3rd Quarter Results- Part I
Telefonica SA
11 November 2004
Quarterly results
January - September 2004
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Telefonica Group
Market Size
Financial Highlights
Consolidated Results
Financial Data
RESULTS BY BUSINESS LINES
Fixed Line Business
• Telefonica de Espana Group
• Telefonica Latinoamerica Group
Mobile Business
Other Business
• Directories Business
• Terra Networks Group
• Atento Group
• Content and Media Business
• Telefonica Deutschland Group
AddendA
Companies included in each Financial Statement
Key Holdings of the Telefonica Group and its Subsidiaries
Significant Events
Changes to the Perimeter and Accounting Criteria of
Consolidation
NOTE:
The English language translation of the consolidated financial statements
originally issued in Spanish has been prepared solely for the convenience of
English speaking readers. Despite all the efforts devoted to this translation,
certain omissions or approximations may subsist. Telefonica, its representatives
and employees decline all responsibility in this regard. In the event of a
discrepancy, the Spanish-language version prevails.
These consolidated financial statements are presented on the basis of accounting
principles generally accepted in Spain. Certain accounting practices applied by
the Group that conform with generally accepted accounting principles in Spain
may not conform with generally accepted accounting principles in other
countries.
TELEFONICA GROUP
Market Size
(Data in thousands)
EUROPE AFRICA
Spain Morocco
WIRLINE WIRELESS
T de Espana: Medi Telecom:
19,486 2,572
WIRELESS
T Moviles:
18,697
Deutschland/UK
wholesale adsl lines
T Deutschland Group:
677
LATIN AMERICA
Argentina Brazil Chile Mexico Puerto Rico
WIRLINE WIRLINE WIRLINE WIRELESS WIRELESS
T de Argentina: Telesp: CTC Chile: TEM Mexico: NewComm Wireless:
4,466 13,075 2,579 4,495 158
WIRELESS WIRELESS WIRELESS
TCP Argentina: CRT Celular: CTC Movil: Peru Venezuela
2,606 2,953 3,002 WIRLINE WIRLINE
TeleSudeste Cel: T del Peru: CAN TV:
El Salvador 4,065 Guatemala 2,269 2,943
WIRLINE TeleLeste Celular: WIRLINE WIRELESS WIRELESS
T. El Salvador: 1,264 T. Guatemala: T Moviles: CAN TV:
61 Global Telecom: 39 1,966 2,747
WIRELESS 2,299 WIRELESS PAY-TV customers
T. El Salvador: Telesp Cel. Group: T. Guatemala: Cable Magico:
335 8,757 298 383
TeleCentro Oeste:
5,307
Note: The clients of BellSouth Latin American operators are not included.
TELEFONICA GROUP
MARKET SIZE
Unaudited figures (Thousands)
Totals Weighted (*)
Sep 2004 Sep 2003 % Chg. Sep 2004 Sep 2003 % Chg.
Lines in service (1) 45,594.0 43,449.7 4.9 39,661.8 37,733.0 5.1
In Spain 19,486.3 18,887.7 3.2 19,486.3 18,887.7 3.2
In other countries 26,107.6 24,562.0 6.3 20,175.4 18,845.3 7.1
Cellular customers (2) 61,519.5 50,262.0 22.4 36,040.2 29,343.7 22.8
In Spain 18,696.8 19,107.9 (2.2) 17,285.2 17,663.4 (2.1)
In other countries 42,822.7 31,154.0 37.5 18,755.1 11,680.3 60.6
Total (3) 107,496.8 94,066.7 14.3 76,078.1 67,421.6 12.8
(*) Weighted by the equity interest of Telefonica in each of the companies.
(1) Lines in service: includes all lines in service for Telefonica de Espana, Telefonica CTC Chile, Telefonica de
Argentina, Telefonica del Peru, Telesp, CanTV, Telefonica Moviles El Salvador, Telefonica Moviles Guatemala and
Telefonica Deutschland.
(2) Cellular customers: includes all cellular customers of Telefonica Servicios Moviles Espana, MediTelecom,
Telefonica Movil Chile, TCP Argentina, Telefonica Moviles Peru, Brasilcel (the Joint Venture with Portugal Telecom in
Brazil), NewCom Wireless Puerto Rico, Telefonica Moviles Guatemala, Telefonica Moviles El Salvador, Telefonica Moviles
Mexico and CanTV Celular.
(3) Includes Pay TV customers of Cable Magico in Peru.
TELEFONICA GROUP
Financial Highlights
The most relevant factors of the Telefonica Group results during the first nine
months of 2004 are the following:
• Strong operating growth registered at the revenues (+5.2%), EBITDA (+5.5%)
and Operating Profit (+18.1%) levels in comparison with the same period of
2003.
• Sound growth at Telefonica de Espana Group, where revenues climbed by
2.3% and EBITDA by 6.6% respectively.
• Telefonica Latinoamerica Group achieved growth of 2.5% in revenues and
1.8% in EBITDA respectively. In constant euros, revenues were up by 8.0%
and EBITDA by 7.2% respectively.
• The cellular business, although it slowdown its growth trend in the
third quarter, experienced increases both in revenues (+12.0%) and
EBITDA (3.7%) respectively compared to September 2003.
• Sustainable growth of the total customer base due to intense commercial
efforts, mainly in the cellular and broadband businesses:
• Managed clients of Telefonica Group totaled 101.8 million (+14.5% vs.
September 2003). Including customers from BellSouth operators1, this
figure would jump up to 114.9 million.
• The Group had 58.8 million customers at September 30 (47.8 million
twelve months ago). The net adds registered in the third quarter
amounted 3.0 million clients, representing a 9.2% increase over the
second quarter of 2004.
• The Group's ADSL connections both in Spain and Latin America reached
3.4 million, with net adds in the first nine months of 2004 of 1.3
million connections.
• Increase of operating efficiency and free cash flow:
• EBITDA margin stood at 44.7%, compared with 44.6% twelve months ago
and 44,5% six months ago.
• Growth of 6.6% in the operating free cash flow (EBITDA-CapEx)
generated, amounting to 7,397.7 million euros.
• Consolidated net income of 2,117.1 million euros, with a year-on-year
increase of 5.1%:
• Excluding the extraordinary net effect of the 2003-2007 Redundancy
Program relating to 2004, net income would have risen by 25.4% to
2,526.0 million euros.
• Strong growth in profitability, with earnings per share soaring by
5,9% over the period.
• A 12.2% decrease in net debt over the last year down to 17,976.6 million
euros.
• Telefonica, S.A. expects to close the year 2004 with consolidated growths
of +5/+7% in EBITDA and +7/+9% in Operating Free Cash Flow growth
(EBITDA-CapEx) respectively, both in constant currency terms2.
----------------------------------------
1 Including 13.1 million subscribers from BellSouth's Latin American operators,
at the end of August 2004, last month of the third fiscal quarter of BellSouth.
2 All estimates are in constant currency terms, assuming constant exchange rates
as of 2003 and excluding changes in consolidation. Telefonica de Espana Group
and Telefonica Latinoamerica Group's projections include Telefonica Empresas'
Spanish and Latin American businesses, respectively, in 2003 and 2004.
----------------------------------------
TELEFONICA GROUP
Consolidated Results
The results obtained by Telefonica Group and the management report included in
this report are based on the actions carried out by the various business units
in the Group and which constitute the units over which management of these
businesses is conducted. This implies a presentation of results based on the
actual management of the various businesses in which Telefonica Group is
present, instead of adhering to the legal structure observed by the
participating companies.
In this sense, income statements are presented by business, which basically
implies that each line of activity participate in the companies that the Group
holds in the corresponding business, regardless of whether said holding has
already been transferred or not, even though it might be the final intent of
Telefonica, S.A. to do so in the future.
It should be emphasized that this presentation by businesses in no case alters
the total results obtained by Telefonica Group. These results are incorporated
from the date of effective acquisition of the holding.
Starting first quarter 2004, Telefonica Empresas results will be included in
Telefonica de Espana Group and Telefonica Latinoamerica Group results. In that
sense, Telefonica Data Espana and Telefonica Soluciones results will be
incorporated within Telefonica de Espana Group, whereas Telefonica Data in Latin
America and TIWS will be incorporated in Telefonica Latinoamerica Group results.
Finally, Telefonica Deutschland Group results will be incorporated to Other
Companies in Telefonica S.A. accounts.
The results corresponding to the first nine months of the year reflect the more
intense commercial effort in all business lines of the Telefonica Group,
resulting in a solid growth in the Group's client base and a sound progress in
the efficiency of operations and profitability. Thus, revenues recorded a
year-on-year growth of 5.2%, EBITDA margin stood at 44.7% and net income per
share increased 5.9%. Net debt dropped by 1,258.7 million euros in relation to
December 2003 to 17,976.6 million euros.
Operating free cash flow generation (EBITDA-CapEx) in January-September 2004 was
7,397.7 million euros, 6.6% more than in the same period of the previous year
primarily thanks to the Telefonica de Espana Group (2,943.2 million euros, up
16.4% year-on-year).
The Group's managed client base of fixed and mobile telephony and pay television
stood at 101.8 million at September 30th, 14.5% up on September 2003 and 3.6%
more than in June 2004. Including clients from the Latin American Bell South1
operators, the number of clients managed by the Telefonica Group would reach
114.9 million.
This growth was mainly due to the strong commercial activity of Telefonica
Moviles, which recorded net adds of 3.0 million clients during the last quarter
and 11.0 million over the past year to reach a total of 58.8 million clients
managed at September 30th. Including Bell South1 clients, the total number of
clients would amount 71.9 million, of which 50.6 million would correspond to
Latin America.
----------------------------------------
1 Including 13.1 million subscribers from BellSouth's Latin American operators,
at the end of August 2004, last month of the third fiscal quarter of BellSouth.
----------------------------------------
ADSL connections in Spain and Latin America totaled 3.4 million at September
30th 2004, a year-on-year growth of 62.4%. In Spain, there were 2.2 million
connections (1.4 million twelve months ago), giving the Group a 73.5% estimated
market share of the total broadband market. Telefonica Group retail ADSL clients
in Spain totaled 1.7 million, representing a total estimated market share of
58.1% of this total market. In Latin America, ADSL connections recorded a growth
of 85.1% compared to the previous year, up to 1.2 million, highlighting the
performance in Brazil (Telesp) with 0.7 million (0.4 million in September 30th
2003).
The Group's operating revenues total 21,926.5 million euros during the first
nine months of 2004, which was 5.2% more than in the same period of 2003. In
line with the trend recorded throughout 2004, all business lines recorded an
increase in their sales, with the exception of the Content and Media business,
which was affected by the deconsolidation of Antena 3 TV from the consolidation
perimeter. Excluding the negative impact of variations in exchange rates and in
the consolidation perimeter, revenues would grow 8.5%, mainly due to the
contribution of the cellular business and the Telefonica Latinoamerica Group.
However, there was a slight slowdown in comparison with the first half of 2004,
when revenues increased by 9.4%.
The cellular business, the main contributor in the Group's growth, registered
operating revenues of 8,447.1 million euros in January-September 2004, which was
12.0% more than in the same period of 2003. This growth was mainly explained by
Telefonica Moviles Espana (+10.5%; revenues from services +9.3%), VIVO (+21.0%
in local currency), Mexico (+38.2% in local currency) and Argentina (+54.3% in
local currency).
The Telefonica Latinoamerica Group registered operating revenues of 5,046.0
million euros in the first nine months of 2004 , experimenting a year-on-year
increase of 2.5% in current euros. This growth rate rose to 8.0% in constant
euros due to the good performance of Telesp (+16.0%) and TASA (+9.4%) - both in
local currency - and Telefonica Empresas America (+13.8%) and TIWS (+22.7%), in
constant euros. CTC, in turn, recorded a 6.8% year-on-year decrease in local
currency over the same period of 2003, although it improved in comparison with
the first half of 2004 (-9.4%).
Telefonica de Espana Group's revenues recorded a year-on-year growth of 2.3% as
of September 2004 up to 8,133.3 million euros, accelerating the growth rate
recorded in both the first quarter (+1.7%) and the first half of the year
(+2.2%). This progressive improvement is due to the greater contribution of the
Internet and broadband revenues, which more than offset the fall in revenues
from traditional services at September..
By geographic areas at the end of September, Spain accounted for 61.5% of the
Group's consolidated revenues, a contribution that was down by 0.7 percentage
points year on year as a result of the increased contribution from Brazil (17.6%
compared with 16.8% at September 2003), thus increasing the contribution of
total revenues from Latin America to 33.5% (32.8% at September 2003).
The Group's total expenses at the end of the third quarter (12,610.6 million
euros) maintained the same growth rate as observed in the first half of the year
(+4.3%). This variation is due to the 12.3% year-on-year increase in supply
expenses, primarily from interconnection and handset purchases, and the 7.0%
year-on-year increase in subcontracts due to intensified commercial activity. In
turn, personnel expenses decreased by 6.0% compared with the first nine months
of 2003, mainly due to the 2003-2007 Redundancy Program at Telefonica de Espana.
In comparable terms, i.e. excluding the variations in exchange rates and in the
consolidation perimeter, total expenses would have grown 8.7% less than the 9.6%
registered in the first half of the year as a result of the higher cost
containment in the cellular business and in the Telefonica Latinoamerica Group.
Bad debt management continued to show good performance, as reflected in the bad
debt provision as a percentage of revenues by the Telefonica Group, which stood
at 1.3% at September, an improvement of 0.5 percentage points over the same
period of the previous year and remaining steady in comparison with the first
half of 2004. By business lines, it is important to highlight the drop in the
bad debts ratio over the past twelve months for both the Telefonica de Espana
Group (-0.6 percentage points to 0.5% of revenues) and the cellular business
(-0.5 percentage points to 1.0% of revenues). The bad debt ratio as a percentage
of revenues in Latin America decreased year on year to record a general
improvement for all operators. TASA continued to maintain a ratio around 1% of
revenues, CTC 3.7% of revenues and Telesp 3.2% of revenues.
Consolidated EBITDA for the first nine months of 2004 reached 9,807.0 million
euros, 5.5% higher than in the same period of the previous year. Like in the
case of revenues, all business lines recorded a higher EBITDA than in the first
nine months of 2003, except for the Content and Media business, that was
affected by the deconsolidation of Antena 3 TV from the consolidation perimeter.
Assuming constant exchange rates and excluding variations in the consolidation
perimeter, EBITDA showed a year on year increase of 7.1% (8.2% in the first half
of 2004).
In terms of EBITDA margin as a percentage of revenues, positive progress was
made as for September, reaching an EBITDA margin of 44.7% and posting, a
year-on-year increase of 0.1 percentage points and a 0.2 percentage points
increase over the first half of the year. The increase in the margin over the
last year is due to the improvement in the margins at the Telefonica de Espana
Group (+1.8 percentage points to 45.9%,), the Atento Group (+3.5 percentage
points to 15.0%), the directories business (+3.3 percentage points to 35.8%) and
the Terra Networks Group (+13.1 percentage points to 1.1%).
By companies, the Telefonica de Espana Group is the Group's biggest contributor
to EBITDA growth in absolute terms for the second consecutive quarter, amounting
to 3,736.2 million euros in the first nine months of the year, 38.1% of the
total. The year-on-year EBITDA growth amounted to 6.6%, with an acceleration in
comparison with previous quarters (+4.2% on January-March and +6.2% on
January-June) due to the higher level of revenues and the 10.3% reduction in
personnel expenses following the savings obtained from the 2003-2007 Redundancy
Program. In the opposite side, the item of subcontracts increased by 14.0% due
to greater commercial activity.
