me
optimistic that the Group will improve its performance in 2006.
At the start of 2005, management had identified two deep mines as being high
risk, where geological problems might not permit economic production of coal.
Costs incurred in attempting to overcome these problems and in subsequently
closing or mothballing the mines, along with the unexpected closure of Ellington
due to flooding, resulted in large exceptional costs which have impacted
performance.
At the ongoing deep mines, however, production recovered in the final four
months of the year, after issues caused by longer than anticipated face gaps in
the first half of the year were resolved.
We are pleased with progress in surface mining, where we have been granted
permission to extract 257,000 tonnes at Stony Heap and 987,000 tonnes at
Stobswood North and remain hopeful this signals a change in planning decisions.
Production at the surface mining operations was 1.0 million tonnes (2004: 2.0
million tonnes), reflecting the constraints imposed by the existing planning
permissions.
There was a successful disposal of Monckton, the Group's coking business, in
June 2005. The total proceeds were £13.1 million, returning a profit on sale of
£3.1 million.
We continue to develop the Group's extensive property portfolio, with a strategy
of increasing occupancy in the business parks, developing existing brownfield
sites and maximising planning consents on our agricultural land. Overall rentals
rose by some 24%. A revaluation of the portfolio was carried out at 30 June 2005
and updated at the year end. This showed an increase, on a like for like basis,
of 34% on the value at the end of 2004, and is some £181.5 million more than the
book value of the properties.
Harworth Power's profitability decreased slightly compared to 2004 as a result
of lower Emission Trading credits. Methane capture rates grew as a result of the
development of improved techniques. It was pleasing that planning permission was
granted for the first wind farm the Group is to develop. Applications on a
further eight wind farms will be submitted in 2006.
Financial Results
Detailed reviews of both the operations and the financial results are set out in
the Operating and Financial Review. The Group made an operating loss before
Exceptional Items of £21.9 million (2004: £27.0 million), with the Group
returning to profitability in the final quarter of 2005. Exceptional Items
amounted to £31.4 million (2004: £10.1 million) and principally related to the
closure and mothballing of mines including redundancy costs and curtailment
gains, offset by credits relating to income under the Coal Investment Aid Scheme
and the profit on sale of Monckton.
As a result of the loss for the year of £62.2 million (2004: £33.5 million), the
Group has net liabilities of £14.7 million (2004: net assets of £56.8 million).
If the Group's properties were included at their revalued amounts, the Group
would have net assets of £166.8 million. The Group increased borrowings during
the year to fund the rationalisation of the deep mines operations and to invest
in the ongoing mines. As a consequence borrowings, including finance leases,
rose to £96.5 million (2004: £48.3 million).
Dividend
Following the expenditure on rationalisation and investment in deep mines, and
consequent increase in borrowings, the Board is not recommending the payment of
a final dividend (2004: 1.0p per share). Future dividends will be dependent on a
return to profitability and a reduction in the borrowings of the Group.
Directors and employees
Patrick O'Brien resigned from the Board on 28 November 2005. Patrick has served
the Group in senior positions for many years, latterly as Director of Surface
Mine operations and will continue to be employed until March 2006. Graham
Menzies will be stepping down from the Board on 9 March 2006. Graham joined UK
COAL in 2004 and has made a significant contribution in his role as Senior
Independent Director and Chairman of the Remuneration Committee. I would like to
take this opportunity to thank Patrick and Graham for their contributions and
wish them well in the future.
We have been through a year which has unfortunately required a large number of
redundancies from the workforce. The decision to make redundancies is never
taken before all other avenues have been investigated. I would like to thank all
our employees, both serving and former, for their hard work and commitment to
the Group during 2005.
Offer for the Company
The Board was approached during the early part of 2005 by a consortium headed by
Alchemy Partners LLP regarding a possible offer for the Company. This
unsolicited approach proved an unhelpful distraction to management. Following
highly tentative discussions, the consortium indicated in November 2005 that it
would not be making any formal offer.
UK Energy Policy
At the end of last year the Government announced it would conduct a review of
the UK's energy policy. The Department of Trade and Industry is leading the
review, and has launched a public consultation to consider the Government's
goals of reducing CO2 emissions, maintaining secure energy supplies, promoting
competitive markets, and making energy affordable for all.
The energy review will be taking into account all the circumstances surrounding
UK energy policy - including the role of domestically mined coal in the energy
mix. UK COAL currently provides around 7% of the country's energy needs for
electricity generation and will be actively engaging with the energy review
process. UK COAL makes an important contribution to supporting policy objectives
on security, diversity of supply and price stability in coal markets that have
recently seen dramatic variations which are unhelpful to business and domestic
electricity consumers alike. The Group will be making the strongest possible
case for a long-term, healthy and competitive coal industry in the UK, which
allows UK COAL to fulfil its social obligations, provides customers with a hedge
against price volatility and allows expensive investment in port and rail
capacity to be deferred. The review will conclude in April with final policy
proposals expected in late summer.
The energy review represents an important opportunity to influence Government
policy for years to come. UK COAL has already made a start in leading the debate
by hosting a policy meeting in Parliament with MPs, Peers and the Energy
Minister, Malcolm Wicks MP. Over the next few weeks, UK COAL will be responding
to the review consultation and building the strongest possible base of support
in Parliament for the coal industry in the UK.
Outlook
The actions taken in 2005 leave the Group well placed for the coming year and
this is supported by the performance in the final quarter of 2005 and the first
weeks of 2006. As noted above, we continue to talk to the Government on several
key issues affecting the Group. I believe the current political and market
conditions herald a brighter future for coal as it is recognised that the
country's needs must be supported by domestic production. UK COAL is well
positioned to benefit from the changes this will bring.
David Jones
Chairman
2 March 2006
Operating and Financial Review
Summary financial performance
UK COAL promised and has delivered an operating turnaround. Considerable
expenditure was incurred on rationalising the operations and the decision to
close or mothball three collieries, identified as high risk at the start of the
year, was announced. Operating losses before Exceptional Items were reduced to
£21.9 million (2004: £27.0 million), with the Group returning to profitability
in the last quarter of 2005. Exceptional Items were £31.4 million (2004: £10.1
million), resulting in a pre interest loss of £53.3 million (2004: £37.1
million).
Net finance costs were £8.8 million (2004: £5.1 million), the increase
principally the consequence of higher borrowings as a result of the losses
incurred. The charge within finance costs reflecting the unwinding of discounts
amounted to £5.1 million (2004: £5.9 million).
Revenue in the year reduced to £341.2 million (2004: £433.8 million), reflecting
the lower production in both the deep and surface mine operations, following
colliery closures in 2004 and 2005 and the sale of Monckton. Total coal
production amounted to 10.0 million tonnes (2004: 14.0 million tonnes).
The property portfolio, which consists of agricultural property, land held for
development and business parks, generated rental income in the year of £4.8
million (2004: £3.9 million) and operating profit of £16.4 million (2004: £4.6
million), which includes a revaluation surplus of £4.5 million. Total disposal
proceeds in the year were £15.0 million (2004: £4.3 million) with a profit on
disposal of £9.6 million (2004: £2.8 million).
During the year The Monckton Coke & Chemical Company Limited ('Monckton') was
disposed of for gross proceeds of £13.1 million and a profit on sale of £3.1
million.
At 31 December 2005 there was an unprovided deferred tax asset of £66.9 million
(2004: £38.6 million).
The Business
Markets
Despite the advent of the EU Emissions Trading Scheme at the start of 2005, coal
consumption in the UK in 2005 has remained strong. Record prices of other
competing fuels, especially gas, have enabled coal fired power stations to run
at consistently high load factors with the result that coal burn in the
electricity sector has increased slightly over the previous year.
International coal prices have steadily fallen from the 2004 peak of $77.56 per
tonne, to an average in 2005 of $60.66 per tonne to the price in January 2006 of
$54.54 per tonne, a fall of 29.7%. The forward curve for 2006 and 2007 has,
however, strengthened. Coal sourced on the international market is traded
actively, but does not provide the same level of security over supply and price
as indigenously mined coal. With its coal reserves, UK COAL is able to offer
longer term contracts at prices which provide a hedge against the volatility of
the spot market.
As noted in the Chairman's Statement, the Government is currently conducting an
energy review, seeking views on the medium and long-term energy policy issues.
Since the last Energy White Paper, published in 2003, fossil fuel prices have
risen sharply, and are projected to rise further; the UK has become a net gas
importer sooner than expected and is now forecast to import around three
quarters of our primary energy requirements by 2020. Against this background, UK
COAL, which currently supplies approximately 7% of the country's energy needs
for electricity, will be lobbying extensively to ensure indigenous coal has a
future role to play in the energy market, offering security of supply and price
stability in an uncertain energy world.
Electricity Supply Industry
In 2005:
•UK power stations consumed some 52 million tonnes* (2004: 51 million
tonnes) of coal;
•Steam coal imports increased by 24% from 30 million tonnes to 37 million
tonnes*.
The fuel mix for electricity generation for 2004 and 2005 is shown in the
following table:
2005* 2004
% %
Coal 34 33
Gas 39 40
Nuclear 19 19
Oil, hydro & renewables 8 8
Total 100 100
* 2005 numbers based on provisional numbers from the Dti.
