Interim Results & Recovery Plans For Bhs
Storehouse PLC
18 November 1999
Interim results for 28 weeks ended 9 October 1999
STOREHOUSE REPORTS INTERIM RESULTS AND
ANNOUNCES RECOVERY PLANS FOR Bhs AND MOTHERCARE
* Group turnover £601.1 million (1998: £648.3 million)
* Loss before tax and exceptional items of £15.7 million
(1998: £38.7 million profit)
* Launch of major recovery plans for Bhs and Mothercare
* Significant change to Bhs format:
- radical shift in clothing ranges and values
- more space to home and gifts
- reintroduction of food
* Key features of Mothercare recovery:
- increased focus on pre-school child
- 40 more Mothercare World stores
- aggressive development of new channels: Mothercare.com
* Major restructuring leading to separation of the businesses
Commenting today, Storehouse Chairman, Alan Smith, said:
'Following a wide ranging review, we are taking radical action to
reposition Bhs and Mothercare. This represents a fundamental change to
the way these businesses operate with new approaches to merchandise,
formats, values and service. In addition, we have concluded that the
current holding company structure no longer adds value and we intend to
implement a major restructuring of the businesses to enable Bhs and
Mothercare to operate as independent companies'.
Enquiries to:
Storehouse plc
Alan Smith, Chairman 0171 339 2115
(alan.smith@bhs.co.uk)
Chris Martin, Group finance director 0171 339 2152
(chris.martin@bhs.co.uk)
Stephen Pain, Director of corporate 0171 339 2577
affairs(stephen.pain@bhs.co.uk)
Brunswick Group Limited
Susan Gilchrist/Victoria Sabin 0171 404 5959
1. Group results
Group sales during the period were affected by two main factors: the
overall decline in the clothing market and aggressive competition. As a
result, group sales were £601.1 million compared with £648.3 million for
the same period last year.
Group gross margins were affected by intense price pressure and the
increase in the level of markdown necessary to control stock levels.
Group gross margins were 2.8 percentage points lower than last year.
Costs, including the increase in depreciation as a result of new
investment, increased as anticipated by 7.3 per cent.
An exceptional charge of £6.9 million has been made for store disposals
in Bhs and Mothercare and one-off costs. The performance of retail
operations before the exceptional charge resulted in a loss of £11.6
million. Before the exceptional charge, the group made a pre-tax loss of
£15.7 million compared with a pre-tax profit of £38.7 million for the
previous year.
Losses per share before the exceptional charge were 2.7p and after the
exceptional charge were 4.1p. The board has decided that the payment of
an interim dividend is inappropriate. A decision on the final dividend
will depend on the performance of the business during the second half of
the year.
Capital investment for the half year amounted to £70.1 million (1998:
£71.9 million) but the year as a whole will be significantly lower than
last year. The group's balance sheet remains strong with continued
tight control on working capital. Net debt at the end of the period was
£118.2 million and gearing was 19.8 per cent.
2. Bhs
Sales at Bhs were £370.7 million (1998: £400.4 million). This decline
together with lower margins resulted in an operating loss for the period
of £8.3 million compared with a profit of £28.9 million last year.
UK sales at Bhs were £359.9 million (1998: £376.6 million), a reduction
of 4.4 per cent, 9.2 per cent down on a like-for-like basis.
The principal reason for this was the downturn in the market,
particularly in clothing. Given the competitive nature of the market
together with a slow start to the Autumn/Winter season, levels of
markdown were much higher than anticipated. This impacted gross margins
which were 2.1 percentage points down compared with last year. However,
intake margins continued to improve.
Sales of Bhs product to overseas franchisees were down by 54.8 per cent
to £10.8 million (1998: £23.8 million). The continued weakness in the
Middle East economy, the most important of Bhs' international markets,
combined with the financial crises in Russia and the Far East were the
main factors behind a disappointing performance.
3. Mothercare
Mothercare reported a loss of £3.3 million compared with a profit of
£12.3 million last year on sales which were down by 7.1 per cent to
£230.4 million (1998: £247.9 million).
Sales in the UK declined by 2.9 per cent, a reduction of 1.2 per cent
like-for-like, to £212.7 million (1998: £219.0 million) and although
intake margins were held, gross margins fell by 4.8 percentage points
compared with last year. Sales of transport and nursery equipment were
strong but the market for children's clothing became ever more
challenging with high levels of markdown necessary to clear stocks ahead
of the Autumn/Winter season.