The cellular business EBITDA amounted to 3,577.8 million euros in the first nine
months of the year, posting a year on year growth of 3.7% and contributing with
36.5% in the consolidated EBITDA. This performance is mostly due to Telefonica
Moviles Espana, with a year-on-year increase in EBITDA of 7.7%. In comparison
with the first half of the year, however, EBITDA variations in this business
slowed down as a result of an increase in commercial costs on the main operating
markets. Thus, the cumulative EBITDA margin at September 30th dropped to 42.4%
(45.8% twelve months ago).
EBITDA at the Telefonica Latinoamerica Group stood at 2,291.8 million (23.4% of
consolidation EBITDA) at the end of the third quarter, recording a year-on-year
growth of 1.8%, 7.2% in constant euros. The margin as a percentage of revenues
stood at 45.4% in September, 0.4 percentage points below the margin recorded
twelve months ago, although a 0.7 percentage point improvement on that of the
first half of the year. During the third quarter, the margin amounted to 46.8%
compared with the 46.3% of July-September 2003.
Unlike its distribution of revenues, Spain increased its contribution to
consolidated EBITDA by 1.3 percentage points over the past year to reach 71.4%,
while Latin America's contribution dropped to 28.3% (30.5% a year ago) due to
lower contributions from Brazil (17.0%, -0.6 percentage points), Argentina
(4.0%, -0.4 percentage points), Peru (3.8%, -0.4 percentage points) and Chile
(4.1%, -0.5 percentage points) and the higher losses recorded in Mexico (-1.0%,
-0.3 percentage points).
The cumulative operating profit at September 2004 amounted to 5,420.5 million
euros, a year-on-year growth of 18.1%. There was a slowdown in the growth
obtained in June (+21.4%), as a result of lower EBITDA growth, which was not
offset by the higher year-on-year decrease in amortization (-6.7% compared with
-6.1% in the first half of the year). Assuming constant exchange rates and
excluding variations in the consolidation perimeter, the operating profit would
have grown by 18.6%, 2.4 percentage points less than in June.
The negative results of associated companies recorded an improvement of 112.8
million euros over the past year to -48.6 million euros at the end of September.
This year-on-year reduction of 69.9% was primarily due to the merger between Via
Digital and Sogecable, the sale of Audiovisual Sport, the lower losses related
to Medi Telcom and IPSE-200, the better results at Pearson2 and the increased
participation in Portugal Telecom.
----------------------------------------
2 On September 23rd, Telefonica sold its 4.88% stake, causing deconsolidation
from the Telefonica Group consolidation perimeter as from this date.
----------------------------------------
Total net financial costs at the end of September reached 817.7 million euros vs
750.6 million euros in January-September 2003. Excluding the positive impact of
the Argentine peso's appreciation in the same period of 2003 and the effects of
the slight depreciation in 2004, and the positive result coming from the
cancellation of US dollars denominated debt in the first half of 2003, the
comparable results (809.7 million euros in the first nine months of 2004 vs.
1,190.4 million euros in the same period of 2003) would drop 380.7 million euros
(-32.0%). This fall in the net financial costs was due to the 11.6% decrease in
the average net debt as well as the reduction of its average cost as a result of
the drop in interest rates in the euro and in the Brazilian real.
The free cash flow generated by Telefonica Group during the first nine months of
2004 was 4,416.5 million euros, of which 973.4 million euros were devoted to
dividend payments by Telefonica S.A., 1,548.8 million euros to financial
investments (net of real estate divestitures) and 542.4 million euros to
cancellation of commitments acquired by the Group, derived basically from the
headcount reduction plan. Thus, free cash flow after financial investments and
dividend payments, which corresponds to the one available for debt reduction was
1,351.9 million euros.
Net debt of Telefonica Group at the end of September 2004 stood at 17,976.6
million euros. The reduction of 1,258.7 million euros with respect to the
consolidated debt at the end of 2003 (19,235.3 million euros) came mainly from
the aforementioned generation of free cash flow after financial investments and
dividend payments (1,351.9 million euros). Likewise, there was a 39.1 million
euros increase due to the currencies movements effect on the non-euro
denominated debt (mainly due to the appreciation of the dollar against the
euro), as well as 54.1 million euros due to the changes in consolidation and
other effect on financial statements.
Goodwill amortization amounted to 320.6 million euros, 1.7% less than in the
first nine months of 2003. The allocation in the fourth quarter of 2003 of part
of the Telefonica Moviles Mexico goodwill as higher value of the operator's
licenses explains the year-on-year reduction in the cellular business goodwill
amortization. However, the inclusion of Sogecable's goodwill in July 2003 led to
an increase in the Content and Media business goodwill amortization
Extraordinary results as of September 30th totaled -866.4 million euros (-52.3
million euros in the same period of 2003), mostly due to the provision of 670.0
million euros related to the acceptance of the 2,417 applications received in
2004 for the 2003-2007 Redundancy Program by Telefonica de Espana. As an
exceptional measure, 55 pre-retirement have been accepted in addition to the
2,362 applications accepted for 2004. Between the rest of extraordinary
expenses, it should be highlighted: i) Restructuring of the Terra Networks Group
(-37.5 million euros) and ii) Impact of the arbitration award related to the
claim presented by the Radio Blanca Group to Uniprex (-31.4 million euros),
which is currently being appealed by the Antena 3 TV Group under the Provincial
Court.
The tax provision for the period January-September 2004 totaled 976.9 million
euros, which will mean a reduced cash outflow in the Group due to the
compensation of negative tax bases obtained in previous years.
The results attributed to minority interests deducted 273.1 million euros from
the Group's net income at September, compared with -168.5 million euros in
January-September 2003. This increase of 62.1% is mainly due to the stake of
minority interests in the increased net income at Telesp, VIVO and CTC Chile
(primarily through the sale of Telefonica Movil Chile to the Telefonica Moviles
Group) and the higher stake of the Group in Terra Networks.
As a result of this, the consolidated net income for the first nine months of
2004 amounted to 2,117.1 million euros, posting a year-on-year growth of 5.1%.
Excluding the net effect of the 2003-2007 Redundancy Program for 2004, net
income would total 2,526.0 million euros, an increase of 25.4%.
CapEx at the end of the third quarter amounted to 2,409.2 million euros, up by
2.2% year on year, mostly due to the higher investments made by the cellular
business (+45.9%) in the rollout of the UMTS network in Spain, the GSM networks
in Argentina and Mexico and to the increase in network capacity in Brazil.
Finally, the average workforce of the Group at September 30th was 153,111
employees, compared with 150,370 a year ago (+1.8%). Excluding the Atento Group,
there was a 9.3% year-on-year decline in the average workforce, mainly due to
the layoffs carried out at Telefonica de Espana through the 2003-2007 Redundancy
Program and at Telesp in 2003 and 2004.
Estimates for full year 2004: Upon the revision of Telefonica Moviles Group
outlook, Telefonica, S.A. estimates to finish the year 20043 with:
• Consolidated EBITDA growth: +5/+7% (+7/+10% previously).
• Consolidated Operating Free Cash Flow (EBITDA-CapEx): +7/+9% (+8/+11%
previously).
Likewise, Telefonica S.A. reiterates all published financial guidance for 20043
corresponding to its subsidiaries Telefonica de Espana Group and Telefonica
Latinoamerica Group. Moreover, the Company reaffirms its growth targets already
communicated in terms of revenues, EBIT and CapEx for the consolidated Group.
----------------------------------------
3 All estimates are in constant currency terms, assuming constant exchange rates
as of 2003 and excluding changes in consolidation. Telefonica de Espana Group
and Telefonica Latinoamerica Group's projections include Telefonica Empresas'
Spanish and Latin American businesses, respectively, in 2003 and 2004.
----------------------------------------
TELEFONICA GROUP
Financial Data
TELEFONICA GROUP
SELECTED FINANCIAL DATA
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
January - September
2004 2003 % Chg
Operating revenues 21,926.5 20,833.2 5.2
EBITDA 9,807.0 9,294.1 5.5
Operating profit 5,420.5 4,591.4 18.1
Income before taxes 3,367.2 3,301.1 2.0
Net income 2,117.1 2,014.4 5.1
Net income per share 0.427 0.403 5.9
Avg. No of shares (millions) (1) 4,955.9 4,993.9 (0.8)
(1) Weighted average number of shares in the period adjusted by free capital increases funded by reserves, that mean a
change in the number of shares that did not produce any variation of equity structure, as if they were done at the
beginning of the first period presented. That relates the two capital increases funded by a charge on freely disposable
reserves, recorded with the Mercantile Register on February 18, 2003 and on July 24, 2003. Moreover, the number of
shares in 2003 is affected by the capital reduction by amortization of treasury stock shares, from July 11, 2003, when
the AGM was held, and that was recorded with the Mercantile Register on September 10, 2003. Accordingly, there was an
average number of shares outstanding at the end of the period of 4,955,891,361
TELEFONICA GROUP
RESULTS BY COMPANIES
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
REVENUES EBITDA OPERATING PROFIT
Sep 2004 Sep 2003 % Chg Sep 2004 Sep 2003 % Chg Sep 2004 Sep 2003 % Chg
Telefonica de Espana Group 8,133.3 7,946.7 2.3 3,736.2 3,504.4 6.6 1,932.5 1,511.6 27.8
Telefonica Latinoamerica 5,046.0 4,921.5 2.5 2,291.8 2,252.4 1.8 1,040.9 913.7 13.9
Group
Cellular Business 8,447.1 7,539.4 12.0 3,577.8 3,451.3 3.7 2,416.3 2,315.4 4.4
Directories Business 452.3 425.8 6.2 162.1 138.4 17.1 145.4 118.8 22.5
Terra Networks Group 406.3 390.1 4.2 4.3 (47.1) c.s. (43.9) (104.3) (57.9)
Atento Group 432.9 356.6 21.4 64.9 41.0 58.5 36.7 0.2 n.s.
Content & Media Business 831.9 1,036.7 (19.8) 127.0 160.8 (21.1) 105.7 121.4 (12.9)
Other companies 615.4 602.6 2.1 (119.1) (156.0) (23.7) (218.2) (266.1) (18.0)
Eliminations (2,438.7) (2,386.2) 2.2 (38.1) (51.1) (25.4) 5.0 (19.3) c.s.
Group Total 21,926.5 20,833.2 5.2 9,807.0 9,294.1 5.5 5,420.5 4,591.4 18.1
TELEFONICA GROUP
CAPEX BY BUSINESS LINES
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
January - September
2004 2003 % Chg
Telefonica de Espana Group 793.0 976.3 (18.8)
Telefonica Latinoamerica Group 427.6 407.9 4.8
Cellular Business 1,076.8 738.1 45.9
Directories Business 12.7 10.2 23.9
Terra Networks Group 15.6 61.1 (74.4)
Atento Group 14.5 8.9 62.2
Content & Media Business 17.8 129.4 (86.2)
Other companies & Eliminations 51.3 24.9 106.4
Group Total 2,409.2 2,356.9 2.2
TELEFONICA GROUP
CONSOLIDATED INCOME STATEMENT
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
January - September July - September
2004 2003 % Chg 2004 2003 % Chg
Operating revenues 21,926.5 20,833.2 5.2 7,602.0 7,269.9 4.6
Internal expend capitalized in fixed assets (1) 308.6 357.0 (13.6) 102.1 131.1 (22.1)
Operating expenses (12,271.4) (11,694.2) 4.9 (4,177.9) (3,993.6) 4.6
Supplies (5,133.3) (4,570.9) 12.3 (1,769.3) (1,597.3) 10.8
Personnel expenses (3,262.7) (3,470.6) (6.0) (1,085.6) (1,125.9) (3.6)
Subcontracts (3,501.0) (3,273.1) 7.0 (1,197.5) (1,117.9) 7.1
Taxes (374.4) (379.5) (1.3) (125.5) (152.5) (17.7)
Other net operating income (expense) (156.7) (201.9) (22.4) (86.5) (69.3) 24.9
EBITDA 9,807.0 9,294.1 5.5 3,439.6 3,338.1 3.0
Depreciation and amortization (4,386.5) (4,702.7) (6.7) (1,440.1) (1,564.8) (8.0)
Operating profit 5,420.5 4,591.4 18.1 1,999.5 1,773.4 12.8
Profit from associated companies (48.6) (161.4) (69.9) (22.4) (28.9) (22.5)
Financial net income (expense) (817.7) (750.6) 8.9 (330.8) (454.1) (27.2)
Amortization of goodwill (320.6) (326.0) (1.7) (109.0) (113.8) (4.2)
Extraordinary net income (expense) (866.4) (52.3) n.s. (140.2) (92.1) 52.3
Income before taxes 3,367.2 3,301.1 2.0 1,397.1 1,084.4 28.8
Income taxes (976.9) (1,118.2) (12.6) (417.9) (402.4) 3.8
Net income before minority interests 2,390.3 2,182.9 9.5 979.2 682.0 43.6
Minority interests (273.1) (168.5) 62.1 (116.3) (93.2) 24.7
Net income 2,117.1 2,014.4 5.1 862.9 588.7 46.6
Average shares (millions) (2) 4,955.9 4,993.9 (0.8) 4,955.9 4,955.9 0.0
Net income per share 0.427 0.403 5.9 0.174 0.119 46.6
(1) Including work in process.
(2) Weighted average number of shares in the period adjusted by free capital increases funded by reserves, that mean a
change in the number of shares that did not produce any variation of equity structure, as if they were done at the
beginning of the first period presented. That relates the two capital increases funded by a charge on freely disposable
reserves, recorded with the Mercantile Register on February 18, 2003 and on July 24, 2003. Moreover, the number of
shares in 2003 is affected by the capital reduction by amortization of treasury stock shares, from July 11, 2003, when
the AGM was held, and that was recorded with the Mercantile Register on September 10, 2003. Accordingly, there was an
average number of shares outstanding at the end of the period of 4,955,891,361.
TELEFONICA GROUP
CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEET
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
September
2004 2003 % Chg
Subscribed shares not paid-in 0.0 223.6 n.s.
Long-term assets 42,430.9 45,346.1 (6.4
Start up expenses 448.4 566.2 (20.8)
Intangible net assets 7,288.7 7,311.5 (0.3)
Fixed net assets 23,249.0 25,034.7 (7.1)
Investment 11,444.8 12,433.7 (8.0)
Goodwill on consolidation 6,099.9 6,628.7 (8.0)
Deferred expenses 445.2 562.1 (20.8)
Current assets 12,164.0 10,508.1 15.8
Inventories 672.8 393.2 71.1
Accounts receivable 6,626.5 6,515.0 1.7
Short-term investments 3,488.9 2,708.8 28.8
Cash and banks 605.9 558.3 8.5
Others 769.9 332.7 131.4
Assets = Liabilities 61,140.0 63,268.6 (3.4)
Shareholder's equity 15,819.4 17,178.3 (7.9)
Minority interests 3,959.5 4,718.6 (16.1)
Badwill on consolidation 11.2 10.1 11.0
Deferred income 505.1 772.4 (34.6)
Provisions for risks and expenses 7,802.0 6,548.8 19.1
Long-term debt 15,009.6 19,306.4 (22.3)
Accrued taxes payable 755.8 1,300.4 (41.9)
Short-term debt including current maturities 7,571.3 4,806.4 57.5
Interest payable 288.2 271.9 6.0
Other creditors 9,417.8 8,355.4 12.7
Financial Data
Consolidated net debt (1) 17,976.6 20,462.8 (12.2)
Consolidated debt ratio (2) 46.1% 46.1% 0.0 p.p.
(1) Net debt: Long-term debt + Short-term debt including current maturities - Short-term and Long-term finantial
investments - Cash and banks.
(2) Debt ratio: Net debt / (Shareholders' equity + Minority interests + Deferred income + Accrued taxes payable + Net
debt).
