Final Results
MFI Furniture Group PLC
26 February 2004
26 February 2004
Preliminary results for the 52 weeks to 27 December 2003
Financial highlights
- Turnover up 15.1% to £1,482m
- Howden Joinery up 37.1% to £448m
- UK Retail up 5.7% to £911m
- France Retail up 21.2% to £114m
- Pre-tax profit of £117.9m
- Pre-tax profit before property profits up 28.6% to £103.8m*
- EBITDA up 26.4% to £162.3m (see note 11)
- Earnings per share of 15.4p
- Earnings per share before property profits up 26.5% to 12.9p*
- Dividends per share up 22.6% to 3.8p
* reported before profit on disposal of fixed assets of £14.1m
Business highlights
- Continuing progress on all strategic priorities
- Sixth year of exceptional growth at Howden Joinery
- Continued growth from UK Retail - now entering final phase of store
refurbishments
- Excellent performance from new product categories
- France Retail responding well to store refits based on UK High Street
template
- Decision taken to move to test phase of Howden Millwork
John Hancock, Chief Executive, said:
'For the first time in the Group's history, operating profits have exceeded
£100m.
'We are pleased to be reporting on such strong financial results in what is an
increasingly competitive retail environment. The retail divisions are nearing
the end of a significant transition period that has seen a number of changes
over the past three years, including the refurbishment of the UK and French
store portfolios, the introduction of new product categories and international
pilots. The growth of Howden Joinery has added balance and stability to the
Group as a whole. With a focus on costs, I feel confident that MFI is strongly
positioned for future growth in profitability.'
- ends -
Contacts:
MFI Furniture Group Plc
John Hancock, Chief Executive 020 8913 5319
Martin Clifford-King, Finance Director 020 8913 5350
Brunswick Group Limited
Susan Gilchrist / Fiona Laffan / Katya Reynier 020 7404 5959
Overview
We have continued to make progress on our key strategic priorities - namely the
rollout of the new format into our stores both in the UK and in France, the
continued expansion of our highly successful Howden Joinery trade operation in
the UK, together with the continued piloting of a trade operation in the US and
the development of new supply chain initiatives.
The Group has achieved a significantly improved financial performance for the
fourth successive year in a period when we have invested heavily. We are growing
our profitability despite an increasingly unpredictable environment.
Financial results
Group sales and profitability increased strongly, with the outstanding
performance of Howden Joinery adding further balance and stability to the Group.
Sales of £1,482m represented a 15.1% increase on the previous year, 8.9% on a
same store basis. Profit before tax and exceptional credits rose by 28.6% to
£103.8m. An exceptional credit of £14.1m, arising from the disposal of
properties, resulted in reported profit before tax of £117.9m. Earnings per
share before exceptional items rose by 26.5% to 12.9p.
Sales growth versus last year within each route to market was as follows:
Sales Total Same store
Howden Joinery 37.1% 27.2%
UK Retail 5.7% 1.8%
France Retail 21.2% 7.3%
Total Group 15.1% 8.9%
Overall gross margin has increased from 50.2% to 50.9% reflecting more efficient
global sourcing, together with an increased mix of higher margin product in the
refurbished MFI stores and improved margins in the Howden Joinery depots.
Total selling and distribution costs have increased by 14.6%. Within this figure
is the impact of the acquisition of Sofa Workshop and the additional cost of the
new and reformatted stores and depots; after deducting these, same store costs
are up 8%.
Within operating profit there is a £2.7m provision for employer national
insurance arising from our various share incentive schemes and a further £0.7m
(2002 - £0.1m) amortisation of goodwill arising on the acquisition of Sofa
Workshop. Also we have received £4.1m for the surrender of leases which have
been credited to operating profit.
Routes to market
- Howden Joinery
Howden Joinery has continued to deliver outstanding results with operating
profits of £72.0m, up 62.2% on last year's figure of £44.4m. Operating margins
have grown from 13.6% to 16.1% over the period. The returns achieved today are a
result of the investment decisions taken in 1999 when we increased our opening
programme with the associated revenue costs and impact on profitability at the
time.
