Annual Financial Report
Manchester & London Investment Trust Plc
Announcement of the Audited Group Results
For the year ended 31st July 2013
The Directors Announce the Audited Results for the year ended 31st July 2013
Company Registered Number: 01009550
Financial Summary
Total Return
Year to Year to Percentage
31st July 31st July (decrease)/
2013 2012 increase
Total return (£'000) 2,522 (19,945)
Return per 25p ordinary share - 11.2p (88.8)p
fully diluted
Total revenue return per 25p 13.8p 14.3p (3.5)
ordinary share
Cash dividend per 25p ordinary 13.75p 13.0p 5.8
share
Capital
At At Percentage
31st July 31st July (decrease)/
2013 2012 increase
Net assets attributable to equity 75,050 75,515 (0.6)
shareholders (£'000)
Net asset value per 25p ordinary share 334.2p 336.3p (0.6)
- fully diluted
Benchmark performance 19.9
Performance versus benchmark (20.5)
Ongoing Charges
Year to Year to
31st July 31st July
2013 2012
Ongoing charges as a percentage of
average net assets 0.89% 0.86%
Financial Calendar
Year ended: 31st July 2013
Results announced: 25th October 2013
Report and Accounts made available to shareholders: 25th October 2013
Annual General Meeting to be held in Manchester: 2nd December 2013
Expected final dividend payment: 6th December 2013
Chairman's Statement
Results for the year ended 31st July 2013
Our 2013 financial year was a year marked by strong performances across equity
markets but unfortunately for the second year running, it has been a
disappointing period for the fund. The majority of the fund is exposed to the
cyclical sectors such as Mining, Oil & Gas and Industrial Engineering that have
continued to perform badly and hence we remained somewhat static as the market
moved ahead of us. We are encouraged that our holdings saw their underlying
earnings increase, but the market derated these earnings over the course of the
year. More details regarding our performance can be found in the Investment
Manager's report. Plenty of issues remain ahead of us in 2014. The problems in
the Eurozone remain unresolved and are healing only slowly, the Federal Reserve
appears fearful of retracting quantitative easing and there are an abundance of
geo-political tensions throughout the globe as the balance of power shifts
following the 2008 crisis.
In time, and with patience, we believe investors will be drawn back to globally
exposed, well established, cash generative growth stocks which is where we are
positioned. As a board, we have some sympathy with the investment manager as
the cash generative nature of our holdings can be evidenced by the fact that
our total dividend last year represented such a material dividend yield premium
to the investment trust sector. The fund's long term strategy is to be
positioned to gain advantage from the benefits of global population growth,
productivity gains, urbanisation and the growth of the middle classes. This
strategy used to be popular but it has gone dramatically out of favour and may
well not regain popularity for some time. Nonetheless, we will remain patient
in our faith that, in the medium term, the future earnings power of the
developed markets will be overtaken by the developing markets.
Over the last financial year, Manchester & London's net asset per share
decreased by 0.6 per cent, which is an underperformance against our benchmark,
which generated an increase of 19.9 per cent. The Directors are proposing a
final dividend of 8.25p, making a total of 13.75p per share for the year, an
increase of 5.8 per cent for the year. This total payment compares with the
Total revenue return per ordinary share for the year of 13.8p. The discount
between the share price and the net asset value per share has remained in line
with its medium term historic level.
Post the year end, the founder of the company, Mr Brian Sheppard, retired from
the board of directors as the representative of the Sheppard family's
shareholding. Brian started the company in 1972 with capital of £100,000 and
has done an exceptional job of turning that capital into the £98.3m it reached
at our year end in 2011. Between the two dates, the compound annual return has
been 19.0 per cent compared with our benchmark which has returned 7.2 per cent
per year. We wish Brian well in his retirement.
Whilst Mark Sheppard remains the lead manager of the fund there will no longer
be a Sheppard on the board of the company. Hence, we also welcomed Mr Brett
Miller to the board on 30th August 2013. Brett works directly as executive
director and co-manager of the Damille series of closed end funds so offers the
board some further financial markets experience.
Annual General Meeting
I look forward to welcoming shareholders to our forty first Annual General
Meeting to be held at a new venue, being St. Ann's Church, St. Ann Street,
Manchester M2 7LF, at 1.05 pm on Monday, 2nd December 2013.
Mr P H A Stanley.
Chairman
Investments
As at 31st July 2013
Valuation % of Net
Listed investments Sector £'000 Assets
PZ Cussons plc Personal Goods 17,725 23.6
Weir Group plc Industrial Engineering 9,392 12.5
Vodafone Group plc Mobile 6,962 9.3
Telecommunications
Diageo plc Beverages 6,735 9.0
Smith & Nephew plc Healthcare Services 6,613 8.8
Glencore Xstrata plc Mining 6,557 8.7
Standard Chartered plc Banking 6,411 8.5
Syngenta AG¹ Chemicals 6,160 8.2
Unilever plc Food Producers 5,699 7.6
BG Group plc Oil & Gas Producers 5,618 7.5
BP plc Oil & Gas Producers 5,545 7.4
Rio Tinto plc Mining 5,503 7.3
Burberry Group plc Personal Goods 5,083 6.8
Afren plc Oil & Gas Producers 4,628 6.2
Jardine Matheson Holdings Ltd² General Industrial 4,384 5.8
Smiths Group plc General Industrial 3,365 4.5
Hang Seng 50 Index Longs³ Index Long Position 2,682 3.6
Vedanta Resources plc Mining 2,326 3.1
Rolls-Royce Holdings plc Aerospace & Defence 2,209 2.9
Echo Entertainment Group Ltdâ´ Travel & Leisure 1,802 2.4
Etablissements Maurel et Prom Oil & Gas Producers 1,718 2.3
S.A.âµ
Trinity Exploration & Production Oil & Gas Producers 1,419 1.9
plc
HMS Hydraulic Machines & Systems Industrial Engineering 1,385 1.8
Group plc²
Lloyds Banking Group plc Banking 1,118 1.5
Millennium & Copthorne Hotels plc Travel & Leisure 1,062 1.4
Northern Petroleum plc Oil & Gas Producers 789 1.0
Deere & Company² General Industrial 652 0.9
Joy Global Inc² Mining 504 0.7
Heritage Oil plc Oil & Gas Producers 276 0.4
Walter Energy Inc² Mining 273 0.4
Associated British Foods plc Food Producers 265 0.3
Fortune Oil plc Oil & Gas Producers 119 0.2
Sundance Resources Ltdâ´ Mining 43 0.1
Listed investments 125,022 166.6
Unlisted at Director's valuation 124 0.2
Total Long Positions 125,146 166.8
FTSE 100 Index Shorts (4,834) (6.4)
S&P 500 Index Shorts² (48,076) (64.1)
Cash and net current assets/ 2,814 3.7
(liabilities)
Net assets 75,050 100.0
All investments listed above are equities (unless otherwise stated),
denominated in Sterling (except ¹CHF, ²USD, ³HKD, â´AUD and âµEuro) that have
been issued by companies registered in England (save for Glencore Xstrata,
Syngenta, Jardine Matheson, Hang Seng 50 Index Longs, Echo Entertainment,
Establissements Maurel et Prom, HMS Hydraulic Machines & Systems, Deere &
Company, Joy Global, Heritage Oil, Walter Energy, Sundance Resources and S&P
500 Index Shorts that are registered in Jersey, Switzerland, Bermuda, Hong
Kong, Australia, France, Cyprus, USA, USA, Jersey, USA, Australia and USA
respectively).
Portfolio Sector Analysis
As at 31st July 2013
% of Net
Sector Assets
Personal Goods 30.4
Oil & Gas Producers 26.8
Mining 20.3
Industrial Engineering 14.4
General Industrial 11.2
Banking 10.0
Mobile Telecommunications 9.3
Beverages 9.0
Healthcare Services 8.8
Chemicals 8.2
Food Producers 7.9
Travel & Leisure 3.8
Index Long Positions 3.6
Aerospace & Defence 2.9
Unlisted Investments 0.2
Short Positions, Cash and net current assets/(liabilities) (66.8)
Net Assets 100.0
Investment Manager's Review
An explanation of our core investment style in more detail.
We are seeking to invest in stocks for our core portfolio that are
characterised by the following attributes:
1. well established, with a strategy that we believe has a future;
2. quality operations with competitive advantages (exhibiting attractive
returns on investment);
3. cash generative business models;
4. have the ability to capture the potential for growth; and
5. are trading at reasonable valuations.
