Final Results
Cropper(James) PLC
20 June 2006
Issued by Citigate Dewe Rogerson Ltd, Birmingham
Date: Tuesday, 20 June 2006
Embargoed: 7.30am
James Cropper PLC
Preliminary Results
for the year ended 1 April 2006
Full year to Full year to
1 April 2 April
2006 2005
Turnover £64.2m £64.6m
Group profit/(loss) before tax £0.3m £2.4m
Prior to net IFRS pension adjustments (£0.1m) £1.6m
After net IFRS pension adjustments
(Losses)/Earnings per share (1.2p) 12.6p
Dividend per share 4.1p 8.2p
Gearing 46% 43%
TFP total sales up 9%; TFP US sales up 16%
Paper Mill Shop turnover up 18% with 5 new outlets opened
Energy costs increased by 54% over last year
'The outlook for Speciality Papers will remain difficult for the foreseeable
future given the volatile nature of energy markets. Global pulp inventories
continue to decline, owing to strong demand and reduced pulp production, mostly
resulting from closures in North America. As a consequence pulp is expected to
advance on an upward trend in the current financial year. It should therefore be
anticipated that the profitability of Speciality Papers will deteriorate further
in the short term'.
'I am encouraged by the recent improvement in the performance of Technical Fibre
Products. An emerging portfolio of new product developments combined with a
well-managed cost base provides confidence that this improvement will continue
despite the recent weakening of the US$'.
'Despite the current slow down in consumer spending across the retail sector
development of The Paper Mill Shop brand will progress through new routes to
market'.
'I am very disappointed that it has been necessary to reduce this year's final
dividend payment. In due course management plans, backed by the Board's firm
resolve, will return the Group to acceptable levels of profitability, therefore
enabling our progressive dividend policy to be restored'.
J A Cropper, Chairman
FULL STATEMENT ATTACHED
Enquiries:
Alun Lewis, Chief Executive
John Denman, Group Finance Director Katie Dale
James Cropper PLC Citigate Dewe Rogerson
Today: 020 7638 9571 (8.00am - 11.30am) Today: 020 7638 9571
Thereafter: 01539 722002 Thereafter: 0121 455 8370
www.cropper.com Mobile: 07770 788624
-2-
------------------------------------------------------------
Summary of Results IFRS basis UK GAAP basis
Group 5 Year Performance 2006 2005 2005 2004 2003 2002
Group turnover £'000 64,201 64,568 64,568 58,010 56,419 55,835
------------------------------------------------------------
Profit and Loss Summary £'000
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Trading activities
Paper Division
(papermaking
and retail) (6) 2,157 2,207 806 1,011 1,064
Converting
Division 62 385 389 438 551 1,069
Technical
Fibre Products 777 521 522 506 646 314
---------------------------------------------------------
'On-going'
trading
operating
profit 833 3,063 3,118 1,750 2,208 2,447
Profit on sale
of trade
investment 116
---------------------------------------------------------
Trading operating
profit 949 3,063 3,118 1,750 2,208 2,447
Joint Venture (89) (114) (114) (93) (23)
Other
income/(expenditure) (200) (200) (50) 16 (271)
---------------------------------------------------------
Trading profit
before
interest 860 2,749 2,804 1,607 2,201 2,176
Net interest (511) (357) (337) (355) (408) (629)
---------------------------------------------------------
Trading profit
before tax 349 2,392 2,467 1,252 1,793 1,547
---------------------------------------------------------
(After future service
pension contributions
paid)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net pension adjustments
Operating
profit (364) (423) (696) (467) 74 (21)
Net interest (114) (330)
---------------------------------------------------------
Net pension
adjustment
before tax (478) (753) (696) (467) 74 (21)
---------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Group after
pension adjustments
Operating
profit 585 2,640 2,422 1,283 2,282 2,426
Joint Venture (89) (114) (114) (93) (23)
Other
(expenditure)/
income (200) (200) (50) 16 (271)
---------------------------------------------------------
Profit before
interest 496 2,326 2,108 1,140 2,275 2,155
Net interest (625) (687) (337) (355) (408) (629)
---------------------------------------------------------
(Loss)/Profit
before Tax (129) 1,639 1,771 785 1,867 1,526
---------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(Losses)/Earnings
per Share (1.2p) 12.6p 13.8p 7.6p 15.1p 9.2p
Dividends per
Share 4.1p 8.2p 8.2p 7.8p 7.5p 7.0p
---------------------------------------------------------
Balance Sheet Summary £'000
Non-pension Assets - excl.