The continued organic growth from our existing depots, and the rollout of the
opening programme, resulted in total sales of £448m - an increase of 37.1% on
last year. Same depot sales growth was 27.2%.
By the end of 2003 we had 300 depots trading in the UK, 31 being opened in the
year. We aim to open a further 30 depots in 2004 and are ultimately targeting a
total of at least 380 depots within the UK.
- UK Retail
Sales were £911m, representing an increase over the previous year of 5.7%, up
1.8% on a same store basis. The operating profit of the UK Retail division has
increased from £37.7m to £41.7m, an increase of 10.6%. This has been achieved
after incurring £19m of costs and lost revenues associated with the
refurbishment programme (2002 - £20m).
A further 46 stores were opened in the new format in 2003 bringing the total to
122 today, two-thirds of the chain. Of these stores 74 are in full refit, 23
have received a partial refit and 25 have received a new partial refit. And by
the end of this year 156 will be in the new format, representing just under 90%
of our orders. The remaining stores will not be converted.
The first year uplift in orders in our full refit stores was 23%, compared to
the 25% level that we saw in 2002. Full refit stores trading in the second year
since refit have shown a 10% decline in orders against the first year, impacted
by a weak fourth quarter and a reduction in new product development in the year.
We are working to improve the performance in the second year using additional
promotional support.
At the time of the interims we said we were piloting a new partial refitted
store and these stores have achieved a 17% improvement in their first year,
compared to the 12% improvement we are seeing in the original partial refits.
Critical mass will be achieved during 2004 which will give us a wider range of
opportunities to promote our brands; including the ability to launch national
brand advertising across all our products and to develop better long-term
relationships with our customers. This, combined with an increased focus on
service levels, should drive both customer footfall and frequency of visits.
New product categories are performing in line with expectation with bathrooms
accounting for 8% (2002 - 8%) of sales in those stores where the product is
sold, reflecting a run-rate of £55m of sales per annum. Sofa sales are running
at £75m per annum and represent 5% (2002 - 4%) of sales in those stores where
the product is sold. The improvement in the sofa performance is encouraging as
we said 12 months ago that it was a key focus for 2003. Our move towards
solutions for every room in the house has valuable growth potential, as the
furniture market becomes increasingly fashion-driven.
As we anticipated the pace of product innovation during 2003 was slowed as we
rolled out the store refits. As we complete the refurbishment programme in 2004
the product development will return to former levels of investment with a
particular focus on lower-priced kitchens, bedrooms and beds.
- France Retail
Notwithstanding a weaker furniture market in France, sales were £114m, up 21.2%
on last year (10% in local currency) and with same store growth up by 7.3% in
local currency.
We have focussed on the refurbishment programme of our stores during the year,
and this will be virtually complete by the end of 2004. We have added 40 new
format stores (36 refits and 4 new stores) to the 28 that were open at the
beginning of the year - making a total of 68. And we are seeing first year
uplifts of around 20% on the refits. We now have 135 stores and plan to open
five during 2004.
Operating profits are £0.3m (2002 - £2.3m) after incurring £5m costs of
disruption arising from the conversion process (2002 - £4m) and further
investment in the infrastructure of the company.
- Howden Millwork
We have extended our initial pilot of 12 depots in the US to 15 during the year.
The pilot has given us confidence that US tradesmen like the Howdens service
proposition and that we can attract and retain good staff. Losses of £8.4m in
the year were in line with our expectations and in line with the Howden business
model where losses are incurred in the early stages.
We are now moving to the next phase where we will fully evaluate the customers'
requirements by testing both pricing and demand for product made to a US
specification. This will help validate that the business model can provide
acceptable levels of return on any further investment. Plans have been approved
to open a further five depots in the Southeast of the US in 2004, expanding the
total depot portfolio for the purposes of the test to 20 depots, with an
anticipated loss of £10m for the year. The test will continue to be low risk and
it is results, not a timetable, which will drive the future development of the
business.