TELEFONICA GROUP
FREE CASH FLOW AND CHANGE IN DEBT
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
January - September
2004 2003 % Chg
I Cash flows from operations 8,963.6 8,853.2 1.2
II Extraord. payments related to operating activities and commitm. (695.0) (697.4)
III Net interest payment (1) (889.9) (1,314.3)
IV Payment for income tax (151.0) (167.8)
A=I+II+III+IV Net cash provided by operating activities 7,227.7 6,673.7 8.3
B Payment for investment in fixed and intangible assets (2,526.2) (2,594.9)
C=A+B Net free cash flow after CAPEX 4,701.5 4,078.8 15.3
D Cash received from sale of Real State 210.8 330.6
E Net payment for financial investment (1,759.6) (1,936.5)
F Dividends paid (2) (1,800.8) (821.1)
G=C+D+E+F Free cash flow after dividends 1,351.9 1,651.8 (18.2)
H Effects of exchange rate changes on net debt 39.1 (586.8)
I Effects on net debt of changes in consolidation and others 54.1 168.3
J Net debt at beginning of period 19,235.3 22,533.1
K=J-G+H+I Net debt at end of period 17,976.6 20,462.8 (12.1)
(1) Including cash received from dividends paid by subsidiaries that are not under full consolidation method.
(2) Dividends paid by Telefonica S.A. and dividend payments to minoritaries from subsidiaries that are under full
consolidation method.
TELEFONICA GROUP
RECONCILIATIONS OF CASH FLOW AND EBITDA MINUS CAPEX
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
January - September
2004 2003 % Chg
EBITDA 9,807.0 9,294.1 5.5
- CAPEX accrued during the period (EoP exchange rate) (2,409.2) (2,356.9)
- Extraord. payments related to operating activities and comm. (695.0) (697.4)
- Net interest payment (889.9) (1,314.3)
- Payment for income tax (151.0) (167.8)
- Investment in working capital (960.3) (678.9)
= Net Free Cash Flow after Capex 4,701.5 4,078.8 15.3
+ Cash received from sale of Real Estate 210.8 330.6
- Net payment for financial investment (1,759.6) (1,936.5)
- Dividends paid (1,800.8) (821.1)
= Free Cash Flow after dividends 1,351.9 1,651.8 (18.2)
Note: At the Investor Conference held in October 2003, the concept expected 'Free Cash Flow' 2003-2006 was introduced
to reflect the amount of cash flow available to remunerate Telefonica S.A. Shareholders, to protect solvency levels
(financial debt and commitments), and to accomodate strategic flexibility.
The differences with the caption 'Net Free Cash Flow after Capex' included in the table presented above, are related to
'Free Cash Flow' being calculated before payments related to commitments (workforce reductions and guarantees) and
after dividend payments to minoritaries, due to cash recirculation within the Group.
Jan-Sep 2004 Jan-Sep 2003
Net Free Cash Flow after Capex 4,701.5 4,078.8
+ Payments related to cancellation of commitments 542.4 556.0
- Dividend payments to minoritaries (827.4) (179.1)
= Free Cash Flow 4,416.5 4,455.6
TELEFONICA GROUP
NET FINANCIAL DEBT AND COMMITMENTS
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
September 2004
Long-term debt 15,009.6
Short term debt including current maturities 7,547.0
Cash and Banks (605.9)
Short and Long-term financial investments (1) (3,974.1)
A Net Financial Debt 17,976.6
Guarantees to IPSE 2000 557.7
Guarantees to Sogecable 80.0
Guarantees to Newcomm 49.2
B Commitments related to guarantees 686.9
Gross commitments related to workforce reduction (2) 5,302.3
Value of associated Long-term assets (3) (609.6)
Taxes receivable (4) (1,407.6)
C Net commitments related to workforce reduction 3,285.1
A + B + C Total Debt + Commitments 21,948.6
Net Financial Debt / EBITDA (5) 1.4x
Total Debt + Commitments/ EBITDA (5) 1.7x
(1) Short term investments and certain investments in financial assets with a maturity profile longer than one year,
whose amount is included in the caption 'Investment' of the Balance Sheet.
(2) Mainly in Spain, except 53.7 million euros related to the provision of pension fund liabilities of corporations
outside Spain. This amount is detailed in the caption 'Provisions for Contingencies and Expenses' of the Balance Sheet,
and is the result of adding the following items: 'Provision for Pre-retirement, Social Security Expenses and Voluntary
Severance', 'Group Insurance', 'Technical Reserves', and 'Provisions for Pension Funds of Other Companies'.
(3) Amount included in the caption 'Investment' of the Balance Sheet, section 'Other Loans'. Mostly related to
investments in fixed income securities and long-term deposits that cover the materialization of technical reserves of
the Group insurance companies.
(4) Net present value of tax benefits arising from the future payments related to workforce reduction commitments.
(5) Calculation based on twelve months rolling EBITDA, that is from September 2003 to September 2004.
TELEFONICA GROUP
EXCHANGES RATES APPLIED
P&L (1) Balance Sheet and CapEx (2)
Jan - Sep 2004 Jan - Sep 2003 Sep 2004 Sep 2003
US Dollar / Euro 1.225 1.110 1.241 1.165
Argentinean Peso / Euro 3.592 3.287 3.699 3.397
Chilean Peso / Euro 745.789 733.788 755.584 770.162
Brasilian Real / Euro 3.639 3.457 3.547 3.406
Peruvian Nuevo Sol / Euro 4.093 3.867 4.147 4.058
Mexican Peso / Euro 13.976 12.131 14.159 12.732
(1) These exchange rates are used to convert the P&L accounts of the Group foreign subsidiaries from local currency to
euros. P&L accounts for subsidiaries that use inflation adjusted accounting criteria (Mexico, Chile, Peru, Colombia and
Venezuela), are first converted to US dollars at the closing exchange rate, and then the conversion into euros is made
according to the average exchange rate.
(2) Exchange rates as of 30/09/04 and 30/09/03.
RESULTS BY BUSINESS LINES
Fixed Line Business
TELEFONICA DE ESPANA GROUP
During the first nine months of the year, the Telefonica de Espana Group
achieved growth in revenues and EBITDA of 2.3% and 6.6% respectively, with a
2.6% increase in revenues and 7.5% in EBITDA over the third quarter compared to
the same quarter of 2003, as a result of the Group's increased commercial
efforts and efficiency.
The success of Telefonica de Espana's strategy in the development of broadband
services was a deciding factor in these results. The following commercial
actions undertaken by the company during the last months should be highlighted:
• On September 30th, Telefonica de Espana began the process to double the
speed of the ADSL service, 512 Kbps access becoming the lowest speed
available. The speed of 94% of the ADSL access has already been doubled.
This process is to be completed by November 2004. The doubling of access
speeds enables ADSL clients to enjoy improved access to the Internet and the
wide range of Value Added Services (VAS) marketed by Telefonica. This
improvement, at not extra cost to clients, is applicable to both retail and
wholesale ADSL as a drive for the market growth as a whole.
• Presentation to the CMT of a new ADSL modality known as 'ADSL tailor made'
for approval, with download speeds of 512 Kbps and the aim of reducing the
service access barrier. On October 7th 2004, the CMT decided to approve the
commercialization of the following three options:
• Weekends (21.90 euros/month): Flat rate from 9 p.m. Friday through 8
a.m. Monday, as well as 11 hours of free Internet access outside these
times.
• Evenings (21.90 euros/month): Flat rate every day from 9 p.m. through
8 a.m. the following day plus 11 hours of free Internet access outside
these times.
• Evenings + Weekends (29.70 euros/month): Flat rate evenings and
weekends plus eleven hours free Internet access outside these periods.
• 'Back to school' promotion with free ADSL subscription in September and
free monthly fees for the 'PC security pack' over three months (antivirus +
firewall).
• ADSL PC promotion, with the commercialization of three different tabletop
and laptop computer configurations at very attractive prices for both
current ADSL clients and those requesting subscription. PC payment can be
financed into up to twelve monthly interest-free installments and are
charged through the telephone bill itself.
• Strengthening of the movies catalogue for the Imagenio video-on-demand
service following the agreement reached with Buenavista, one of the top
movie distributors. Following this initial agreement, Telefonica plans to
reach new agreements with other companies of reference in the sector in the
near future. Furthermore, three new thematic channels (Eurosport, Euronews
and Bloomberg) have been added to the basic Imagenio TV offer.
Other remarkable commercial actions taken by the company include:
• Free PSTN line connection fee campaign from September 20th through 30th.
This campaign was notably successful, with a total of 110,000 subscriptions
during the offer period.
• As of October 31st 2004, reduction in the price of fixed-to-mobile calls
in compliance with the 2% price-cap (CPI-4%) established for 2004. The
largest reductions were implemented during times of greatest consumption,
with discounts of between 10.16% and 7.24% during this time zone, according
to the target operator.
• Launching of new local traffic flat rate for calls made to five preset
numbers at 5 euros per month; this new product had a great contribution to
the client win-back and loss contention programs.
• International traffic gain from the growing immigrant community through a
portfolio of services of which the following should be noted:
• Wholesale international traffic card, which at very attractive prices
enabled an increase of 25 percentage points in Telefonica de Espana's
market share on prepaid traffic cards throughout 2004.
• Decrease on international traffic prices for calls made from public
payphones to a group of countries, contributing to doubling the volume
of minutes of international traffic to these countries from the public
payphones during the quarter.
Telefonica de Espana Group revenues totaled 8,133.3 million euros during the
first nine months of the year, presenting a 2.3% growth in comparison with the
same period of the previous year, in line with the 2.2% growth obtained during
the first half of the year. Telefonica de Espana parent company contributed with
revenues of 7,791.9 million euros to this result, which represented a
year-on-year growth rate of 1.7% after recording revenues 133.0 million euros
above those of the period January-September 2003.
Particularly noteworthy when analyzing the contribution to the growth in
revenues of each of the businesses forming Telefonica de Espana parent company
is the good progress made by revenues from the Internet and Broadband Services,
which widely offset the 168.0 million euro decline in Traditional Services
revenues, with 205.7 million euros. The Data and Solutions Business and the
Wholesale Business contributed to growth with 12.7 and 82.7 million euros,
respectively.
• Cumulative revenues as of September from Traditional Services totaled
5,285.6 million euros. The positive evolution recorded during the third
quarter is noteworthy, in which revenues fell by 1.6% to confirm the
progressive slowing of the rate of decline over 2004: they declined by 4.7%
in the first quarter, by 3.8% in the first half and finally by 3.1% in the
January-September period, in comparison with the same period 2003.
Revenues from Client Network Access amounted to 2,225.5 million euros over
the first nine months of the year, which was 0.1% higher in comparison with
the previous year. Along with the positive effect of the rise in the monthly
fees for PSTN lines in April, the surcharges on calls made to toll-free
numbers from public payphones should be added, after receiving the
authorization to implement them during the third quarter. This surcharges
provided a 0.6 percentage point growth in aggregate to Client Network Access
revenues to September. Without this contribution, revenues would have
dropped 0.5%.
The decline in Telefonica's estimated access market share continued to slow,
standing at 89.0% at the end of September 2004, which was 0.3 percentage
points lower than in June 2004 and 2.1 percentage points lower than in
September 2003. In absolute terms, 70,122 lines (PSTN + ISDN basic access)
were lost during the quarter, leading to an aggregate number of 168,575
lines lost in the first nine months of the year, compared with the 297,951
lost in the same period of 2003.
It is worth noting that of the 110,000 new lines subscribed during the free
connection fee campaign, 41,000 actually began operating during September.
The remaining lines will begin operations during the fourth quarter of the
year.
The unbundled loops by competitors of Telefonica de Espana in the third
quarter of the year were 16,600 as fully unbundled loops and 12,165 as
shared access loops; the total number of unbundled loops being 72,187, of
which 57,700 were fully unbundled and 14,487 were shared loops. A slight
drop in the net gain of fully unbundled loops was observed during the
quarter, offset by the higher growth in shared access loops.
Revenues from voice usage amounted to 2,436.8 million euros to September,
down by 4.0% from the same period of the previous year, although the rate of
decline has slowed in recent months. The lower decline in revenues is due
primarily to the changes in the price and bonus discount scheme of the
'Servicio Integral de Mantenimiento (SIM)' (Comprehensive Maintenance
Service), the effects of which will be noted through to the first quarter of
2005.
As regards voice traffic, the estimated total volume of the market in Spain,
expressed in minutes, was down 5.1% in the first nine months of the year in
comparison with the same period of the previous year. Telefonica de Espana's
estimated share of the voice market stood at 72.7% in September, only 0.1
percentage point lower than in June and 3.6 percentage points lower than
September 2003. There has been a slowdown in the year-on-year loss of market
share over recent quarters, amounting to 4.6 percentage points in the twelve
months to June 2004 and 5.2 percentage points in the twelve months to March
2004.
The estimated total volume of minutes processed by Telefonica de Espana
during the first nine months of the year amounted to 92,958 million, a 6.5%
year-on-year decline. Total outgoing traffic (including Internet), which
accounted for 55.7% of total traffic, amounted to 51,790 million minutes and
fell by 15.5% compared to the same period of the previous year. Traditional
outgoing traffic totaled 35,478 million minutes at the end of September,
down by 11.0% year-on-year due to the negative performance of the market and
the aforementioned loss in market share. The negative trend in traffic
continued during the first nine months of the year, with very significant
year-on-year falls in domestic fixed line-to-fixed line traffic: local
traffic was down by 13.6%, provincial traffic by 11.1% and DLD traffic by
9.5%. There was also a 1.7% drop in fixed-to-mobile traffic during this
period. Only international traffic maintained a positive trend, with
year-on-year growth of 2.5%. The number of outgoing minutes to the Internet
amounted to 16,311 million and continued to show a negative year-on-year
variation of 23.8%, mainly as a result of switched Internet traffic
cannibalization by broadband ADSL services. Finally, incoming traffic rose
by 7.9% to 41,168 million minutes.
The total number of preselected lines stabilized over the third quarter,
falling by 312 lines with regard to the total number at the end of last June
and by 34,735 in relation to the maximum share reached in March.
Nevertheless, the introduction of the verbal consent procedure in the
preselection process could lead to positive net adds in preselected lines
over the coming moths. At the end of the third quarter, there were a total
of 2,296,211 preselected lines.
In regard to Value-Added Services, Voice Mailbox and Caller ID services
should be noted. By the end of September 2004, the number of services
activated amounted to 11,793,052 and 7,341,306, respectively, with a
positive progress in the quarter. The growing acceptance of the text
messaging service continued, with a 3.5% increase compared with the previous
quarter. The number of access + traffic modular plans 'Combinados' has
already reached 879,570.
• Internet and Broadband Services recorded cumulative revenues of 816.3
million euros in the first nine months of the year, representing
year-on-year growth of 33.7%.
The total number of ADSL lines in service amounted to 2,157,805 by the end
of September, representing a net gain of 114,077 lines during the third
quarter. It must be noted that although this figure is a drop on the 126,892
accesses of the third quarter last year, Telefonica de Espana retail ADSL
net gain reached a total of 104,051 this year compared to the 91,351
accesses of the third quarter 2003 to give a total of 1,443,798 accesses as
of September. The drop in net gain of ADSL accesses was due to the wholesale
service, with a migration towards services based on unbundled loops.
Telefonica Group estimated retail broadband market share stood at 58.1% by
September 2004, compared to that of 57.8% as of June 2004.