Cash 46,668 47,005 46,155 45,759 43,627 44,190
Non-pension
Liabilities - excl.
Borrowings (11,993) (11,524) (12,044) (11,184) (10,376) (10,864)
---------------------------------------------------------
34,675 35,481 34,111 34,575 33,251 33,326
Net pension
(liabilities)/
assets (7,221) (7,495) 831 (73) 394 320
----------------------------------------------------------
27,454 27,986 34,942 34,502 33,645 33,646
Net Borrowings (8,595) (8,350) (7,404) (7,427) (6,526) (7,164)
----------------------------------------------------------
Equity
shareholders'
funds 18,859 19,636 27,538 27,075 27,119 26,482
----------------------------------------------------------
Gearing % 46 43 27 27 24 27
----------------------------------------------------------
Capital
Expenditure
£'000 2,889 3,228 3,228 3,101 2,299 2,750
----------------------------------------------------------
-3-
STATEMENT BY THE CHAIRMAN, J A CROPPER
I am disappointed to report that the Group recorded a small loss before tax of
£129,000 for the year (a profit of £349,000 prior to net IFRS pension
adjustments). This compares with a profit before tax of £1,639,000 for the
previous year (a profit of £2,392,000 prior to net IFRS pension adjustments).
In my thirty-five years as Chairman I have never previously experienced a year
during which the papermaking business has had to absorb such dramatic and rapid
increases in its cost base. At the AGM on 3 August 2005 I drew attention to the
adverse impact that the rising cost of energy would have on the profitability of
the Group and James Cropper Speciality Papers in particular. In fact the Group's
cost of energy consumption increased over the previous year by £1,443,000 to
£4,139,000, up 54%. In such difficult trading conditions, Speciality Papers did
well to limit its loss to such a low level.
Our policy of diversification proved its worth in the year. In contrast to the
difficulties that confronted Speciality Papers, I am pleased to report that
Technical Fibre Products delivered a significant improvement in profitability
during the year.
Since 1989 the Group has held a 35% holding in Pacofa S.A., a converting company
located in northern France. Over recent years the performance of this business
has been disappointing. This holding was sold during the year giving rise to a
gain of £116,000 compared to the written down value of the investment.
Dividends
In view of the difficult trading climate, the Board is proposing a final
dividend payment of 2.2p, making a total dividend for the full year of 4.1p
compared to 8.2p in 2005, an overall decrease of 50%.
James Cropper Speciality Papers ('Speciality Papers')
The operating profit of Speciality Papers fell from £1,787,000 to a loss of
£247,000 over the year. Sales were down by 3.6%.
The financial results amply demonstrate an extremely difficult year. Subdued
markets combined with very significant cost increases, particularly in the
second half, had a dramatic impact on profitability. The scale of cost increases
relating to energy, effluent charges and pulp, totalling in excess of £2.5m
compared to the previous year, were such that initiatives to mitigate their
impact were only partially successful during the year. Although price increases
were achieved, the competitive nature of both UK and export markets limited the
full recovery of the dramatic increase in the cost base.
Despite these subdued markets however, steady progress was made in developing
new business opportunities in the UK and export markets.
Speciality Papers' prime source of energy is natural gas. Increasing unit costs,
driven by falling North Sea production, low UK storage capacity, major
distortions in the European natural gas market and international events, had a
significant impact on profitability in the year. Expenditure on gas totalled
£3.2m for the year against £2.0m in the previous year, an increase of 60% with
unit costs averaging 50p per therm for the 12 months. The average cost of
natural gas in the first half was 30p per therm. However prices climbed
dramatically during the course of November to peak at an average of 82p per
therm in December 2005. After falling in January and February 2006, prices again
climbed in March 2006 averaging 75p per therm for the month.
continued...