In May, the decision was taken to develop Mothercare in three formats;
Mothercare World stores (more than 10,000 sq ft), Mothercare stores (up
to 10,000 sq ft) and Mothercare Direct, the home shopping operation.
As a result, it was announced in May that 68 of the smaller Mothercare
stores were to close whilst the programme to transform the largest,
30,000 sq ft stores into 'world class' stores would be accelerated.
Substantial progress has been made on both the closure programme and the
refurbishments. Currently, 47 of the 68 stores have been sold and a
further 14 identified for closure.
During the period, the refurbishment of eight new format Mothercare
World stores was completed making a total of 11 to date. The Mothercare
World format is performing well.
Sales to Mothercare's overseas franchisees were £17.7 million (1998:
£28.9 million), a reduction of 38.7 per cent.
4. Current trading
Bhs sales in the UK for the first five weeks of the second half of the
year to 13 November were 3.0 per cent down - 6.4 per cent down like-for-
like. Margins were reduced by 0.4 percentage points.
Mothercare's total UK sales were 4.9 per cent lower - down 2.3 per cent
like-for-like - with margins which were 2.5 percentage points down.
Sales for the ongoing stores, after excluding the stores which are being
closed, increased by 5.1 per cent, 0.6 per cent on a like-for-like
basis. Margins declined by 1.5 percentage points.
5. Strategic restructuring
Since June, the board has been conducting a fundamental review of the
group, its businesses and the markets in which they operate. The review
also considered options and proposals for the corporate structure
including sale or merger. The review concluded that shareholders'
interests will be best served by restructuring and repositioning Bhs and
Mothercare to operate in the future as separate, independent companies.
At that time, Storehouse plc will be dissolved and, until that time,
Alan Smith will continue as Executive Chairman. Therefore, the current
search for a chief executive has now been terminated.
The management challenges presented by these plans are substantial.
Both businesses will strengthen their existing teams and acquire new
skills to affect these changes with speed and determination.
6. Bhs turnaround plan
Bhs aims to be the value retailer on the high street. The Bhs turnaround
plan is based on radically improving sales densities on the 4.5 million
sq. ft. of prime high street space. Following trials this Autumn, which
eliminated underperforming ranges and increased space for new categories
of merchandise, Bhs will:
* Radically shift clothing ranges and values
* Allocate more space to home and gifts
* Reintroduce food retailing and extend food services
6.1. Clothing
Bhs will reduce underperforming ranges, duplication and complexity to
give increased emphasis to casualwear. Next Spring, Bhs will have 15
per cent less options in its range. This more focused product range
will be bought in depth to improve value, increase availability and
release space for new merchandise. Branded merchandise will become
part of the Bhs offer and trials will begin next Spring.
Bhs will reduce selling prices on core merchandise significantly. Next
Spring, Bhs clothing prices on like-for-like merchandise will be 15 per
cent less than last year.
A supply chain project is underway to increase direct buying and reduce
costs. The savings to be made are substantial.
6.2. Home and gifts
The space allocated to homewares and gifts, which are destination
divisions at Bhs, will be increased. The Bath Homestore format
introduced authoritative new ranges in furnishings, lighting and
decorative products on substantially extended space. This provides the
blueprint for the chain. New ranges are being introduced which will be
displayed on increased space in all stores.
Bhs' Christmas gift business delivers the highest trading density and
profit per square foot of all product groups. A year-round gift range
is being developed on these strong foundations.
6.3. Food
Food retailing is returning to the high street. This trend is being
driven by the increasing customer demand for frequently purchased fresh
food available in conveniently located shops. The reintroduction of
food at Bhs could transform store economics. The first Food Hall, in
partnership with Iceland, opened on 2 November in Bhs' Birmingham store.
The early results have been positive and, in addition, non-food sales
have improved despite reduced footage. Plans are in place to introduce
the Food Hall to a further 10 stores before the end of the current
financial year. It will be possible to reintroduce food into over 100
Bhs stores.
The food services business continues to grow profitably in all three
formats, Restaurant, Sandwich Shop and Cafe Gio. Food services will be
extended from the present 100 stores to all stores.
7. Mothercare recovery plan
Mothers-to-be and parents of small children expect Mothercare to be the
complete destination store for all their product needs. This
expectation is met in the Mothercare World format and the ranges of
children's transport, home products and pre-school toys. It is not met
consistently in clothing and in the service and standards provided in
many stores. The Mothercare recovery plan will deliver:
* A destination range of clothing, hardware and toys for the pre-school
child
* A rapid improvement in store operating standards
* An aggressive development of new channels: Mothercare World; Mothercare
Catalogue and Mothercare.com
7.1. Merchandise range
Mothers-to-be and parents of young children from all socio-economic
groups expect Mothercare to provide for all their product needs.
