Clarification Final Results
Telefonica SA
15 April 2002
INFORMATION REQUESTED BY THE SPANISH NATIONAL SECURITIES AND MARKET COMMISSION
REGARDING 2001 TELEFONICA, S.A.'S INDIVIDUAL ANNUAL ACCOUNTS AND THE TELEFONICA
GROUP'S CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL ACCOUNTS
In answer to the request made by the Spanish National Securities and Market
Commission regarding certain information included in Telefonica, S.A 's
individual annual accounts and the Telefonica Group's consolidated annual
accounts, corresponding to the fiscal year that closed at December 31st, 2001,
Telefonica, S.A informs that:
1. Uncertainty expressed in the audit reports on the annual accounts in relation
with the Telefonica Group's investment in Argentina.
The audit reports on Telefonica, S.A.'s annual accounts and those of the
Telefonica Group include a degree of uncertainty regarding the impact that
certain events could have on the investments held by the Group in Argentina.
It should be underlined that the qualified opinion issued by the auditors
corresponds to the uncertainty and is not a question of an error or a breach
of the generally recognised accounting principles and norms. That is to say,
the Telefonica Group's annual accounts do not need to include any
adjustments to the provisions made, neither do they require the registering
of additional provisions to cover events that have arisen and have not been
previously considered.
Therefore, the uncertainty expressed by the auditor reflects the existence
of a situation whose final outcome cannot be foreseen at the date of the
auditors'issuing of the report, as this depends on the evolution of the
situation. As a consequence, the Telefonica Group is unable to form a
feasible opinion as to what degree, if this should be the case, the annual
accounts should be adjusted.
Therefore, the Telefonica Group, and this is also the conclusion reached by
the the auditors, neither had, nor currently have, any possibility of making
a reasonable estimate, be it specifically or globally, neither is it
possible to include in the annual accounts the effect of the aforementioned
currency forecasts, as these items depend on future events whose outcome is
unforeseeable.
In order to draw up the annual accounts for fiscal 2001, the Telefonica
Group carried out a thorough analysis, including all the necessary tasks, in
order to quantify and register all those provisions deemed necessary
applying the information provided, the events that had taken place to date
and the accounting norms in force, which included the announcement made by
the Institute for the Accounting and Auditing of Accounts (Instituto de
Contabilidad y Auditoria de Cuentas). This analysis, which was subsequently
audited, studied the solvency of assets, evaluated the viability of
investments and analysed the degree to which the goodwill could be
recovered, etc. Nevertheless, as we have mentioned before, events that could
take place in the future cannot to objectively assessed and these may, as
the auditors have stated, affect the annual accounts for fiscal 2001.
The Group, and its auditors, assessed, applying prudent criteria, the
provisions needed to cover the investments made in Argentina at December
31st, 2001, at all times considering the sustaining of the businesses
managed by the participated companies, and in a situation in which, despite
the outcome of unforeseen future events, further provisions could be deemed
excessive or even unnecessary. The auditor draws a similar conclusion
stating in the report a certain degree of uncertainty and stating that no
errors or breaches in accounting principles exist.
Finally, with an aim to reflecting the highest degree of transparency, the
Telefonica Group's consolidated annual accounts for fiscal 2001 set forth
all the relevant information on the items that this letter outlines. The
information provides a detailed breakdown of the effect the devaluation of
the Argentinian peso has had on the consolidated annual accounts, as well as
the effect of this on fiscal 2002 depending on the latest exchange rate
registered for this currency prior to the drawing up of this information.
2. UMTS licences
The table below provides a breakdown of the Telefonica Group companies that
have acquired UMTS licences, along with the amount paid for each licence.
Companies Million euros Telefonica Group's Country
proportional stake
Group 3G UMTS Holding GmbH 8,471.0 4,491.3 Germany
3G Mobile Telecommunications GmbH 117.0 108.5 Austria
3G Mobile AG 32.5 30.1 Switzerland
The companies mentioned above are registered in the Telefonica Group's
consolidated accounts applying the global integration method. Likewise, the
Group holds a stake in the Italian company Ipse 2000, S.p.A. whose UMTS
licence carried an acquisition price of Euros 3,269 million (Euros 1,514.9
million for the Telefonica Group's proportional stake), and is valued
applying the equity method.
Whatever the case, Telefonica will provide information on any change in
value that could take place during the updating of the business plans for
the UMTS licences, and this will be announced through its quarterly and
six-monthly publications.
3. Companies whose equity is lower than half its share capital.
The Telefonica Group's consolidated annual accounts corresponding to
fiscal 2001, reflect the existence of several companies that at December
31st, 2001 registered equity which was lower that half the share
capital. This is a temporary circumstance that often occurs in large
corporations.
These companies are referred to individually in Annex I of the
Telefonica Group's consolidated annual accounts and its Management
Report.
These companies should be analysed, dividing them into different groups,
whithin each of which the situations are comparable.
a. companies that are being wound up, and that the result of this process solely
depends on the finalising of the pertinent legal procedures. Any material
effect these companies may have on the Group's results has already been duly
registered.
b. Companies that are non- active and do not have personnel, regarding which the
decision to initiate the winding up process has already been taken. In the
same way as those mentioned in the previous paragraph, any material effect
on the Group's result has already been duly registered.
c. Companies whose size is irrelevante within the Telefonica Group (companies
whose total figure for shareholders'equity is below Euros 2 million)
d. Foreign companies whose local legislation sets forth that if their
shareholders'equity is below half their share capital, their net worth is
not considered to be unstable therefore, legally speaking, no action is
needed to re- establish the balance.
e. Companies whose net worth has regained a balanced position at the date of
this document.
f. Companies whose operating losses have reflected the shareholder equity
situation previously described and whose net worth balance will be duly re-
established within the legal periods imposed to this effect, be this through
financing or the capitalisation of loans or any other way deemed necessary.
In order to provide some idea as to the relevance of all the companies
referred to in Annex 1 of the Annual Report, twenty companies represent
93 percent of the total figure for the share capital of this group of
companies.
Excluding the Group's companies in Argentina, due to the situation
previously mentioned, to date only two of these companies reflect the
need to re- establish the balance of their net worth, which is foreseen
to occur in the near future. The economic amount of the necessary
contribution for the aforementioned re-establishment represents 0.27% of
the Telefonica, S.A.'s consolidated equity.
Madrid, April 15th, 2002
This information is provided by RNS
The company news service from the London Stock Exchange