- Supply chain
The supply chain is a key area of focus for the Group as it is the backbone of
our business and is instrumental to our continuing growth.
We have invested £50m in total in integrated IT systems, which replace legacy
systems that were inadequate for supporting our business growth. The first phase
of our SAP project - the financial systems - went live in July on schedule, and
the second phase - supply chain - will be completed in March. Future stages -
covering manufacturing, warehouse management and the retail stores - will be
evaluated on their benefit to the business.
We have recently established a joint venture in Hong Kong to source Chinese
product. China is the lowest cost country for sourcing many of our core products
and components that are currently procured within Europe. The potential savings
are considerable, and the joint venture should begin operation during 2004.
Structural Guarantee
As reported at the interims we continue to vigorously contest HM Customs &
Excise's challenge to the Company's VAT treatment for structural guarantees. The
maximum potential exposure is £50m at the year-end, but this would be expected
to be offset by the recovery of approximately £13m of insurance premium tax paid
on the sale of extended structural guarantees and by underwriting profit within
our captive insurance company. In common with all of our product categories we
revise our products from time to time and we will be changing the current
insurance product in the first half. We are carrying the tax paid of £46m on our
balance sheet as a debtor without any provision and further disclosure is given
in note 12 of the accompanying notes.
Cash flow
The Group is highly cash generative with EBITDA rising to £162.3m, compared to
£128.4m in the previous year. Working capital has increased as we built stock to
ensure that we can meet our customers' requirements and expanded the Howden
Joinery business - nevertheless we expect to obtain improvements in the use of
working capital as a result of the introduction of our new systems.
A higher level of gross capital expenditure has been incurred as the business
has focussed on its extensive organic growth plans, but this has been partially
funded by a sale and leaseback programme covering some of our tertiary sites.
As a result the Group had net borrowings of £1.2m at the year-end (2002 - net
free cash of £32.2m). This shows a reduction of net free cash of £33.4m during
the year, but is struck after lodging £46m with HM Customs & Excise for the
disputed VAT on the structural guarantee. In addition the Group held £11.8m
(2002 - £6.7m) on short-term deposit, held in escrow for future insurance claims
on the structural guarantee.
Dividend
The Board has proposed a raised final dividend of 2.0p per share to be paid on
11 June 2004 to shareholders on the register at 28 May 2004. The shares will be
quoted ex-dividend from 26 May 2004. This brings a total dividend for the year
to 3.8p per share, an increase of 22.6% over the previous year.
The Board is reviewing the relative dividend payout ratio between the first and
second half. This is primarily due to the second half accounting for a growing
proportion of profits, driven by the increasing contribution of Howden Joinery
to the Group's results. In future it is likely that the final dividend will
increasingly account for a greater proportion of the full-year dividend.
Current trading and outlook
Total Group orders from Boxing Day to 24 February have increased by 4% (up 2% on
a same store basis). Howden Joinery continues to perform well whilst UK Retail
has suffered from a slowdown in new product development - particularly in
lower-priced kitchens, bedrooms and beds - as we have rolled out the
refurbishment programme.
Orders Total Same
store
Howden Joinery 23% 18%
UK Retail (2)% (3)%
France Retail 24% 11%
Total Group 4% 2%
The UK Retail performance for the year to date is a little disappointing, but it
is struck part way through the winter sale and is measured against strong
comparatives (2002 - same store orders for the full winter sale were up 8% on
2001). In order to provide a comprehensive update on trading following the end
of the winter sale, we will issue a further trading update on Tuesday 23 March
2004.
We have every confidence that the business remains capable of further strong
growth in a series of highly fragmented markets; markets in which we can
outperform our competitors in terms of product, pricing and service standards.
