Final Results - Year Ended 31 January 2000
Berry Birch & Noble PLC
12 May 2000
Berry Birch & Noble, a leading Independent Financial Services Group, today
announced preliminary results for the full year ended 31 January 2000.
Berry Birch & Noble plc
Preliminary Results 2000
FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS
2000 1999 %
£000 £000 Change
Turnover 9,340 8,308 +12%
Operating profit before exceptional 873 750 +16%
item
Profit before exceptional item and 943 840 +12%
taxation
(Loss) profit before taxation (1,357) 321
Basic earnings per share before 11.8p 11.3p +4%
exceptional item
Dividend 1.0p 3.0p -67%
Net (debt) funds (310) 602
Dividend cover before exceptional item 11.8 times 3.7 times
Employees at 31 January 238 186 +28%
Commenting today Sir Jeremy Black, Chairman, said 'I am pleased to report a
further improvement in profitability for the year ended 31 January 2000.
Group profit before exceptional item and taxation advanced to £943,000
(1999:£840,000), an increase of 12% on the previous year's figure'.
Derek Berry, Chief Executive, said 'As indicated in the Chairman's Statement,
revenue grew in our last half-year period by 23% year-on-year. This momentum
has continued into the current financial year and the results for both
February and March 2000 were above management's expectations.
For further information:
John Owen, Finance Director
Berry Birch & Noble 020 8776 1297
CHAIRMAN'S STATEMENT
In my second full year as Chairman, I am pleased to report a further
improvement in profitability for the year ended 31 January 2000. Group profit
before exceptional item and taxation advanced to £943,000 (1999:£840,000), an
increase of 12% on the previous year's figure. It is encouraging to see that
after a number of years, during which time operating results have fluctuated,
we have at last been able to build a solid foundation from which we can
deliver profitable and sustainable growth.
The current year's results were achieved by an increase of 12% in both
turnover and operating costs before exceptional item, when compared with the
previous financial year. At the interim stage I had explained that operating
costs had risen at a faster rate than revenue in the first half of the year.
This was due to our wish to strengthen the organisational structure of the
Group and the additional expenditure needed relating to the Year 2000 issue.
I am pleased to confirm that this situation reversed significantly in the
second half of the year with revenue having increased at a much faster rate
than operating costs.
Over the last few years the second half of our financial year has been
historically weaker than the first, partly due to the fact that the end of
the tax year in April falls into our first half, a time when many clients are
seeking advice. However, due to continued organic growth and the positive
effects of the acquisitions completed over the last months, revenue in the
second half outstripped that of the first half - the first time for many
years that it has done so - and represented revenue growth of 23% as compared
with the same period last year. Equally, due to stringent efforts to keep
operating costs under control, operating profit before exceptional item in
the second half accelerated significantly as compared with the same period
last year.
As I mentioned to you at the interim stage, the Group has started to expand
by acquisition and details of those acquisitions, including that of the
personal financial planning business of Moores Marr Bradley were highlighted
at that time. Since then the pace of expansion has accelerated following the
acquisition in October 1999 of the major part of the financial services
division of the Bradstock Group. This latter acquisition has significantly
contributed to increased revenue and profit in the last three months of our
financial year to 31 January 2000.
Pensions Review
I have written previously about the Pensions Review and our wish to complete
phase 2 of the Review as quickly as possible. With this in mind, we have made
a good start in reviewing cases where clients have expressed such a wish.
However, as a result of this work, it has become apparent that the provision
for redress which we had already made in previous years will now be
insufficient to cover the expected liabilities from the Review. It is for
this reason that we have decided, regrettably, to increase at this time our
Pensions Review provision by a further £2,300,000.
