Vodafone Group Plc
07 June 2007
7 June 2007
FURTHER STATEMENT ON AGM RESOLUTIONS
Vodafone Group Plc ('Vodafone' or the 'Company') has received a letter from
Efficient Capital Structures ('ECS') containing a requisition signed by
shareholders holding in aggregate 210,000 ordinary shares. The requisition
principally relates to proposals regarding the structure of the Vodafone Group's
shareholding in Verizon Wireless and the Group's levels of debt. The Board of
Vodafone has reviewed the proposals from ECS and has unanimously concluded that
continued execution of its clearly stated strategy will deliver greater value
for shareholders. In particular, the Board of Vodafone believes the proposals
from ECS would undermine both its ability to maximise the value of its
shareholding in Verizon Wireless and Vodafone's ability to invest in its
businesses as well as exploit potential value creating opportunities.
The letter from ECS sets out four resolutions which ECS requires the Company, in
accordance with the Companies Act, to submit to shareholders at the Company's
AGM to be held on 24 July 2007. The resolutions are as follows:
A. A Special Resolution to amend the Company's Articles of Association to give
shareholders the right to direct the Company's Board by means of an Ordinary
Resolution of shareholders.
B. An Ordinary Resolution that proposals be put to shareholders by 31st March
2008 to alter the Company's capital structure either by the issue of tracking
shares or a spin-off, for the purpose of separating out the Company's 45 per
cent interest in Verizon Wireless from its other assets. If such proposals
are not made, then all fees payable to Directors would be allocated and
paid to the Chairman.
C. An Ordinary Resolution that proposals be put to shareholders by 31st March
2008 to create a new group holding company to enable the issue of Vodafone
bonds directly to Vodafone shareholders, increasing the group's leverage by
approximately £34 billion. If such proposals are not made, then all fees
payable to Directors would be allocated and paid to the Chairman.
D. A Special Resolution to amend the Company's Articles of Association to limit
the Company's ability to make any acquisition with a consideration of more
than £1 billion or acquisitions with an aggregate consideration of more
than £5 billion in any two year period before 31st March 2010, without
first obtaining approval from shareholders by Special Resolution in a
general meeting, unless Vodafone has first altered its capital structure
by the issue of tracking shares and the issue of Vodafone bonds.
The Board of Vodafone has considered these resolutions in detail as follows:
Resolution B
Vodafone's 45 per cent shareholding in Verizon Wireless has generated
significant value accretion for shareholders in recent years reflecting its
market leading position, superior growth and cash generation. The Board believes
the strategy of maintaining its ownership in Verizon Wireless is in the best
interest of shareholders at this time.
Maximising the value of this shareholding is a key element of Vodafone's current
strategy and one that is kept under constant review. As part of these reviews,
Vodafone has considered a number of alternative structures, including tracking
shares and spin off options, to assess whether they might deliver greater value
to shareholders. In summary, the Board has concluded the following:
- Tracking shares would be likely to trade at a material valuation discount
to the fundamental value of the shareholding given their complexity, lack
of transparency and limited rights over the underlying business. Similar
discounts in valuation have led many of the tracking shares issued by other
companies to be unwound in recent years
- Spin off structures would also be likely to create securities that would
trade at a material discount to value of the underlying shareholding given
the complexities in achieving favourable tax status, the indirect nature
of the shareholding, the lack of any assured dividend stream and the
Board's view that the UK is not the natural listing for such securities,
nor UK shareholders the natural holders of such securities
Taken together, these factors have led the Board of Vodafone to conclude that
the structures proposed by ECS would not deliver to shareholders effectively the
value of the Verizon Wireless shareholding today and could potentially
significantly undermine the Board's ability to maximise the value of the
shareholding in the future.
Resolution C
Over the last three years, Vodafone's net debt has increased from around £10
billion to £24 billion and it has returned in aggregate approximately £28
billion to shareholders by way of dividends and one off distributions. It has
also increased its dividend payout ratio to 60 per cent of adjusted earnings per
share.
Vodafone believes that a substantial increase in leverage from current levels as
envisaged by the ECS proposal to increase debt by approximately £34 billion
would create significant additional risk, constrain future flexibility and erode
the Group's ability to generate value for its shareholders in the future.
ECS's proposals would lead to Vodafone becoming a sub-investment grade borrower.
As such Vodafone's cost of debt would rise materially contributing to
incremental interest expense of at least £2 billion per annum. At this level of
leverage it is unlikely that Vodafone could benefit from tax deductibility on
the full interest amount. Vodafone's existing dividend policy would also be put
at risk.
The Board of Vodafone regularly reviews its capital structure and distribution
policy and believes that its current capital structure appropriately balances
the needs of its European businesses, and the challenging markets in which they
operate, while maintaining flexibility to invest in selective growth
opportunities including acquisitions in the EMAPA region.
Resolutions A and D
The resolutions proposed by ECS to amend the Articles to allow shareholders to
give directions to the Board at lower voting thresholds and limit the Company's
ability to make acquisitions would significantly constrain the Board's
flexibility in managing both Vodafone's global business and implementing its
successful strategy to deliver value to shareholders.
In particular, the requirement to seek shareholder approval for acquisitions at
the low levels proposed by ECS would place Vodafone at a material disadvantage
in competing for assets. In the view of the Board, this type of constraint could
have prevented Vodafone from making many of the significant and attractive value
creating acquisitions it has made in recent years, such as those in Romania,
Turkey and India. The Board of Vodafone has already established and communicated
clear financial criteria for all acquisition activity.
The Board of Vodafone welcomes an active and open dialogue with its
shareholders. However, having taken advice, it believes that implementation of
ECS's proposals would not be in the interest of Vodafone's shareholders. The
Board believes that the Group's recent financial results confirm the benefits
being delivered to shareholders through the delivery of its strategy. It remains
confident that continued execution of this strategy will deliver sustained
growth in value for shareholders.
- ends -
For further information:
Vodafone Group
Investor Relations Media Relations
Telephone: +44 (0) 1635 664447 Telephone: +44 (0) 1635 664444
Notes to Editors
As at 7th June, Vodafone has 52,909,904,713 ordinary shares in issue (excluding
treasury shares).
A Special Resolution needs at least a 75% majority of those voting to be
approved. An Ordinary Resolution needs over 50% majority of those voting to be
approved.
This information is provided by RNS
The company news service from the London Stock Exchange
*A Private Investor is a recipient of the information who meets all of the conditions set out below, the recipient:
Obtains access to the information in a personal capacity;
Is not required to be regulated or supervised by a body concerned with the regulation or supervision of investment or financial services;
Is not currently registered or qualified as a professional securities trader or investment adviser with any national or state exchange, regulatory authority, professional association or recognised professional body;
Does not currently act in any capacity as an investment adviser, whether or not they have at some time been qualified to do so;
Uses the information solely in relation to the management of their personal funds and not as a trader to the public or for the investment of corporate funds;
Does not distribute, republish or otherwise provide any information or derived works to any third party in any manner or use or process information or derived works for any commercial purposes.
Please note, this site uses cookies. Some of the cookies are essential for parts of the site to operate and have already been set. You may delete and block all cookies from this site, but if you do, parts of the site may not work. To find out more about the cookies used on Investegate and how you can manage them, see our Privacy and Cookie Policy
To continue using Investegate, please confirm that you are a private investor as well as agreeing to our Privacy and Cookie Policy & Terms.