From 1 January 2005, UK power stations were required to participate within the
EU Emissions Trading Scheme. The establishment of this scheme is a major step
forward in EU policy to reduce carbon emissions. The effect on coal consumption
will be dependent on the price of carbon allowances together with the relative
prices of coal and gas.
During 2005, total coal sales to the power station market, were 9.1 million
tonnes (2004: 13.0 million tonnes) reflecting lower than expected production. UK
COAL successfully resolved the outstanding force majeure issue with Drax. The
contract cover with all customers, for the five years from, and including, 2006
is 29.5 million tonnes.
As noted above, the spot price of coal on the commodity exchanges demonstrates
huge volatility. UK COAL believes there is an appetite among its customers for
price certainty and secure supply, which it is able to satisfy. However, any
future contracts must be based on sales prices which allow UK COAL to recover
the investment needed to mine the coal, develop further faces and provide
adequate risk adjusted returns. The Group will be concentrating its efforts on
ensuring any new contracts fulfil these requirements and will focus less on
short term international prices or projected forward prices, which have proved
to be a poor predictor of the outturn.
Industrial and Domestic
In the industrial market, a number of contracts have been renewed taking into
account the increased prices of competing international supplies. This process
will continue into 2006 as existing contracts come to an end.
Sales volumes into both the industrial and domestic markets at 0.9 million
tonnes (2004: 1.2 million tonnes) showed a decrease on the previous year, in a
declining market. Prices, however, have shown a significant improvement,
benefiting from the rise in price of competing fuels. In this sector, UK COAL
increased its prices by around 25% during 2005.
Customers
The Group has three major customer profiles: for coal; for property and for
electricity. Details of coal sold by customer type is summarised as follows:
2005 2004
Tonnes (m) % Tonnes (m) %
Electricity Supply Industry 9.1 91.0 13.0 91.6
Large industrial 0.1 1.0 0.2 1.4
Small industrial 0.2 2.0 0.2 1.4
Other 0.6 6.0 0.8 5.6
Total 10.0 100.0 14.2 100.0
The directors do not foresee any material change in the mix of the Group's coal
sales in the coming period.
The Group's rental income derives from a large number of individual leases with
concerns ranging from companies leasing units on the business parks, to
individuals renting small parcels of agricultural land.
Harworth Power provides supplies of electricity both internally and to the local
distribution network.
Review of Operations
A detailed review of each of the operating segments of the Group is set out in
the following paragraphs. A summary of the Group's results, by segment is set
out below. A more detailed segmental analysis is given in note 2 to the
financial statements.
Exceptional 2005 Exceptional 2004
Operating Items within Total operating Items within Total
profit/(loss) cost of sales profit/(loss) Cost of sales
£000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Deep Mining (31,789) (46,649) (78,438) (30,262) (14,669) (44,931)
Surface Mining 3,347 (2,504) 843 4,065 (4,323) (258)
Property 16,418 - 16,418 4,600 - 4,600
Harworth Power 3,362 - 3,362 4,239 - 4,239
Other 4,482 - 4,482 (700) - (700)
Operating loss (4,180) (49,153) (53,333) (18,058) (18,992) (37,050)
Finance costs (8,761) (5,148)
Loss from continuing (62,094) (42,198)
operations
Discontinued - 8,667
operations
Loss before tax (62,094) (33,531)
Deep Mining
Development and Performance
The Group operates five ongoing deep mines, situated in Nottinghamshire,
Yorkshire and the West Midlands. During the year the Group has closed one mine
and announced the decision to mothball two others. Production amounted to 9.0
million tonnes (2004: 12.0 million tonnes). The results for the deep mines
operations for the two years ended 31 December 2005 may be summarised as
follows:
2005 2004
£000 £000
Revenue 299,028 364,848
Operating loss before Exceptional Items (46,430) (39,164)
Exceptional Items within cost of sales (46,649) (14,669)
Coal Investment Aid 14,641 8,902
Operating loss (78,438) (44,931)
The year ended 31 December 2005 was, as expected, a transitional year for the
deep mine operations, which lost £46.4 million before Exceptional Items included
within cost of sales and Coal Investment Aid (2004: loss of £39.2 million).
Exceptional Items within cost of sales amounted to £46.6 million (2004: £14.7
million), resulting in a loss after Exceptional Items of £78.4 million (2004:
loss of £44.9 million). However, the performance in the final quarter was
encouraging and demonstrates the deep mines can operate profitably. This
improved performance was maintained during January 2006.
Several fundamental operational issues were identified during 2004, and a great
deal of time and effort, both by management and the workforce, was expended in
addressing and resolving these issues. The actions taken included the following:
• new wage structures introduced at four of the ongoing collieries. These
eliminate daily bonuses, guarantee increases in machine available times,
have increased the certainty of earnings for individuals and allowed the
Group to plan working time more effectively, with reduced threat of
industrial disputes;
• the launch of a structured daily maintenance programme, which predicts
component failure and allows pro active planned replacement, replacing
reactive unscheduled repair during expensive downtime;
• the introduction of better budgetary techniques improving project
management and cost control and, ultimately, the profitability of the mines;
and
• utilisation of new techniques in ground control, including polyurethane
injection, which help to control adverse face conditions and accommodate
faster face advance.
These risks continue to be reduced by utilising the latest seismic technology.
Success has been achieved in increasing production at the five ongoing deep
mines. However, it was necessary to close or mothball three mines in 2005, the
main details are summarised below:
•In January 2005, Ellington Colliery suffered a sudden ingress of water at
its working face, resulting in the loss of that face and equipment. If
mining continued, UK COAL could not guarantee the safety of its workforce
and this, allied to the cost of pumping, recovery of equipment and
development of a new face, resulted in the decision to close Ellington
during January;
•Following the introduction of many of the operational changes noted
above, the output and financial performance at Harworth Colliery improved
substantially in the early part of 2005. Unfortunately, high methane levels,
together with extremely difficult geological conditions, meant that
extraction of further reserves could not be carried out economically. The
decision was taken to mothball Harworth, and the seam will be abandoned once
the current coal panel is exhausted during the first quarter of 2006.
Options are being pursued, which will allow mining to continue at Harworth
following the development of improved ground control techniques: this is,
however, dependent on securing a combination of appropriate finance;
proceeds from customers sufficient to recover the development and coal
extraction costs and to provide a risk adjusted return; and continued
flexibility from the workforce; and
•Rossington Colliery encountered difficult conditions in 2004. In an
effort to keep the mine open a plan, which utilised advancing longwall
panels, together with revised shift patterns, was adopted. Advancing
longwall panels are rarely used in current mining practice, because of
inherent problems controlling cycle times and gate roads. This approach
proved unable to provide returns sufficiently high enough to maintain
production and cover the substantial investment the mine required. As a
result the decision was taken to close, and possibly mothball, the colliery.
The decision to close or mothball a mine is never taken lightly. The costs to
the individuals and to the communities in which mines are located are carefully
considered. However, there has to be a reasonable prospect of an economic return
the investment of substantial sums needed to develop new faces.
Ongoing mines
Face gaps at the ongoing mines in 2005 totalled 33 weeks, compared to 23 weeks
in 2004. Management expended considerable effort in the year on controlling and
managing these face gaps, however, total face gaps lasted some 18 weeks more
than planned. The majority of the down time occurred in the second quarter of
the year, with some over runs into the third quarter, which affected unit costs.
Quarter1 Quarter 2 Quarter 3 Quarter 4 Total
Face Gaps (weeks) 3 23 7 - 33
Tonnes (000) 2,090 1,357 1,610 2,480 7,537
Cost per Gj (£) 1.27 1.89 1.78 1.35
Production at the ongoing mines was lower in the second and third quarters due
to face gaps. At Daw Mill, the largest of the Group's mines, production was
reduced due to the need to resolve floor heave, which was not anticipated when
the developments were designed. Production and efficiency increased sharply at
all mines in September following the ramp up of new faces and holiday periods in
July and August. Cost per Gigajoule ('Gj') is a key measure of how efficiently
the mines are operating. This improved significantly in the last quarter and
provides a good platform for the start of 2006.
Investment Aid
During the year ended 31 December 2005, the Group credited £17.1 million (2004:
£8.9 million) to the income statement arising from claims under the Government's
Coal Investment Aid Scheme, of which £4.4 million (2004: £0.3million) was
released from the deferred creditor in the balance sheet. The deferred creditor
at 31 December 2005 was £14.0 million (2004: £14.0 million).
£2.5 million was written off the Investment Aid debtor during the year. This
related to amounts owed to UK COAL as reimbursement for investments made at
collieries which had to be closed or mothballed. These amounts are included as
Exceptional Items. Despite having made the investment and safeguarded jobs, the
Dti has indicated that if investment is made which is lost due to geological or
other unforeseen events, it may be repayable. This is a situation which has to
be resolved before the Group will claim under any further aid scheme. As a
result, future investments will be considered assuming no aid is available, and
the viability of collieries will be assessed on this basis.
Cash received in respect of Investment Aid amounted to £18.5 million and the
debtor at 31 December 2005 was £7.3 million (2004: £11.1 million).
The Investment Aid Scheme is now in its final year. The Group has entered into
dialogue with the Government over the form and extent of a replacement scheme.
Management of UK COAL believes that any replacement for the Coal Investment Aid
Scheme must be in a significantly different form, preferably including
Government guarantees or with a more appropriate view of risk, in order to help
with major investment in collieries.