In periods when low Return on Invested Capital ("ROIC") stocks outperform high
ROIC stocks, we are very rarely interested in "dashing for trash". If quality
is going to underperform, then so be it. We would rather travel up with the
market capturing only a proportion of its returns in the knowledge that we do
so with holdings that have the resilience to take a few knocks.
Please note our investment style for generating our trading income is somewhat
less restrictive and is more event driven.
It is important to note that potentially we have three structural advantages
over a vanilla open-ended fund, we take a longer-term investment horizon of ten
years (due to our ownership structure), we are able to adapt gearing levels to
our comfort levels with the market's valuation (a benefit of closed end funds)
and we should be able to have a lower cost structure (another historic benefit
of closed end funds).
What we hope to achieve in any investment period.
Our job is multi-fold and we will discuss below how the year under review has
progressed.
1. Controlling costs and generating trading income.
Austerity, bonuses and costs are the favourite topics for journalists. One
hears constant criticism of fund managers with regard to their fee levels. We
think it's important to make the following points regarding our fees:
a. We do not charge a performance fee, yet 62 per cent of investment trusts
do. (Source: The Financial Times, August 2013)
b. Our investment management fee structure is 0.5 per cent per annum whereas
the AIC average is 1.2 per cent per annum. (Source: The AIC, July 2013)
c. If you analyse Chart 1 below*, you will see that for the last five years
the trading income we have generated has exceeded our investment management
fees hence, to use an old stockbroking expression, "we have washed our
face". In addition, in three of the last five years, trading income has
actually covered all the non-finance expenses of the Company.
2013 was another year of positive results for trading income.
*Please see Chart 1 in the Annual Report on page 10.
2. Paying our shareholders a dividend.
We are in the era of the reach for yield. In 2013, we have increased the total
annual dividend per share by 5.8 per cent which is slightly more than the UK
benchmark which increased its equivalent dividend per share by 5.6 per cent.
Chart 2 below* shows that we have followed a progressive dividend policy and we
are fully aware that this is what our shareholders want.
Many shareholders may have seen the point that some journalists have been
making regarding investment trusts not actually covering all their costs when
paying a dividend. We have some sympathy with this point of view so this year
we have charged 100 per cent of the cost of our investment management fee to
revenue. Previously, we had annually apportioned up to 65 per cent of our
investment management fee to capital.
Our 2013 dividend yield (using the mid price at the year end) was 4.6 per cent
which is materially higher than the 2.4 per cent of the investment trust sector
benchmark.
*Please see Chart 2 in the Annual Report on page 11.
3. Generating capital returns.
We aim to ensure that our total return is positive and preferably exceeds the
return on cash. In 2013, we achieved this objective with a total return of 3.3
per cent. However, ideally, we would also like our Net Asset Value per share to
increase in line with the stock market.
2013
This year was another depressingly disappointing year for capital returns. We
underperformed our benchmark by 20.5 per cent. The constituents of this
underperformance are broken down as follows:
Underperformance due to maintaining our Net Long materially lower than 5.5%
our Net Assets
Underperformance of Oil & Gas investments 5.4%
Underperformance of Mining investments 4.9%
Underperformance of Consumer Goods investments 2.2%
Underperformance of Capital Goods investments 1.3%
Underperformance of Financial Sector investments 1.1%
Other elements of underperformance 0.1%
Total underperformance 20.5%
Source: MNL
Is there a chance matters may improve?
The best way to exceed market returns is to ensure that we buy stocks that:
1. increase their earnings equal to, or faster than, the market; and
2. are reasonably valued in relation to the market.
Chart 3 below* shows that the underlying forecast earnings per share of our top
twenty holdings increased at a greater rate over the last five year period than
our benchmark. More importantly, the chart shows that since the middle of 2011,
the underlying earnings of Manchester and London Investment Trust's ("MLIT")
holdings have increased whilst our Net Asset Value per share has declined.
Hence, since mid 2011, our problem has not been that our holdings have lost
their earnings power it is that the valuation multiples of our holdings have
de-rated. In other words, we actually did achieve point 1 above as we held
stocks that increased their earnings faster than the market when one considers
that over the relevant time period the market's valuation has also re-rated
upwards.
Please note it is too difficult to graph the underlying earnings of the exact
portfolio throughout the whole period, so we have used our top twenty holdings
as at the year end. Many would be correct to criticise this methodology for
being skewed by a survivorship bias but it provides a good illustrative
example. Forecast earnings per share are used for the year in advance of the
year of data capture. It is important to note that our top twenty holdings
represented more than 100 per cent of our Net Asset Value as at the year end.
*Please see Chart 3 in the Annual Report on page 12.
Our problem remains the same as in 2012. Although, we do not believe our
holdings were overvalued to start with, they have continued to de-rate for the
last two years.
The sectors that have felt this most acutely are the Mining and the Oil & Gas
sectors. Chart 4 below* shows the material valuation de-rating of both these
sectors over the last two years to 31st July 2013. Please note that as at the
year end, we held a combined 47.1 per cent of our Net Asset Value in these
combined sectors.
*Please see Chart 4 in the Annual Report on page 13.
More on the Mining sector
We note from recent fund managers' surveys that there are now extreme
underweight positions in the Mining sector with sector relative performance now
at the lows of 2008. We understand investors' views on the end of the "super
cycle" and the concern that management teams are just "big hole junkies".
However, we are not so sure and we believe that the management team of Glencore
Xstrata are driving a revolution of attitude in the industry with cost cuts,
lower speculative capital spend and innovative JV ideas. Having recently
attended (with thanks) the DB Consumer Goods conference, investors were
salivating at the future prospects of global consumer goods companies who were
all presenting that the key drivers of their future growth would occur through
the urbanisation of developing markets and the swelling of the middle classes.
If these factors are drivers for consumer goods companies, why aren't they
drivers for the miners too?
The answer may lie in the rate of change, but we believe that dividend yields
at around 4 per cent and valuations sub-book value are attractive. We see
current dividends as defensible and we believe there is material upside
potential if commodity prices stabilise, capex drops off and costs continue to
be cut. In conclusion, very few funds buy the Mining sector as its constituents
move with sickening volatility and within that lies opportunity.
More on the Oil & Gas sector
Many of the points we have made above are also pertinent for the Oil & Gas
sector. In general, Oil & Gas stocks are trading at material discounts to
consensus NAVs and are now paying attractive dividends. It must be remembered
that over the last 30 years, the Oil & Gas sector has been the third most
successful in total shareholder return terms. This is partly because it is
volatile, nauseating and risky, and that means many avoid it.
Why we think our other stocks are relatively under valued
Chart 5 below* shows the expected cumulative operating profit that our top
twenty holdings may generate over the next three years as a percentage of their
total market value (based largely on consensus forecasts).
EBIT can be used as a reasonable proxy for normalised free cash flow before
taxation and interest (assuming capex equals depreciation). It can clearly be
seen that our portfolio weighted average valuation (shown by the red bar) is
materially less expensive than the UK market and, in the case of some of our
stocks, significantly so.
*Please see Chart 5 in the Annual Report on page 14.
The year ahead
There are numerous reasons why we are not convinced that markets should be
trading at such high multiples:
* Markets are correlated to productivity - US productivity has been weak and
materially below the +2.2 per cent average over the last 20 years.
* Global debt - many countries are still highly leveraged with Japan of
particular concern. It is possible that Japan can not sustain these debt
levels if trade surpluses were to switch to deficits consistently. It is
possible that other Asian exporters will not tolerate the continuing
devaluation of the Yen.
* Europe - whilst some progress has been made, the periphery still has debt,
competitiveness and banking leverage problems. Despite being several years
into the "Euro Crisis" we are yet to see a credible plan that would ensure
the viability of the bloc in the long-term. Either the periphery leave, or
the Germans pay for the weaker nations or the pain and unemployment
continue.
* Demographics in developed markets - in Japan 32 per cent of the population
is over 60, in the UK it is 23 per cent and the US 19 per cent. This
demographic shift is expected to continue and could be a significant drag
on equity markets in the longer term.
* Inflation - whist the unprecedented level of QE has yet to materially feed
into consumer prices or commodities, it would be premature to write this
off as a future risk, particularly if the emerging markets decide their own
QE is the best way to respond to the aggressive printing in Japan.