I would again like to stress that, contrary to all the media hype about
'pensions mis-selling', we have not found any evidence of mis-selling
whatsoever during our review work. However, advice given up to 10 years ago,
which we believe satisfied the regulations in place at that time, as well as
the regulator, is now being judged against the stricter compliance regime in
place today. Many observers have commented that natural justice has been
overridden, whereby the industry is being requested to pay compensation to
clients who have not suffered, and may never suffer, financial loss, and
where the high cost of redress results mainly from the current low annuity
rates and the reduced investment returns available to pension funds
subsequent to the removal of the tax credit on dividend income.
The total cost of redress will be higher than previously expected due to two
major reasons. Firstly, indications are that the average cost of redress for
phase 2 cases will turn out to be far higher than estimated in the FSA's
consultation paper CP7, the basis on which our provision had previously been
estimated. Secondly, the 'success' of the Government's well-publicised
'R.U.OWED?' campaign has generated levels of response far greater than those
anticipated by the industry.
Dividends
Due to the additional provision that has been deemed necessary in relation to
the Pensions Review, the directors believe it inappropriate to propose a
final dividend. The Board intends to restore dividend payments as soon as is
practicable.
Change of name
Last year we indicated a number of strategic objectives that the Board had
set out to achieve. The main thrust of this strategy was to improve
profitability, and to grow, both organically and by acquisition. As we move
towards these goals, the Board has considered it appropriate, at this time,
to modernise the image of the Company. For this reason, a proposal will be
made at the Annual General Meeting this year to change the name of the
Company to Berry Birch plc.
Appreciation
I would like to take this opportunity to thank our shareholders for their
support, and my fellow Board members, as well as management and staff, for
their hard work that has laid the foundation to our continuing expansion.
Sir Jeremy Black
Chairman
12 May 2000
CHIEF EXECUTIVE'S REVIEW OF OPERATIONS
Whilst the Group has achieved increased revenue from ongoing business
activities, the most significant boost during the financial year under review
came from the acquisition of the major part of the financial services
business of the Bradstock Group. This acquisition has enabled us to expand
our representation across the United Kingdom by a further five branches, four
of which are in City Centre locations in Birmingham, Nottingham, Manchester
and Glasgow. This will strengthen the service the Group can provide to our
expanding corporate client base.
For a number of years the Group has been managed by an organisational
structure based on four business streams. However, following the substantial
expansion of the Group in the last year, the increased number of branches
made it impractical and unwieldy to continue managing our financial services
arm in this way, and as a result our business now operates under a regional
structure encompassing twelve U.K. offices. Only our insurance broking
operation is managed separately.
Personal Financial Planning
With the wealth of the population growing, there is an increasing need for
financial advice. Our team of skilled financial planning consultants perform
this vital role. The services we provide to employees and pensioners of major
companies make up much of our work in this area. Our involvement in seminars
ensures a healthy flow of new clients, added to our already impressive list
of FTSE100 companies and activity has increased considerably.
Mortgages
A mortgage is likely to be one of the largest financial commitments any
person will undertake, and thus it is essential to obtain quality advice. Our
consultants continue to provide professional advice, which is paramount,
especially with the very large number of schemes available. However, business
in this area has declined during the last year and adverse publicity
surrounding the future of the endowment mortgage has not been helpful. Whilst
endowment mortgages can still be attractive in certain circumstances, the
removal of MIRAS tax relief and lower bonus payments has made them less
competitive. We are now active in repositioning our marketing to attract new
clients through our call centre and intranet sites.
Group Employee Benefits
During the course of last year, our team of employee benefits advisers was
strengthened. This operation provides advice to a wide spectrum of clients,
particularly the small to medium-sized employer, covering most aspects of
employee benefits, e.g. pension, life assurance, permanent health and private
medical insurance. The latter is now being recognised as a very valuable part
of an employee's package and, with the well-publicised problems of the
National Health Service, looks set to continue in popularity despite ever
increasing costs. Our legal and actuarial departments provide valuable
support to our clients and offer a truly comprehensive service. With the
advent of the stakeholder pension, due to start in April 2001, employers will
be seeking independent advice on which route to take and how this would
affect their existing occupational schemes. We are well placed to give that
advice.