Production
The production tonnages for the two years ended 31 December 2005 may be
summarised as follows:
2005 2004
Million tonnes Million tonnes
Daw Mill 2.0 3.0
Kellingley 2.0 0.9
Maltby 1.1 1.4
Thoresby 1.4 1.1
Welbeck 1.0 0.9
Harworth 0.8 0.9
Rossington 0.5 0.6
Ellington 0.2 0.5
Riccall - 1.2
Stillingfleet - 1.4
Wistow - 0.1
Total Deep Mines 9.0 12.0
Exceptional Items
The deep mine operations incurred several exceptional costs during the year,
principally relating to the mothballing of Harworth and Rossington, the closure
of Ellington and the additional mining costs relating to the force majeure event
at Kellingley. It is possible that further such costs will be incurred in 2006
but at present it is not possible to quantify them. Other redundancy costs
relate to the reorganisation and rationalisation of the head office to reflect
the reduced scale of activities within the Group and redundancies made following
reorganisations of ongoing collieries. The Exceptional Items within the deep
mine operations may be summarised as follows:
Stores Asset Closure
stock impairment costs Redundancy Other* Total
£000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000
Harworth (1,685) (967) (8,913) (11,565)
Rossington (933) (5,634) (3,331) (4,843) (14,741)
Kellingley (7,708) (7,708)
Ellington (14) (5,635) (3,077) (8,726)
Other (2,064) 249 (6,924) 4,830 (3,909)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total (4,696) (6,601) (5,386) (22,245) (7,721) (46,649)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* Other costs refers to the additional labour costs incurred at Rossington and
Kellingley consequent to the revised mining plans following invocation of the
force majeure clause of the Drax contract, offset by curtailment gains on post
retirement benefits, relating to redundancies during 2005.
The Exceptional Items are discussed in greater detail in notes 3 and 4 to the
financial statements.
Future Prospects
In the final quarter of 2005, the deep mines operated profitably. The tonnage
extracted in the fourth quarter was encouraging, and tonnes per manshift, whilst
at a five year high, have the potential to be increased further.
There is only one scheduled face gap in 2006, for four weeks in March at Maltby
Colliery. Apart from this, and in the absence of unforeseen problems, continuous
production at all mines should be possible.
The reserves available in the deep mine operations are critical to the long term
prospects of the Group. New advances in seismic exploration, allowing 3D
representations of seams, provide better definition of the reserves at the
remaining mines. These techniques have already been put into use at Daw Mill and
Kellingley, and the seismic interpretation has improved understanding of the
reserves.
The Group's latest estimate of its deep mine coal reserves are set out in the
following table:
Coal (million
tonnes)
Reserve 64
Resource 119
Mineral Potential 90
Total 273
Reserve: Proven reserves which are accessible using the broad infrastructure in
place at the current time, and which are in the current mining plan.
Resource: Proven reserves, however these require substantial development and
other costs to allow accessibility and are not currently in any mining plan.
Mineral Coal that has been assessed (although possibly not to the same extent as
Reserve and
Potential: Resource coal) but UK COAL does not have any licenses or planning
permission to extract the deposits.
These figures must be treated with caution; they are based on the Group's best
estimate at the current time. A number of factors may cause the actual
production to vary significantly from these estimates. These factors include,
but are not limited to:
•Ongoing seismic surveying of reserves - these could result in either an
increase or a decrease to the production estimates;
•Geological problems - despite the improved seismic surveying being
carried out, there remains a risk that a coal face is subject to unforeseen
geological problems that makes production unsustainable;
•Sales price of future coal and cost increases; these could render
production plans uneconomic or could allow extraction from areas previously
believed to be unviable; and
•Government support - this could allow investment into new areas of mines
not included in current plans.
Harworth Insurance Limited
Harworth Insurance is the Group's captive insurance company and provides
insurance services for Group companies to cover risks which are either
uninsurable on the open market or where premiums are at uneconomic levels. These
principally relate to deep mining operations.
Centechnology (UK) Limited
During 2005, the Group established a new trading subsidiary, Centechnology (UK)
Limited, to supply skilled labour to fulfil mining and other associated
requirements. Centechnology (UK) Limited will add flexibility to UK COAL's
labour and will allow the Group to earn revenue externally when there is spare
capacity.
Surface Mining
Development and Performance
With the completion of coaling at Orgreave in January 2006, the Group is
currently operating only one surface mine, Maidens Hall, in Northumberland. In
addition, there are 33 sites (2004: 38 sites) at which mining has been
completed, and which are subject to restoration and rehabilitation, in
accordance with the terms of the planning permission.
The results for the surface mine operations for the two years ended 31 December
2005 are summarised as follows:
2005 2004
£000 £000
Revenue 25,203 45,028
Operating profit before Exceptional Items 3,347 4,065
Exceptional Items within cost of sales (2,504) (4,323)
Operating profit / (loss) 843 (258)
The surface mining operations produced a profit, before Exceptional Items, of
£3.3 million (2004: £4.1 million). After Exceptional Items of £2.5 million
(2004: £4.3 million) this resulted in an operating profit of £0.8 million (2004:
loss of £0.3 million). £10.8 million (2004: £8.1 million) was spent on
restoration and rehabilitation projects in the year. Exceptional costs were in
respect of redundancy payments and the write down of redundant assets.
Production amounted to 1.0 million tonnes (2004: 2.0 million tonnes), the
reduction compared to 2004 being due to the completion of coaling at four sites,
with no replacements being available as a result of the lack of planning
consents to mine new sites. Unit costs were £1.31 per Gj (2004: £1.10 per Gj).
This rise reflects the inefficiencies which result from operating a limited
number of sites.
Future Prospects
UK COAL owns approximately 97 million tonnes of surface coal reserves situated
under its owned land, which, at current prices, should be capable of economic
extraction. With the import of coal potentially restrained by port and rail
capacity in the country, these reserves should form an important national
resource. Planning permission for coaling has been difficult to obtain in
previous years, however UK COAL believes this attitude is changing, and is
confident that in future, schemes can be progressed. The Group is continuing its
efforts to obtain planning permission based on improvements in the environmental
acceptability of brownfield site regeneration. The end result will be not only
additional domestic production but also sites restored to a standard and at a
cost prohibitive without prior mining.
The Group has significant surface mining plant, equipment and expertise and is
actively looking at additional sites in England, Scotland and Wales in order
that these resources may be used efficiently. Planning approval was received for
one site, Stony Heap in 2005 and a further site at Stobswood North in 2006. A
Public Inquiry has been held on the Group's proposals for Long Moor, following
which a decision is still awaited. Applications to mine at four sites with
reserves of 4.4 million tonnes were submitted to the respective Mineral Planning
Authorities during 2005 and appeals have been lodged against the decision to
reject coaling at two further sites, these should be heard at Public Inquiries
during the first half of 2006. Applications to mine in excess of four million
tonnes at a further six separate sites will be lodged during the coming year. At
31 December 2005, surface mining reserves with planning consent amounted to 2.7
million tonnes (2004: 3.2 million tonnes).
A summary of activity is set out in the table below:
Site Tonnage
Remaining (000
tonnes)
Maidens Hall Extension 920
Cutacre 1,500
Stony Heap 257
Stobswood North 987
Sites With Planning 3,664
Sharleston Colliery 360
Steadsburn 1,000
Long Moor 725
Lodge House 1,000
Potland 2,000
Sites in Planning 5,085
Chesterfield Canal 400
Dawley Road 650
White Lea 1,000
Blair House 1,000
Bradley 500
Minorca 800
Sites to come into Planning 4,350
Property
Development and Performance
Significant progress in the property business has been made during 2005:
• Strong increase in property valuation - 34% on like for like basis
• Increase in profit on sale of assets to £9.6 million from £2.8 million
• Growth in commercial rental income of 32% to £2.1 million
• Growth in agricultural rental income of 18% to £2.7 million
• Received planning permissions on an additional 140 acres for commercial
development with a further 80 acres submitted and awaiting decisions
The results for the property operations for the two years ended 31 December 2005
are summarised as follows:
2005 2004
£000 £000
Revenue 4,841 3,912
Profit on sale of assets 9,611 2,760
Operating profit* 16,418 4,600
Valuation (including investment properties) 274,169 208,626
* Operating profit in 2005 includes £4.5 million in respect of revaluation of
investment properties and the profit on sale of assets.
Income derived from the Group's property portfolio may be summarised by type of
rental as follows:
2005 2004
Rental income Rental income
£000 % £000 %
Agricultural land 2,701 55.8 2,296 58.7
Business parks 2,140 44.2 1,616 41.3
Total 4,841 100.0 3,912 100.0
Agricultural Land
Agricultural land continues to be managed on a tenancy basis to selected
occupiers. The portfolio comprises in excess of 600 individual tenancies, on
which income rose by 18% in the year, in what continues to be a difficult
market. This growth was achieved by a combination of rent reviews, increased
land usage and additional income from land returned from surface mining use
following restoration.
Business Parks
Income at the Group's business parks grew by some 32% in the year, from higher
occupancy, rent reviews and new leases. Asfordby and Whitemoor both had an
occupancy rate of around 95% at the year end. During 2005 the new lease at Mid
Cannock and the first lease at Gascoigne Wood contributed to the year on year
profit increase. A new development at Bilsthorpe is proceeding well; the first
20,000 sq ft building was completed during 2005 and is under offer for lease.