Value-Added Services on the retail ADSL service continued to perform
solidly, amounting to 864,442 operative services. 39.4% of our retail
clients have signed up to some kind of value-added service. Of the most
successful services, 'ADSL Solutions' recorded growth of 9.5% compared with
June 2004, with a total of 153,225 operative units (44,347 Net-LAN and
remote access solutions). The 'Mantenimiento Integral ADSL' (ADSL
Comprehensive Maintenance Service) also presents strong growth, having
reached 127,687 clients.
Hence, revenues from the Telefonica de Espana retail broadband services grew
57.6% to reach 621.2 million euros. It is important to highlight that 9.2%
of retail ADSL ARPU comes from Value-Added Services.
Narrowband Internet revenues continued to decline: they were down 9.8% to
195.1 million euros, due primarily to the migration of clients to broadband
services.
• The Data and Service business recorded an aggregate growth in revenues of
1.9% and totaled 692.5 million euros at the end of September.
The main item of these revenues, comprising 55.0% of Data and Solutions
revenues, relates to the planning and operating of virtual private networks.
These revenues fell slightly by 0.2% as a result of the migration towards
lower priced products based on IP technology, not completely offset by the
increase in plant.
On the other hand, the Solutions and Value-Added Services for Businesses
segment recorded a year-on-year growth of 18.5%, accounting for 26.1% of
total Data and Solutions revenues and 3.7 percentage points up on last year.
There are currently 169 agreements for the management or outsourcing of
services for large corporations, of which 49 are client management centers
operated by Telefonica, and there has been a 49.9% increase in the number of
hosting servers.
• Wholesale Business contributed with 997.5 million euros to consolidated
revenues, a 9.0% increase in relation to the same period of the previous
year. 'Other national operators services' contributed to this increase with
a 29.3% growth in the quarter, thus reflecting the impact of agreements
signed with large domestic operators for transit traffic carriage to Mobile
networks.
27.0% of Wholesale revenues came from National interconnection services,
which increased by 3.4% due, basically, to the 25.9% growth in
fixed-to-mobile interconnection revenues and a slight decrease in
fixed-to-fixed interconnection revenues.
In addition, it is important to highlight the substantial 46.9% growth in
the wholesale ADSL services with revenues totaling 168.9 million euros.
Telefonica de Espana Group's operating expenses experienced a year-on-year
decrease of 0.7% to 4,476.5 million euros. The 10.3% reduction in personnel
expenses in comparison with the same period of the previous year must be noted,
which amounted to a total of 1,576.6 million euros, as a result of the staff
joining the 2003-2007 Redundancy Program. Telefonica de Espana parent company
headcount reached 35,447 employees at the end of September 2004, representing a
reduction of 1,612 employees since the beginning of the year. Up to the end of
September 2004, 1,831 employees had left Telefonica de Espana under the
Redundancy Program. The remaining employees included in the total figure of
redundancies accepted by the company in 2004 will leave Telefonica de Espana in
the remaining months of the year.
Contrary to personnel expenses evolution, company's increased commercial
activities aimed at revenue growth led to a 14.0% rise in External Services &
Others, which totaled 856.8 million euros.
Supplies expenses, amounting to 1,908.4 million euros, grew by 2.4% despite the
slight 2.3% decrease in interconnection expenses following the reduction in
fixed-to-mobile interconnection tariffs that came into effect in November 2003.
The increase in expenses at Telyco linked to the handset sale business had, as a
whole, a decisive impact on the evolution of supplies expenses at the Telefonica
de Espana Group; without them, the Group's supplies expenses growth would have
fallen to 0.3%.
Telefonica de Espana Group EBITDA amounted to 3,736.2 million euros, up 6.6%
year-on-year. The Group's EBITDA margin reached 45.9% (1.8 percentage points
higher than in the same period of the previous year). Telefonica de Espana
parent company's EBITDA amounted to 3,718.2 million euros (+6.7% on the previous
year).
Telefonica de Espana Group's operating profit amounted to 1,932.5 million euros
in the first nine months of the year, +27.8% over the same period of the
previous year as a result of the positive evolution of EBITDA and the 9.5%
decrease in amortization and depreciation.
CapEx by the Telefonica de Espana Group dropped by 18.8% to 793.0 million euros
to reach a CapEx over Revenues ratio of 9.7%, reflecting Telefonica de Espana's
aim of taking forward the transformation process into a less capital-intensive
company.
Operating free cash flow, defined as EBITDA minus CapEx, amounted to 2,943.2
million euros in the period January-September 2004, up by 16.4% on the same
period of 2003.
TELEFONICA DE ESPANA
SELECTED OPERATING DATA
Unaudited figures (Thousands)
September
2004 2003 % Chg
Equivalent lines (1) 19,486.3 18,887.7 3.2
PSTN Lines 14,868.7 15,123.6 (1.7)
ISDN equivalent basic access 1,850.7 1,800.8 2.8
ISDN equivalent primary accesses y 2/6 equivalent accesses 551.4 530.6 3.9
Fully unbundled local loops 57.7 12.4 365.4
ADSL connections 2,157.8 1,420.5 51.9
Telefonica de Espana retail ADSL 1,443.8 938.0 53.9
Traffic (minutes in millions) (2) 92,958.0 99,435.0 (6.5)
Employees (units) 35,447 42,193 (16.0)
(1) PSTN (including Public Use Telephony) (x 1) - ISDN Basic accesses (x 2) - ISDN Primary access (x 30) - 2/6 Accesses
(x 30) - ADSL Lines (x1).
(2) January - September cumulative data.
TELEFONICA DE ESPANA PARENT COMPANY
OPERATING REVENUES
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
January - September July - September
2004 2003 % Chg 2004 2003 % Chg
Traditional Services 5,285.6 5,453.6 (3.1) 1,760.7 1,789.4 (1.6)
Client network access (1) 2,225.5 2,224.0 0.1 758.0 734.4 3.2
Voice usage (Net total) (2) 2,436.8 2,539.0 (4.0) 814.5 829.9 (1.9)
Local 575.7 603.0 (4.5) 180.8 182.9 (1.1)
Provincial 186.6 195.2 (4.4) 60.1 62.6 (4.1)
Domestic long distance 327.0 341.9 (4.4) 105.3 109.1 (3.5)
International long distance 208.6 190.2 9.6 82.0 67.8 21.0
Fixed to mobile 903.7 945.7 (4.4) 309.4 322.3 (4.0)
IRIS and others (3) 235.3 263.1 (10.5) 76.8 85.2 (9.9)
Handsets sales and maintenance 456.3 523.4 (12.8) 138.9 169.7 (18.2)
Other business lines (4) 166.9 167.2 (0.2) 49.3 55.4 (11.0)
Internet and Broadband Services 816.3 610.6 33.7 285.8 211.7 35.0
Narrowband 195.1 216.4 (9.8) 56.2 66.8 (15.8)
Broadband (retail) 621.2 394.3 57.6 229.6 144.9 58.5
Data and Solutions Services 692.5 679.8 1.9 218.1 236.8 (7.9)
Corporate networks (5) 511.5 527.1 (3.0) 164.3 182.0 (9.7)
Solutions 181.0 152.7 18.5 53.7 54.8 (1.9)
Wholesale Services 997.5 914.8 9.0 351.9 314.8 11.8
National interconnection 269.1 260.4 3.4 83.9 85.1 (1.4)
Wholesale ADSL (Megabase, Megavia and GigADSL) 168.9 115.0 46.9 58.2 40.2 44.6
International operators services 227.8 233.6 (2.5) 75.5 85.6 (11.8)
Other national operators services (6) 331.7 305.8 8.5 134.3 103.9 29.3
Total operating revenues 7,791.9 7,658.9 1.7 2,616.4 2,552.5 2.5
Note: Starting first quarter 2004, Telefonica Data Espana and Telefonica Soluciones results will be incorporated within
Telefonica de Espana Group. 2003 figures are proforma for the benefit of comparison.
(1) Revenues derived from monthly and connection fees (PSTN, Public Use Telephony, ISDN and Corporate Services), public
telephone booths and network services.
(2) Voice usage net of discounts, foreign participation (international long distance) and payments to Intelligent
Network providers.
(3) Services included: Intelligent Network services, Special Valued Services and others.
(4) Special Projects, Services agency and others. (Broadcasting included).
(5) Included leased circuits, VPN and delicated internet access.
(6) Services included: Commercial wholesale services (access, carrier and maintenance), wholesale leased circuits,
other IP services and ULL.
TELEFONICA DE ESPANA PARENT COMPANY
OPERATING REVENUES - PROFORMA 2003
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
2003
Jan - Mar Jan - Jun Jan - Sep Jan - Dec
Traditional Services 1,816.2 3,664.3 5,453.6 7,243.3
Client network access (1) 737.8 1,489.6 2,224.0 2,950.0
Voice usage (Net total) (2) 849.6 1,709.2 2,539.0 3,366.1
Local 213.6 420.2 603.0 816.9
Provincial 66.6 132.5 195.2 259.5
Domestic long distance 116.8 232.8 341.9 461.6
International long distance 58.5 122.5 190.2 243.9
Fixed to mobile 305.9 623.5 945.7 1,257.9
IRIS and others (3) 88.3 177.9 263.1 326.3
Handsets sales and maintenance 174.8 353.7 523.4 706.0
Other business lines (4) 54.1 111.8 167.2 221.1
Internet and Broadband Services 191.0 399.0 610.6 849.0
Narrowband 79.9 149.6 216.4 291.9
Broadband (retail) 111.1 249.4 394.3 557.1
Data and Solutions Services 215.3 443.0 679.8 928.6
Corporate networks (5) 168.8 345.1 527.1 705.4
Solutions 46.4 97.9 152.7 223.3
Wholesale Services 287.7 600.1 914.8 1,256.7
National interconnection 83.5 175.3 260.4 356.6
Wholesale ADSL (Megabase, Megavia & GigADSL) 35.7 74.8 115.0 166.1
International operators services 71.9 148.1 233.6 309.3
Other national operators services (6) 96.5 201.9 305.8 424.7
Total operating revenues 2,510.1 5,106.3 7,658.9 10,277.6
Note: Starting first quarter 2004, Telefonica Data Espana and Telefonica Soluciones results will be incorporated within
Telefonica de Espana Group. 2003 figures are proforma for the benefit of comparison.
(1) Revenues derived from monthly and connection fees (PSTN, Public Use Telephony, ISDN and Corporate Services), public
telephone booths and network services.
(2) Voice usage net of discounts, foreign participation (international long distance) and payments to Intelligent
Network providers.
(3) Services included: Intelligent Network services, Special Valued Services and others.
(4) Special Projects, Services agency and others. (Broadcasting included).
(5) Included leased circuits, VPN and delicated internet access.
(6) Services included: Commercial wholesale services (access, carrier and maintenance), wholesale leased circuits,
other IP services and ULL.
TELEFONICA DE ESPANA GROUP
CONSOLIDATED INCOME STATEMENT
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
January - September July - September
2004 2003 % Chg 2004 2003 % Chg
Operating revenues 8,133.3 7,946.7 2.3 2,733.9 2,663.9 2.6
Internal expend capitalized in fixed assets (1) 97.2 120.8 (19.5) 30.9 37.0 (16.4)
Operating expenses (4,476.5) (4,506.6) (0.7) (1,505.2) (1,522.9) (1.2)
Other net operating income (expense) (17.9) (56.6) (68.3) (10.9) (16.5) (34.2)
EBITDA 3,736.2 3,504.4 6.6 1,248.7 1,161.4 7.5
Depreciation and amortization (1,803.7) (1,992.8) (9.5) (566.1) (655.7) (13.7)
Operating profit 1,932.5 1,511.6 27.8 682.6 505.7 35.0
Profit from associated companies (0.8) (0.7) 5.4 (0.2) (0.2) 9.8
Financial net income (expense) (287.6) (340.1) (15.4) (89.3) (111.7) (20.0)
Amortization of goodwill (2.5) 0.2 c.s. (0.8) 0.0 c.s.
Extraordinary net income (expense) (652.8) 21.5 c.s. (41.8) 2.8 c.s.
Income before taxes 988.8 1,192.5 (17.1) 550.5 396.7 38.8
Income taxes (295.2) (340.5) (13.3) (182.3) (114.1) 59.7
Net income before minority interests 693.6 852.0 (18.6) 368.1 282.5 30.3
Minority interests (0.2) (0.0) 225.0 (0.1) 0.0 n.s.
Net income 693.4 851.9 (18.6) 368.0 282.5 30.3
Note: Starting first quarter 2004, Telefonica Data Espana and Telefonica Soluciones results will be incorporated
within Telefonica de Espana Group. 2003 figures are proforma for the benefit of comparison.
(1) Including work in process.
TELEFONICA DE ESPANA GROUP
CONSOLIDATED INCOME STATEMENT - PROFORMA 2003
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
2003
Jan - Mar Jan - Jun Jan - Sep Jan - Dec
Operating revenues 2,590.0 5,282.9 7,946.7 10,695.4
Internal expend capitalized in fixed assets (1) 41.2 83.8 120.8 174.6
Operating expenses (1,460.6) (2,983.7) (4,506.6) (6,048.7)
Other net operating income (expense) (12.5) (40.1) (56.6) (58.9)
EBITDA 1,158.2 2,343.0 3,504.4 4,762.4
Depreciation and amortization (675.7) (1,337.1) (1,992.8) (2,638.8)
Operating profit 482.5 1,005.9 1,511.6 2,123.6
Profit from associated companies (0.4) (0.6) (0.7) (0.9)
Financial net income (expense) (117.1) (228.4) (340.1) (447.5)
Amortization of goodwill (0.7) 0.2 0.2 (2.8)
Extraordinary net income (expense) (3.0) 18.7 21.5 (1,374.1)
Income before taxes 361.3 795.8 1,192.5 298.2
Income taxes (104.4) (226.4) (340.5) (18.1)
Net income before minority interests 257.0 569.4 852.0 280.1
Minority interests (0.0) (0.1) (0.0) (0.0)
Net income 256.9 569.4 851.9 280.1
Note: The incorporation of the assets corresponding to Telefonica Empresas into Telefonica de Espana Group in 2004,
implies the presentation of Telefonica de Espana Group proforma financial statements for fiscal year 2003, under the
same criteria, for the benefit of comparisons. In February 27th, 2004, the company notified the main metrics of these
proforma financial statements for fiscal year 2003 under the new consolidation perimeter. The final definition of the
assets to be incorporated to Telefonica de Espana Group makes these metrics to vary slightly with respect to the ones
previously presented (-4.4 million euros in revenues and -10.4 million euros in EBITDA), a change that does not imply
modifications in neither Telefonica de Espana Group nor Telefonica Group published accounts in the above mentioned
fiscal year.
(1) Including work in process.
RESULTS BY BUSINESS LINES
Fixed Line Business
TELEFONICA LATINOAMERICA GROUP
Results at Telefonica Latinoamerica, in terms of both operating revenues and
EBITDA, continued to record positive growth in current euros. In the third
quarter of the year, almost all Latin American currencies appreciated against
the dollar (with the exception of the Argentine peso, which depreciated
slightly). Furthermore, the average dollar/euro exchange rate remained almost
unchanged throughout this quarter of the year. However, in the first nine months
of 2004, on a year on year basis, these currencies continued to record levels of
depreciation against the dollar that were higher than those of the first half of
2004 (except for the Peruvian sol), which had a negative impact on the revenues
for the third quarter.
Operating revenues amounted to 5,046.0 million euros, representing year on year
growth of 2.5%, which in constant euros becomes 8.0%, slowing down the growth of
previous quarters slightly. The evolution of the revenues in constant euros
reflects the behavior of revenues at:
• Telesp (up 16.0% in local currency), as a result of the positive progress
made by the traditional business (up 14.8%), assisted by the good
performance of the new businesses (SMP, long distance outside Sao Paulo,
...), the July and September 2004 tariff increases and the increase in
fixed-to-mobile and public telephone traffic.