Insurance Broking
This operation has comfortably exceeded targets for the year and personal
lines are doing particularly well. The hardening of rates by direct writers
has meant that the public is beginning to appreciate that it is worthwhile to
search the market for competitive quotes on household, motor and travel
insurance. This division has developed some innovative schemes which are
marketed to our affinity groups with excellent results. Our plans are to
expand significantly our insurance broking business over the coming months
and we have recently acquired additional premises adjoining our existing
Summit House office to facilitate this strategy.
Marketing
We have been very active in this area during the past year, through regular
mailings to our increased client base. Marketing the Group's services to
employees and pensioners of our corporate clients continues through bulletins
and other communications. This department also organises all seminars run on
behalf of our corporate clients. Once again we have been very successful in
building new relationships with corporate clients.
Outlook
There is a growing awareness amongst the public of the need for financial
advice to protect their personal wealth. The Group is ideally placed to
benefit from the consolidation of the IFA market, a result of the Pensions
Review, and intends to remain one of the key players in the industry.
As indicated in the Chairman's Statement, revenue grew in our last half-year
period by 23% year-on-year. This momentum has continued into the current
financial year and the results for both February and March 2000 were above
management's expectations.
Gratitude
I am, as always, appreciative of the continued support given to me by my
fellow directors and the staff. My thanks to them for their commitment and
loyalty.
Derek Berry
Chief Executive
12 May 2000
UNAUDITED CONSOLITATED PROFIT AND LOSS ACCOUNT
for the year ended 31 January 2000
Before Before
except-ional Except except- Except-ional
-
ional ional
item item Total item item Total
(Note (Note 11) 1999
11)
2000 2000 2000 1999 1999
Note £000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000
Turnover 2 9,340 - 9,340 8,308 - 8,308
Operating (8,467) (2,300)(10,767) (7,558) (519) (8,077)
costs
Operating 2 873 (2,300) (1,427) 750 (519) 231
(loss)
profit
Net 3 70 - 70 90 - 90
interest
receivable
(Loss) 2 943 (2,300) (1,357) 840 (519) 321
profit
before
taxation
Taxation 4 (175) 193 18 (106) 163 57
(Loss) 768 (2,107) (1,339) 734 (356) 378
profit
after
taxation
Dividends 5 (65) - (65) (196) - (196)
Retained 703 (2,107) (1,404) 538 (356) 182
(loss)
profit
for the
year
(Loss)
earnings
per
share
- basic 6 11.8p (32.3p) (20.5p) 11.3p (5.5p) 5.8p
- diluted 6 11.8p (32.3p) (20.5p) 11.3p (5.5p) 5.8p
UNAUDITED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF TOTAL RECOGNISED GAINS AND LOSSES
for the year ended 31 January 2000
2000 1999
£000 £000
(Loss) profit after taxation (1,339) 378
Surplus on revaluation of property 482 -
Total recognised gains and losses for the year (857) 378
BIRCH BERRY & NOBLE PLC
UNAUDITED CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEET AT
31 JANUARY 2000
2000 1999
£000 £000
Fixed Assets
Intangible 506 -
Tangible 1,862 1,559
Investments in subsidiary companies - -
2,368 1,559
Current Assets
Debtors 2,472 2,139
Cash at bank 690 1,468
3,162 3,607
Creditors: amounts falling due within one year (2,270) (3,386)
Net current assets 892 221
Total assets less current liabilities 3,260 1,780
Creditors: amounts falling due after more than one (450) -
year
Provision for liabilities and charges (2,652) (700)
Net assets 158 1,080
Capital and reserves
Called-up share capital 652 652
Share premium account 78 78
Revaluation reserve 482 -
Profit and loss account (1,054) 350
Equity shareholders' funds 158 1,080
Berry Birch & Noble plc
UNAUDITED CONSOLIDATED CASH FLOW STATEMENT