Investment Properties
Asfordby Business Park was classed as an investment property in 2003. Whitemoor
Business Park and the Group's land at Mid Cannock, a vacant site leased for 50
years, have been classed as such during 2005. In accordance with accounting
standards, £4.6 million of gains on the initial recognition of investment
properties have been taken to reserves, while £4.5 million of gains on
subsequent revaluations have been recognised in the income statement. Future
movements in the value of the investment properties will similarly be taken to
the consolidated income statement. At 31 December 2005, investment properties
were valued at £17.8 million, compared to £6.7 million at 31 December 2004.
Development Properties
During 2005, the Group received planning permission for commercial use on 140
acres of land, including 80 acres at phase 2 of Waverley AMP. This represents a
significant step forward in the development of these sites. A further 15 acres
has been allocated for mixed development in the Gedling Local Plan. During the
year, applications were made to Selby District Council for permission to use the
Stillingfleet, Riccall, Wistow and Gascoigne Wood sites for alternative
purposes. Unfortunately these applications have been rejected. We will, however,
appeal these decisions and dialogue continues with Selby District Council about
how these sites can be developed to meet both parties' respective goals.
Profits from property sales amounted to £9.6 million (2004: £2.8 million),
arising from partial disposals at Tetron Point, Houghton Main, Denby Hall and
Waverley AMP. These sales generated proceeds of £15.0 million (2004: £4.3
million). These disposals relate to land where we believe we have extracted full
added value opportunities.
We have continued to add value through development of our portfolio and in 2005
we spent £7.8 million on various projects to improve and add value to our
existing properties. The major areas of spend were:
• Continued infrastructure works at Tetron Point;
• Site preparation and building works at Bilsthorpe;
• Infrastructure works at Denby;
• Contribution to infrastructure costs at Waverley AMP;
• Compaction costs at Waverley (Orgreave); and
• Planning and consultation costs at Waverley (Orgreave) and Prince of
Wales.
Valuation
Like for
Like
Land Category Dec-04 Jun-05 Dec-05 Dec-04 to
£000 £000 £000 Dec- 05
Business Parks 17,410 18,960 19,210 55%
Development Properties
Commercial with Planning 34,004 33,140 30,060 17%
Other commercial or residential 91,406 115,167 114,992 24%
Agricultural 59,086 92,991 92,157 57%
Total excluding investment properties 201,906 260,258 256,419 35%
Investment Properties 6,720 17,750 17,750 24%
TOTAL 208,626 278,008 274,169 34|
A full independent property valuation of all properties was carried out at 30
June 2005, with an update at the year end, in accordance with the 'RICS
Appraisal and Valuation Standards' published by the Chartered Institute of
Surveyors. This follows the limited update to the 2002 valuation carried out at
31 December 2004.
The gross valuation (excluding investment properties) has increased by 29.8% to
£256.4 million (31 December 2004: £197.6 million), the major reason being the
uplift in the agricultural valuation (including residential properties) since
2002 and the planning consents obtained since that date. The valuation is before
the deduction of rehabilitation and restoration costs of £66.4 million (31
December 2004: £77.2 million), which are provided in the accounts and relate
mainly to working surface mines and sites in aftercare. On a like for like
basis, taking into account disposals and development expenditure, the property
portfolio (excluding investment properties) has shown a gain of £67.0 million
(35%). The valuation has declined slightly since the half year; the result of
sales in the second half but on a like for like basis shows no movement. The
valuation exceeds the amount recorded in the books by £181.5 million (31
December 2004: £126.3 million).
The valuation of the non-agricultural properties was undertaken by NAI Fuller
Peiser acting in the capacity of external valuers. The basis of value is market
value, but subject to a number of assumptions, the most important of which are:
•The sites will be cleared of redundant buildings, levelled and prepared
ready for development;
•The values are on the basis that no material environmental contamination
exists on the subject or adjoining sites, or where this is present the sites
will be remediated by UK COAL to a standard consistent with the intended
use; and
•No deduction or adjustment has been made in relation to clawback
provisions, or other taxes which may be payable.
It should be noted that changes, such as planning approvals, could have a
material effect on future valuations.
The agricultural land in the north of England and Scotland was valued by Bell
Ingram with the remaining land valued by Smiths Gore. Both valuations used
market value subject to existing tenancies and were based on existing use.
Future Prospects
The Group is currently managing around 40 separate property projects. In the
short term, it is the intention of management to maintain, and enhance where
possible, the current income streams while adding value by:
•Completing master planning at our key development sites;
•Completing construction and letting of development properties;
•Commencement of master planning at appropriate sites;
•Constructing new buildings at existing business parks, where demand for
pre let accommodation is strong;
•Continuing the process of securing planning at sites where there is the
opportunity to create value through new commercial development;
•Exploiting agricultural portfolio for surface mining, residential
development and possible disposals of surplus land and properties; and
•Continuing infrastructure works and disposal programme at appropriate
development sites.
Harworth Power
Development and Performance
The results for Harworth Power for the two years ended 31 December 2005 are
summarised as follows:
2005 2004
£000 £000
External revenue 862 76
Inter company revenue 2,868 3,881
Total Turnover 3,730 3,957
Emissions Trading credits 2,446 2,972
Methane costs (to Deep Mining) (475) -
Other costs (2,341) (2,690)
Operating profit 3,360 4,239
During the year, Harworth Power made an operating profit of £3.4 million (2004:
£4.2 million), achieved by the generation of 104,526 MWH of electricity (2004:
104,234 MWH). The fall in profit arises from a decrease in credits from the UK
Emissions Trading Scheme to £2.4 million (2004: £3.0 million), together with the
introduction by the deep mines of charges for methane, amounting to £0.5 million
in 2005 (2004: £nil).
Planning permission was received in the year for the operation of three wind
turbines at the Royal Oak site in County Durham, generating some 3.9 MW. It is
anticipated that construction will commence during 2006, with the expectation
that the wind farm will commence operations during the first half of 2007.
Harworth Power has a total installed capacity of 32 MW (2004: 32 MW).
Future Prospects
Extraction of methane from existing sites is expected to continue into the
foreseeable future. Generation is forecast to increase with the installation of
new engines at mine sites where methane capture is being improved. Capital will
be invested where adequate returns are available, principally in the
installation of new engines at mine sites. The UK Emissions Trading Scheme
finishes at the end of 2006, reducing the incentive to invest in certain
emissions reduction projects. UK COAL is actively involved in discussions as to
the form of any replacement scheme.
The Group will submit further applications in respect of eight wind farms,
generating 80MW from 74 turbines during 2006. Provided the applications are
successful, commissioning of these farms would be phased during 2007 and 2008.
The Group has identified other opportunities to generate additional power
utilising renewable energy sources. It is evaluating the commercial strengths
and risks of these schemes and the level of investment needed and will make
investment in those schemes that match the returns required by the Group.
Monckton
Monckton, which produces coke and high quality coking products, was sold during
June 2005. Monckton made an operating profit of £1.4 million during the six
months to June 2005 (2004: £0.3 million for twelve months).
Monckton was sold for a consideration of £13.1 million, with £8.3 million
received in the year and the remainder to be paid in instalments ending June
2007. The terms of the sale grant UK COAL a royalty on future sales, in addition
to opening a sales channel for suitable products at favourable prices.
Capital Structure
The Group had net liabilities of £14.7 million at 31 December 2005, compared to
net assets of £56.8 million at 31 December 2004, a reduction of £71.5 million.
It should be noted that the Group's properties have been valued at an amount
which is £181.5 million higher than their book value. If the properties were
included at their revalued amounts, therefore, the Group would have net assets
of £166.8 million, excluding provision for any clawback or taxation liabilities.
The major movements in the balance sheet are summarised in the following
paragraphs:
•Property, plant and equipment have decreased by £36.2 million in the
year, the result of additions of £27.5 million being offset by depreciation
/ impairment of £54.2 million, disposals of £8.9 million and transfers to
investment properties of £1.9 million.
•Two further properties have been included as investment properties in the
year in accordance with the Group's accounting policy.
•The Group has reduced its inventories by some £5.5 million, a reflection
of lower activity levels in both deep and surface mines together with
provisions against stores stocks for closed or mothballed mines.
•The Group makes provisions in respect of redundancies where there is an
obligation at the balance sheet date. Provisions are also made in respect of
employer and public liability claims; surface damage; surface and deep mine
restoration and rehabilitation costs including shaft capping where
appropriate; and pumping costs at closed sites. A table containing detailed
financial information is set out in note 9 to the financial statements.
•Retirement benefit obligations have increased by £5.2 million. This
movement may be summarised as follows:
Pension Concessionary Fuel Total
£m £m £m
1 January 2005 (114.5) (22.6) (137.1)
Employer's current service costs (12.8) (0.5) (13.3
Expected return on assets 16.1 - 16.1
Interest on deficit (18.1) (0.8) (18.9)
Net actuarial losses (10.3) (4.0) (14.3)
Gains on curtailments 2.2 3.0 5.2
Employer's contributions 19.4 0.6 20.0
31 December 2005 (118.0) (24.3) (142.3)
Net actuarial losses represent the difference between the actuarial gains
(actual returns over those expected from the schemes' assets), and actuarial
losses (losses as a result of changes in assumptions used to value the
liabilities). The retirement benefit obligations position noted above should be
read in conjunction with note 9. The retirement benefit obligation valuations
are subject to a number of uncertainties, including, but not limited to, the
estimation of future rates of return from the pension scheme assets and the
actuarial assumptions underpinning the liabilities, including life expectancy,
inflation and salary increases.