* China - whilst we remain positive in the long term on the prospects for
Asia and do not see a hard landing as the base case in the short term, we
would be remiss not to consider the potentially challenging rebalancing
China is undergoing as a risk to the global economy.
* Bond Bubble - when a 30 year bull market in bonds culminates in Rwanda
getting 10 year debt away under 7 per cent one has to be concerned about a
bubble in the debt markets. After all, the US 10 year yield was above this
level as recently as 1995. Since then, Rwanda's yield has jumped to over 8
per cent, and US yields have also increased to over 2.5 per cent. With the
average US ten year yield over the last 100 years close to 5 per cent, we
could still be far from a normalised discount rate level, particularly once
the QE taper has been unpaused.
* Geopolitical tensions - geopolitical risks remain high with continuing
unrest in the Middle East, and tensions between China and Japan, and North
Korea always on the radar. There are risks of a total breakdown in Sunni
and Shia relations in the Middle East, which apart from causing human
conflict, could lead to an oil price shock.
What about prospects for the USA?
* US debt situation - whilst the headline debt figures look manageable at 105
per cent of GDP, once the sizeable unfunded liabilities of Social Security,
Medicare and Medicaid are included, total net liabilities soar to 600 per
cent of GDP or nearly $100tr. This is a material burden for future tax
payers (and bond holders), unless serious policy changes are made.
* Households - whilst total household balance sheets are healthy with net
assets of $70tr, there is a big disparity around the spread of wealth. The
mean US household has over $500k in net assets, but the latest data from
the US Census Bureau for 2011 shows a median net worth of just $68k, or
$17k excluding home equity. For those in the lowest quintile the situation
was even worse, with a net worth of just under $5k. For this group of
consumers, the impact of rising mortgage rates could be significant.
* US valuations - the S&P 500 is on ~17x PE (FT) which is a 1.2 per cent
premium to its long run fair value of 16.4x (DB). More importantly, the
current multiple represents a 66 per cent premium to the Hang Seng (FT), a
27 per cent premium to the Singapore Market (FT) and a 134 per cent premium
to the Chinese Market (FT). The relative level of the S&P vs the Hang Seng
is now at its highest level since 2006.
Please see Chart 6 in the Annual Report on page 15.
* Shale is not a game changer - whilst lower energy prices have certainly
helped, the benefit is not sufficient to close the competiveness gap to
emerging markets. In addition, faster than expected shale decline rates are
a material risk. Gas exports could improve the US trade balance over the
next few years, but the US cannot have its cake and eat it, it must choose
between energy exports or lower prices.
Where do we think the S&P should be?
* Whilst we are not overall bears on the global market, we do think the US is
overvalued relative to its own fundamentals and overvalued compared with
emerging market equities.
* The QE led moves into defensive equity sectors over the last few years has
highlighted the key importance of the US bond yield in equity valuations.
This is intuitively understandable as on a theoretical level the value of
any stock is the discounted value of all future dividends. Therefore the
discount rate - which is commonly related to the bond yield - and
assumptions regarding future growth are the two key drivers of valuation.
* Going back to 1960, the monthly correlation between the Earnings Yield
(inverse P/E) and the US 10 year bond yield is 0.7 per cent.
Please see Chart 7 in the Annual Report on page 16.
* If US 10 year bond yields were to increase to 4 per cent (which is below
the long run average) and equity risk premiums increase to the long run
average of 4.2 per cent (New York University) then the implied fair value
earnings yield becomes 8.2 per cent. That equity earnings yield derives a
PE of 12.2x resulting through a 2013 consensus EPS of $109.5 (Source:
Factset) to an implied S&P level of ~1335. Clearly, this is materially
below the current level so we are not suggesting this is a realistic
target, but it is illustrative of the downside risks.
Conclusion
It seems logical that if QE has pumped the market upwards then its removal may
at least lead to some volatility. Hence, although we remain substantially
invested into the equity market, we are by no means fully invested. This could
be a grave error but we would rather play the situation somewhat more
defensively and suffer the ensuing underperformance if we are proved wrong.
In the meantime, we will strive every day to seek trading income opportunities
to ensure we are able to continue to reward our loyal shareholders with an
above-market, covered dividend yield and to ensure our core portfolio is
focused on growing, cash generative, well established quality operators at
inexpensive valuations.
We have little option but to learn the virtues (tediousness) of patience.
Investment Manager
Midas Investment Management Ltd.
Principal Portfolio Holdings
PZ Cussons plc ("PZ Cussons")
PZ Cussons is a global personal goods manufacturer, with a portfolio of more
than 30 brands, including Imperial Leather, Carex, Cussons Baby and Morning
Fresh. The company operates in the UK, Africa, Asia, Central Europe and
Australia. PZ Cussons has a five year compound earnings per share ("EPS")
growth rate of 9.0 per cent.
PZ Cussons is exposed to developing markets and the volatility that incurs. We
believe medium term prospects are encouraging and we have no intention of
reducing our stake in the short term. PZ Cussons' geographic footprints and
distribution network should be attractive to a major.
Weir Group plc ("Weir")
Weir is a global leader in the manufacture of specialised pumps. The group is
well-established in each of their three main markets; Mining, Power and Oil &
Gas, and generates more than half of their revenues from aftermarket products
and services. Weir has a five year compound EPS growth rate of 30.5 per cent.
Weir is a quality British engineer exposed to growth markets that should
attract the majors in a consolidating market.
Vodafone Group plc ("Vodafone")
Vodafone is a leading global telecommunications company. While the potential
sale of its Verizon Wireless stake was the key driver for our investment, and
we were pleased to see a deal on attractive terms, the valuation of the
remaining assets remains too low in our opinion. We now see the potential for a
takeover by a larger competitor such as AT&T, which has indicated it is looking
for European assets.
Though the attractive dividend yield and defensive nature of this stock are
welcome in the short term, this is primarily an event driven investment part of
which has been disposed of since the year end.
Diageo plc ("Diageo")
Diageo is a global alcoholic beverages company, and the world's largest
producer of premium spirits. The company holds an enviable portfolio of iconic
brands such as Johnnie Walker, Smirnoff, Baileys and Guinness.
Diageo continues to benefit from the growth of the middle classes in emerging
economies and their increasing demand for premium brands. The company has
targeted medium-term organic sales growth of 6 per cent per annum and has a
five year compound EPS growth rate of 11.4 per cent.
We believe Diageo is starting to look fully valued however, and this holding
may be reduced in the medium term.
Smith & Nephew plc ("Smith & Nephew")
Smith & Nephew is a global medical devices company focusing on orthopaedics,
endoscopy and advanced wound management. The company has distribution channels
in over 90 countries and generates annual sales of over $4 billion. Smith &
Nephew has a five year compound EPS growth rate of 7.8 per cent.
Smith & Nephew remains attractively placed to benefit from the changing
demographics and personal activity levels across the world. The stock is
inexpensive against its historic trading multiples and with further
consolidation expected in the sector, it is a takeover candidate.
Glencore Xstrata plc ("Glencore Xstrata")
Glencore Xstrata is a leading global mining & trading group, covering a wide
range of essential commodities from copper to oil to grain. The recently merged
group is undergoing a transformational period, with production ramp up at owned
mines, post merger synergies and capex run-off expected to result in material
free cash flow generation over the next few years.
As a result, we believe Glencore Xstrata is materially undervalued, but we
would reduce this overweight holding should valuations become more realistic.
Standard Chartered plc ("Standard Chartered")
Standard Chartered is engaged in consumer and wholesale banking globally and
has a strong focus on the Asia-Pacific, Middle East and African regions, which
provide approximately 90 per cent of the group's profit. The bank has been a
strong historic performer and has delivered 10 successive years of record
profits, with a five year compound growth rate of 11.5 per cent.
Standard Chartered is exposed to developing markets and the volatility that
incurs. The current valuation of <1.5x book value seems an undeserved discount
to its historic average of around 2.5x. In the longer term, we believe the
attractions of Standard Chartered's footprint will be attractive to one of the
top 5 global mega-banks.
Syngenta AG ("Syngenta")
Syngenta is a global agri-science business engaged in crop protection and
seeds. Urbanisation and changing dietary preferences across the middle classes
of the developing nations is forcing the agricultural industry to increase
yields.