for year ended 31 January 2000
2000 1999
£000 £000
Net cash (outflow) inflow from operating activities. Note 8 (177) 677
Returns on investments and servicing of finance
Interest received 99 144
Interest paid (29) (54)
Net cash inflow from returns on investments and servicing 70 90
of finance
Taxation
Taxation recovered (paid) 11 (48)
Net cash inflow (outflow) from taxation recovered (paid) 11 (48)
Capital expenditure
Purchase of tangible fixed assets (295) (124)
Sale of tangible fixed assets 317 183
Net cash inflow from capital expenditure 22 59
Acquisitions and disposals
Purchase of business operations (642) -
Net cash outflow from acquisitions and disposals (642) -
Equity dividends paid
Dividends paid (196) (130)
Net cash outflow from equity dividends paid (196) (130)
Net cash (outflow) inflow before financing (912) 648
Financing
Capital element of finance lease repayments (366) (307)
Incremental bank loan 500 -
Net cash inflow (outflow) from financing 134 (307)
(Decrease) increase in cash in the year (778) 341
Balance at 1 February 1,468 1,127
Balance at 31 January 690 1,468
NOTES TO THE UNAUDITED FINANCIAL RESULTS
1 Basis of Preparation
These financial results have been prepared on the basis of the accounting
policies set out in the Group's statutory accounts for the year ended 31
January 1999. The information contained in these financial results for the
year ended 31 January 2000 does not constitute statutory accounts as
defined in section 240 of the Companies Act 1985. The financial results
have been extracted from the unaudited accounts.
The financial results for the preceding year have been extracted from the
statutory accounts for the financial year ended 31 January 1999. Those
accounts upon which the auditors issued an unqualified opinion have been
delivered to the Registrar of Companies.
2 Segmental Information
The analysis by class of the Group's turnover, all of which is derived from
external clients, and (loss) profit before taxation is set out below:
2000 1999
£000 £000
Turnover
Financial Services 7,270 6,589
Insurance broking 2,070 1,719
9,340 8,308
(Loss) profit before taxation
Financial services (1,566) 74
Insurance broking 139 157
Operating (loss) profit (1,427) 231
Net Interest receivable 70 90
(1,357) 321
3 Net Interest receivable
2000 1999
£000 £000
Interest receivable - on bank balances 99 144
Interest payable - on finance leases (29) (54)
70 90
4. Taxation
Before Except-ional Total Before Except-ional Total
except-ional item except-ional item
item item 1999 £000
2000 £000 2000 £000 1999 £000
2000 1999
£000
£000
UK 175 (175) - 109 (109) -
corporation
tax at
27%
(1999:21%)
Advance - (18) (18) - (54) (54)
corporation
tax
written
back
Prior - - - (3) - (3)
years
175 (193) (18) 106 (163) (57)
The taxation charge for the year before exceptional item incorporates
certain permanent disallowable expenses. The exceptional item taxation
credit comprises appropriate relief for the Pensions Review provision
together with advance corporation tax written back, which the directors
believe will be relieved in the forthcoming financial year. At 31 January
2000 and at 31 January 1999, no provision for deferred tax was necessary
under the Group's accounting policy in that there were no material timing
differences.
5. Dividends
2000 1999
£000 £000
Interim dividend of 1p per share (1999:1p) 65 65
Final dividend passed (1999:2p) - 131
65 196
6. (Loss) earnings per share
The calculation of the basic loss per share of 20.5p (1999: 5.8p earnings)
is based on loss after taxation of £1,339,000 (1999: £378,000 profit)
divided by the number of shares in issue during the year of 6,516,836
(1999: 6,516,836). The diluted loss per share of 20.5p (1999: 5.8p
earnings) is based on the same loss after taxation of £1,339,000 (1999:
£378,000 profit) divided by 6,516,836 (1999: 6,516,836) shares.