•The pension deficit has recorded a modest increase of £3.5 million, the
result of an increase in the value of liabilities of £73.3 million, largely
reflecting lower bond yields, outweighing the investment returns of £53.1
million and contributions of £16.7 million (net of benefits paid). The
discount rate used is determined by reference to AA rated corporate bond
yields, which are at a historic low.
•During the year ended 31 December 2005, additional contributions
amounting to £6.5 million were paid to the pension schemes. It is
anticipated these additional contributions will continue, and the deficit
will reduce over a ten year period.
Cash Flow and Funding
Net cash at 31 December 2005 and 31 December 2004 is summarised as follows:
2005 2004
£000 £000
Cash deposited to cover insurance requirements 25,447 29,747
Subsidence security fund 26,769 25,544
Other cash balances 1,004 326
Cash and cash equivalents 53,220 55,617
Debt (75,295) (12,225)
Finance leases and hire purchase contracts (21,246) (36,106)
Borrowings (96,541) (48,331)
Net (borrowings) / funds (43,321) 7,286
As a requirement of the Financial Services Authority and The Coal Authority,
cash is held to match provisions in respect of employer and public liabilities
and surface damage and shaft treatment liabilities. At the year-end, cash held
for such purposes was £52.2 million (2004: £55.3 million).
The Group has increased its borrowings by £48.2 million in the year. The major
items are summarised as follows:
•Capital expenditure amounted to £18.7 million; receipts from the sale of
plant, property and equipment were £15.9 million;
•Receipts from the sale of Monckton in the year were £8.3 million; a
further £4.8 million will be recovered in 2006 and 2007;
•Repayment of finance leases were £19.8 million;
•Coal Investment Aid received of £18.5 million;
•Additional payments to pension schemes of £6.5 million;
•Redundancy payments amounted to £16.1 million; and
•Other payments were £31.3 million in relation to the restoration of
former surface mines and deep mines, surface damage claims, and insurance
settlements.
At 31 December 2005, the Group had committed banking facilities of £105.5
million, consisting of £74.0 million on its syndicated revolving credit
facility, which expires in July 2007, £21.5 million on a property and
development loan expiring in 2008, and a £10.0 million overdraft facility. Since
the year end, the Group has negotiated an increase in its banking facilities to
£143.0 million, plus leasing.
Contingent liability
No amounts in relation to the ongoing proceedings concerning early-retirement,
pension-related redundancy payments for employees transferred to the Group on
privatisation have been provided in the financial statements. The contingent
liability should be noted as, if UK COAL loses its case, the effect on the
results and cash resources could be significant. Full details are set out in
note 10.
Income Statement
For the year ended 31 December
2005 2004
Notes £000 £000
Continuing operations
Revenue 2 341,214 433,818
Cost of sales 3 (412,606) (470,787)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gross loss (71,392) (36,969)
Coal Investment Aid 4 14,641 8,902
Appreciation in fair value of investment 4,530 -
properties
Profit on disposal of property, plant and 10,074 3,317
equipment
Profit on sale of business 5 3,100 -
Other operating income and expenses (14,286) (12,300)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Operating loss (53,333) (37,050)
Interest payable and similar charges 6 (11,753) (9,753)
Interest receivable 6 2,992 4,605
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net finance costs 6 (8,761) (5,148)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Loss before tax (62,094) (42,198)
Tax - -
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Loss for the year from continuing activities (62,094) (42,198)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Discontinued operations
Loss for the year from discontinued operations (72) (1,626)
Profit on disposal of discontinued operations - 10,293
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total (loss) / profit from discontinued (72) 8,667
operations
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Loss for the year (62,166) (33,531)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Attributable to:
Equity holders of the parent (62,166) (33,480)
Minority interest - (51)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(62,166) (33,531)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Loss per share p p
From continuing operations:
Basic and diluted (41.9) (29.0)
From discontinued operations:
Basic and diluted - 6.0
From total operations:
Basic and diluted (41.9) (23.0)
Statement of Recognised Income and Expense
For the year ended 31 December
2005 2004
£000 £000
Loss for the year (62,166) (33,531)
Actuarial losses on defined benefit pension schemes (10,286) (14,025)
Actuarial (loss) / gain on concessionary fuel reserve (3,995) 2,307
Accrual for long term incentive plan liabilities 173 (211)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net losses not recognised in income statement (14,108) (11,929)
Total recognised expense for the year (76,274) (45,460)
===================================================================================================
Attributable to:
Equity holders of parent (76,274) (45,409)
Minority interests - (51)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(76,274) (45,460)
==================================================================================================
Balance Sheets
At 31 December
2005 2004
Notes £000 £000
ASSETS
Non current assets
Property plant and equipment 322,050 358,232
Investment property 17,750 6,720
Trade and other receivables 4,728 4,131
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
344,528 369,083
===================================================================================================
Current assets
Inventories 42,168 47,641
Trade and other receivables 63,312 62,358
Cash and cash equivalents 53,220 55,617
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
158,700 165,616
====================================================================================================
LIABILITIES
Current liabilities
Financial liabilities
- Borrowings 7 (55,575) (12,225)
Trade and other payables (104,927) (106,871)
Obligations under hire purchase and finance leases 7 (7,411) (10,998)
Provisions 8 (52,320) (46,837)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(220,233) (176,931)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net current liabilities (61,533) (11,315)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Non current liabilities
Financial liabilities
- Borrowings 7 (19,720) -
- Derivative financial instruments (55) -
Obligations under hire purchase and finance leases 7 (13,835) (25,108)
Provisions 8 (121,778) (138,812)
Retirement benefit obligations 9 (142,338) (137,059)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(297,726) (300,979)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net (liabilities) / assets (14,731) 56,789
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Equity
Capital and reserves
Ordinary shares 1,485 1,462
Share premium 1,771 122
Revaluation reserve 4,565 -
Capital redemption reserve 257 257
Fair value reserve 4,530 -
Retained earnings (27,339) 54,948
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(Deficit) / surplus on total shareholders' equity (14,731) 56,789
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash Flow Statements
For the year ended 31 December
2005 2004
£000 £000
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash flows from operating activities
Loss for the year (62,166) (33,531)
Depreciation / impairment of property, plant and equipment 50,119 55,336
Fair value appreciation in investment properties (4,530) -
Net interest receivable and amortisation of discount on provisions 8,376 5,148
Net charge / (credit) for share based remuneration 173 (211)
Net credit for surface mine development and restoration costs (3,356) (1,649)
Profit on disposal of property, plant and equipment (10,074) (3,317)
Profit on sale of interests in businesses (3,100) (10,293)
Decrease in provisions (23,676) (29,200)
Tax 72 -
Dti contributions to redundancy payments - 5,200
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Operating cash flows before movements in working capital (48,162) (12,517)
Decrease in stocks 2,004 10,828
(Increase) / decrease in receivables (1,551) 24,589
Decrease in payables (5,936) (5,524)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash (used in) / generated from operations (53,645) 17,376
Tax paid (72) -
Financing cost (738) -
Interest paid (5,744) (4,006)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash (used in) / generated from operating activities (60,199) 13,370
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash flows from investing activities
Interest received 2,992 4,605
Net receipt from insurance and security provision funds 3,075 3,675
Disposal of businesses 8,844 19,571
Proceeds on disposal of property, plant and equipment 15,861 6,382
Purchase of property, plant and equipment (18,688) (51,370)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash generated from / (used in) investing activities 12,084 (17,137)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash flows from financing activities
Proceeds from issue of share capital 1,672 122
New bank loans raised 63,464 5,067
Purchase of treasury shares - (43)
Proceeds from new finance leases 4,939 22,185
Repayments of obligations under hire purchase and finance leases (19,799) (9,986)
Dividends paid to shareholders (1,483) (14,573)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash generated from financing activities 48,793 2,772
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Effects of exchange rate differences - (63)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Increase / (decrease) in cash 678 (1,058)
====================================================================================================
At 1 January
Cash 326 1,384
Cash equivalents 55,291 58,966
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
55,617 60,350
Reduction in cash equivalents (net receipt from insurance and (3,075) (3,675)
security funds)
Increase / (decrease) in cash 678 (1,058)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
53,220 55,617
====================================================================================================
At 31 December
Cash 1,004 326
Cash equivalents 52,216 55,291
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash and cash equivalents 53,220 55,617
====================================================================================================
Notes to the Accounts
1 Accounting Policies
These financial statements have been prepared in accordance with International
Financial Reporting Standards ('IFRS') and IFRIC interpretations and with those
parts of the Companies Act 1985 applicable to companies reporting under IFRS (as
endorsed by the EU). The consolidated financial statements have been prepared
under the historical cost convention, as modified by the revaluation of
investment properties in accordance with IAS 40 'Investment Property'.
The rules for first time adoption of IFRS are set out in IFRS 1 'First time
adoption of International Financial Reporting Standards'. In preparing the
financial statements, these rules have been applied to the amounts previously
reported under UK GAAP. IFRS 1 generally requires full retrospective application
of the standards and interpretations in force at the first reporting date.