• TASA (up 9.4% in local currency), due to the good performance of the plant
and traffic operating variables in comparison with 2003, despite the tariff
freeze in force since January 2002, which made it possible to achieve growth
of 7.5% in local currency in revenues from traditional services.
• CTC recorded a fall in revenues of 6.8% in local currency, with a slow
down in the decreasing rate recorded in the first half (-9.4%) due to the
updated impact of the tariff decree in line with the new version published
in September, which gives a slight improvement on tariffs issued in the
decree initially published in May, the flexibility of tariffs for heavy
consumers, and the minute plans. However, the drop in traffic due to the
high level of competition on the market and the replacement effect of mobile
telephony continued.
• TdP, with a 14.1% increase year on year in its plant of equivalent lines,
recorded a slight growth in revenue of 0.2% in local currency. The 2.5% fall
in Traditional business revenues in local currency, due to the greater
contribution of lines associated to the new tariff plans, was offset by the
60.8% rise in Internet (narrowband and broadband) revenues in local
currency.
• Telefonica Empresas America and TIWS, where the positive trend of the
previous quarter continued with growth of 13.8% and 22.7%, respectively, in
constant euros.
The total operating expenses of Telefonica Latinoamerica stood at 2,813.4
million euros at September 30, 2004, which was 2.5% more in current euros than
in 2003. In constant euros, these expenses rose by 7.9%, compared with 11.4% in
the first half, as a result of the smaller growth in expenses in local currency
at Telesp and TdP, which offset the slowing down in the decreasing costs at CTC
and the increase in costs at TASA, in this case due to the continued increase in
activity. Expenses at Telefonica Empresas also made a positive contribution and,
despite rising 8.5% in constant euros due to increased activity, slowed down
their growth rate in comparison with the first six months of the year (up
12,4%). TIWS succeeded in reducing its expenses (by 3.8% in constant euros)
despite the large increase in revenues.
EBITDA at the end of the third quarter stood at 2,291.8 million euros,
representing growth of 1.8%, which rises to 7.2% in constant euros (7.8% to
June), achieving an EBITDA margin of 45.4% in the first nine months of the year,
compared to 44.7% in the first half, mostly due to the general improvement in
the margin on fixed telephony operators. The decrease in depreciation and
amortization expense (-1.9% in constant euros), as a result of the drop in the
rhythm of investment over recent years, made it possible to achieve an operating
profit of 1,040.9 million euros, representing an improvement of 20.7% in
constant euros.
In the first nine months of the year, Telefonica Latinoamerica recorded
extraordinary net income of 418.4 million euros, compared with the negative 84.8
million euros of the same period of the previous year. The July sale of
Telefonica Movil Chile (until then a 100% subsidiary of CTC) to Telefonica
Moviles had a determining impact, contributing to extraordinary net income with
425.5 million euros. The financial results stood at -240.1 million euros,
compared with the previous years -71.8 million euros. Excluding the impact of
the exchange rate differences, which in 2003 had a great positive impact due to
exchange rate gains recorded by Argentine companies (around 140 million euros)
and the profit recorded in 2003 as a result of the cancellation of the debt
denominated in dollars (around 250 million euros), Telefonica Latinoamerica net
financial results were down 42.6% as a result of the lower interest expenses
connected with the lower volume of debt and lower interest rates.
These results, together with a tax provision of 195.0 million euros, allowed
Telefonica Latinoamerica to record a net income of 645.6 million euros, with a
year-on-year increase of 89.7%.
CapEx at Telefonica Latinoamerica amounted to 427.6 million euros, which was
4.8% more than in 2003 (+8.1% in constant euros). The containment of investments
and the growth in EBITDA led to an operating free cash flow (EBITDA-CapEx)
generated at Telefonica Latinoamerica in the first nine months of the year
amounting to 1,864.2 million euros, with year on year growth of 1.1% (+7.0% in
constant euros).
Telefonica Latinoamerica's plant of equivalent lines totaled 22.4 million, which
was 3.7% more than in September 2003, thanks to the efforts made in the
broadband business, which are reflected in the strong growth of the plant with
443,025 new clients since the beginning of the year. At September 30, the total
number of Telefonica Latinoamerica broadband connections totaled 1.2 million, an
85.1% growth compared to September 2003. It should be highlighted that the
growth rate of broadband connections continues to accelerate (+78.6% in the
first half of 2004), now representing 5.4% of equivalent lines compared with
3.0% in September 2003.
In turn, traditional business lines totaled 21.2 million, showing a year on year
increase of 1.2% more, since the growth recorded at TdP (+9.4%) and TASA (+3.6%)
and the stabilizing of the Telesp plant (+0.05%) exceeded the losses of lines at
CTC (-3.6%) affected by the disconnections made in 2003 because of bad debt
problems. There was a net gain of 323,005 lines in the first nine months of
2004, with the biggest contribution being made by TASA and TdP, with a net gain
of 147,002 and 132,414 lines, respectively.
Telesp
On July 2nd, Telesp increased tariffs approved by Anatel, leading to a rise in
local telephony basket tariffs by an average of 6.89% and domestic long distance
tariffs by 3.2%, in line with the conditions of the privatization contract,
according to the IGP-DI (wholesale price index). Moreover, under the judgment
handed down by the Higher Court of Justice that ruled in favor of allowing fixed
line telephony operators an additional increase in tariffs in compensation for
the difference between the 2003 tariff increase and the result of applying the
IGP-DI as the reference index, as approved by Anatel, since September 4th Telesp
has raised tariffs by 4.1%, a second increase of 3.9% remaining pending for
November.
At the end of the third quarter, the equivalent lines in service (traditional
business + ADSL) at Telesp amounted to 13.1 million, 2.3% higher than in
September 2003 due to the strong increase recorded in the ADSL plant (+69.0%)
and the stability of traditional lines. Telesp was able to reverse the trend of
traditional plant loss experienced during the first half of the year (net gain
of 138,370 lines in the last quarter compared with the -76,143 in the first six
months of the year) thanks to the launch of new products aimed at clients with
low income (economic and super-economic lines), subscription to which has been
extremely popular over recent months.
Telesp continued to pursue its priority of broadband expansion to give fixed
lines greater value. Telesp totaled 715,600 users at the end of September, a
year-on-year increase of 69.0%, to achieve a record net gain during the quarter
of 110,052 connections, compared with the 87,373 connections of the second
quarter 2004 and the 33,782 of the first. The growth in Telefonica's ISP
(itelefonica) users continued, reaching a total of 1.94 million users and a
market share of around 25%.
Insofar as the long distance market, Telesp launched several commercial
initiatives in the third quarter to increase its market share and to counteract
the negative effects of the decline in the global market on operator revenues.
Thus, its estimated share in the domestic intra-state long-distance market stood
at around 88%, 1 percentage point up on the last quarter. In inter-state long
distance, the company had a 57% estimated market share, which was slightly more
than 3 percentage points more in comparison with June, while the international
long distance estimated market share remained stable at around 47% with regard
to June.
Telesp obtained operating revenues of 2,734.3 million euros, an increase of
16.0% compared to the same period in 2003 in local currency, thanks to the
increase in tariffs, the good performance of new businesses (SMP, long distance
outside Sao Paulo, etc.), the notable progress of value-added services and the
increase in fixed-to-mobile traffic and public telephones traffic, leading to a
14.8% growth in traditional business revenues in local currency. In addition to
this, there was a notable increase in broadband revenues (+69.0% in local
currency) due to the growth in the customer base, leading to an 37.0% increase
in Internet revenues (broadband + narrowband) in local currency to contribute
6.3% of the operator's total operating revenues.
Although operating expenses were 20.0% higher in local currency than in the same
period 2003, the rate of increase had slowed progressively (-4.5 percentage
points lower than June). This increase was the result of the higher
interconnection expenses (+28.5% in local currency) associated with the
increased fixed-to-mobile, SMP and long distance traffic revenues. Personnel
expenses were 7.3% lower in local currency as a result of the reduction in the
average workforce due to the lay-offs that took place in 2003 and in the second
quarter of 2004. Subcontracting expenses rose by 19.7% due to the increased
commercial activity, higher co-billing expenses and the indexing of certain
contracts.
Bad debt provision as a percentage of revenues continued to drop in September to
3.2% (0.8 percentage points down on the previous year), mostly due to new
products that are more closely adapted to the different client profiles.
Telesp's EBITDA stood at 1,237.7 million euros, which represented a year-on-year
increase of 7.7% in local currency. Although the EBIDTA margin as a percentage
of revenues was down 3.5 percentage points in comparison with the previous year
due to the higher proportion of revenues accounted for by businesses with
associated interconnection (fixed-to-mobile, long distance outside Sao Paulo,
SMP), it continued to recover and was 1.0 percentage point up on June to total
45.3% for the first nine months (47.2% in the third quarter).
CapEx dropped by 7.5% in local currency with regard to the previous year to
stand at 221.0 million euros, due to the execution of projects depending on
their profitability and the strategic nature of the investment. Accordingly, the
operating free cash flow (EBITDA - CapEx) generated amounted to 1,016.7 million
euros, an increase of 11.5% year on year in local currency.
Telesp had 7,008 employees as of September end, a year-on-year decrease of 14.8%
due to the lay-off schemes implemented in 2003 and second quarter of 2004.
Telefonica de Argentina
The relative stability of the macroeconomic situation continued in Argentina
during the third quarter. Particularly of note is the stability of the peso
against the dollar, with a slight 1.7% depreciation in the exchange rate from
December 2003 to September 30, 2004. Furthermore, the Telecommunications sector
continued to grow thanks to the gradually recovery of the fixed line telephony
market, the strong growth of broadband and the sustained increase in the mobile
market. Along these lines, the management of Telefonica de Argentina remained in
keeping with the recovery of the market, which caused that plant and traffic
operating indicators performed positively.
The plant of traditional lines recorded growth of 3.6% with respect to 2003,
accelerating the growth rate recorded during the first half of the year (+2.2%)
to stand at 4.3 million lines, thanks to the good performance in demand (46.6%
year-on-year increase in gross additions). The net gain recorded during the
first nine months of the year amounted to 147,002 lines (compared with the loss
of 15,500 in the same period of 2003), of which an increasing proportion were
prepaid and consumption control (28.0% of the total plant, 1.5 percentage points
up on September 2003). The good performance in total traffic per line continued,
which was 8.5% higher than in 2003, driven mainly by the increase in prepaid
traffic, both in cards and prepaid lines. There was also a substantial increase
in the ADSL plant (up by 167.9%), which stood at 149,728 lines with a net gain
of 41,517 lines in the quarter, compared with 23,464 lines in the second quarter
and 15,410 from January through March. This growth has enabled the company to
increase its estimated broadband market share in the Southern area by 13.3
percentage points since September 2003 (to 78.8%). The ratio of lines to
employee stood at 554 lines, representing an increase of 4.8% over September
2003.
Thanks to the good performance of the operating variables with respect to 2003,
TASA operating revenues recorded a year-on-year increase of 9.4% in local
currency, compared with the 7.9% of the first half, to reach 602.4 million
euros, despite the tariff freeze in place since January 2002. When comparing the
figures for 2004 with those of the previous year, is important to remember that
it was in the second quarter of 2003 that the impact of agreements with
operators for mutual invoicing applying CER (inflation indexing of wholesale
offerings) was recorded for the whole of 2002. Excluding this effect, TASA's
revenues rose by 12.0% in local currency. Broken down by business, revenues from
traditional services (accounting for 92.9% of the total) rose 7.5% in local
currency due to the growth in traffic and plant, while revenues from the
Internet (Narrowband + Broadband) business rose 42.2% thanks to expansion of the
ADSL plant.
The strong growth rate of revenues is coupled with an 8.6% increase in operating
expenses in local currency, despite the fact that TASA continued to apply a
strict policy for cost rationalization and control, adopted as a result of the
crisis in 2002. Of particular note over the year was the effective management of
bad debts, which has made it possible to maximize debt recovery and place bad
debt provision as a percentage of revenues at around 1%.
Cost control, together with the increased sales, enabled TASA to achieve EBITDA
of 361.6 million euros over the year, an increase in local currency of 10.0%
over the same period of 2003. Comparison of EBITDA in uniform terms (excluding
the impact on 2003 revenues of CER invoicing related to 2002) gives a
year-on-year growth rate of 13.3%. The EBITDA margin was 0.4 percentage points
higher than in the same period of 2003, at 60.0%.
The good performance of EBITDA enabled the company to achieve an operating free
cash flow (EBITDA-CapEx) of 291.0 million euros, 6.7% less in local currency
than in 2003, due to the sharp increase in investment, in line with the recovery
of demand. This investment focused primarily on massive ADSL rollout, which
accounted for 40.2% of CapEx. The CapEx to revenues ratio stood at 12.1% in
local currency.
Telefonica CTC Chile
On September 21st, the Chilean General Controller published a review of the
2004-2009 Tariff Decree in which most of the suggestions made by CTC were
accepted. This review has meant an increase in tariffs with regard to the
version of the Decree published in May this year. Although the final version is
yet to be approved and these conditions to be applied to the market, since early
May CTC's accounts have included the impact of the initial Decree and in
September the effects of the new version of the Decree were recorded, the effect
of which were also retroactive to May.
The traditional plant improved with regard to the previous quarter, recording a
slight net gain of 733 lines compared with the loss of 22,183 lines in the
second quarter. This improvement was mostly due to July's launch of new
services: the minute plans (which in September totaled 116,000 clients) and the
Controlled Line (low consumption line). The traditional line plant totaled
2,398,137 lines at the end of September.
In terms of the Broadband business, it must be highlighted that CTC launched the
2V (double broadband speed without increase in prices for customers) in
September. CTC users totaled 180,487 at September end, a year-on-year increase
of 67.8%.
Although the domestic long distance market continued to decline (down 8.5% year
on year), as observed in previous quarters, CTC succeeded in increasing its
market share by 4.6 percentage points over September 2003, giving it a market
share of 44.8%. CTC also improved its share of the international long distance
market, which recorded a growth of 1.5% with regard to September 2003, by 1.6
percentage points to 30.6%.
Operating revenues for the first nine months of the year amounted to 648.2
million euros, which were 6.8% lower in local currency than for the same period
of 2003, in line with the improvement seen in the previous quarter (excluding
the effect of the CPP tariff reduction in force since the beginning of the year,
the variation would be only -2.6%). This progress compares favorably with the
9.4% decline in local currency of the first half of the year, thanks to the
better performance of traditional business revenues, down 8.8% in local currency
(-11.4% in the first half), favored by plant stability in the third quarter, the
good acceptance of the minute plans and by the new tariff situation following
the last review. Furthermore, Internet (Narrowband + Broadband) revenues
maintained their high growth rate (up 46.8% in local currency), accounting for
5.6% of CTC operating revenues.
Operating expenses remained at levels below those of 2003, 10.4% down in local
currency at September. The general cost containment policy is reflected in all
items, except those related to commercial management, one of the priorities of
the company. The lower fixed-to-mobile traffic tariffs also favored this result,
as the volume of interconnection costs declined (-26.2% in local currency). The
ratio of bad debts to revenues was down from 3.8% in the same period of 2003 to
3.7%. EBITDA stood at 296.2 million euros at the end of the third quarter, which
was 1.8% less in local currency than in 2003, a 4.7 percentage point improvement
with regard to the fall in EBITDA during the first half, mainly due to the
improvement in revenues evolution.
The investments made up to the end of September placed CapEx at 53.5 million
euros, which was 2.6% less in local currency than in the same period of 2003.
