Re AGM
Jardine Matheson Hldgs Ld
17 May 2001
The following announcement was issued to the London Stock Exchange
on 17th May 2001.
Chairman Highlights Success in Creation of Value for Shareholders
at Jardine Matheson Annual General Meeting
- Three year total shareholder return among highest for
Asian conglomerates
- Strength of Group structure contributes to value creation
- Good prospects for further growth in earnings per share
in 2001
Bermuda, 17th May 2001 -- Jardine Matheson Holdings Limited
today released a statement made by its Chairman, Henry
Keswick, to shareholders at the Company's Annual General
Meeting.
In the statement, Mr. Keswick recommended shareholders reject
certain resolutions, similar to those they rejected in 2000,
aimed primarily at changing the structure of the Jardine
Matheson Group. He said that they are not conducive to the
success of the Company and risk the destruction of shareholder
value.
Mr. Keswick pointed to Jardine Matheson's strong growth in
earnings in 2000, the total returns in US dollars averaging
20% per annum over three years and the growth in net asset
value per share increasing by an average of 18% per annum over
ten years as evidence of the Company's ability consistently to
deliver value, despite the volatility of the Asian region.
'We have been able to achieve such good returns in no small
part because of the benefits of the Group's current
shareholding structure,' Mr Keswick said. 'We will continue
to dedicate our efforts to generating strong operating
performances which create sustainable shareholder value.'
Jardine Matheson is well respected for its transparency, its
high ethical standards and its strict adherence to the laws
and regulations governing the Company. Mr. Keswick said the
guiding principle that must be followed is that the Directors
and management of the Company should be allowed to set the
priorities and strategic direction, as it is they who have the
detailed knowledge of the business. The Board is always
prepared to consider the views of shareholders, and takes its
obligations to act in the interests of all shareholders very
seriously.
'Looking forward, we expect to see a continuing improvement in
recurrent earnings per share in 2001. Our businesses are well
positioned and offer excellent opportunities for future
growth,' Mr. Keswick concluded.
Attached are Mr. Keswick's Annual General Meeting Statement
and the Total Shareholder Returns Schedule distributed to the
meeting.
Jardine Matheson is a multinational group of seven core
businesses focused primarily on the Asia-Pacific region. Its
operations employ some 150,000 people and its activities are
leaders in the fields of property, hotels, supermarkets,
consumer marketing, engineering and construction, insurance
broking and motor trading.
For further information, please contact:
Jardine Matheson Limited
Neil M McNamara (1 441) 239 8128
Matheson & Co.
Martin Henderson (44) 20 7816 8135
Golin/Harris Forrest
David Dodwell (852) 2501 7902
Leslie Fung (852) 2501 7905
Golin/Harris Ludgate
Richard Hews (44) 20 7324 8888
Trish Featherstone
Statement Made by the Chairman
of Jardine Matheson Holdings Limited at the
Annual General Meeting of the Company held on 17th May 2001
It is disappointing that such resolutions are being raised,
even though very similar resolutions were overwhelmingly
rejected by shareholders at last year's Annual General
Meeting.
However, as a Board committed to safeguarding the interests of
all shareholders, we have again considered the issues
carefully, and have again concluded that the proposals are not
conducive to the success of the Company. The proposals
continue to display a lack of understanding of the region
within which the Group operates, and would risk the
destruction of shareholder value. Therefore, your Board
unanimously recommends that, as last year, shareholders reject
the proposed resolutions.
We believe it more worthwhile to continue to dedicate our
efforts to generating strong operating performances, such as
those recently announced, which will create sustainable
shareholder value. The work we have done to reshape the Group
in recent years has produced real results. We have achieved
shareholder returns in United States dollars averaging 20% per
annum over the past three years, which is one of the best
performances among Asian conglomerates. In addition our net
asset value per share has increased by an average of 18% per
annum over the past ten years, which is far in excess of the
performance of the Morgan Stanley Capital International index
for Asia Pacific ex. Japan.
Turning to the issues raised by the resolutions, the guiding
principle that must be followed is that the Directors and
management of the Company should be allowed to set its
priorities and strategic direction. It is they who have the
detailed knowledge of the business and can make an informed
assessment of opportunities, risks and the potential impact of
market and economic conditions. While we are always prepared
to consider the views of shareholders, the final decisions
must rest with the Board.
We have, in the Addendum to Notice of Annual General Meeting,
given our reasons for recommending shareholders to vote
against the proposals. However, I would like to reinforce
some points. With respect to the proposal to privatize
Jardine Strategic, the Board regularly reviews the Company's
investment strategy, and that includes the level of its
shareholding in Jardine Strategic. We believe that the
privatization scenario outlined would be ill-advised and
detrimental to Jardine Matheson, and therefore its
shareholders, owing to the inherent unnecessary risks, such as
over-borrowing at a time of regional and global uncertainty.
The current structure was approved by shareholders and the
relevant regulators. It was in place when the requisitioner
made the decision to commit a significant portion of its
clients' money to investing in Jardine Matheson shares, and is
entirely appropriate - and not untypical - for the markets
within which Jardines operates. The cross-shareholding
provides a crucial element of stability against which
management can concentrate on growing their businesses in a
region marked by considerable volatility, as has been vividly
demonstrated over the past few years.
The Board has always taken its obligations to all shareholders
very seriously. Jardines is highly transparent - indeed it
exceeds the financial disclosure levels practised by virtually
all other companies in the region - and has the reputation of
operating to the highest ethical standards. As a Bermuda-
incorporated company, with listings in London and Singapore,
the Company complies fully with all applicable governing laws
and regulations and is subject ultimately to the British legal
system. We are proud of our culture of good corporate
governance. Our share trading facilities operate effectively,
and there is no evidence that any lasting benefit would accrue
if we listed in Hong Kong.