The strong sector outlook, the group's technological edge and their enviable
product pipeline suggest the shares are attractively valued, particularly if
Syngenta achieve their target to increase sales in key crop areas to $25bn by
the end of the decade. Syngenta has a five year compound EPS growth rate of
14.3 per cent. Syngenta appears to have many years of growth before it so it is
viewed as a core holding for the medium term.
Unilever plc ("Unilever")
Unilever is a multinational consumer goods champion, with universally
recognisable brands in personal goods (Dove, Sure, Tresemme, VO5), household
goods (Persil, Domestos, Surf) and food (Ben & Jerry's, Flora, PG Tips). It has
a high exposure to fast growing emerging markets, driving compound annual
revenue growth of 5 per cent over the last 5 years. Despite this, it trades at
a discount to pure-play specialists such as L'Oreal. However, Unilever has
been slowly divesting non core food brands and over time we look for further
non-core disposals to drive a re-rating towards valuations more appropriate for
a quality pure-play personal goods company. It is possible that we will then
divest our holding at this time.
BG Group plc ("BG")
BG is a global diversified oil & gas E&P company, with top tier assets in the
Santos Basin (Brazil), Australia and the North Sea. The group also has an LNG
arm, capitalising on global price differences by transporting gas in liquid
form from producing nations to high demand regions such as Asia.
BG has a five year compound EPS growth rate of 5.2 per cent and trades at a
significant discount to its NAV. As production in Brazil and Australia ramps
up, we would anticipate this discount closing in time, given the material shift
this should mean to the group's cash flow profile and capacity for shareholder
returns.
Investment Record of the Last Ten Years
Dividend
Return per per Total Net Asset Value
Total ordinary share ordinary assets less per 25p share
Year ended Return Basic Fully share liabilities Basic Fully
£'000 p diluted p £'000 p diluted
p p
31st July 5,512 73.49 53.15 9.50 28,901 385.35 282.39
2004
31st July 5,426 72.35 52.33 9.50 33,611 448.15 327.34
2005
31st July 3,206 42.75 31.14 9.50 36,107 481.43 351.17
2006
31st July 5,799 41.58 41.58 10.00 52,554 376.80 376.80
2007
31st July (3,490) (25.02) (25.02) 10.00 47,669 341.80 341.80
2008
31st July 645 4.43 4.43 10.50 57,495 328.44 328.44
2009
31st July 13,151 71.75 71.75 11.50 85,203 379.40 379.40
2010
31st July 15,691 69.87 69.87 12.50 98,267 437.60 437.60
2011
31st July (19,945) (88.81) (88.81) 13.00 75,515 336.26 336.26
2012
31st July 2,522 11.23 11.23 13.75 75,050 334.19 334.19
2013
In 2006, the Company adopted International Financial Reporting Standards
("IFRS"). As a result, the data has been restated to reflect the change to
IFRS.
In the period from 1981 to 2003, total assets less liabilities increased from £
241,000 to £24,200,000. Net Assets per share increased from 24.1p to 323.2p.
Report of the Directors
The Directors present their report and financial statements for the year ended
31st July 2013.
The Chairman's Statement forms part of the report of the Directors.
Business Review
The purpose of the business review is to provide an overview of the business of
the Company by:
* Analysing development and performance using appropriate key performance
indicators ("KPIs").
* Outlining the principal risks and uncertainties affecting the Company.
* Describing how the Company manages these risks.
* Explaining the future business plan of the Company.
* Providing information about persons with whom the Company has contractual
or other arrangements which are essential to the business of the Company.
* Outlining the main trends and factors likely to affect the future
development, performance and position of the Company's business.
Status
The Company is an Investment Company as defined by Section 833 of the Companies
Act 2006 and operated as an Investment Trust in accordance with Section 1158 of
the Corporation Tax Act 2010.
The Company is also governed by the Listing Rules and Disclosure and
Transparency Rules of the Financial Conduct Authority and is listed on the main
market of the London Stock Exchange under the epic code "MNL".
The close company provisions of the Corporation Tax Act 2010 do not apply to
the Company.
Company registered number: 01009550.
Principal activities
The Company carries on business as an Investment Company. A review of
investment activities for the year ended 31st July 2013 and the outlook for the
coming year is given by the Investment Manager.
The Company's subsidiaries, OSP Limited (formerly Osprey Smaller Companies
Income Fund Limited) ("OSP") and Stakeholders' Momentum Investment Limited
(formerly Stakeholders' Momentum Investment Trust plc) ("SMIL") carried on
business as a dealing subsidiary and as an investment subsidiary, respectively.
OSP, a company incorporated in Guernsey, is the sole branch outside of the
United Kingdom.
Performance and key performance indicators
The key measures by which the Board judges the success of the Company are the
share price, the net asset value per share and the ongoing charges measure.
The Board considers the most important key performance indicator to be the
comparison with its benchmark index. This is referred to in the Financial
Summary.
Total net assets at 31st July 2013 amounted to £75,050,000 compared with £
75,515,000 at 31st July 2012, a decrease of 0.6 per cent, whilst the fully
diluted net asset value per ordinary share decreased to 334.2p from 336.3p.
This decrease of 0.6 per cent compared with an increase over the period of 19.9
per cent by our benchmark index, equated to an underperformance by the Group of
20.5 per cent.
Group net revenue after taxation for the year was £3,089,000, a decrease of 4.1
per cent.
The share price during the period under review has been quoted at discounts to
net asset value of 7.8 to 19.2 per cent which the Directors consider to be
satisfactory in the context of the discounts applicable to other investment
trusts and was achieved without using the Company's powers to acquire its own
shares in the market.
Ongoing charges is a measure of the total expenses (including those charged to
capital) expressed as a percentage of the average net assets over the year. The
Board regularly reviews the ongoing charges measure and monitors Group
expenses.
Principal risks and uncertainties associated with the Company
An investment in the Company is only suitable for financially sophisticated
investors who are capable of evaluating the risks and merits of such an
investment, or other investors who have been professionally advised with regard
to investment and who have sufficient resources to bear any loss which might
result from such an investment. There can be no guarantee that investors will
recover their initial investment. The investment may employ gearing and may be
subject to sudden and large falls in value. Investors should be aware that
movements in the price of the Company may be more volatile than movements in
the price of the underlying investments and that there is a risk that investors
may lose all their invested money. Investors considering an investment should
consult their stockbroker, bank manager, solicitor, accountant and/or other
independent financial adviser.
In respect of some of the companies in which the Company may invest:
* the company may be undergoing significant change, or be exposed to the
volatility of emerging or developing markets;
* they may have less mature businesses, a more restricted depth of management
and accordingly a higher risk profile;
* the quality of the investments' management may have been overestimated;
* the market value of, and income derived from, such shares can fluctuate;
and
* there may not be a liquid market for their shares. The fact that a share is
traded on a market does not guarantee its liquidity. Accordingly, such
shares may be difficult to realise at quoted market prices.
Any change in the tax treatment of dividends paid, or income received by the
Company, may reduce the level of yield received by shareholders. Any change in
the Company's tax status, or in legislation, could affect the value of the
investments held by the Company and its performance.
Investment in the Company should be regarded as long-term in nature. There can
be no guarantee that any appreciation in the value of the Company's investments
will occur and investors may not get back the full value of their investment.
There can be no guarantee that the investment objective of the Company will be
met.
The Company is exposed to a range of economic and market risks, liquidity,
interest rates, exchange rates and general financial risks.
The market capitalisation of the Company will make the market of the ordinary
shares less liquid than would be the case for a larger company.
Whilst the use of borrowings by the Company should enhance the net asset value
of the ordinary shares when the value of the Company's underlying assets is
rising, it will have the opposite effect when the underlying asset value is
falling. Furthermore, should any fall in the underlying assets' values result
in the Company breaching the financial covenants applicable to the borrowings,
the Company may be required to repay such borrowing in whole or in part
together with any attendant costs. In order to repay such borrowings, the
Company may have to sell assets at less than their quoted market values. A
positive net asset value for the ordinary shares will be dependent upon the
Company's assets being sufficient to meet any debt.
On a winding-up of the Company, the ordinary shares rank for repayment of
capital after repayment of all other creditors of the Company. Ordinary shares
are only appropriate for investors who understand that they may receive an
amount less than their original investment.