CONSOLIDATED PROFIT AND LOSS ACCOUNT
_________________________________________________________________________________
For the 52 weeks to 27 December 2003
52 weeks to 52 weeks to
27 December 2003 28 December 2002
Notes
£m £m
Turnover: Group and share of
joint ventures 2 1,485.1 1,288.8
Less: Share of joint
ventures (3.6) (1.4)
------ ------
Group turnover 1,481.5 1,287.4
Cost of sales (727.2) (641.2)
------ ------
Gross profit 754.3 646.2
Selling and distribution
costs (581.4) (507.4)
Administrative expenses (66.6) (58.9)
Goodwill amortisation (0.7) (0.1)
------ ------
Operating profit 2 105.6 79.8
Share of operating loss of
joint ventures (2.1) (2.0)
------ ------
Total operating profit -
Group and share of joint
ventures 103.5 77.8
Net profit on disposal of
fixed assets 3 14.1 0.1
------ ------
Profit on ordinary
activities before interest 117.6 77.9
Interest receivable and
similar income 1.5 3.2
Interest payable and similar
charges (1.2) (0.3)
------ ------
Profit on ordinary
activities before taxation 117.9 80.8
Tax on profit on ordinary
activities 4 (31.1) (23.4)
------ ------
Profit for the financial
period 86.8 57.4
Dividends paid and proposed 5 (21.9) (17.4)
------ ------
Amount transferred to
reserves 7 64.9 40.0
====== ======
Earnings per share
Basic earnings per 10p
ordinary share 6 15.4p 10.2p
====== ======
Diluted earnings per 10p
ordinary share 6 14.3p 9.5p
====== ======
Earnings per share before
profit on sale of fixed
assets
Basic earnings per 10p
ordinary share 6 12.9p 10.2p
====== ======
Diluted earnings per 10p
ordinary share 6 12.0p 9.5p
====== ======
All results are derived from continuing operations
CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEET
________________________________________________________________________________
27 Dec 2003 28 Dec 2002
Notes £m £m
FIXED ASSETS
Intangible assets 14.5 14.6
Tangible assets 387.0 356.8
Investments 51.3 46.1
------ ------
Total fixed assets 452.8 417.5
------ ------
CURRENT ASSETS
Stocks 195.7 177.1
Debtors 187.9 124.0
Investments 11.8 6.9
Cash at bank and in hand 48.8 33.3
------ ------
444.2 341.3
CREDITORS
Amounts falling due within one year 8 334.9 316.0
------ ------
Net current assets 109.3 25.3
------ ------
Total assets less current liabilities 562.1 442.8
CREDITORS
Amounts falling due after more
than one year 9 51.5 2.8
PROVISIONS FOR LIABILITIES AND
CHARGES 10 21.2 21.9
------ ------
Net assets 489.4 418.1
====== ======
CAPITAL AND RESERVES
Called up share capital 62.0 61.3
Share premium account 7 65.8 62.1
Revaluation reserve 7 22.3 40.0
Other reserves 7 26.7 24.3
Profit and loss 7 312.6 230.4
------ ------
Equity shareholders' funds 489.4 418.1
====== ======
CONSOLIDATED CASH FLOW STATEMENT
________________________________________________________________________________
For the 52 weeks to 27 December 2003
52 weeks to 52 weeks to
27 Dec 2003 28 Dec 2002
Notes £m £m
Net cash inflow from operating
activities 11 93.6 138.0
Returns on investments and
servicing of finance 11 0.3 2.9
Taxation (22.2) (16.2)
Capital expenditure and financial
investment 11 (85.1) (117.5)
Acquisitions 11 - (8.5)
Equity dividends paid (19.7) (16.0)
------ ------
Cash outflow before use of liquid
resources and financing (33.1) (17.3)
Management of liquid resources (4.9) (6.7)
Financing 11 52.9 5.5
------ ------
Increase/(decrease) in cash in
the period 11 14.9 (18.5)
====== ======
RECONCILIATION OF NET CASH FLOW TO MOVEMENT IN NET FUNDS
________________________________________________________________________________
52 weeks to 52 weeks to
27 Dec 2003 28 Dec 2002
Notes £m £m
Increase/(decrease) in cash in the
period 11 14.9 (18.5)
Cash movement on : 11
bank loans (48.7) -
debt and lease financing - (0.1)
liquid resources 4.9 6.7
------ ------
Change in net funds resulting from
cash flows (28.9) (11.9)
Foreign currency translation
differences 11 0.6 (0.3)
------ ------
Movement in net funds in the (28.3) (12.2)
period
Net funds at the beginning of the
period 11 38.9 51.1
------ ------
Net funds at the end of the period 11 10.6 38.9
====== ======
1. BASIS OF PREPARATION
The financial information set out does not constitute statutory financial
statements for the periods ended 52 weeks to 27 December 2003 and 52 weeks to 28
December 2002, but is derived from those accounts. Statutory accounts for the 52
weeks to 28 December 2002 have been delivered to the Registrar of Companies and
those for the 52 weeks to 27 December 2003 will be sent to shareholders and
filed with the Registrar of Companies on 16 April 2004. The auditors have
reported on the accounts, their reports were unqualified and did not contain
statements under Section 237(2) or (3) of the Companies Act 1985.