This, and the improved performance of EBITDA during this last quarter, meant
that the operating free cash flow (EBITDA-CapEx) generated was almost the same
as in 2003, only 1.7% less in local currency than that of the previous year,
compared with the 10.0% fall in the first half of the year.
Telefonica del Peru
On September 1st, Telefonica del Peru started to apply the new productivity
factor for the price cap system (CPI-x) that regulates the local and long
distance telephony tariffs of the company. This new factor, set at 10.07% for
baskets C (installation fee) and D (monthly fee and local calls), and 7.8% for
long distance tariffs, came into force for a period of 3 years.
Telefonica del Peru continued to accelerate its growth in the plant of
equivalent lines (up 14.1% year-on-year, 0.7 percentage points higher than in
the previous quarter), thanks to the 9.4% growth in traditional lines (largely
as a result of the marketing of new tariff plans since March 2003), as well as
the growth in broadband connections (up by 144.7%) which, with a net gain of
76,201 connections in the first nine months of 2004 (up 125.4% year on year),
totaled 166,890 lines.
Operating revenues totaled 771.8 million euros, representing year-on-year growth
of 0.2% in local currency thanks to the 60.8% increase in Internet revenues
(narrowband + broadband), which accounted for 6.7% of operating revenues and
made up for the 2.5% fall in revenues from the Traditional Business. Traditional
Services were affected (i) by the impact of migrations to new plans,
representing 68.4% of the traditional plant (7.6 percentage points higher than
the previous quarter), (ii) by the application of new Conditions for Use since
May leading to users being refunded the amounts corresponding to monthly fees
for periods of line disconnection and revenues from the payment of packages and
that of associated value added services (i.e. memobox - voicemail) and (iii) by
the entering into force of the new productivity factor for the price cap system
as of September 1st.
The Long Distance business continued to be affected by competition from prepaid
cards. At the end of September, the company's shares of the domestic and
international markets stood at 70.1% and 57.2%, respectively, which represented
slight reductions with regard to the previous quarter (down 2.1 percentage
points and 0.3 percentage points, respectively), due to the enforcement imposed
by OSIPTEL since July to publish detailed information on TdP clients for
knowledge of the competition.
The cost containment policy implemented by TdP, together with the lower
interconnection expenses (-5.5%) due to the decrease in traffic terminating on
mobile networks, resulted in a slight increase of only 0.1% in operating
expenses, despite the higher level of activity and the 4.5% increase in
personnel expenses due to the increase in the average workforce. As in previous
quarters, TdP recorded an improvement in the level of bad debts as a result of
the prepaid plant, the bad debt to revenues ratio standing at 2.6% in comparison
with the 3.2% of the same period in 2003.
The company's EBITDA remained stable in local currency in relation to September
2003 at 339.7 million euros.
CapEx also remained stable in local currency in comparison with the same period
of last year and, therefore, the control of investments (46.4 million euros)
made it possible to achieve an operating free cash flow (EBITDA-CapEx) of 293.3
million euros, in line with the third quarter of 2003.
At September 30th, the company had a workforce of 3,198 employees, which was
1.9% lower year on year (including the workforce at subsidiaries, the total
number of employees was 5,084, up by 5.0%). As a result, the productivity ratio
stood at 709 lines per employee, up by 16.4% year on year.
TELEFONICA EMPRESAS AMERICA
Operating revenues amounted to 332.3 million euros, representing year-on-year
growth of 13.8% in constant terms. Noteworthy was the growth and the
contribution to Value Added Services recorded by Solutions revenues, with a
45.5% growth in constant terms to represent 13.2% of total revenues, and Hosting
/ASP, which recorded a 55.1% growth in constant currency. Continuing with the
policy for the optimization of resource management, EBITDA recorded growth of
92.2% (+98.9% in constant terms) and totaled 37.9 million euros, thereby
achieving an EBITDA margin of 11.4% (up by 5.0 percentage points in comparison
with the same period of 2003). All of this, together with the a growth-oriented
CapEx policy (particularly in Brazil, Chile and Argentina), enabled Telefonica
Empresas America to record an operating free cash flow (EBITDA - CapEx) of +13.0
million euros at September end, compared with the negative figure reached at the
end of September 2003.
Telefonica Empresas Brazil continued to account for more than a third of
operating revenues at Telefonica Empresas America with a growth of 14.9% in
local currency year on year. EBITDA rose by 58.3% in local currency year on
year, maintaining the 5 percentage point improvement in the EBITDA margin
recorded in the first half of the year.
Argentina, Chile and Peru, whose joint EBITDA amounted to 31.1 million euros,
continued to generate positive operating free cash flow (EBITDA-CapEx) totaling
21.7 million euros. Of particular note is the performance of Chile, which
achieved growth in local currency of 11.6% in revenues and 26.2% in EBITDA.
With regard to the other countries, it must be noted that Colombia recorded a
positive EBITDA of 1.9 million euros and generated positive operating free cash
flow. Mexico and the United States, which together contributed around 13% of
Telefonica Empresas America sales, showed substantial growth in operating
revenues in local currency at the end of September (+102.7% and +15.2%,
respectively). Both operations continued to achieve improvements in the EBITDA
margin with regard to 2003 (+18.9 percentage points and +6.1 percentage points,
respectively), by recording joint EBITDA of -12.0 million euros compared with -
13.6 million euros in the same period of 2003.
TELEFONICA INTERNATIONAL WHOLESALE SERVICES (TIWS)
TIWS continued to focus on increasing profitability. In the first nine months of
2004, the company recorded growth of 17.2% in its operating revenues, which
totaled 114.2 million euros, continuing with the positive trend of previous
quarters. Sales from the international IP services remained its main contributor
with a growth of 31.5%. Despite the high level of growth in revenues, operating
expenses continued to decrease (down by 10.8% year on year), thanks to the fall
in supplies (down 12.7%) and subcontracts (down by 16.9%). As a result, TIWS
obtained an EBITDA margin of 29.3%, representing a 22.4 percentage point
improvement on the same period of 2003. The improvement in operating free cash
flow (EBITDA-CapEx), which amounted to 22.9 million euros, therefore continued.
TELEFONICA LATINOAMERICA GROUP
SELECTED OPERATING DATA
Unaudited figures (Thousands)
September
2004 2003 % Chg
Telesp
Lines (1) 13,074.8 12,776.9 2.3
PSTN Lines 11,282.3 11,191.9 0.8
ISDN equivalent accesses 27.7 31.4 (11.8)
2/6 Accesses for PBX and Ibercom 1,049.2 1,130.0 (7.2)
ADSL connections 715.6 423.5 69.0
Employees (units) (2) 7,008 8,229 (14.8)
Traffic (millions of minutes) (3) 61,357.6 63,612.0 (3.5)
Telefonica de Argentina
Lines (1) * 4,465.6 4,222.6 5.8
PSTN Lines 4,234.5 4,086.5 3.6
ISDN equivalent accesses 6.2 6.3 (2.2)
2/6 Accesses for PBX and Ibercom 75.2 74.0 1.7
ADSL connections 149.7 55.9 167.9
Employees (units) (2) 8,061 7,990 0.9
Traffic (millions of minutes) (3) 29,435.6 26,548.2 10.9
Telefonica CTC Chile
Lines (1) * 2,578.6 2,594.5 (0.6)
PSTN Lines 2,247.2 2,336.4 (3.8)
ISDN equivalent accesses 96.1 93.3 2.9
2/6 Accesses for PBX and Ibercom 54.8 57.2 (4.1)
ADSL connections 180.5 107.6 67.8
Employees (units) (2) 3,213 3,236 (0.7)
Traffic (millions of minutes) (3) 16,856.3 18,202.0 (7.4)
Telefonica del Peru
Lines (1) 2,268.7 1,989.0 14.1
PSTN Lines 2,068.3 1,886.0 9.7
ISDN equivalent accesses 33.5 34.8 (4.0)
2/6 Accesses for PBX and Ibercom 0.0 0.0 n.d
ADSL connections 166.9 68.2 144.7
Employees (units) (2) 5,084 4,843 5.0
Traffic (millions of minutes) (3) 9,777.1 9,878.1 (1.0)
TELEFONICA LATINOAMERICA GROUP
Lines (1) 22,387.6 21,583.0 3.7
PSTN Lines 19,832.3 19,500.7 1.7
ISDN equivalent accesses 163.4 165.9 (1.5)
2/6 Accesses for PBX and Ibercom 1,179.2 1,261.2 (6.5)
ADSL connections 1,212.7 655.2 85.1
Employees (units) (4) 23,366 24,298 (3.8)
Traffic (millions of minutes) (3) 117,426.6 118,240.2 (0.7)
* In 2003, number of lines is affected by internal reclassification in line with 2003 criteria, homogeneous within the
operators.
(1) PSTN (including Public Use Telephony) (x 1) - ISDN Basic access (x 2) - ISDN Primary access (x 30) - 2/6 Accesses
(x 30) - ADSL Lines (x1) and Cablemoden (in Peru).
(2) Calculated with the wireline company staff of the fixed telephone operator (OTF) and the subsidiaries that are
consolidated by the full integration method.
(3) Including total invoiced incoming and outgoing traffic: Local, PUTs, DLD and ILD. January-September accumulated
data.
(4) Calculated with the wireline company staff of the fixed telephone operator (OTF) and the subsidiaries that are
consolidated by the full integration method. Does not included the employees of Telefonica Empresas America and those
of TIWS. As of 30/09/04 day were 2,402 and 249 respectively.
TELEFONICA LATINOAMERICA GROUP
SELECTED FINANCIAL DATA
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
January - September
2004 2003 % Chg
Telesp
Operating revenues (1) 2,734.3 2,482.9 10.1
EBITDA 1,237.7 1,210.0 2.3
EBITDA margin 45.3% 48.7% (3.5 p.p.)
Telefonica de Argentina
Operating revenues 602.4 601.9 0.1
EBITDA 361.6 359.1 0.7
EBITDA margin (2) 60.0% 59.7% 0.4 p.p.
Telefonica CTC Chile
Operating revenues 648.2 706.0 (8.2)
EBITDA 296.2 306.2 (3.3)
EBITDA margin 45.7% 43.4% 2.3 p.p.
Telefonica del Peru
Operating revenues 771.8 815.6 (5.4)
EBITDA 339.7 359.4 (5.5)
EBITDA margin 44.0% 44.1% (0.1 p.p.)
Telefonica Empresas America
Operating revenues 332.3 309.9 7.2
EBITDA 37.9 19.7 92.2
EBITDA margin 11.4% 6.4% 5.0 p.p.
TIWS
Operating revenues 114.2 97.5 17.2
EBITDA 33.5 6.6 406.4
EBITDA margin 29.3% 6.8% 22.5 p.p.
Note: EBITDA before management fees. Data for Telefonica de Argentina include the ISP business of Advance, while those
of Telefonica del Peru includes CableMagico.
(1) Net of international accounting payments, homogeneous within Latin America operators. Criteria applied
retroactively in 2003.
(2) Net of fixed to mobile interconnection.
TELEFONICA LATINOAMERICA GROUP
CONSOLIDATED INCOME STATEMENT
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
January - September July - September
2004 2003 % Chg 2004 2003 % Chg
Operating revenues 5,046.0 4,921.5 2.5 1,769.9 1,788.7 (1.1)
Internal expend capitalized in fixed assets (1) 30.3 34.5 (12.2) 11.0 12.3 (10.4)
Operating expenses (2,665.9) (2,583.8) 3.2 (917.1) (932.8) (1.7)
Other net operating income (expense) (118.7) (119.8) (1.0) (36.0) (39.6) (9.0)
EBITDA 2,291.8 2,252.4 1.8 827.8 828.6 (0.1)
Depreciation and amortization (1,250.9) (1,338.7) (6.6) (426.3) (461.4) (7.6)
Operating profit 1,040.9 913.7 13.9 401.5 367.2 9.3
Profit from associated companies (0.6) 1.0 c.s. 0.1 (1.3) c.s.
Financial net income (expense) (240.1) (71.8) 234.2 (83.0) (200.9) (58.7)
Amortization of goodwill (65.0) (68.8) (5.5) (21.7) (22.3) (2.4)
Extraordinary net income (expense) 418.4 (84.8) c.s. 408.0 (37.9) c.s.
Income before taxes 1,153.5 689.3 67.4 704.9 104.9 n.s.
Income taxes (195.0) (275.0) (29.1) (135.5) (27.5) n.s.
Net income before minority interests 958.5 414.3 131.4 569.4 77.3 n.s.
Minority interests (312.9) (74.0) 322.7 (246.3) (25.3) n.s.
Net income 645.6 340.3 89.7 323.1 52.1 n.s.
Note: Starting first quarter 2004, Telefonica Data in Latin America and TIWS results will be incorporated in
Telefonica Latinoamerica Group. 2003 figures are proforma for the benefit of comparison.
(1) Including work in process.
TELEFONICA LATINOAMERICA GROUP
CONSOLIDATED INCOME STATEMENT - PROFORMA 2003
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
2003
Jan - Mar Jan - Jun Jan - Sep Jan - Dec
Operating revenues 1,498.2 3,132.7 4,921.5 6,744.9
Internal expend capitalized in fixed assets (1) 10.3 22.2 34.5 47.4
Operating expenses (785.4) (1,650.9) (2,583.8) (3,548.5)
Other net operating income (expense) (39.7) (80.3) (119.8) (142.5)
EBITDA 683.4 1,423.8 2,252.4 3,101.3
Depreciation and amortization (428.4) (877.3) (1,338.7) (1,805.7)
Operating profit 255.1 546.5 913.7 1,295.6
Profit from associated companies 6.3 2.3 1.0 2.5
Financial net income (expense) (13.5) 129.1 (71.8) (228.6)
Amortization of goodwill (23.4) (46.6) (68.8) (91.1)
Extraordinary net income (expense) (41.5) (47.0) (84.8) (128.1)
Income before taxes 182.9 584.4 689.3 850.3
Income taxes (92.5) (247.4) (275.0) (169.7)
Net income before minority interests 90.3 337.0 414.3 680.7
Minority interests (26.1) (48.8) (74.0) (122.1)
Net income 64.3 288.2 340.3 558.5
(1) Including work in process.
RESULTS BY BUSINESS LINES
Mobile Business
During the third quarter of 2004 the Group's operators made a strong commercial
effort in their markets, in a context of sustained and even intensified
competitive pressure from the other players compared with the previous quarter.
The high level of commercial activity has translated into managed net adds of
almost 3 million customers in the third quarter of 2004, an increase of 74% vs.
the third quarter of 2003 and 9.2% vs. the second quarter of 20041. We would
point out the strong increase in net adds in the contract segment, which grew
47% in the third quarter of 2004 vs. the second quarter of 2004, and especially
in Latin America (where they tripled from the second quarter of 2004).
The Group has increased its managed customer base by close to 7 million since
the start of the year to 58.8 million customers at the end of September (+23%
vs. the same period of last year). Of this total, 37.5 million correspond to the
Latin American operators and 18.7 million to Telefonica Moviles Espana.
Including the customers from BellSouth's Latin American operators2, whose
acquisition was agreed in March, Telefonica Moviles would have over 71.9 million
managed customers, 50.6 million of which correspond to Latin America.
----------------------------------------
1 The second quarter of 2004 figures exclude the impact of the 1.3 million
inactive prepaid SIM cards adjusted in Telefonica Moviles Espana's reported
customer base as of April 2004.
2 Including 13.1 million subscribers from BellSouth's Latin American operators
at the end of August 2004, last month of the third fiscal quarter of 2004 for
BellSouth.