Risk management
The risks with regards to financial instruments, and the Company's policies for
management of these risks, are detailed in note 18 to the financial statements
- "Risks - Contracts for differences, derivatives, other financial instruments
and other risks". The Company manages the risks inherent in portfolio
management by investing in approximately 20 to 40 securities of companies
operating in a range of industrial sectors and varying the extent of cash
holdings or gearing in relation to the Investment Manager's assessment of
overall market conditions.
The Company does not have any employees and consequently relies upon the
services provided by a number of third parties. The Board therefore relies on
the control procedures of these third parties which include the Company's
Investment Manager, Registrar, Custodian and Broker. This type of operational
structure is not uncommon with Investment Trust companies.
The Board via reports from the Administrator reviews the internal control
procedures of its third party service providers and assesses the reliability of
these procedures as part of its risk management strategy. The Risk Management
function is a responsibility of the Administrator, M & M Investment Services,
which is a division of Manchester & Metropolitan Investment Limited and
operates as a standalone unit, comprised of individuals who are not members of
the Board or the Sheppard family. Further details with regards to the Board's
risk management procedures are detailed in the "Internal Financial Control"
section of the Statement of Corporate Governance.
Gearing
The company operates a Flexible Revolving Loan Facility with a limit of £11m
with Pershing Securities Limited, a subsidiary of The Bank of New York Mellon
Corporation. No arrangement fee is payable on this facility and interest is
charged at the Bank of England Base Rate plus three per cent per annum on
drawdowns.
By the year end the portfolio had been geared, using this facility and CFDs, to
a level whereby gross long investments represented 166.8 per cent of net assets
and the net long position represented 96.3 per cent of net assets. In
addition, the weighted average percentage of gearing (calculated as net debt
divided by market capitalisation) held by our top 20 portfolio holdings
(excluding banks) on their own balance sheets was 16 per cent. (Sources:
FactSet Research Systems Inc. plus other.)
Management
Details of the Company's management agreement with Midas Investment Management
Limited ("the Investment Manager" or "Midas") are contained in note 3 to the
financial statements.
Future development
A commentary on the trends and factors likely to affect the future development,
performance and position of the Company, which includes an assessment of market
sentiment and the effectiveness of government intervention, is set out in the
Chairman's Statement and the Investment Manager's Report and is also released
monthly in a fund factsheet published via the Company's website.
Investment objective and policy
The Group's investment objective and policy has not changed during the year
under review.
Results
The Group's total comprehensive profit for the year, after taxation, amounted
to £2,522,000 (2012: £19,945,000 total comprehensive loss).
Total net assets at 31st July 2013 amounted to £75,050,000 compared with £
75,515,000 at 31st July 2012, whilst the fully diluted net asset value per
ordinary share decreased to 334.2p from 336.3p.
Ordinary dividends
An interim dividend of 5.5p per ordinary share was paid on 29th April 2013
(2012: 5.2p) and the Directors are recommending a final dividend of 8.25p per
ordinary share (2012: 7.8p), a total for the year of 13.75p per ordinary share
(2012: 13.0p).
Subject to shareholders' approval at the Annual General Meeting, the final
dividend will be paid on 6th December 2013 to shareholders registered on 15th
November 2013. The shares will be declared ex-dividend on 13th November 2013.
Share valuations
On 31st July 2013, the middle market quotation and the net asset value per
ordinary 25p share were 299.9p and 334.2p, respectively. This indicates that
the discount on the Company's shares was 10.3 per cent. This is not uncommon as
the share prices of closed-end funds are often traded at a discount to their
net asset values.
Events after the reporting period
There have been no significant events since the end of the reporting period.
Supplier terms
It is the Group's policy to obtain the best terms for all business, including
purchases of investments and to abide by those agreed terms.
The Group had trade payables of £99,000 (2012: £106,000) at the year end. Trade
payables are settled by the due date for payment. Payables in respect of
investment purchases are settled in accordance with Stock Exchange regulations.
Directors' Responsibilities in Relation to the Annual Report and the Financial
Statements
The Directors are responsible for preparing the Annual Report, the Directors
Remuneration Report and the Group and Parent Company financial statements in
accordance with applicable law and regulations.
Company law requires the Directors to prepare financial statements for each
financial year. Under that law the Directors have prepared the Group and Parent
Company financial statements in accordance with International Financial
Reporting Standards (IFRS) adopted by the European Union and Article 4 of the
EU IAS Regulation. Under Company law, the Directors must not approve the
financial statements unless they are satisfied that they give a true and fair
view of the state of the affairs of the Company and the Group and of the profit
or loss of the Company and Group for that period.
In preparing those financial statements, the Directors are required to:
* properly select suitable accounting policies and apply them consistently;
* present information, including accounting policies, in a manner that
provides relevant, reliable, comparable and understandable information;
* make judgements and accounting estimates that are reasonable;
* provide additional disclosure when compliance with the specific
requirements of IFRS are insufficient to enable users to understand the
impact of particular transactions, other events and conditions on the
Group's and Company's financial position and financial performance;
* state that the Group and Company financial statements have been prepared in
accordance with IFRS, subject to any material departures disclosed and
explained in the financial statements; and
* make an assessment of the ability of the Group and Company to continue on a
going concern basis.
The Directors are responsible for keeping adequate accounting records that show
and explain the Group and Company's transactions and disclose with reasonable
accuracy, at any time, the financial position of the Company and of the Group
and to enable them to ensure that the financial statements comply with the
Companies Act 2006 and Article 4 of the IAS Regulation. They are also
responsible for safeguarding the assets of the Group and Company and hence for
taking reasonable steps for the prevention and detection of fraud and other
irregularities.
The Directors are responsible for the maintenance and integrity of the
corporate and financial information included on the company's website.
Legislation in the United Kingdom governing the preparation and dissemination
of financial statements may differ from legislation in other jurisdictions.
Under applicable law and regulations, the Directors are also responsible for
preparing a Directors' Report and Corporate Governance Statement that comply
with that law and those regulations.
To the best of the knowledge of each of the Directors:
a. the financial statements, prepared in accordance with the IFRS adopted by
the European Union, give a true and fair view of the assets, liabilities,
financial position and profit or loss of the Company and the undertakings
included in the consolidation taken as a whole; and
b. the Directors' Report includes a fair review of the development and
performance of the fund and the position of the Company and the
undertakings included in the consolidation taken as a whole, together with
a description of the principal risks and uncertainties that they face.
Each of the Directors accepts responsibility accordingly.
On behalf of the Board of Directors
Mr P H A Stanley
Chairman
23rd October 2013
Independent Auditor's Report To The Members of Manchester & London Investment
Trust plc
The Company's financial statements for the year ended 31st July 2013 have been
audited by CLB Coopers. The entire Auditor's report, which is unqualified, can
be found in the Company's Annual Report and Financial Statement at
www.manchesterandlondon.co.uk.
Consolidated Statement of Comprehensive Income
For the year ended 31st July 2013
2013 2013 2013 2012 2012 2012
Note Revenue Capital Total Revenue Capital Total
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Gains
Losses on investments 10 - (240) (240) - (22,448) (22,488)
at fair value through
profit or loss
Trading income 2 627 - 627 934 - 934
Investment income 2 3,189 - 3,189 2,690 - 2,690
Gross return 3,816 (240) 3,576 3,624 (22,488) (18,864)
Expenses
Investment management 3 (411) - (411) (145) (268) (413)
fee
Cost of investment (82) - (82) (8) (43) (51)
transactions
Other operating 4 (232) - (232) (250) - (250)
expenses
Total expenses (725) - (725) (403) (311) (714)
Return before finance 3,091 (240) 2,851 3,221 (22,799) (19,578)
costs and tax
Finance costs 6 (2) (327) (329) - (367) (367)
Return on ordinary 3,089 (567) 2,522 3,221 (23,166) (19,945)
activities before tax
Tax expense 7 - - - - - -
Return on ordinary 3,089 (567) 2,522 3,221 (23,166) (19,945)
activities after tax
Earnings per ordinary
share (pence)
Basic 9 13.76 (2.53) 11.23 14.34 (103.15) (88.81)
Fully diluted 9 13.76 (2.53) 11.23 14.34 (103.15) (88.81)
The total column of this statement represents the Statement of Comprehensive
Income of the Group prepared in accordance with IFRS. The supplementary revenue
return and capital return columns are both prepared under guidance published by
the Association of Investment Companies.