2. SEGMENTAL ANALYSIS
52 weeks to 52 weeks to
27 Dec 2003 28 Dec 2002
£m £m
TURNOVER (1)
Howden Joinery 448.1 326.9
UK Retail 910.9 861.4
France Retail 114.2 94.2
Howden Millwork 5.1 2.0
Other operations 3.2 2.9
------ ------
Turnover 1,481.5 1,287.4
Joint venture operations 3.6 1.4
------ ------
Total turnover 1,485.1 1,288.8
====== ======
PROFIT BEFORE TAXATION(2)
Howden Joinery 72.0 44.4
UK Retail 41.7 37.7
France Retail 0.3 2.3
Howden Millwork (8.4) (4.5)
Other operations - (0.1)
------ ------
Operating profit 105.6 79.8
Joint venture operations (2.1) (2.0)
------ ------
Total operating profit 103.5 77.8
Profit on disposal of fixed assets 14.1 0.1
Net interest receivable 0.3 2.9
------ ------
Profit before taxation 117.9 80.8
====== ======
NET ASSETS
Howden Joinery 132.8 85.6
UK Retail 270.8 229.4
France Retail 39.1 29.3
Howden Millwork 4.6 4.6
Other operations 1.3 1.5
Joint venture operations 1.1 2.1
------ ------
449.7 352.5
Unallocated net assets(3) 39.7 65.6
------ ------
Total net assets 489.4 418.1
====== ======
1 The analysis of turnover by destination is not materially different from the
analysis of turnover by origin.
2 All results are from continuing operations.
3 Unallocated net assets comprise balances in respect of dividends, cash,
borrowing and investment in own shares.
3. PROFIT ON DISPOSAL OF FIXED ASSETS
The profit on disposal of fixed assets of £14.1m (2002: £0.1m) represents net
profits on disposal of land and buildings. The associated tax charge is £nil
(2002: £nil) as the profit is offset by available tax losses.
4. TAX ON PROFIT ON ORDINARY ACTIVITIES
52 weeks to 52 weeks to
27 Dec 2003 28 Dec 2002
£m £m
Taxation on profit for the period comprises:
UK corporation tax 32.8 19.0
Adjustment relating to prior periods (5.3) (4.0)
Deferred tax 3.6 8.4
------ ------
31.1 23.4
====== ======
The taxation charge is calculated at 30.0% (2002 - 29.0%) on profits before
profits on disposal of fixed assets.
5. EQUITY DIVIDENDS
52 weeks to 52 weeks to
28 Dec 2003 28 Dec 2002
£m £m
Interim paid - 1.8 pence per share
(2002 - 1.5 pence per share) 10.3 8.0
Final proposed - 2.0 pence per share
(2002 - 1.6 pence per share) 11.6 9.4
====== ======
Total dividend - 3.8 pence per share
(2002 - 3.1 pence per share) 21.9 17.4
====== ======
6. EARNINGS PER SHARE
Earnings per share for the 52 weeks to 28 December 2002 have been restated to
exclude shares held by the Group's employee share trusts in accordance with
FRS14: 'Earnings per share'.