The range of children's transport and home products is a combination of
Mothercare own label goods and selected brands. It is the best in the
UK, the market leader and is growing sales.
In toys, a pre-school own label toy range has been developed
successfully which, in combination with leading brands, is growing well.
This range will be developed to destination status for the needs of the
pre-school child.
The Mothercare clothing range is stretched over too many age groups.
The range is being repositioned to provide depth and authority in
maternitywear and clothing for baby and the pre-school child. In order
to achieve full destination store status in this category, Mothercare
will, as in hardware and toys, introduce leading national and
international brands.
7.2. Stores
The highest operational priority in the business is to improve store
standards. A programme is underway which includes increased staffing
and service training, improved availability and clearer layouts. Stores
already in this programme are showing higher customer satisfaction
ratings and increased sales.
There will be two store formats, Mothercare World - over 10,000 sq. ft.
both out of town and on larger high streets, and Mothercare - 5-10,000
sq. ft. on smaller high streets. Forty new Mothercare World stores are
planned to open during the next three to four years, both as new
locations and re-sites.
The Mothercare World stores will carry the full merchandise range and,
in future, will provide new services offering advice and support to
mothers of young children. The Mothercare stores will be tailored to
their local market with a full range of clothing and an edited range of
hardware and toys.
8. Mothercare direct
The potential for the Mothercare business presented by the growth of e-
commerce is big and exciting. In the US, web-sites devoted to the needs
of mothers-to-be and parents of young children have grown rapidly over
the past two or three years. Mothercare is uniquely positioned to
deliver an internet service in the UK specialising in this high-spending
customer group.
The site will be launched in the Spring of 2000. It will be a
transactional vertical portal with the full Mothercare product range, an
extensive information service, specialist advice, 'chat rooms' and
bulletin boards.
The development has started and is being carried out in partnership with
a team experienced in building new e-commerce businesses end-to-end.
Mothercare.com will be a separate subsidiary managed by a specialist
team.
The Mothercare catalogue was relaunched in the Spring of this year since
when it has been trading at 50 per cent above last year's levels.
9. International
The Bhs turnaround plan and Mothercare recovery plan provide a sound
foundation for the future development of the international businesses.
A new international management team is now in place committed to
developing the key partnerships which already exist with Bhs and
Mothercare franchisees.
10. Restructuring
The restructuring plans now underway will result in substantial one-off
costs which will be taken at the end of the current financial year. It
is too early to determine precisely the costs for the restructuring of
Bhs. However, costs for the restructuring of Mothercare are expected to
be in the range of £25m to £30m with a further £3m to £5m for the
development of Mothercare.com.
Creating two independent businesses will lead to the dissolution of
Storehouse plc as the holding company. The method by which the holding
company is dissolved will be decided by the board, at the appropriate
time, to deliver the greatest value to shareholders. The process will
be carried out by the Storehouse team to avoid any distractions in the
operating businesses and is not expected to be complete before 2001.
INTERIM RESULTS
For the 28 weeks ended 9 October 1999 (1998 - 28 weeks ended 10 October)
Notes 28 28 weeks 28 28 52
weeks ended weeks weeks weeks
ended 9.10.99 ended ended ended
9.10.99 9.10.99 10.10.98 27.3.99
Pre-
excepti Exceptio Total
onal nal
£m £m £m £m £m
TURNOVER 1 601.1 - 601.1 648.3 1,328.6
______ _______ _______ _______ _______
(LOSS)/PROFIT FROM 2
RETAIL OPERATIONS (11.6) (7.5) (19.1) 41.2 98.1
Profit/(loss) on 3
disposal of stores - 0.6 0.6 - (12.1)