The Group does not have any Other Comprehensive Income and hence the return on
ordinary activities after tax, as disclosed above, is the same as the Group's
Total Comprehensive Income/(Loss).
All items in the above statement derive from continuing operations.
Consolidated and Company Statements of Changes in Equity
For the year ended 31st July 2013
Group Capital Capital
Share Share Other reserve reserve Retained
capital premium reserves (unrealised) (realised) earnings Total
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Balance at 1st 5,614 35,132 (79) 27,171 27,057 3,372 98,267
August 2011
Changes in equity
for 2012
Total - - - - - (19,945) (19,945)
comprehensive loss
Transfer of - - - (19,025) (4,141) 23,166 -
capital loss
Ordinary dividend - - - - - (2,807) (2,807)
paid (note 8)
Balance at 31st 5,614 35,132 (79) 8,146 22,916 3,786 75,515
July 2012
Changes in equity
for 2013
Total - - - - - 2,522 2,522
comprehensive
income
Transfer of - - - (2,550) 1,983 567 -
capital loss
Ordinary dividend - - - - - (2,987) (2,987)
paid (note 8)
Balance at 31st 5,614 35,132 (79) 5,596 24,899 3,888 75,050
July 2013
Company
Share Share Other Capital Capital
capital premium reserves reserve reserve Retained
(unrealised) (realised) earnings Total
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Balance at 1st 5,614 35,295 (79) 27,171 3,256 26,581 97,838
August 2011
Changes in equity
for 2012
Total - - - - - (19,851) (19,851)
comprehensive loss
Transfer of - - - (19,092) (4,145) 23,237 -
capital loss
Ordinary dividend - - - - - (2,807) (2,807)
paid (note 8)
Balance at 31st 5,614 35,295 (79) 8,079 (889) 27,160 75,180
July 2012
Changes in equity
for 2013
Total - - - - - 2,865 2,865
comprehensive
income
Transfer of - - - (2,483) 2,419 64 -
capital loss
Ordinary dividend - - - - - (2,987) (2,987)
paid (note 8)
Balance at 31st 5,614 35,295 (79) 5,596 1,530 27,102 75,058
July 2013
Consolidated Statement of Financial Position
At 31st July 2013
2013 2012
Note £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Non-current assets
Investments at fair value through 10 75,689 79,966
profit or loss
Contracts for differences - longs 18 49,457 23,443
125,146 103,409
Current assets
Trade and other receivables 12 190 81
Contracts for differences - shorts 18 55,673 34,637
Cash and cash equivalents 13 21,802 11,432
77,665 46,150
Gross Assets 202,811 149,559
Current liabilities
Borrowings 14 (10,967) (9,899)
Trade and other payables 15 (1,863) (2,052)
Contracts for differences - 18 (114,931) (62,093)
liability
Net assets 75,050 75,515
Equity attributable to equity
holders
Ordinary share capital 16 5,614 5,614
Share premium 35,132 35,132
Other reserves
Capital reserve - realised 24,899 22,916
Capital reserve - unrealised 5,596 8,146
Goodwill reserve (79) (79)
Retained earnings 3,888 3,786
Total equity 75,050 75,515
Net asset value per share
Ordinary shares - basic 17 334.2p 336.3p
18
Ordinary shares - fully diluted 17 334.2p 336.3p
The financial statements were approved by the Board of Directors and authorised
for issue on 23rd October 2013 and are signed on their behalf by:
Mr P H A Stanley (Chairman)
Mr D Harris
Directors
Company Statement of Financial Position
At 31st July 2013
2013 2012
Note £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Non-current assets
Investments at fair value through 10 75,689 79,009
profit or loss
Contracts for differences - longs 18 31,027 23,443
Investment in subsidiaries 11 17 2,180
106,733 104,632
Current assets
Trade and other receivables 12 2,761 83
Contracts for differences - shorts 18 34,180 34,637
Cash and cash equivalents 13 14,134 11,336
51,075 46,056
Gross Assets 157,808 150,688
Current liabilities
Borrowings 14 (10,967) (9,899)
Trade and other payables 15 (1,880) (3,516)
Contracts for differences - 18 (69,903) (62,093)
liability
Net assets 75,058 75,180
Equity attributable to equity
holders
Ordinary share capital 16 5,614 5,614
Share premium 35,295 35,295
Other reserves
Capital reserve - realised 1,530 (889)
Capital reserve - unrealised 5,596 8,079
Goodwill reserve (79) (79)
Retained earnings 27,102 27,160
Total equity 75,058 75,180
The financial statements were approved by the Board of Directors and authorised
for issue on 23rd October 2013 and are signed on their behalf by:
Mr P H A Stanley (Chairman)
Mr D Harris
Directors
Consolidated Statement of Cash Flows
For the year ended 31st July 2013
2013 2012
£'000 £'000
Cash flow from operating activities
Return on operating activities before taxation 2,522 (19,945)
Interest paid 329 367
(Profit)/loss on investments (9,106) 17,288
(Increase)/decrease in receivables (109) 122
(Decrease)/increase in payables (189) 1,829
Decrease in contracts for differences 5,788 3,371
Net cash (used in)/generated from operating (765) 3,032
activities
Cash flow from investing activities
Purchase of investments (16,548) (6,759)
Sale of investments 29,931 11,703
Net cash generated from investing activities 13,383 4,944
Cash flow from financing activities
Equity dividends paid (2,987) (2,807)
Drawn from/(Repaid to) loan facility 1,068 (969)
Interest paid (329) (367)
Net cash used in financing activities (2,248) (4,143)
Net increase in cash and cash equivalents 10,370 3,833
Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of year 11,432 7,599
Cash and cash equivalents at end of year 21,802 11,432
Company Statement of Cash Flows
For the year ended 31st July 2013
2013 2012
£'000 £'000
Cash flow from operating activities
Return on operating activities before taxation 2,865 (19,851)
Interest paid 329 367
(Profit)/loss on investments (9,605) 17,596
(Increase)/decrease in receivables (2,678) 1,350
(Decrease)/increase in payables 1,162 1,964
Decrease in contracts for differences 683 3,637
Net cash generated from operating activities (7,244) 5,063
Cash flow from investing activities
Purchase of investments (16,368) (4,353)
Sale of investments 28,658 9,946
Net cash generated from investing activities 12,290 5,593
Cash flow from financing activities
Equity dividends paid (2,987) (2,807)
Drawn from/(Repaid to) loan facility 1,068 (969)
Interest paid (329) (367)
Net cash used in financing activities (2,248) (4,143)
Net increase in cash and cash equivalents 2,798 6,513
Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of year 11,336 4,823
Cash and cash equivalents at end of year 14,134 11,336
Notes Forming Part of the Financial Statements
For the year ended 31st July 2013
1. Accounting policies
Manchester & London Investment Trust plc ("MLIT") is a public limited company,
which is listed on the London Stock Exchange and is incorporated and domiciled
in the United Kingdom. The consolidated financial statements of the Company for
the year ended 31st July 2013 comprise the Company and its subsidiaries
(together referred to as the `Group' and individually as `Group entities').
a) Basis of preparation and statement of compliance
In accordance with European Union regulations, these financial statements have
been prepared in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards
(IFRS) issued by the International Accounting Standards Board ("IASB"), as
adopted for use in the EU effective at 31st July 2013.
The financial statements have been prepared on the historical cost basis except
where IFRS require an alternative treatment.
To the extent that presentational guidance set out in the Statement of
Recommended Practice ("SORP") for investment trusts revised by the Association
of Investment Companies ("AIC") is inconsistent with the requirements of IFRS,
the Directors have sought to prepare the financial statements on a basis
compliant with the recommendations of the SORP.
2. Income
2013 2012
£'000 £'000
Trading income 627 934
Income from investments
Dividend income 3,181 2,681
Other income
Deposit interest 8 9
Investment income 3,189 2,690
Total income 3,816 3,624
Total income comprises
Trading income 627 934
Dividends 3,181 2,681
Interest 8 9
3,816 3,624
Income from investments
Listed 3,181 2,681
3,181 2,681
3. Investment management fee
2013 2013 2013 2012 2012 2012
Revenue Capital Total Revenue Capital Total
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Investment management 411 - 411 145 268 413
fee
Midas provides investment services to the Company under a management agreement
with a termination period of three months. The annual fee is 0.5 per cent of
the total portfolio value including cash and short term deposits, payable
quarterly in arrears. The fee is not subject to Value Added Tax ("VAT").