52 weeks to 27 December 2003 52 weeks to 28 December 2002
------------------ -----------------
Earnings Weighted Earnings Earnings Weighted Earnings
average per share average per share
number of number
shares of shares
£m m p £m m p
Basic earnings
per share
Earnings
attributable
to ordinary
shares 86.8 565.4 15.4 57.4 564.3 10.2
Effect of
dilutive share
options - 41.3 (1.1) - 39.5 (0.7)
------ ------- ------- ------ ------ ------
Diluted
earnings per
share 86.8 606.7 14.3 57.4 603.8 9.5
====== ======= ======= ====== ====== ======
Reconciliation of
earnings per
share to exclude
profit on sale of
fixed assets
Basic earnings per
share 86.8 565.4 15.4 57.4 564.3 10.2
Profit on sale
of fixed assets (14.1) - (2.5) (0.1) - -
------ ------- ------- ------ ------ ------
Basic earnings
per share before
profit on sale
of fixed assets 72.7 565.4 12.9 57.3 564.3 10.2
====== ======= ======= ====== ====== ======
Diluted
earnings
per share 86.8 606.7 14.3 57.4 603.8 9.5
Profit on sale
of fixed assets (14.1) - (2.3) (0.1) - -
------ ------- ------- ------ ------ ------
Diluted
earnings per
share before
profit on sale
of fixed assets 72.7 606.7 12.0 57.3 603.8 9.5
====== ======= ======= ====== ====== ======
7. RESERVES
Share Profit and
premium Other Revaluation loss
account reserves reserve account
£m £m £m £m
At 28 December 2002 62.1 24.3 40.0 230.4
Retained profit for the period - - - 64.9
Shares issued 3.7 - - (0.2)
Amortisation of goodwill - 2.4 - (2.4)
Realised revaluation surplus - - (17.7) 17.7
Foreign exchange - - - 2.2
------- ------ -------- --------
At 27 December 2003 65.8 26.7 22.3 312.6
======= ====== ======== ========
8. CREDITORS
AMOUNTS FALLING DUE WITHIN ONE YEAR
27 Dec 2003 28 Dec 2002
£m £m
Trade creditors 140.7 128.7
Corporation tax 19.8 14.5
Other taxation and social security 21.8 21.3
Proposed dividends 11.6 9.4
Other creditors 22.8 17.8
Accruals and deferred income 118.2 124.3
-------- --------
334.9 316.0
======== ========
9. CREDITORS
AMOUNTS FALLING DUE AFTER MORE THAN ONE YEAR
27 Dec 2003 28 Dec 2002
£m £m
Bank loans 50.0 1.3
Other creditors 1.5 1.5
------- --------
51.5 2.8
======= ========
10. PROVISIONS FOR LIABILITIES AND CHARGES
Pension Property Deferred
provision provision taxation Total
£m £m £m £m
At 28 December 2002 9.2 3.0 9.7 21.9
Created in the period - - 3.6 3.6
Utilised/released in the period (2.3) (2.0) - (4.3)
------ ------- ------ -------
At 27 December 2003 6.9 1.0 13.3 21.2
====== ======= ====== =======
11. CONSOLIDATED CASH FLOW STATEMENT
(a) Reconciliation of operating profit to net cash inflow from operating
activities
52 weeks to 52 weeks to
27 Dec 2003 28 Dec 2002
£m £m
Operating profit before exceptional items 105.6 79.8
Depreciation of tangible fixed assets 47.5 40.2
Amortisation of goodwill 0.7 0.1
Amortisation of fixed asset investment 8.5 8.3
------- -------
EBITDA 162.3 128.4
Increase in stocks (18.6) (45.9)
Increase in debtors (18.0) (10.4)
Increase in creditors and provisions 13.9 67.5
------- -------
Net cash inflow - pre exceptional operating
activities 139.6 139.6
VAT paid re Structural Guarantee (46.0) -
Net cash outflow - operating exceptionals - (1.6)
------- -------
Net cash inflow from operating activities 93.6 138.0
======= =======
(b) Analysis of cash flows for headings netted in the cash flow statement
52 weeks to 52 weeks to
27 Dec 2003 28 Dec 2002
£m £m
Returns on investments and servicing of finance