Looking forward, we expect to see a continuing improvement in
recurring earnings per share in 2001, building on our strong
earnings growth in 2000. Our businesses are well positioned
and offer excellent opportunities for further development.
Before closing, I would like to take this opportunity to
clarify the Board's decision to allow these resolutions to be
proposed. Last year the requisitioners did not meet the basic
requirements laid down in the company law. Despite this, we
allowed the resolutions to go ahead.
Given the cost to Jardine Matheson shareholders of such a
debate, we are, as I have said, disappointed that a
substantially similar set of resolutions has again been
proposed this year. The requisitioners have again failed to
meet Bermuda's legal requirements. Nevertheless, we have
decided to allow the resolutions to go forward for a second
year so that any lingering questions can be addressed and to
counter any ill-informed claims that we were frustrating a
genuine shareholder process.
In the interests of shareholders, we are making it clear that
we will not allow such an exercise to take place in future
without full respect for the law and compliance with the
relevant regulations.
In summary, the business strategy we are pursuing is creating
value for all shareholders, as demonstrated by the Company's
top quartile returns. The cross-shareholding and the current
listings remain appropriate for the Asian region where the
Group's assets are mainly situated.
Your Board unanimously recommends you once again to vote
against these resolutions.
_____________________________________________________________________
Total Shareholder Returns* (Compound Average Growth Rate)
in United States Dollar as at 27 April 2001
1 year 3 year 5 year 10 year
1 JARDINE MATHESON 57.76% 19.67% (3) 0.54% (5) 8.32% (7)
2 JARDINE STRATEGIC 37.58% 15.62% (6) 6.15% (4) 9.46% (6)
3 CHINA RESOURCES
ENTERPRISE 17.76% -4.54% (12) 20.70% (1) 20.51% (2)
4 WHEELOCK & CO. 17.43% -2.40% (11) -14.56% (11) 5.90% (8)
5 CHEUNG KONG
HOLDINGS -0.20% 21.42% (2) 12.59% (3) 20.43% (3)
6 SWIRE PACIFIC 'A' -3.98% 4.94% (8) -4.61% (7) 12.46% (5)
7 NEW WORLD
DEVELOPMENT -7.29% -25.03% (16) -21.68% (13) 2.25% (9)
8 SIME DARBY BERHAD -10.13% 6.74% (7) -15.63% (12) 1.64% (10)
9 MITSUBISHI
CORPORATION -11.85% 1.45% (10) -10.81% (9) -1.52% (13)
10 ITOCHU
CORPORATION -13.43% 19.40% (4) -10.61% (8) -0.92% (12)
11 HUTCHISON
WHAMPOA -14.98% 26.23% (1) 16.85% (2) 23.84% (1)
12 AYALA
CORPORATION -22.77% -16.67% (14) -13.28% (10) -0.36% (11)
13 KEPPEL
CORPORATION -25.45% -12.41% (13) -23.14% (14) -5.52% (14)
14 CITIC PACIFIC -33.19% 4.43% (9) -1.57% (6) 19.57% (4)
15 SAMSUNG
CORPORATION -58.74% 15.76% (5) -27.35% (15) -12.30% (15)
16 ASTRA
INTERNATIONAL -73.17% -19.39% (15) -29.42% (16) -21.25% (16)
17 MSCI ASIA PACIFIC
EX-JAPAN -32.29% -2.61% -6.66% 3.21%
* Based on data adjusted to US Dollars and assuming that
dividends are re-invested to purchase additional units of an
equity at the closing price applicable on the ex-dividend
date.
()Number in the bracket represents the ranking of shareholder
returns of the company in terms of 3 year, 5 year, and 10
year Compound Average Growth Rate.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
Net Asset Value Based Returns* (Compound Average Growth Rate)
for period to 31 December 2000
1 year 3 year 5 year 10 year
JARDINE MATHESON (Note 1) 73.28% 14.45% 13.33% 17.97%
JARDINE STRATEGIC (Note 1) 31.04% 11.63% 4.42% 8.58%
SWIRE PACIFIC 'A' 13.28% -1.93% -0.18% 10.05%
BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY 6.51% 16.64% 22.89% 24.25%
BRANDES EMERGING MARKETS
EQUITY (Note 2) -17.19% 3.70% 1.19% na
BRANDES INTERNATIONAL
EQUITY (Note 3) 2.79% 22.02% 20.47% 19.37%
FIDELITY INTERNATIONAL
GROWTH AND INCOME -14.06% 13.26% 11.89% 10.43%
FIDELITY PACIFIC
BASIN FUND -35.32% 15.43% 4.89% 7.04%
VANGUARD
INTERNATIONAL GROWTH -8.60% 10.53% 9.97% 10.28%
Notes:
1 Book value basis NAV and market value basis NAV are used for
Jardine Matheson and Jardine Strategic respectively, in
accordance with the bases adopted in their respective
published accounts.
2 Based on Brandes published data, net of commissions and other
execution costs. Fund inception: 31 December 1994.
3 Based on Brandes published data, net of commissions and other
execution costs.
* Based on assumption that dividends, capital gains and
interest are re-invested at net asset value per share, where
applicable.
_____________________________________________________________________
www.jardines.com Source: UBS Warburg (Published accounts,
FactSet, Bloomberg, Datastream, Brandes)