Interest (4.1) - (4.1) (2.5) (5.7)
______ _______ _______ _______ _______
(LOSS)/PROFIT 4
BEFORE (15.7) (6.9) (22.6) 38.7 80.3
TAXATION
Taxation 4.4 1.2 5.6 (10.8) (26.5)
______ _______ _______ _______ _______
(LOSS)/PROFIT AFTER 5
TAXATION (11.3) (5.7) (17.0) 27.9 53.8
Dividends - - - (15.8) (38.6)
______ _______ _______ _______ _______
RETAINED (LOSS)/ 6
PROFIT FOR THE
PERIOD (11.3) (5.7) (17.0) 12.1 15.2
______ _______ _______ _______ _______
(LOSS) EARNINGS PER 7
SHARE - PRE
EXCEPTIONAL (2.7)p 6.6p 16.8p
(LOSS) EARNINGS PER 7
SHARE (4.1)p 6.6p 12.7p
(LOSS) EARNINGS PER 7
SHARE diluted (2.7)p (4.1)p 6.6p 12.6p
DIVIDENDS PER SHARE 6 Nil 3.7p 9.1p
GROUP NET ASSETS
As at 9 October 1999 (1998 - 10 October)
9 10 27
October October March
Notes 1999 1998 1999
£m £m £m
FIXED ASSETS
Tangible fixed assets 661.5 646.9 658.7
Investments 3.1 2.9 6.5
______ ______ ______
664.6 649.8 665.2
______ ______ ______
CURRENT ASSETS
Stocks 194.8 216.2 185.2
Debtors 71.4 109.1 98.4
Cash at bank and in hand and
time deposits 45.6 53.2 48.8
CREDITORS: amounts falling due 8
within one year (323.3) (370.7) (323.6)
______ ______ ______
NET CURRENT
(LIABILITIES)/ASSETS (11.5) 7.8 8.8
______ ______ ______
Creditors: amounts falling due
after one year (18.2) (27.7) (27.3)
Provisions for liabilities and 9
charges (36.6) (17.6) (31.4)
______ ______ ______
598.3 612.3 615.3
______ ______ ______
NET GEARING/EQUITY % 19.8 18.2 14.8
GROUP CASH FLOW
For the 28 weeks ended 9 October 1999 (1998 - 28 weeks ended 10 October)
28 weeks 28 weeks 52 weeks
ended ended ended
9.10.99 10.10.98 27.3.99
£m £m £m
(Loss)/profit from retail operations
before exceptional items (11.6) 41.2 104.3
Depreciation 35.3 30.7 63.2
Working capital 11.8 (30.1) 0.4
Exceptional costs/other (2.1) (0.7) (1.0)
______ ______ ______
Net cashflow from operations 33.4 41.1 166.9
Returns on investments and servicing
of finance (4.1) (2.5) (5.7)
Taxation 2.7 (4.4) (31.2)
Capital expenditure
Purchase of tangible fixed assets (70.1) (71.9) (140.2)
Sale of tangible fixed assets 33.9 - 12.3
Acquisitions and disposals - (0.9) (4.7)
Equity dividends paid (22.8) (22.8) (38.5)
Other - 1.7 1.6
______ ______ ______
Movement in net debt in the period (27.0) (59.7) (39.5)
Net debt at the beginning of the
period (91.2) (51.7) (51.7)
______ ______ ______
Net debt at the end of the period (118.2) (111.4) (91.2)
====== ====== ======
NOTES
These interim results have been prepared under the historical cost
convention and using accounting policies consistent with previous years
except that all freeholds are being depreciated in accordance with FRS
15.
28 weeks 28 weeks 52 weeks
ended ended ended
9.10.99 10.10.98 27.3.99
£m £m £m
1. TURNOVER - continuing businesses
Bhs 370.7 400.4 856.2
Mothercare 230.4 247.9 472.4
______ ______ ______
601.1 648.3 1,328.6
______ ______ ______
2. RETAIL (LOSS)/PROFIT - continuing
businesses before exceptional items
Bhs (8.3) 28.9 86.4
Mothercare (3.3) 12.3 17.9
______ ______ ______
(11.6) 41.2 104.3
______ ______ ______
3. EXCEPTIONAL ITEMS
Store closures and other one-off costs charged to the loss from
retail operations
Additional provision has been made for the redundancies and other
related costs arising from the store closure programme announced at
the year end at Mothercare in accordance with FRS 12. In addition,
the group has incurred various one-off costs including the cost of
the strategic review; the compensation paid to two directors for loss
of office in accordance with their service contracts and the write
down of the shares held by the Storehouse Employee Share Trusts in
accordance with UITF 13 and FRS 11. In total, £7.5m has been charged
to the loss from retail operations.
Profit/(loss) on disposal of stores
During the half year the group has disposed of a number of stores
arising from the Mothercare store disposal programme. In addition,
the group's interests in the freehold of four Bhs stores have been
sold. As a result, the group has generated a net profit on disposal
of stores of £12.5m and generated cash of £33.9m. In addition, the
group has provided for the cost of disposing of six Bhs stores. The
provision for loss on disposal includes £5.0m to cover the future
lease obligations and costs of £0.5m.