Transactions with Midas during the year are disclosed in note 19.
The investment management fee is chargeable 100 per cent to revenue (2012: 35
per cent to revenue and 65 per cent to capital).
4. Other operating expenses
2013 2012
£'000 £'000
Directors' fees 57 70
Staff costs (note 5) - -
Auditors' remuneration - audit 28 28
Registrar fees 10 9
Exchange rate variances 3 4
Other expenses 134 139
232 250
Directors' fees - Subsidiaries 12 25
Directors' fees - Company 45 45
57 70
Fees payable to the Company's auditor for the audit 25 25
of the parent company and consolidated financial
statements
Fees payable to the Company's auditor for other
services:
* the audit of the Company's subsidiaries pursuant 3 3
to legislation
* other services relating to taxation 7 8
35 36
Other operating expenses include irrecoverable VAT where appropriate.
5. Staff numbers and costs
Excluding Directors, the Group employs no members of staff.
Included in Directors' fees above (note 4) are the emoluments paid to the
Chairman as follows:
2013 2012
£'000 £'000
P H A Stanley (Chairman) 18 18
6. Finance costs of flexible revolving loan facility
2013 2012
£'000 £'000
Charged to revenue 2 -
Charged to capital 327 367
329 367
7. Taxation
2013 2013 2013 2012 2012 2012
Revenue Capital Total Revenue Capital Total
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Current UK corporation tax - - - - - -
The charge for the year can be reconciled to the profit per the income
statement as follows:
Profit/(loss) before tax 3,089 (567) 2,522 3,221 (23,166) (19,945)
Tax at the UK corporation 731 (134) 597 773 (5,560) (4,787)
tax rate of 23.67% (2012:
24%)
Tax effect of non-taxable (727) - (727) (643) - (643)
dividends/unrealised
profits
Income not subject to UK (32) - (32) (213) - (213)
corporation tax
Brought forward losses - (30) (30) (1) - (1)
utilised during the period
Losses on investments not - 165 165 - 5,495 5,495
relieved
Other non-taxable income (112) - (112) - - -
less expenses not
deductible for tax
Excess management expenses 140 (1) 139 84 65 149
Current year tax charge - - - - - -
The Company's taxable income exceeded its management expenses, which include
the capital and revenue elements of the management fee. The Company has surplus
management expenses at 31st July 2013 of £2,538,000 (2012: £1,951,000).
At 31st July 2013, there is an unrecognised deferred tax asset, measured at the
standard rate of 23 per cent, of £584,000 (2012: £468,000). This deferred tax
asset relates to surplus management expenses. It is unlikely that the Group
will generate sufficient taxable profits in the future to recover these amounts
and therefore the asset has not been recognised in the year, or in prior years.
As at 31st July 2013, the Company has unrelieved capital losses of £9,330,000
(2012: £9,330,000). There is therefore, a related unrecognised deferred tax
asset, measured at the standard rate of 23 per cent, of £2,146,000 (2012: £
2,239,000). These capital losses can only be utilised to the extent that the
Company does not qualify as an investment trust in the future and, as such, the
asset has not been recognised.
8. Dividends
2013 2012
£'000 £'000
Amounts recognised as distributions to equity holders in
the period:
Final dividend for the year ended 31st July 2012 of 7.8p 1,752 1,639
(2011: 7.3p) per share
Interim dividend for the year ended 31st July 2013 of 1,235 1,168
5.5p (2012: 5.2p) per share
2,987 2,807
A final dividend in respect of 2013 of 8.25p per share which, together with the
interim dividend, amounts to a total dividend of £3,087,843 is to be proposed
at the Annual General Meeting on 2nd December 2013 and has been excluded as a
liability in these financial statements in accordance with IFRS.
We also set out below the total dividend payable in respect of the financial
year, which is the basis on which the requirements of section 1158 of the
Corporation Tax Act 2010 are considered.
2013 2012
£'000 £'000
Interim dividend for the year ended 31st July 2013 of 5.5p 1,235 1,168
(2012: 5.2p) per share
Proposed final dividend for the year ended 31st July 2013 1,853 1,752
of 8.25p (2012: 7.8p) per share
3,088 2,920
9. Return per ordinary share
The calculation of the basic and fully diluted earnings per ordinary share is
based on the following:
2013 2013 2013 2012 2012 2012
Revenue Capital Total Revenue Capital Total
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Return:
Basic and fully diluted 3,089 (567) 2,522 3,221 (23,166) (19,945)
Basic revenue, capital and total return per ordinary share is based on the net
revenue, capital and total return for the period and on the weighted average
number of ordinary shares in issue of 22,457,042 (2012: 22,457,042).
10. Investments at fair value through profit or loss
Group Company
2013 2012 2013 2012
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Investments as below 75,689 79,966 75,689 79,009
Group Group Group Company Company Company
Listed Unlisted Total Listed Unlisted Total
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Opening cost at 1st 67,751 56 67,807 66,861 56 66,917
August
Opening unrealised 12,089 70 12,159 12,022 70 12,092
appreciation at 1st
August
Opening fair value at 79,840 126 79,966 78,883 126 79,009
1st August
Purchases at cost 16,548 - 16,548 16,368 - 16,368
Sales proceeds (29,931) - (29,931) (28,658) - (28,658)
Realised profit on 5,761 - 5,761 5,558 - 5,558
sales
Increase/(decrease) in 3,347 (2) 3,345 3,414 (2) 3,412
unrealised appreciation
Closing fair value at 75,565 124 75,689 75,565 124 75,689
31st July
Closing cost at 31st 60,129 56 60,185 60,129 56 60,185
July
Closing unrealised 15,436 68 15,504 15,436 68 15,504
appreciation at 31st
July
Closing fair value at 75,565 124 75,689 75,565 124 75,689
31st July
Gross capital return Group Company
2013 2012 2013 2012
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Realised gains/(losses) on sale of 1,859 (2,726) 1,656 (2,967)
investments
Transfer of investments to contracts 3,902 450 3,902 450
for differences
Realised profit on sales and transfers 5,761 (2,276) 5,558 (2,517)
of investments
Realised gains on short duration (289) (231) (284) -
investment holdings
Realised gain on subsidiaries - - 635 -
Increase/(decrease) in unrealised 3,238 (15,012) 3,304 (15,079)
appreciation
Contracts for differences movement (8,950) (4,969) (8,950) (4,969)
excluding trading income
(240) (22,488) 263 (22,565)
11. Subsidiary undertakings
Company
2013 2012
£'000 £'000
Opening cost at 1st August 2,180 2,180
Subsidiaries purchase of own shares (2,163) -
Closing cost at 31st July 17 2,180
The Company has investments in the following subsidiary undertakings:
Name of undertaking Principal Country % of shares held
Activity of
incorporation Ordinary Preference
and operation shares shares
OSP Limited Trading Company Guernsey 100 -
Stakeholders' Momentum Investment England 100 -
Investment Limited Company
Manchester & London Dormant England 100 -
Securities Limited
Saintclose Limited Dormant England 100 -
Beacontree Plaza Limited Dormant England 100 100
Beaconbranch Limited Dormant England 100* -
Darethrift Limited Dormant England 100 -
Fileglow Limited Dormant England 100 -
Zealgate Limited Dormant England 100 -
All these subsidiary undertakings are included in the consolidation.
*Beaconbranch Limited is 100 per cent owned by Beacontree Plaza Limited.
On 15th February 2013 Stakeholders' Momentum Investment Limited implemented a
buyback of its own shares.
Under the terms of the buyback agreement SMIL bought and cancelled, via a
capital reduction, 5,727,693 of its issued ordinary 25 pence shares for a
consideration of £1,626,000. This was settled via a corresponding reduction in
the SMIL loan balance due from MLIT.
On 11th July 2013 OSP implemented a buyback of its own shares.
Under the terms of the buyback agreement OSP bought and cancelled, via a
capital reduction, 1,156,202 of its issued ordinary 10 pence shares for a
consideration of £1,172,000. This was settled via a corresponding reduction in
the OSP loan balance due from MLIT.
In the opinion of the Directors, there is no material difference between the
book value and fair value of these investments.