----------------------------------------
Key aspects of the results as of September 04 are as follows:
• Year-on-year growth of 12.8% in operating revenues to 8,236.4 million
euros. The incorporation of Telefonica Movil Chile into the Group's
consolidation perimeter contributed 0.9 p.p. to revenue growth, while
exchange rate fluctuations led to a 2.4 p.p. decline in the growth of
operating revenues as of September 2004.
By components, service revenues totalled 7,282 million euros as of September
04, a year-on-year increase of 10.5% and of 10.2% in the third quarter of
2004 vs. third quarter of 2003, with improved growth rates in the third
quarter of 2004 vs. second quarter of 2004. Handset sales (954 million euros
as of September 2004) registered year-on-year growth of 34%.
By companies, Telefonica Moviles Espana obtained operating revenues of
6,042.9 million euros as of September 2004 (+10.5% vs. the same period of
2003).
Consolidated Latin American operators contributed 2,195 million euros of
operating revenues in the first nine months of 2004, with growth in euro
terms of 20.0%. Excluding the impact of Telefonica Movil Chile's
incorporation into the Group's consolidation perimeter and of exchange rates
fluctuations, these revenues would have shown growth of 26.1% vs. the first
nine months of 2003.
• Greater commercial activity and increased competitive pressure impacted
consolidated EBITDA, which grew 4.7% vs. the first nine months of 2003 to
3,527.6 million euros. The incorporation of Telefonica Movil Chile into the
Group's consolidation perimeter contributed 0.5 p.p. to cumulative EBITDA
growth, while exchange rate fluctuations led to a 0.3 p.p. declines in the
growth of EBITDA as of September 04.
The EBITDA margin was 42.8% as of September 2004, virtually unchanged
compared with the first half of 2004, despite the increase in commercial
activity and greater commercial efforts in most markets, which translated
into an increase in per unit commercial costs in the main markets.
In Spain, Telefonica Moviles Espana's EBITDA reached 3,195.6 million euros
as of September 2004 (+7.7% vs. the first nine months of 2003), leaving an
EBITDA margin of 52.9%.
EBITDA for the Group's consolidated Latin American subsidiaries, in euros,
fell by 16.6% vs. the first nine months of 2003, affected by the commercial
efforts made to lead growth in the markets in which the Group is present.
Nonetheless, we would highlight a slight containment of the erosion in
EBITDA margins vs. previous quarters, despite the increased commercial
activity, especially in Mexico.
Assuming constant exchange rates and excluding Telefonica Movil Chile's
contribution to the consolidated results, these companies' EBITDA would have
declined 17.5% vs. the first nine months of 2003.
• The consolidated CapEx as of September 2004 amounted to 1,029 million
euros, a 59% year-on-year increase, due to higher investments in the main
markets (the rollout of Telefonica Moviles Espana's UMTS network and GSM
networks in Argentina and Mexico, as well as the increase in capacity in
Brazil) and the impact of the incorporation of Telefonica Movil Chile. CapEx
committed at the end of September was 1,437 million euros.
Regarding the evolution of the Mobile Business of Telefonica Group (including
Telefonica Movil Chile since January 1st, 2004), the operating revenues totalled
8,447.1 million euros as of September 2004, a year-on-year increase of 12%
compared to the same period of last year. On the other hand, EBITDA reached
3,577.8 million euros, a year-on-year increase of 3.7%.
OUTLOOK FOR 2004 IN THE CURRENT OPERATING ENVIRONMENT
In the increasingly mature Spanish market, there have been since the beginning
of the year significant changes in the competitive environment, with strong
commercial pressure from competitors, both in number portability and in prices.
This has prompted the Company to increase customer loyalty actions and traffic
promotions and has led to strong pressure on prices in the corporate segment.
On the other hand, the commercial performance observed during the first nine
months of the year and at the start of the fourth quarter shows a strong
dynamism in the major Latin American markets. This is driven by increased
competition - derived from more aggressive commercial policies by existing
operators and the entry, in some countries or regions, of new players - and by
the macroeconomic stability in the region, which has translated into significant
year-on-year growth in the total number of wireless users. This growth, which in
most cases has surpassed the most optimistic forecasts, has prompted an upward
revision of the growth potential of these markets, both by the Company and by
third parties (regulators, investments banks, etc).
In this context, Telefonica Moviles' priority remains to preserve its leadership
position in Spain, encompassed with a best in class operating efficiency, which
will allow it to continue being a reference in Europe. At the same time, the
Company will seek to capture the strong growth opportunities in the different
Latin American markets.
All this translates into greater commercial efforts, both in customer
acquisition and retention initiatives, with an impact on both commercial
expenses and operating revenues (greater traffic promotions and loyalty points,
accounted as for lower revenues). This has led the Company to review its outlook
for full-year 2004.
REVENUES
The Company estimates that growth in consolidated operating revenues in 2004
will be around 12%-13%3.
In Spain, considering the factors already mentioned, along with lower growth in
the active customer base, the higher number of gross adds without handsets and
the impact of the 12% reduction in mobile termination rates recently approved by
the regulator - to take effect from 1 November- growth rate in both operating
and service revenues is expected to exceed 8% in 2004.
EBITDA
The Company estimates the year-on-year growth of consolidated EBITDA in 2004
will be around 3%3.
In Spain, in spite of greater commercial costs over 2003, Telefonica Moviles
Espana reiterates its target of maintaining an EBITDA margin of over 50% for
full-year 2004, which will allow it to continue being a reference in Europe.
In Brazil, the stronger growth of the total market and the increasing
aggressiveness of competitors, compared to the Company's initial expectations,
have prompted Vivo to increase its commercial objectives for 2004. In this
scenario, the Company expects to reach an EBITDA margin for full-year 2004,
after management fees, of 30%-35%. In spite of the downward revision of margins
for the short term, the Company reiterates its goal of achieving EBITDA margins
of above 40% in the medium term, once the pace of market growth starts to ease
from maximum levels.
In Argentina, higher economic growth and the launch of the GSM network are
allowing a significant expansion of the customer base. This leads the Company to
expect strong commercial activity in the coming months, which logically should
have a significant impact on margins for the full year. Therefore, the Company
does not expect any significant contribution from its operations in Argentina to
Group EBITDA in 2004.
CAPEX
The Group estimates consolidated CapEx4 of just over 1,500 million euros for
full-year 2004, vs. its initial forecast of 1,600 million euros.
Of the total, about 650 million euros will correspond to Telefonica Moviles
Espana. In Mexico, the Company expects to invest slightly above 400 million
euros in 2004 to continue expanding its GSM network across the country. In
Brazil, CapEx corresponding to 50% of Vivo will stand at about 250 million
euros, driven by the strong growth in the customer base. In Argentina, CapEx
forecast by TCP Unifon for 2004 stands at 130 million euros and will be used to
roll out the new GSM network.
----------------------------------------
3 Assuming constant exchange rates and excluding changes in the consolidation
perimeter with respect to December 2003. Excludes the impact of consolidation of
Telefonica Movil Chile from 1 August 2004 and the assets acquired from BellSouth
in Latin America in the fourth quarter of the year.
4 Excludes the impact of consolidation of Telefonica Movil Chile from 1 August
2004 and the assets acquired from BellSouth in Latin America in the fourth
quarter of the year.
----------------------------------------
BUSINESS PREFORMANCE BY GEOGRAPHIC REGION
SPAIN
Market conditions during the third quarter of 2004 were the same as those
observed in the first half of the year, with growing commercial pressure from
competitors, mainly focused on number portability actions and on more aggressive
pricing in the corporate segment.
In the current market environment, Telefonica Moviles Espana's commercial
strategy has continued to focus primarily on high-value segments and certain
niches with strong growth potential, for which several new commercial
initiatives have been launched during the quarter.
Telefonica Moviles Espana ended September with a total customer base of 18.7
million, after reaching 58,000 net adds in the third quarter of 2004. This
figure was driven by nearly 270.000 net adds in the contract segment
(residential and corporate), which was partly offset by the loss of customers in
the prepaid segment partly explained by number portability actions. The weight
of the contract segment over the total customer base now stands at 47.5%, 8.2
p.p. higher than at the end of September 2003. Such performance is boosted by
ongoing prepaid to contract migrations, with levels over 200,000 migrations per
quarter and approximately 780,000 as of September, similar to the figure
registered in the first nine months of 2003.
Meanwhile, in line with the Company's customer loyalty strategy, handset
upgrades reached close to 2.7 million in the first nine months of the year,
which reflects the healthy handset upgrade pace achieved through ongoing
initiatives.
Taking into account all its commercial initiatives (gross additions, migrations
and handset upgrades), commercial activity as of September 2004 grew 7% vs. the
same period of 2003.
In recent months the Company has launched several initiatives aimed at
increasing traffic on Telefonica Moviles Espana's networks, among which we would
highlight the specific summer promotion 'Mis Favoritos' (where a 3 euros
subscription fee entitled any Telefonica Moviles Espana customer to choose two
telephone numbers with whom to speak and send SMS and MMS for just 0.01 euros/
min.). The Company has also launched the 'Numero Internacional Activa'
initiative to meet the communication needs of the growing number of foreign
residents in Spain. Finally, the 'Sub-26' rate was launched, offering very
attractive terms for customers under the age of 26.
Thanks to these initiatives and the overall increase in customer usage, traffic
carried on Telefonica Moviles Espana's networks increased by 12% in the third
quarter of 2004 vs. third quarter of 2003 and 5% over the second quarter of
2004, with an accumulated increase of 14% in the first nine months of 2004.
MOU as of September 2004 was 128 minutes (138 in the third quarter of 2004).
Regarding data services, customer usage continues to increase: more than 2.8
million customers used web browsing with GPRS technology in September, more than
800,000 customers carried multimedia messages (MMS) and half a million used its
i-mode service.
Also of note is the Ring-Back Tones service, launched during the second quarter
as a pioneer service in Spain, under the commercial name 'Ya Voy', which at the
end of September already had close to 700,000 users, who pay a monthly fee to
maintain the service.
New data and content services launched recently include a new Single European
Data Tariff for Internet, Intranet and WAP traffic via GPRS within the SET
(Single European Tariff) zone, which comprises most western European countries,
and also allows for a single voice tariff for Telefonica Moviles Espana
customers using Roaming services.
It is also worth highlighting the launch of other new services in Spain, such as
'SMS Sorpresa' and multimedia soccer services (videos and photos of goals, live
scores from the Spanish league, etc.). Telefonica Moviles Espana has also
launched pioneering telesurveillance and remote control services allowing users
to watch on their handset online images captured with a webcam. Also worth
noting is the collaboration between Telefonica Moviles Espana and ONCE, the
Spanish National Organization for the Blind, to launch a lottery service based
on GPRS handsets, a service already available nationwide with more than 6,000
GPRS mobile handsets managed through Telefonica Moviles Espana's network.
All these factors have led to a healthy growth in data revenues to 721 million
euros in the first nine months of 2004 (+15% vs. the figure as of September
2003). Data ARPU totaled 4.2 euros as of September 2004.
ARPU performed positively, reaching 32.4 euros as of September 2004 and 35.0
euros in the third quarter of 2004.
Highlights of Telefonica Moviles Espana's financial results in the period are as
follows:
• Operating revenues rose 7.1% year-on-year in the third quarter of 2004 to
2,139 million euros, with a 10.5% increase in the first nine months of 2004
vs. the first nine months of 2003.
By components, service revenues (1,953 million euros in the third quarter of
2004) showed a slight improvement in its year-on-year growth rate, with a
8.0% increase vs. the third quarter of 2003 (+7.1% in the second quarter of
2004 vs. the second quarter of 2003). Total service revenues as of September
2004 stood at 5,433 million euros, 9.3% higher than in the same period of
2003.
Handset sale revenues stood at 186 million euros in the third quarter of
2004, slightly below the third quarter of 2003, but were up 23% year-on-year
at the end of September 2004.
• Due to the stronger commercial activity in the market and the Telefonica
Moviles Espana's greater focus on subscriber acquisition and retention
initiatives, the weight of subscriber acquisition and retention costs over
operating revenues stood at 8.3% in the third quarter of 2004 (+1.5 p.p. vs.
the third quarter of 2003) and 8.2% as of September 2004 (+1.3 p.p. vs. the
figure as of September 2003). This increased effort was primarily driven by
the increasing weight of number portability initiatives, which bear a high
commercial cost, and the efforts made in subscriber acquisition and
retention activities this summer.
• EBITDA in the third quarter of 2004 was 1,137 million euros, an increase
of 4.2% vs. the third quarter of 2003. EBITDA at the end of September was
3,195.6 million euros (+7.7% vs. the first nine months of 2003).
The EBITDA margin was 53.2% in the third quarter of 2004 and 52.9% as of
September 2004 (-1.4 p.p. vs. the figure as of September 2003), despite the
Company's greater commercial activity.
Once again this quarter, we note that since March 1st 2004, the fee for
using the UMTS spectrum has no longer been capitalized, nor have the other
expenses related to this technology. Additionally, UMTS-related expenses
capitalized up to now have started being depreciated, with a 31 million
euros impact on depreciation.
• CapEx as of September 2004 totaled 439 million euros, driven by the
rollout of the UMTS network, which accounted for nearly one third of total
CapEx in the period.
MOROCCO
Medi Telecom ended September with 2.572 million customers, an increase of 37.9%
year-on-year and 20% vs. the second quarter of 2004.
The third quarter of 2004 featured stronger commercial activity as a result of
the launch of new packs and the summer campaigns. Net adds in the quarter
amounted to 424,000 customers, 4 times higher than in the second quarter of 2004
and the third quarter of 2003.
As for financial results, revenues and EBITDA continued to advance, driven by
customer and traffic growth. At the end of September, operating revenues, in
euro terms, grew 23% year-on-year to 248 million euros (100 million euros in the
third quarter of 2004). EBITDA as of September of 2004 was 103 million euros,
51% higher than in the same period of last year (38 million euros in the third
quarter of 2004, once again marking an improvement on the previous quarter).
The third quarter of 2004 EBITDA margin is affected by the high level of
commercial activity in the quarter, standing at 38% (41.5% as of September
2004).
Thanks to this performance and the CapEx containment, operating cash flow
reached 66 million euros at the end of September 2004, double the total for all
of 2003.
LATIN AMERICA
Brazil
In spite of the seasonality of the period following the strong commercial
campaigns for Mothers' Day and Valentine's Day in the second quarter of 2004,
the Brazilian cellular market continued to post strong growth rates for another
quarter.
Wireless penetration rate reached over 33% at the end of September, compared to
30% in June (with 35% penetration in Vivo's areas of operation).
In a context of a rapidly expanding market, with increased commercial efforts by
all operators, Vivo maintains its leadership positioning, ending September 2004
with a total customer base of 24.6 million (+33.4% compared with September 2003
and 5% compared with June 2004). Net adds in the quarter stood at more than 1.1
million customers, driven by the Father's Day campaign in August (although below
the 1.6 million in the second quarter of 2004 due to the aforementioned
seasonality of the third quarter, and compared with 0.95 million in the third
quarter of 2003).
At the end of third quarter of 2004 Vivo's estimated average market share was
42% for Brazil as a whole and 53% in its areas of operation.
As for customer usage, blended MOU in the third quarter of 2004 was 87 minutes,
while blended ARPU was 32 reais.
MOU and ARPU's year-on-year performance was shaped by the sharp growth in the
total customer base -mostly in the prepaid segment- increased traffic promotions
and the impact on incoming traffic of the blocking of fixed-to-mobile calls by
fixed line operators. Prepaid customers accounted for 80% of total customers at
the end of September 2004, vs. 74% in the third quarter of 2003. Comparison with
the second quarter of 2004 is also affected by the higher weight of the prepaid
segment in the customer base.