Interest received 1.5 3.2
Interest paid (1.2) (0.3)
------- -------
Net inflow on investments and servicing of finance 0.3 2.9
======= =======
Capital expenditure and financial investment
Payments to acquire tangible fixed assets (127.2) (98.3)
Receipts from sales of tangible fixed assets 58.2 9.5
Payment to acquire own shares (14.9) (25.5)
Investment in joint ventures (1.2) (3.2)
------- -------
Net outflow for capital expenditure and financial
investment (85.1) (117.5)
======= =======
Acquisitions
Acquisition of subsidiary undertaking - (10.9)
Cash acquired with subsidiary undertaking - 2.4
------- -------
Net outflow from acquisitions - (8.5)
======= =======
Financing
Shares issued 4.2 5.4
Loan acquired with subsidiary undertaking (1.3) 1.3
Increase/(decrease) in bank finance 50.0 (0.8)
Capital element of finance lease rental payments - (0.4)
------- -------
Net inflow from financing 52.9 5.5
======= =======
(c) Analysis of net funds
Current Total
Cash at Bank Net asset Finance net
bank loans funds Investments* leases funds
£m £m £m £m £m £m
As at 29 December 2001 52.1 (0.8) 51.3 0.2 (0.4) 51.1
Cash flow (20.9) 0.8 (20.1) 6.7 0.4 (13.0)
Acquisition of
subsidiary 2.4 (1.3) 1.1 - - 1.1
Exchange difference (0.3) - (0.3) - - (0.3)
------ ----- ----- ------- ------ -----
As at 28 December 2002 33.3 (1.3) 32.0 6.9 - 38.9
Cash flow 14.9 (48.7) (33.8) 4.9 - (28.9)
Acquisition of
subsidiary - - - - - -
Exchange difference 0.6 - 0.6 - - 0.6
------ ----- ----- ------- ------ -----
As at 27 December 2003 48.8 (50.0) (1.2) 11.8 - 10.6
====== ===== ===== ======= ====== =====
*£11.8m (2002 - £6.7m) is held in escrow account to cover potential insurance
liabilities
12. HM CUSTOMS & EXCISE CLAIM
In August 2001 the Group introduced an optional insurance-backed structural
guarantee on certain items of furniture sold in its UK retail stores. Value
Added Tax (VAT) on the furniture element of the transaction and Insurance
Premium Tax (IPT) is paid on the sale of these warranties.
An assessment has been raised on the VAT and the relevant tax has been paid to
HM Customs & Excise. The directors have taken extensive legal and taxation
advice and this action is being contested vigorously. The relevant tax, which
has been paid, is carried on the balance sheet as a debtor without any
provision.
To date, the following amounts have been recorded:
Cumulative 2003 2002 2001
£m £m £m £m
Reduction in VAT 50.0 20.7 22.0 7.3
IPT paid (13.0) (5.3) (5.6) (2.1)
External insurance
premium/expenses (6.5) (2.5) (2.8) (1.2)
Reinsurance premium to Group
company (10.4) (4.2) (4.5) (1.7)
Underwriting profit recognised by
Group company 1.0 1.0 - -
------ ------ ------ ------
Profit taken to profit and loss
account 21.1 9.7 9.1 2.3
====== ====== ====== ======
80% of the insurance has been reinsured by the external insurer through the
Group's captive insurance company, Southon Insurance Limited.
The maximum potential exposure is £50m at the year end, but this would be
expected to be offset by the recovery of approximately £13m of insurance tax
premium paid on the sale of extended structural guarantees and by any future
underwriting profit with Southon Insurance Limited. Due to the timing of our
quarterly VAT payments, £46m of the £50m has been paid to HM Customs & Excise at
the year end.
This information is provided by RNS
The company news service from the London Stock Exchange