12. Trade and other receivables
Group Company
2013 2012 2013 2012
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Receivables from - - 2,571 8
subsidiary undertakings
Dividend receivables 49 61 49 61
Other receivables 133 6 133 -
Prepayments 8 14 8 14
190 81 2,761 83
13. Cash and cash equivalents
Group Company
2013 2012 2013 2012
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Cash & cash equivalents 21,802 11,432 14,134 11,336
14. Borrowings
The Company operates a Flexible Revolving Loan Facility with a limit of £11m
with Pershing Securities Limited ("Pershing"), a subsidiary of The Bank of New
York Mellon Corporation. No arrangement fee is payable on this facility and
interest is charged at the Bank of England Base Rate plus three per cent per
annum on drawdowns. This facility is secured against the Company's investments.
In respect of this loan Pershing have a floating charge on the assets it holds
for the group in custody alongside any margin requirements in respect of group
investments.
As at 31st July 2013, the balance on the facility was £10,967,000 (2012: £
9,899,000).
15. Trade and other payables
Group Company
2013 2012 2013 2012
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Trade payables 99 106 99 106
Payables to - - 17 3,345
subsidiary undertakings
Accruals 1,764 1,946 1,764 65
1,863 2,052 1,880 3,516
16. Share Capital
Ordinary share capital 2013 2012
No.(`000) £'000 No.(`000) £'000
Authorised
Ordinary shares of 25p each 28,000 7,000 28,000 7,000
Non-voting Convertible Preference shares 1,000 1,000 1,000 1,000
of £1 each
Ordinary shares of 25p each issued and
fully paid
Balance as at 1st August 22,457 5,614 22,457 5,614
Balance as at 31st July 22,457 5,614 22,457 5,614
Each ordinary share carries the right to one vote in any circumstances and the
right to dividends paid.
17. Net asset value per share
Net asset value Net assets
per share attributable
2013 2012 2013 2012
p p £'000 £'000
Ordinary shares: 334.2 336.3 75,050 75,515
basic and fully diluted
The basic net asset value per ordinary share is based on net assets at the year
end and 22,457,042 (2012: 22,457,042) ordinary shares in issue, adjusted for
any shares held in treasury.
18. Risks - Contracts for differences, derivatives, other financial instruments
and other risks
In order to manage its portfolio efficiently and to enable the Investment
Manager to pursue the investment objectives, the Group holds contracts for
differences, derivatives and other financial instruments. All contracts for
differences, derivative transactions and financial instruments are accounted
for at fair value and comprise securities, cash balances, trade receivables and
trade payables arising directly from financial operations.
The main risk arising from the Group's investment strategy is market price
risk. There is also exposure to liquidity risk, interest rate risk and currency
rate risk.
The Board regularly reviews and agrees policies for managing these risks, which
are monitored by the Administrator, as summarised below.
Market price risk
Market price risk arises mainly from uncertainty about future prices of
financial instruments held. It represents the potential loss the Group might
suffer through holding market positions in the face of price movements. Both
the Investment Manager and the Administrator actively monitor market prices
throughout the year and report to the Board which meets regularly to review
investment strategy.
If the price of these investments and the contracts for differences had
increased by 3 per cent at the reporting date with all other variables
remaining constant, the capital return in the statement of comprehensive income
and the net assets attributable to equity holders of the Group would increase
by £2,081,000.
A 3 per cent decrease in share prices would have resulted in an equal and
opposite effect of £2,081,000, on the basis that all other variables remain
constant.
At the year end the Group's assets exposed to market price risk were as
follows:
Group Company
2013 2012 2013 2012
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Non-current assets
Investments held in equity form 75,689 79,966 75,706 81,189
Contracts for differences - longs 49,457 23,443 31,027 23,443
Current assets
Contracts for differences - shorts 55,673 34,637 34,180 34,637
180,819 138,046 140,913 139,269
During the year the Group transacted in contracts for differences and
derivative investments.
The positions held in CFDs as at the year end are as follows:
Group Company
2013 2012 2013 2012
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Non-current assets 49,457 23,443 31,027 23,443
Contracts for differences - longs
Current assets 55,673 34,637 34,180 34,637
Contracts for differences - shorts
Current liabilities (114,931) (62,093) (69,903) (62,093)
Contracts for differences - liability
(9,801) (4,013) (4,696) (4,013)
Interest rate risk
Interest rate risk arises from uncertainty over the interest rates charged by
financial institutions. It represents the potential increased costs of
financing for the Group. The Investment Manager actively monitors interest
rates and the Group's ability to meet its financing requirements throughout the
year and reports to the Board.
At 31st July 2013, there is a flexible loan facility within the Group.
See note 14 for further details.
Liquidity risk
The Directors have minimised liquidity risk by investing in a portfolio of
quoted companies that are readily realisable.
The Group's un-invested funds are held almost entirely with the Custodian or on
interest bearing deposits with UK banking institutions.
As at 31st July 2013 the financial liabilities comprised:
Group Company
2013 2012 2013 2012
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Contracts for differences - liability 114,931 62,093 69,903 62,093
Loan facility 10,967 9,899 10,967 9,899
Trade payables and accruals 1,863 2,052 1,880 3,516
127,761 74,044 82,750 75,508
Group Company
2013 2012 2013 2012
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Of the above liabilities the following 126,081 72,168 81,070 75,508
are due within one month
All the above liabilities are stated at fair value.
The Group manages liquidity risk through constant monitoring of the Group's
gearing position to ensure the Group is able to satisfy any and all debts
within the agreed credit terms.
Currency rate risk
The only material foreign currency holdings are S&P 500 Index shorts, Jardine
Matheson stock and HMS Hydraulics stock with market values of £48,076,000, £
4,384,000 and £1,385,000 respectively, denominated in US Dollars, Echo
Entertainment stock with market value of £1,802,000, denominated in Australian
Dollars, Etablissements Maurel et Prom stock with market value of £1,718,000
denominated in Euro and Syngenta stock with a market value of £6,160,000,
denominated in Swiss Francs.
The Group constantly monitors currency rate risk to ensure balances wherever
possible are translated at rates favourable to the group.
19. Related party transactions
The Investment Manager of the Company is Midas Investment Management Limited
("Midas"), a Company controlled by Mr M Sheppard. Midas receives a quarterly
investment management fee for these services which in the year under review
amounted to a total of £411,000 (2012: £413,000) excluding VAT, together with a
corporate fee for acting as financial adviser amounting to £30,000 (2012: £
30,000) excluding VAT to the Company and commission fees of £141,000 (2012: £
100,000) excluding VAT to the Group. The balance owing to Midas at 31st July
2013 was £96,000 (2012: £102,000).
The Company's subsidiaries are listed in note 11, along with details of loan
reductions in SMIL and OSP.
To support revenue recognition in line with accounting policy, during the year
positions of £2,563,000 were transferred from MLIT into OSP (2012: £2,430,000
transferred from OSP into MLIT). In addition dividends of £Nil (2012: £
1,050,000) were paid from subsidiaries.
As at 31st July 2013, the Company had the following outstanding interest free
loans:
i. £2,563,000 due from OSP Limited (2012: £2,837,000 due to OSP Limited).
ii. £Nil due to Stakeholders' Momentum Investment Limited (2012: £491,000).
iii. £10,000 due to Saintclose Limited (2012: £10,000).
iv. £8,000 due from Manchester & London Securities Limited (2012: £8,000).
v. £7,000 due to Beacontree Plaza Limited (2012: £7,000).
20. Capital Management
There are no externally imposed capital requirements. The capital managed is
noted in the Statements of Changes in Equity and managed in accordance with the
Investment Policies and Objectives.
21. Ultimate control
The holding company and ultimate parent throughout the year and the previous
year was Manchester & Metropolitan Investment Limited, a company incorporated
in England and Wales. This company was controlled throughout the year and the
previous year by Mr M Sheppard and his immediate family.
A copy of the consolidated financial statements of Manchester & Metropolitan
Investment Limited can be obtained by writing to The Company Secretary, 2nd
Floor, Arthur House, Chorlton Street, Manchester M1 3FH.
22. Annual General Meeting
The Company's forty first Annual General Meeting will be held at St. Ann's
Church, St. Ann Street, Manchester M2 7LF, on Monday 2 2nd December 2013 at
1.05pm.
The notice of this meeting can be found along with the full Annual Report and
Financial Statements on the Company's website www.manchesterandlondon.co.uk.
For further information, please contact:
Manchester & London Investment Trust plc
Tel: 0161 228 2389
Midas Investment Management Limited
Tel: 0161 228 1709