However IFRS 1 allows certain optional exemptions in the application of
particular standards to prior periods in order to assist companies with the
transition process. UK COAL's decisions in respect of these exemptions are as
follows:
•UK COAL has adopted IFRS 5 'Non-current Assets Held for Sale and
Discontinued Operations' with effect from 1 January 2005, with no
restatement of comparative information for 2004.
•UK COAL has opted to continue to measure property, plant and equipment
(excluding investment property) at historical cost, less accumulated
depreciation.
•UK COAL has elected to recognise all cumulative actuarial gains and
losses in respect of retirement benefit schemes in reserves on transition
rather than recognising certain of them through the consolidated income
statement prospectively over a period of time.
•UK COAL has, in recognising fair values of share based payments to
employees, chosen to apply the exemption only to include those awards made
after 7 November 2002 which had not vested at 31 December 2003 in its
calculations at the date of transition.
•UK COAL has assumed cumulative translation differences for foreign
operations to be zero at the date of transition. This related to the
Australian subsidiary, Gloucester Coal, at the date of transition. At 31
December 2004 and 31 December 2005, UK COAL had no foreign subsidiaries.
•UK COAL has not retrospectively applied IFRS 3 'Business Combinations' to
business combinations that occurred before the date of transition.
•UK COAL has elected to adopt IAS 32 'Financial instruments: Disclosure
and presentation' and IAS 39 'Financial instruments: Recognition and
measurement' with effect from 1 January 2005. This allows the recognition of
derivatives for the first time in the accounting period ending 31 December
2005 and does not require comparative figures to be restated. The
comparative numbers were prepared under UK GAAP. No significant adjustments
to the comparative numbers would be required for them to comply with IAS 32
and IAS 39.
•A number of IFRS Standards and Interpretations are not yet mandatory but
can be adopted early under their respective transition arrangements. UK COAL
has adopted early IFRS 6 'Exploration for and Evaluation of Mineral
Resources' and the amendment to IAS 19 'Employee Benefits: Actuarial Gains
and Losses, Group Plans and Disclosures'.
A reconciliation of the Group's results for the year ended 31 December 2004 and
the net assets at 1 January 2004 and 31 December 2004, as reported under UK
GAAP, to those reportable under IFRS was sent to all shareholders with the
interim report.
2 Segmental reporting
Revenue
Revenue from continuing operations arises from: 2005 2004
£000 £000
Sale of goods 334,355 428,865
Rendering of services 6,859 4,953
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
341,214 433,818
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Primary reporting format - business segments
Year ended 31 December 2005 Deep Surface Harworth
Mining Mining Property Power Other Total
£000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Continuing operations
Revenue - gross 312,191 59,278 4,841 3,730 11,280 391,320
Revenue- intra group (13,163) (34,075) - (2,868) - (50,106)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Revenue 299,028 25,203 4,841 862 11,280 341,214
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gross (loss) / profit before (37,337) 6,048 6,754 916 1,380 (22,239)
Exceptional Items within cost of
sales
Exceptional Items within cost of (46,649) (2,504) - - - (49,153)
sales
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gross (loss) / profit (83,986) 3,544 6,754 916 1,380 (71,392)
Coal Investment Aid 14,641 - - - - 14,641
Appreciation in fair value of - - 4,530 - - 4,530
properties
Profit on disposal of property, 305 158 9,611 - - 10,074
plant and equipment
Profit on disposal of business - - - - 3,100 3,100
Other operating income and (9,398) (2,859) (4,477) 2,446 2 (14,286)
expenses
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Operating (loss) / profit from (78,438) 843 16,418 3,362 4,482 (53,333)
continuing operations
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Interest expense (11,753)
Interest income 2,992
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Loss before tax (62,094)
Tax (relating to discontinued operations) (72)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Loss for the year (62,166)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Segmental assets 318,531 71,297 125,167 8,357 523,352
Segmental liabilities (377,444) (106,213) (10,061) (330) (494,048)
Unallocated liabilities - net debt and finance leases (44,035)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net liabilities (14,731)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other segmental items
Capital expenditure 17,533 7,730 2,226 26 - 27,515
Impairment 6,601 500 - - - 7,101
Depreciation 37,114 8,794 - 919 270 47,097
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Year ended 31 December 2004 Deep Surface Harworth
Mining Mining Property Power Other Total
£000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Continuing operations
Revenue - gross 381,819 86,616 3,912 3,957 19,954 496,258
Revenue - intra group (16,971) (41,588) - (3,881) - (62,440)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Revenue 364,848 45,028 3,912 76 19,954 433,818
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gross (loss) / profit before (27,225) 7,041 1,685 1,267 (745) (17,977)
Exceptional Items within cost of
sales
Exceptional Items within cost of sales (14,669) (4,323) - - - (18,992)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gross (loss) / profit (41,894) 2,718 1,685 1,267 (745) (36,969)
Coal Investment Aid 8,902 - - - - 8,902
Appreciation in fair value of - - - - - -
properties
Profit on disposal of property, 58 499 2,760 - - 3,317
plant and equipment
Profit on disposal of business - - - - - -
Other operating income and expenses (11,997) (3,475) 155 2,972 45 (12,300)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Operating (loss) / profit from (44,931) (258) 4,600 4,239 (700) (37,050)
continuing activities
Discontinued operations
Revenue - external 9,092 9,092
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Segment result (1,626) (1,626)
Profit on disposal of business 10,293 10,293
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total profit from discontinued operations 8,667 8,667
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Interest expense (9,753)
Interest income 4,605
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Loss for the year (33,531)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Segmental assets 353,448 84,095 96,824 5,482 10,495 550,344
Segmental liabilities (351,322) (129,207) (4,548) (3,274) (12,489) (500,840)
Unallocated liabilities - net debt 7,285
and finance leases
Net assets 56,789
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other segmental Items
Capital expenditure 48,050 9,597 1,261 285 24 59,217
Impairment of assets 2,256 4,323 - - - 6,579
Depreciation 41,071 13,304 - 677 758 55,810
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Secondary format - geographic segments
The Group manages its business segments on a global basis. Following the sale of
the Australian subsidiary in 2004, the Group is now entirely based in the United
Kingdom. The United Kingdom is the home of the parent company. An analysis of
revenue by destination, together with capital expenditure and segment assets is
given in the following table:
Revenue Segment Capital
assets expenditure
2005 2004 2005 2004 2005 2004
£000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000
Continuing operations
United Kingdom 333,272 423,867 523,352 550,344 27,515 59,018
Europe 7,942 9,951 - - - -
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
341,214 433,818 523,352 550,344 27,515 59,018
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Discontinued operations
United Kingdom - 2,874 - - - -
Europe - - - - - -
Asia - Pacific (Australia) - 6,218 - - - 199
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
341,214 442,910 523,352 550,344 27,515 59,217
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3 Cost of sales Notes 2005 2004
£000 £000
Exceptional Items within cost of sales
Redundancy 4a (24,249) (6,277)
Selby post coaling 4b 249 (6,223)
Ellington post coaling 4c (5,635) -
Ellington impairment 4d - (3,109)
Stores equipment 4e (4,696) -
Impairment of assets at Harworth 4f (967) -
Impairment of assets at Rossington 4g (5,634) -
Recovery costs at Kellingley and Rossington 4h (12,551) -
Surface mine equipment 4i (500) (4,323)
Pension obligation in respect of companies disposed of in 4j - (1,299)
prior years
Amount recovered against TXU debt 4k - 2,239
Costs incurred following approach for company 4l (350) -
Post retirement benefits 4m 5,180 -
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(49,153) (18,992)
Other cost of sales (363,453) (451,795)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total cost of sales (412,606) (470,787)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4 Exceptional Items 2005 2004
£000 £000
Exceptional Items within cost of sales (49,153) (18,992)
Other Exceptional Items -
Coal Investment Aid 4n 17,143 8,902
Amount provided against Coal Investment Aid claim 4o (2,502) -
Profit on disposal of businesses 4p 3,100 -
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total Exceptional Items (31,412) (10,090)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Operating loss before Exceptional Items (21,921) (26,960)
Net charge for Exceptional Items (31,412) (10,090)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Operating loss (53,333) (37,050)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
a) Costs for redundancies announced during the year at deep mines collieries
(other than the Selby Complex), surface mining operations and head office
reorganisation, including senior management (2004: costs predominantly
associated with the closure of the Selby mines and surface works and head office
reorganisation).
b) Costs incurred between cessation of coaling and commencement of
restoration work at Selby not provided at December 2002 when the impairment in
value was recognised.
c) Costs incurred at Ellington Colliery following the cessation of mining
operations in January 2005.
d) Following the announced closure of Ellington Colliery, the carrying value
and estimated useful economic lives of the mine and surface works has been
reviewed giving rise to an impairment in value of £2,256,000 and a write-down in
the value of stores stocks of £853,000.
e) Write down in value of redundant stores equipment.
f) Following the announcement to mothball Harworth Colliery, the assets of
the colliery were reviewed, giving rise to an impairment in value of £967,000
and a write down in the value of stores stocks of £1,685,000 (included within
item 4e).
g) Following the announcement of the mothballing of Rossington Colliery, the
carrying value and estimated useful economic lives of the mine and surface works
has been reviewed giving rise to an impairment in value of £5,634,000 and a
write-down in the value of stores stocks of £933,000 (included within item 4e).
h) Additional labour costs incurred at Rossington and Kellingley consequent
to the revised mining plans following invocation of the force majeure clause of
the Drax contract.
i) Write down in value of redundant surface mine equipment.
j) Pension obligations in respect of Blenkinsopp Collieries Ltd which went
into liquidation after UK COAL disposed of its interest in a previous year.
k) Additional monies credited to the income statement as UK COAL's
entitlements, under the agreement selling its claim against TXU, becoming
clearer as resolution of the agreement progresses.
l) Costs incurred following an approach from a consortium looking to
acquire the Company. It comprises fees from property advisors, lawyers and
financial advisors.
m) Reduction in the Group's liability to provide post retirement benefits in
retirement in respect of staff leaving UK COAL's employment during the financial
year 2005.
n) Coal Investment Aid receivable under the Government Aid Scheme. Includes
£1.8 million relating to the accelerated release of Investment Aid.
o) Claims for Coal Investment Aid which are being challenged following
closure or mothballing of collieries or revised coaling approaches.
p) Profit on disposal of Monckton business.