Regarding Vivo's financial results, accumulated operating revenues as of
September 2004 showed a 21% year-on-year increase in local currency, driven by
higher service revenues and the growth of the customer base. Excluding TCO's
contribution during the first four months of 2004, operating revenues would have
grown 11.5% vs. in the first nine months of 2003 in local currency. The impact
of the competitive environment on the growth of revenues, with a higher volume
of traffic promotions in 2004, must be taken into account, as well as the impact
of the migration to SMP from July 2003.
EBITDA year-on-year growth as of September 2004 stood at 8.7% in local currency.
Excluding TCO's contribution during the first 4 months of 2004, EBITDA would
have decreased 1.6% in local currency, on the back of greater commercial
activity vs. the same period of 2003 and a tougher competitive environment.
As a result, the EBITDA margin after management fees was 31.9% in the third
quarter of 2004 and 34.4% as of September 2004. The almost stable margin in the
third quarter of 2004 vs. the second quarter of 2004, despite lower net adds, is
due to the increase in per unit subscriber acquisition costs deriving from
tougher competition.
Excluding the impact of higher commercial costs, the performance of adjusted5
margin (60.7% as of September 2004 vs. 57.6% as of September 2003) reflects the
improvement in operating efficiency and the economies of scale from the
integration of the different operators under the single Vivo umbrella.
Finally, total CapEx at the end of September 2004 stood at 169 million euros,
driven by investments to boost the capacity of the operators' networks in order
to meet the growth of the customer base and by the further rollout of Vivo's
1XRTT networks.
----------------------------------------
5 EBITDA margin excluding commercial and advertising costs, over service
revenues. For comparison purposes in the first nine months of 2003 includes TCO
from 1 January 2003.
----------------------------------------
Mexico
As a result of Telefonica Moviles Mexico (TMM)'s efforts to extend its
distribution network and improve its efficiency, and to expand the coverage of
its GSM network, the Company continued to make progress in capturing new
customers. In the third quarter of 2004 net adds reached 415,000, a sharp
increase vs. the second quarter of 2004 (+35%) and more than double net adds in
the third quarter of 2003.
TMM's total customer base at the end of September was close to 4.5 million, with
growth accelerating compared with previous quarters (+8% in the second quarter
of 2004 vs. the first quarter of 2004 and +10% in the third quarter of 2004 vs.
the second quarter of 2004).
Note also the positive results in the contract segment, with a clear change in
trend. This is the first quarter with positive net adds (an increase of 20% in
the customer base vs. the second quarter of 2004), driven by the good acceptance
of the new commercial offers for the residential and corporate segments.
As for traffic, MOU in the third quarter of 2004 was 60 minutes (-2.2% vs. the
second quarter of 2004) and ARPU was 172 Mexican pesos (stable from the second
quarter of 2004).
Regarding financial results, we would highlight the positive performance of
operating revenues in local currency in the third quarter of 2004 vs. the second
quarter of 2004 (+5.6%) boosted by the improvement in service revenues, which
were up 8.4% over the second quarter of 2004, driven by the growth of the
customer base.
Despite the more intense commercial activity vs. the second quarter of 2004,
EBITDA losses were 22 million euros in the third quarter of 2004, a 30% decline
vs. the second quarter of 2004 thanks to the Company's cost control policies. As
of September of 2004, TMM posted an EBITDA loss of 101 million euros.
Total CapEx in the first nine months of 2004 was 287 million euros. TMM's GSM
network now reaches 189 cities, a level of population that represents 74% of the
national GDP.
Meanwhile, at the beginning of October TMM sought authorization from the Mexican
telecommunications authorities (COFETEL) to bid for the new PCS frequencies.
Argentina
The Argentine cellular market continued to show rapid growth in the third
quarter of 2004, driven by increased commercial activity from all operators and
the rollout of GSM networks. The estimated penetration rate at the end of the
third quarter of 2004 was 29%, compared with 25% in June 2004 and 19% in the
third quarter of 2003.
In line with the Company's strategy to improve its competitive positioning and
as a result of the increase in the number of points of sale, the marketing
campaigns directed to capturing the growth in the market and the rollout of GSM
in new cities, Unifon recorded net adds of 417,000 customers in the third
quarter of 2004, doubling the figure obtained in the second quarter of 2004 and
five times higher than in the third quarter of 2003.
At the end of September 2004, Unifon's customer base stood at 2.6 million, a
year-on-year increase of 54.3% and 19% more than in the second quarter of 2004.
Growth was driven by GSM customers, which accounted for 17% of the total
customer base at the end of the third quarter of 2004. We would also highlight
the advance in the contract segment, which accounted for more than 36% of
Unifon's customer base at the end of September (31% in the third quarter of
2003).
Continuing with the trend seen in previous quarters, and underpinned by
campaigns aimed at boosting the usage of voice and data services, customer usage
ratios are improving despite the significant growth in the customer base. MOU
increased by 28% vs. the third quarter of 2003, fuelled by growth in both
incoming and outgoing traffic, leading ARPU to increase by 19% vs. the third
quarter of 2003 and 8% vs. the second quarter of 2004 to 45 Argentinean pesos.
In terms of financial results, at the end of September Unifon recorded a 54.3%
year-on-year increase in operating revenues, in pesos, driven by growth in its
customer base, higher traffic and the increase in handset sales.
The higher commercial activity, the increased competitive pressure and those
costs associated with GSM, have led the company post an EBITDA loss in the third
quarter of 2004. EBITDA in local currency in the first nine months of 2004 was
58% lower than in the first nine months of 2003 and EBITDA margin was 8.2% in
the first nine months of 2004 (29.8% in the first nine months of 2003).
As for CapEx, the company has continued the roll out of its GSM network in the
third quarter of 2004, which now reaches a population coverage of 80% of the
national GDP. Total CapEx through September was 71 million euros.
Peru
Telefonica Moviles Peru continued to lead the strong growth of the Peruvian
cellular market in the third quarter of 2004, with net adds of 171,000 customers
(+6% vs. the second quarter of 2004 and 2.7x higher than in the third quarter of
2003.
The strong rate of commercial activity has continued in the quarter, with an
acceleration in the growth of the customer base both in the contract (+15% vs.
the third quarter of 2003) and the prepaid segment (+52% vs. the third quarter
of 2003). Telefonica Moviles Peru ended September 2004 with 1.97 million
customers, with year-on-year growth of 43.8%.
As regards financial results, Telefonica Moviles Peru's operating revenues in
local currency grew 6.5% in the first nine months of 2004 vs. the same period of
last year, driven by the increase in the customer base and growth in outgoing
and on-net traffic. These were partly offset by the lower interconnection
revenues due to the decline in traffic from fixed networks and the reduction of
fixed to mobile tariffs.
It is worth highlighting that despite the more intense commercial activity in
the third quarter of 2004, the EBITDA margin for the quarter stood at 26.7%,
higher than the margin registered in previous quarters thanks to cost control
policies.
As a result of the intense commercial activity, operating expenses increased,
leading to 22.9% decline in EBITDA vs. the cumulative figure as of September
2003 in local currency. EBITDA margin as of September 2004 stood at 26.2% vs.
36.2% as of September 2003.
Chile
The acquisition of 100% of Telefonica Movil Chile, which was already managed by
Telefonica Moviles, was completed on July 23rd.
In a context of a sharp growth in the Chilean market, the Company continued to
lead customer acquisition in the third quarter of 2004, obtaining net adds of
263,000 customers vs. 86,000 in the third quarter of 2003 and 238,000 in the
second quarter of 2004. As a result, the total number of customers stands at 3
million at the end of September. Once again, it is worth highlighting the steady
increase in the GSM customer base, which already accounts for 39% of the total
customer base, with nearly 1.2 million customers.
As regards financial results, the increase in the customer base and in outgoing
traffic drove revenue growth in local currency vs. the first nine months of
2003, more than offsetting lower interconnection revenues due to the reduction
in mobile interconnection tariffs. EBITDA growth was underpinned by the strong
commercial activity compared with the previous year.
As for TM Chile's contribution to Group results in 2004, which includes the
months of August and September, it amounted to 63 million euros in operating
revenues and 15.7 million euros in EBITDA, with an EBITDA margin of 24.8%.
Guatemala and El Salvador
The total customer base managed by Telefonica Moviles' operators in Guatemala
and El Salvador at the end of September 2004 stood at 632,000 (298,000 in
Guatemala and 335,000 in El Salvador), a year-on-year increase of 70.5%.
The acceleration in customer acquisition has continued in both countries in the
third quarter of 2004, with combined net adds of 101,000 customers in the
quarter, (71,000 in the second quarter of 2004 and 12,000 in the third quarter
of 2003) driven by the prepaid segment.
Regarding financial results, at the end of September 2004, total operating
revenues for both companies grew by 19.6% in constant euros as a result of the
larger customer base. The EBITDA margin is impacted by the increased commercial
activity, resulting in a 13.9% reduction in constant euros in the cumulative
EBITDA.
CELLULAR BUSINESS
SELECTED OPERATING DATA: CELLULAR CUSTOMERS
Unaudited figures (Thousands)
September
2004 % Chg 04/03
T Moviles Espana (1) 18,697 n.c.
Contract 8,872 n.c.
Prepaid 9,824 n.c.
Brasilcel 24,645 0.3
Contract 4,989 0.1
Prepaid 19,657 0.4
TCP Argentina 2,606 0.5
Contract 945 0.8
Prepaid 1,661 0.4
T Moviles Peru 1,966 0.4
Contract 339 0.1
Prepaid 1,627 0.5
TEM El Salvador 335 0.4
Contract 76 0.3
Prepaid 258 0.5
TEM Guatemala 298 1.2
Contract 53 0.2
Prepaid 245 1.6
NewCom Wireless Puerto Rico (2) 158 (0.1)
Contract 113 0.1
Prepaid 44 (0.4)
Telefonica Moviles Mexico 4,495 0.6
Contract 260 (0.0)
Prepaid 4,235 0.7
Medi Telecom 2,572 0.4
Contract 127 (0.1)
Prepaid 2,445 0.4
Telefonica Movil Chile (3) 3,002 0.5
Contract 460 0.0
Prepaid 2,542 0.6
Total Managed 58,773 0.2
Note: Telefonica Cellular Business includes Telefonica Movil Chile.
(1) Costumer base net of 1.3 million inactive prepaid SIM cards no longer included in the reported costumer base. For
reporting purposes and regarding all the operating metrics this adjustment has been made from 1 April 2004, in
accordance with the decision adopted by the Company as of June 2004.
(2) Managed by TEM until October.
(3) TM Chile has been incorporated into the consolidation perimeter of Telefonica Moviles Group as of August 2004. In
2003, Telefonica Moviles just managed the company.
CELLULAR BUSINESS
SELECTED FINANCIAL DATA
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
January - September
2004 2003 % Chg
Telefonica Moviles Espana
Operating revenues 6,042.9 5,467.2 10.5
EBITDA 3,195.6 2,966.9 7.7
EBITDA margin 52.9% 54.3% (1.4 p.p.)
Brasilian companies (1)
Operating revenues 1,118.5 973.3 14.9
EBITDA 385.2 373.2 3.2
EBITDA margin (1) 34.4% 38.3% (3.9 p.p.)
Telefonica Moviles Mexico
Operating revenues 456.8 380.8 20.0
EBITDA (101.0) (50.4) 100.2
EBITDA margin (22.1%) (13.2%) (8.9 p.p.)
TCP Argentina
Operating revenues 239.6 169.7 41.2
EBITDA 19.6 50.6 (61.3)
EBITDA margin 8.2% 29.8% (21.7 p.p.)
Telefonica Moviles Peru
Operating revenues 183.9 182.7 0.6
EBITDA 48.2 66.1 (27.2)
EBITDA margin 26.2% 36.2% (10.0 p.p.)
Telefonica Moviles Guatemala and El Salvador
Operating revenues 132.7 123.1 7.8
EBITDA 17.0 21.9 (22.4)
EBITDA margin 12.8% 17.8% (5.0 p.p.)
Telefonica Movil Chile
Operating revenues 276.1 239.3 15.4
EBITDA 65.9 82.6 (20.2)
EBITDA margin 23.9% 34.5% (10.7 p.p.)
Note: Telefonica Cellular Business includes Telefonica Movil Chile.
(1) Year over year comparision is affected by TCO incorporation from May 2003.
TELEFONICA MOVILES GROUP
CONSOLIDATED INCOME STATEMENT
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
January - September July - September
2004 2003 % Chg 2004 2003 % Chg
Operating revenues 8,236.4 7,303.8 12.8 2,948.5 2,667.9 10.5
Operating expenses (4,740.0) (3,953.5) 19.9 (1,692.0) (1,427.9) 18.5
Other net operating income (expense) 31.2 18.4 69.8 0.3 1.7 n.s.
EBITDA 3,527.6 3,368.7 4.7 1,256.8 1,241.7 1.2
Depreciation and amortization (1,103.4) (1,072.2) 2.9 (385.2) (347.4) 10.9
Operating profit 2,424.1 2,296.5 5.6 871.6 894.2 (2.5)
Profit from associated companies (30.1) (56.8) (47.0) (9.1) (9.1) (0.3)
Financial net income (expense) (235.0) (259.0) (9.3) (82.6) (101.9) (19.0)
Amortization of goodwill (59.7) (74.3) (19.6) (21.1) (27.8) (24.0)
Extraordinary net income (expense) (23.0) 5.8 c.s. (8.4) (0.2) n.s.
Income before taxes 2,076.4 1,912.2 8.6 750.4 755.3 (0.6)
Income taxes (721.2) (666.7) 8.2 (283.0) (277.8) 1.9
Net income before minority interests 1,355.2 1,245.5 8.8 467.4 477.5 (2.1)
Minority interests 1.3 12.0 (89.2) (0.1) 1.2 c.s.
Net income 1,356.5 1,257.5 7.9 467.4 478.7 (2.4)
CELLULAR BUSINESS
CONSOLIDATED INCOME STATEMENT
Unaudited figures (Euros in millions)
January - September July - September
2004 2003 % Chg 2004 2003 % Chg
Operating revenues 8,447.1 7,539.4 12.0 2,988.9 2,756.7 8.4
Internal expend capitalized in fixed assets (1) 53.6 55.8 (3.9) 16.9 15.5 9.5
Operating expenses (4,881.6) (4,095.7) 19.2 (1,713.5) (1,484.5) 15.4
Other net operating income (expense) (41.3) (48.3) (14.5) (23.7) (11.3) 109.7
EBITDA 3,577.8 3,451.3 3.7 1,268.6 1,276.3 (0.6)
Depreciation and amortization (1,161.5) (1,135.9) 2.3 (397.4) (371.6) 6.9
Operating profit 2,416.3 2,315.4 4.4 871.3 904.7 (3.7)
Profit from associated companies (31.5) (56.8) (44.6) (9.3) (9.1) 2.6
Financial net income (expense) (249.4) (286.0) (12.8) (83.8) (111.8) (25.1)
Amortization of goodwill (67.5) (84.4) (20.0) (22.6) (31.5) (28.4)
Extraordinary net income (expense) (22.7) 5.5 c.s. (8.6) (0.5) n.s.
Income before taxes 2,045.2 1,893.6 8.0 747.0 751.8 (0.6)
Income taxes (717.1) (666.7) 7.6 (282.3) (281.5) 0.3
Net income before minority interests 1,328.2 1,227.0 8.2 464.7 470.3 (1.2)
Minority interests 15.7 22.5 (30.1) 1.4 5.2 (74.0)
Net income 1,343.9 1,249.4 7.6 466.1 475.5 (2.0)
Note: Telefonica Cellular Business includes Telefonica Movil Chile.
(1) Including work in process.
This information is provided by RNS
The company news service from the London Stock Exchange