The basic earnings per share before exceptional item of 11.8p (1999: 11.3p)
is based on profit before exceptional item but after taxation of £768,000
(1999: £734,000) divided by the number of shares in issue during the year
of 6,516,836 (1999: 6,516,836).
7. Reconciliation of movements in shareholders' funds
2000 1999
£000 £000
(Loss) profit for the financial year (1,339) 378
Dividends (65) (196)
Revaluation of property 482 -
Net (decrease) increase in shareholders' funds (922) 182
Opening shareholders' funds 1,080 898
Closing shareholders' funds 158 1,080
8. Reconciliation of operating profit to net cash (outflow) inflow from
operating activities
2000 1999
£000 £000
Operating profit before exceptional item 873 750
Exceptional item-Pensions Review payments made net of (961) (622)
recoveries
Amortisation of goodwill 16 -
Depreciation charges 257 284
Loss on sale of tangible fixed assets 20 3
(Increase) decrease in debtors (532) 57
Increase in creditors and provisions 150 205
Net cash (outflow) inflow from operating activities (177) 677
9. Reconciliation of net cash flow to movement in net (debt) funds
2000 1999
£000 £000
(Decrease) increase in cash in the year (778) 341
Cash to repay finance leases 366 307
Change in net (debt) funds resulting from cash flows (412) 648
Other non-cash items: new finance leases - (81)
Incremental bank loan (500) -
Movement in net (debt) funds in the period (912) 567
Net funds at 1 February 602 35
Net (debt) funds at 31 January (310) 602
10. Analysis of net (debt) funds
At 1 February 1999 Cash flow At 31 January 2000
£000 £000
£000
Cash at bank 1,468 (778) 690
Loan (500) (500) (1,000)
968 (1,278) (310)
Finance leases (366) 366 -
Net (debt) 602 (912) (310)
funds
11 Pensions Review
The Securities and Investments Board issued a report 'Pension Transfers and
Opt Outs, Review of Past Business' in October 1994 and a further report
'Simplifying the Pensions Review' in November 1996 (phase 1). The objective
was to secure compensation for individuals who since 29 April 1988, the
effective date of the Financial Services Act 1986, had been advised to
transfer or opt out of an occupational pension scheme and have thereby
suffered actual or potential loss.
Based on criteria and procedures set out in these reports, Berry Birch &
Noble Financial Services Ltd (a subsidiary of Berry Birch & Noble plc), as
an intermediary regulated by the Personal Investment Authority (PIA), has
been conducting a review of personal pension business during the relevant
period. The purpose of this review was to assess the extent to which any
compensation should be paid to clients.
In March 1998, the Financial Services Authority (FSA) and the PIA issued a
consultation paper on proposals for a phase 2 of the Pension Transfers and
Opt Outs Review. The purpose of the paper was to give guidance for the
review of those non-priority cases, the so-called younger lives, that were
not reviewed in phase 1. The paper sets out certain estimations of the
number of cases concerned, and an estimate of the probable losses in
respect of transfers, in which the Group was primarily involved. The
directors had estimated the potential range of loss, taking into account
their review of the potential cases, their experience with phase 1 and the
various assumptions in the paper. A further paper has been issued by the
FSA that amends certain assumptions about the numbers likely to seek
redress in phase 2.
As a result of progress made in phase 2 of the Pensions Review it has
become apparent that the total provision for redress already constituted of
£1,819,000 in prior years will be insufficient. The need to increase the
provision has resulted from the average cost of redress for Phase 2 turning
out to be higher than previously estimated as well as higher numbers
seeking redress. A further exceptional item of £2,300,000 was taken to
cover the additional costs of redress and associated costs to complete the
Review. The additional provision is based on up-to-date information,
however, the actual liability may differ as more information becomes
available.
12. The Annual General Meeting will be held at 32 Portland Place, London
W1N 4JP on Wednesday, 21 June 2000 at 11.30 a.m.