5 Profit on sale of business
On 17 June 2005 the Group disposed of its wholly owned subsidiary, The Monckton
Coke & Chemical Company Limited, for a consideration (before transaction costs)
of £12.0 million plus an incremental adjustment in respect of working capital in
the sum of £1.1 million. £8.3 million of the proceeds were received in the year,
with the remainder to be paid in instalments ending June 2007.
£000
Property, plant and equipment 5,557
Inventories 3,469
Trade and other receivables 4,314
Cash and cash equivalents (844)
Trade and other payables (1,222)
Provisions (1,588)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9,686
Profit on disposal 3,100
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash consideration, net of transaction costs 12,786
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6 Net finance costs
2005 2004
£000 £000
Interest payable on bank borrowings (4,018) (1,731)
Amortisation of issue costs of bank loan (344) (446)
Interest payable on hire purchase agreements and (1,877) (1,691)
finance leases
Discounting of non current receivables (391) -
Unwinding of discounts on provisions (5,123) (5,885)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Interest payable and similar charges (11,753) (9,753)
Interest receivable 2,992 4,605
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net interest payable (8,761) (5,148)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7 Financial liabilities - Borrowings
Current
2005 2004
£000 £000
Bank loans and overdrafts due within one year or on demand:
Secured 55,575 12,225
Unsecured - -
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
55,575 12,225
Finance lease obligations 7,411 10,998
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
62,986 23,223
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Non current
2005 2004
£000 £000
Bank loans and overdrafts
Secured 19,720 -
Unsecured - -
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
19,720 -
Finance lease obligations 13,835 25,108
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
33,555 25,108
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bank loans and overdrafts due within one year or on demand are stated after
deduction of unamortised borrowing costs of £556,000 (2004: £441,000). Non
current bank loans and overdrafts are stated after deduction of unamortised
borrowing costs of £280,000 (2004: £nil). The Group's Revolving Credit Facility
comprises one month rolling drawdowns, and are thus disclosed under amounts
falling due within one year. The facility is, however, committed until 2007.
The bank loans and overdrafts are secured by way of fixed and floating charges
over certain assets of the Group.
The exposure of the Group to interest rate changes when borrowings reprice is as
follows:
1 year 1-5 years 5 years Total
£000 £000 £000 £000
As at 31 December 2005
Total borrowings 82,706 13,661 174 96,541
Effect of interest rate swaps (17,000) 17,000 - -
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
65,706 30,661 174 96,541
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
As at 31 December 2004
Total borrowings 23,223 24,759 349 48,331
The effective interest rates at the balance sheet date were as follows.
2005 2004
Bank overdraft 5.5% 5.8%
Bank borrowings 6.1% 6.1%
Finance lease 6.6% 6.8%
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The carrying amount of the Group's borrowings are denominated in sterling.
The minimum lease payments under finance leases fall due as follows:
2005 2004
£000 £000
Not later than one year 8,733 16,268
Later than one year, but not more than five years 15,310 23,825
More than five years 186 372
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
24,229 40,465
Future finance charges on finance leases (2,983) (4,359)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Present value of finance lease liabilities 21,246 36,106
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
8 Provisions
As at At
01-Jan Provided Released Subsidiary Utilised Unwinding 31-Dec
2005 in year in year sold in year of 2005
discount
£000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000
Group
Employer and public 20,780 3,300 (332) - (6,685) 935 17,998
liabilities
Surface damage 22,652 6,016 (3,345) - (4,015) 680 21,988
Claims 1,026 559 - - (47) - 1,538
Restoration and 77,207 530 (2,828) - (10,863) 2,316 66,362
closure costs of
surface mines
Restoration and
closure costs of
deep mines
shaft treatment and 23,324 6,560 (3,114) - (8,934) 658 18,494
pit top
spoil heaps 5,389 275 - - (797) 162 5,029
pumping costs 8,130 790 - - (4) 69 8,985
Ground/groundwater 11,043 - (281) (1,582) - 303 9,483
contamination
Redundancy 16,098 26,394 (2,145) - (16,126) - 24,221
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
185,649 44,424 (12,045) (1,582) (47,471) 5,123 174,098
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Provisions have been analysed between current and non current as follows:
2005 2004
£000 £000
Current 52,320 46,837
Non current 121,778 138,812
174,098 185,649
Provisions are expected to be settled within the timescales set out in the
following table. It should be noted that these are based on the information
available at the time the financial statements were prepared and are subject to
a number of estimates and uncertainties, as noted below.
Within 1 1-2 years 2-5 years More than 5 Total
year years
£000 £000 £000 £000 £000
Employer and public liabilities 9,026 3,613 3,704 1,655 17,998
Surface damage 4,837 4,398 9,675 3,078 21,988
Claims 1,538 - - - 1,538
Restoration and closure costs of 15,846 11,907 33,945 4,664 66,362
surface mines
Restoration and closure costs of
deep mines
shaft treatment and pit top 2,584 220 2,628 13,062 18,494
spoil heaps 337 50 150 4,492 5,029
pumping costs - - - 8,985 8,985
Ground/groundwater contamination - - - 9,483 9,483
Redundancy 18,152 6,069 - - 24,221
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
52,320 26,257 50,102 45,419 174,098
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The total of provisions created net of provisions released was £32.4 million
(2004: £24.6 million). This included £29.6 million (2004: £6.3 million) in
respect of Exceptional Items and £2.8 million (2004: £18.3 million) in respect
of non-exceptional items.
A brief description of the nature of the Group's obligations and an indication
of the uncertainties surrounding each of the above provisions is provided below:
Employer and public liabilities - provisions are made for current and estimated
obligations in respect of claims made by employees and the general public
relating to accident or disease as a result of the business activities of the
Group.
Surface damage - provision is made for the Group's liability to compensate for
subsidence damage arising from past mining operations. Claims can be lodged by
the public up to six years after the date of relevant damage. The estimate is
based on historical claims experience following a detailed assessment of the
nature of damage foreseen.
Claims - where surface mine sites owned by the Group are mined by external
contractors and mining conditions vary from those specified in the contract, the
external contractors may be entitled to claim further costs incurred. Claims are
settled with individual contractors, generally at the completion of a surface
mining site. All claims provisions are based on known mining conditions
encountered, historical experience and contracted rates.
Restoration and closure costs of surface mines - provisions are made for the
total costs of reinstatement of soil excavation and for surface restoration such
as topsoil replacement and landscaping. Costs become payable after coal mining
has been completed. Further liabilities for after-care can extend after
restoration, for a period of up to six years.
Restoration and closure costs of deep mines:
Shaft treatment and pit top - provisions are made to meet the Group's liability
to fill and cap all mine shafts and return pit top areas to a condition
consistent with the required planning permission. No liabilities will arise
until decommissioning of each individual colliery. The current pit top provision
reflects existing planning permissions that require pit areas to be restored to
former use, usually agricultural. The Group will, where possible, seek planning
permission for development use, which, if successful, may reduce the expected
cost.
Spoil heaps - provisions are made for the costs payable to bring spoil heaps to
a condition consistent with required planning permission and to complete
approved restoration schemes. An element of spoil heap restoration is ongoing,
although the majority of costs will be incurred on decommissioning of a
colliery.
Pumping costs - there is a legal requirement to continue pumping activities at
certain mine sites following closure and for a period into the future. The
provision is based on current experience and the net present value of future
cost projections. Pumping costs on continuing operations are expensed as
incurred.
Ground/groundwater contamination - provisions are made for the Group's legal or
constructive obligation to address ground and groundwater pollutants at its
operating sites. The provision is based on estimates of volumes of contaminated
soil and the historical contract costs of ground contamination treatment. These
costs will usually be incurred on the decommissioning of a site.
Redundancy - provision is made for current estimated future costs of redundancy
and ex-gratia payments to be made where this has been communicated to those
employees concerned.
9 Retirement benefit obligations
Defined Contribution Pension Schemes
The Group operates defined contribution pension schemes in respect of all
employees who joined after the privatisation date in 1994. Contributions to
defined contribution schemes amounted to £1.7 million (2004: £2.1 million).
Defined Benefit Pension Schemes
The balance sheet amounts in respect of retirement benefit obligations are:
2005 2004
£000 £000
Industry Wide Schemes 116,730 113,181
Blenkinsopp 1,299 1,299
Concessionary Fuel 24,309 22,579
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
142,338 137,059
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Contributions to defined benefit schemes during the year amounted to £19.3
million (2004: £16.9 million).