The exceptional items can be summarised as follows:
£m
Exceptional items charged to the
loss from retail operations (7.5)
_____
Profit/(loss) on disposal of stores
Profits realised on stores sold 16.8
Losses realised on stores sold (4.3)
Provision for loss on disposal of Bhs stores (11.9)
______
0.6
______
Total exceptional items (6.9)
______
The tax effect of the exceptional items is a credit of £1.2m.
4. INTEREST
Interest comprises: 28 weeks 28 weeks 52 weeks
ended ended ended
9.10.99 10.10.98 27.3.99
£m £m £m
Interest receivable 1.2 1.8 3.4
Interest payable (4.5) (3.4) (7.4)
Obligations under
finance leases (0.2) - (0.1)
Obligations under
property leases (0.6) (0.9) (1.6)
______ ______ ______
(4.1) (2.5) (5.7)
______ ______ ______
5. TAX
Tax is calculated at the estimated effective rate of tax on profit
before exceptionals for the 53 weeks ending 1 April 2000.
6. DIVIDEND
No interim dividend has been proposed. The cost of the prior year's
interim dividend was £15.8 million and the applicable tax credit was
£3.9 million.
7. EARNINGS PER SHARE
28 weeks 28 weeks 52
ended ended weeks
9.10.99 10.10.98 ended
27.3.99
Weighted average number of
shares 420.2m 422.4m 423.5m
in issue
Dilution:
Option schemes - 1.8m 0.6m
LTIP schemes 0.8m 0.2m 0.2m
_____ ______ ______
Diluted weighted average number
of shares in issue 421.0m 424.4m 424.3m
_____ ______ ______
(Loss)/profit after tax £(17.0)m £27.9m £53.8m
(Loss)/profit after tax before
exceptional items £(11.3)m £27.9m £71.0m
Basic (loss)/earnings per share (4.1)p 6.6p 12.7p
(Loss)/earnings per share before
exceptional items (2.7)p 6.6p 16.8p
Diluted (loss)/earnings per (4.1)p 6.6p 12.6p
share
8. CREDITORS - amounts falling due within one year
9 10 27
October October March
1999 1998 1999
£m £m £m
Bank overdrafts 25.3 21.0 22.7
Bills of exchange and bank loans 128.3 122.0 93.0
Obligations under finance leases 1.9 - 1.9
Obligations under property - 6.7 6.8
leases
Trade creditors 78.3 90.7 81.0
Proposed dividend - 15.7 22.8
Current taxation including ACT
payable 29.0 50.8 31.6
Payroll and other taxes,
including social security 7.1 2.3 4.4
Accruals and deferred income 39.5 50.4 47.3
Landlords' contribution 8.5 7.4 10.4
Other creditors 5.4 3.7 1.7
______ ______ ______
323.3 370.7 323.6
9. PROVISIONS FOR LIABILITIES AND CHARGES
Deferred Disposal Exceptional
tax provisions provisions Total
£m £m £m £m
Opening balance 24.9 0.4 6.1 31.4
Utilised - (0.1) (2.0) (2.1)
Exceptional items - - 7.3 7.3
(Note 3)
______ _______ ______ ______
Closing balance 24.9 0.3 11.4 36.6
______ _______ ______ ______
10. ANALYSIS OF NET DEBT
9 10 27
October October March
1999 1998 1999
£m £m £m
Cash at bank 10.2 19.9 14.5
Time deposits 35.4 33.3 34.3
Bank overdrafts (25.3) (20.9) (22.7)
Bills of exchange and bank loans (128.3) (122.0) (93.0)
Bank loans over one year (5.8) - -
Obligations under finance
leases:
short term (1.9) - (1.9)
long term (2.5) - (3.9)
Obligations under property
leases
short term - (6.7) (6.8)
long term - (15.0) (11.7)
______ ______ ______
(118.2) (111.4) (91.2)
______ ______ ______
The obligations under property leases were redeemed early in
September 1999 and replaced by bank loans on similar terms.
11. RECONCILIATION OF MOVEMENT IN SHAREHOLDERS' FUNDS
28 weeks ended
9.10.99
£m
Loss for the financial period and net decrease
in shareholders' funds (17.0)
Opening shareholders' funds 615.3
______
Closing shareholders' funds 598.3
_______
These interim results were approved by the Directors on 18 November
1999. Results for the two half years have not been audited, but
have been reviewed by Arthur Andersen. The financial information
contained in the interim accounts does not constitute statutory
accounts as defined in Section 240 of the Companies Act. The full
year comparatives were extracted from the full Group Accounts which
have been filed with the Registrar of Companies together with an
unqualified auditors' report. All shareholders will receive a copy
of the interim results.