Industry Wide Schemes
The Group operates pension schemes providing benefits based on final pensionable
pay. The majority of the employees within defined benefit schemes are members of
industry wide schemes, being either the Industry Wide Coal Staff Superannuation
Scheme (IWCSSS) or the Industry Wide Mineworkers' Pension Scheme (IWMPS), both
of which commenced on privatisation following the Coal Industry Act 1994.
Contributions are determined by a qualified actuary on the basis of triennial
valuations using the projected unit method. The most recent valuations were at
31 December 2003. The assumptions which have the most significant effect on the
results of the valuation are those relating to the rate of return on investments
and the rates of increase in salaries and pensions. The main assumptions
underlying the valuations of the UK COAL sections of each scheme were as
follows:
2005 2004
Discount rate 4.70% pa 5.25% pa
Rate of return on investments 7.00% pa 7.00% pa
Rate of salary increases 2.70% pa 2.75% pa
Rate of price inflation 2.70%pa 2.75% pa
Rate of return on equities 7.00%pa 7.00%pa
Pensions in payment are assumed to increase in line with price inflation.
Post retirement mortality has been estimated using applicable standard mortality
tables. Normal health and ill health pensioners have been rated up by between
one and three years and by five years respectively.
The overall expected rate of return on assets is based on a historic view of the
yields from equities and the rates prevailing on applicable bonds at the balance
sheet date.
The amounts recognised in the balance sheet are as follows:
2005 2004
£000 £000
Present value of funding obligations (418,270) (344,925)
Fair value of plan assets 301,540 231,744
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net liability recognised in the balance sheet (116,730) (113,181)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
None of the pension schemes own any shares in the Company.
A deferred tax asset of £35.0 million (2004: £34.0 million) would offset the
gross deficit if the Group generates sufficient taxable profits before the
deficit is accounted for.
The amounts recognised in the income statement are:
2005 2004
£000 £000
Current service cost (12,802) (13,043)
Interest cost (18,053) (15,815)
Expected return on plan assets 16,109 13,740
Effect of curtailment or settlement 2,191 1,808
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(12,555) (13,310)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The above amounts are charged to cost of sales, except for the interest cost,
which is included in administrative expenses. A further £10.3 million (2004:
£14.0 million) has been charged to the statement of recognised income and
expense in the year. This represents the net effect of experience and actuarial
gains and losses on the schemes in the year.
Change in assets
2005 2004
£000 £000
Fair value of plan assets at 1 January 231,744 193,324
Expected return on plan assets 16,109 13,740
Actuarial gains on assets 36,975 10,171
Employer contributions 19,292 16,889
Plan participants contributions 3,903 4,677
Benefits paid (6,483) (7,057)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair value of plan assets at 31 December 301,540 231,744
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The major categories of assets as a percentage of total plan assets are as
follows:
2005 2004
£000 £000
Asset category
Equity securities 256,060 193,262
Debt securities 45,480 38,482
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total 301,540 231,744
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change in defined benefit obligations 2005 2004
£000 £000
Present value of defined benefit obligation at 1 (344,925) (296,059)
January
Current service cost (12,802) (13,043)
Interest cost (18,053) (15,815)
Plan participants' contributions (3,903) (4,677)
Curtailment gain 2,191 1,808
Actuarial loss (47,261) (24,196)
Benefits paid 6,483 7,057
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Present value of defined benefit obligation at 31 December (418,270) (344,925)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Analysis of the movement of the balance sheet
liability
2005 2004
£000 £000
1 January (113,181) (102,735)
Total expense as above (12,555) (13,310)
Contributions 19,292 16,889
Net actuarial losses from participants gains (10,286) (14,025)
recognised in year
31 December (116,730) (113,181)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cumulative actuarial gains and losses recognised in
equity
2005 2004
£000 £000
1 January (14,025) -
Net actuarial losses in the year (10,286) (14,025)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
31 December (24,311) (14,025)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The actual return on plan assets was £53.1 million (£23.9 million).
Experience gains and losses
2005 2004
£000 £000
Actual return less expected return on schemes' assets 36,975 10,171
Experience losses arising on schemes' liabilities (5,242) (7,074)
Changes in assumptions underlying present value of (42,019) (17,122)
liabilities
Net actuarial loss (10,286) (14,025)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
History of experience gains and losses
2005 2004 2003* 2002*
£000 £000 £000 £000
Actual return less expected return on 36,975 10,171 19,694 (53,260)
schemes' assets
Percentage of year end scheme assets 12% 4% 10% 36%
Experience (losses) / gains arising on (5,242) (7,074) 5,650 1,396
schemes' liabilities
Percentage of the present value of schemes' 1% 2% 2% 1%
liabilities
*The amounts for 2002 and 2003 are those disclosed under FRS17, as reported in
prior years.
The contribution expected to be paid in 2006 to the schemes during the year
ending 31 December 2006 amounts to £20.7 million.
Blenkinsopp
Blenkinsopp is a section of the industry wide mineworkers scheme covering the
pension arrangements of the various companies comprising parts of the former
British Coal. Blenkinsopp Collieries Limited was sold by UK COAL in 1998,
however the purchaser has since gone into receivership and the retirement
liabilities have reverted to UK COAL. The liability of £1.3 million (2004: £1.3
million) has been calculated on an ongoing basis.
Concessionary fuel
The Group operates a Concessionary Fuel arrangement in the UK. An actuarial
valuation was carried out by an independent actuary at 31 December 2005. The
major assumptions used by the actuary were:
2005 2004
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Discount rate 4.70% 5.30%
Inflation assumption 2.70% 2.80%
Coal price inflation 2.70% 1.80%
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The amounts recognised in the balance sheet are as follows:
2005 2004
£000 £000
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net liability recognised in the balance sheet (24,309) (22,579)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The arrangement is unfunded so no assets are held directly to meet the emerging
liabilities. A deferred tax asset of £7.3 million (2004: £6.8 million) would
offset the gross deficit if the Group generates sufficient taxable profits
before the deficit is accounted for.
The amounts recognised in the income statement are:
2005 2004
£000 £000
Current service cost 489 636
Interest cost 795 1,296
Effect of curtailment or settlement (2,989) -
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(1,705) 1,932
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The above amounts are charged to cost of sales, except for the interest cost,
which is included in administrative expenses. A further loss of £4.0 million
(2004: gain of £2.3 million) has been charged to the consolidated statement of
recognised income and expenses in the year. This represents the net effect of
experience and actuarial gains and losses on the schemes in the year.
Analysis of the movement of the balance sheet liability
2005 2004
£000 £000
Concessionary Fuel reserve at beginning of the year (22,579) (23,444)
Current service cost (489) (636)
Benefits paid to former employees during the year 560 490
Interest cost (795) (1,296)
Actuarial (loss) / gain (3,995) 2,307
Gains on curtailments 2,989 -
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Concessionary Fuel reserve at end of the year (24,309) (22,579)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cumulative actuarial gains and losses recognised in
equity
2005 2004
£000 £000
1 January 2,307 -
Net actuarial losses in the year (3,995) 2,307
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
31 December (1,688) 2,307
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Experience gains and losses
2005 2004
£000 £000
Experience gains on Concessionary Fuel reserve - 3,186
Changes in assumptions underlying present value of (3,995) (879)
liabilities
Total amount recognised in statement of income and expense (3,995) 2,307
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
History of experience gains and losses
2005 2004 2003* 2002*
£000 £000 £000 £000
Experience gains on Concessionary Fuel reserve - 3,186 4,297 829
Percentage of Concessionary Fuel reserve 0% 14% 17% 3%
*The amounts for 2002 and 2003 are those disclosed under FRS17, as reported in
prior years.
10 Contingent liabilities
Guarantees have been given in the normal course of business for performance
bonds of £2.1 million (2004: £2.2 million) to cover the performance of work
under a number of Group contracts.
In our Report and Accounts for the year ended 31 December 2004, we referred to a
claim against the Company to determine whether the Company may be required to
provide certain early retirement pension related benefits on redundancy. Neither
the legal analysis of the merits of the claim nor the difficulties inherent in
quantifying any financial cost to the Company have changed, and therefore no
provision has been made in the accounts. As reported in our interim accounts for
the period ended 30 June 2005, the Board considers, on the basis of legal and
actuarial advice, that the cost to the Company is estimated to be between zero
and £40 million (31 December 2004: between zero and £30 million). However, the
complexities of the legal issues involved, and the difficulties in quantifying
financial exposure, mean there remains a possibility that the cost to the
Company may exceed £40 million.
The increase in the range of estimated cost is principally the result of
redundancies announced since 31 December 2004, and a better estimate of
pensionable salary which could require top up by the Company to pensions in
payment and already paid by the former British Coal Corporation.
The hearing date for the case has been re-scheduled and is now expected to be
heard in the High Court during July 2006. The Company continues to vigorously
defend the claim.
11 Statutory Accounts
Financial information contained in this document does not constitute statutory
accounts within the meaning of section 240 of the Companies Act 1985 ('the
Act'). The statutory accounts for the year ended 31 December 2005 will be filed
with the Registrar of Companies following the Company's Annual General Meeting.
The auditors have reported on these accounts: their report was unqualified and
did not contain a statement under section 237(2) or (3) of the Act.
This information is provided by RNS
The company news service from the London Stock Exchange