-4-
Although the € was relatively stable against £Sterling throughout the year, the
US$ fluctuated against both currencies. This affected the relative prices of
Northern Bleached Softwood Kraft ('NBSK') pulp, the market benchmark priced in
US$s and hardwoods priced in €. NBSK opened the financial year at US$645 per
tonne and fell to US$585 per tonne by the end of September 2005. Thereafter the
cost of NBSK progressively increased to US$630 per tonne at the end of the
financial year. In the second half of the year a similar pattern emerged for €
priced hardwoods. Pulp costs in the year as a whole, were over £0.8m higher than
in the previous 12 months.
In recent years, Speciality Papers has been subjected to significant increases
in the cost of waste water treatment by our local water services utility
company. OfWat, the UK water regulator, has granted these increases to allow the
utility company to raise revenue to fund general investment. The increases,
which do not relate to the actual cost of treatment, have been imposed on users
on a mandatory basis. The cost of water treatment charges rose by 19% in the
financial year to £830,000.
During the year an automated reel and sheet packaging line was commissioned.
This £1,000,000 investment characterises the innovative technical solutions
required by the business to maintain flexibility whilst improving throughput,
product presentation and productivity.
The Paper Mill Shop
Despite an impressive growth record over recent years, The Paper Mill Shop was
not immune to the general slowdown in the retail economy during the course of
the financial year. Turnover was £6,159,000, up 18% on the previous year, with
five new outlets opened in Mansfield, Hatfield, Portsmouth, Fleetwood and
Braintree, taking the number of outlets to 23 across the UK. However operating
profit was £241,000 compared to £370,000 in the previous year. Like-for-like
sales were down by 3.7%. During the course of the previous year warehousing and
distribution activities were relocated to a larger facility in order to manage
the expansion of this business. The full year cost effect of this move was
therefore felt in the financial year.
Technical Fibre Products ('TFP')
Operating profit for the year was £777,000 against £521,000 with turnover up
8.7% on the previous year at £6,700,000. TFP's sales in the first six months
were broadly in line with the same period last year. Sales moved ahead of the
comparable period in the second half year. This reflected growth in sales of
higher margin products and a modest strengthening of the US$. Sales into the US
market grew by 16% in £Sterling terms and by 11% in US$ terms. Growth was
largely attributable to composite materials containing metal-coated carbon
fibres. The majority of these fibres are now supplied by Electro Fiber
Technologies LLC ('EFT'), the joint venture company in which TFP has a 50%
share. EFT incurred a small loss in the period. At the average exchange rate for
the year, sales to the US market represented approximately 44% of TFP's turnover
in £Sterling terms.
James Cropper Converting ('Converting')
Converting's turnover fell by 4.2% to £10,887,000 while operating profit
declined from £385,000 to £62,000. The strengthening of the US$ eased margin
pressure on mountboard sales to the USA by Converting. However sales of
displayboard have been lower than the high levels seen last year as a result of
reduced activity in the retail sector. Nevertheless the Division continued to
maintain its position as the leading UK manufacturer of display board. Planned
investment and product rationalisation over the coming months will allow the
decommissioning of older equipment with significant increases in capability,
output and productivity of the remaining machines. Converting's reported profit
is after a deduction of £250,000 relating to accelerated depreciation
attributable to equipment due to be decommissioned.
continued...
-5-
Pensions and International Accounting Standard 19 ('IAS 19')
Actual future service pension contributions paid in the period by the Group to
its two final salary schemes in accordance with the actuaries' recommendations,
resulting from their latest 'on-going' valuations, were £1,028,000. Under IAS 19
the charge against profit in the year was £1,506,000, which was £478,000 in
excess of the future service contributions that were actually required. In
addition, contributions totalling £914,000 were paid to the two schemes in
respect of their past service deficits brought forward.
Environment
I am pleased to report that Speciality Papers has recently gained dual
certification to FSC (Forest Stewardship Council) and PEFC (Programme for the
Endorsement of Forest Certification) standards. This development enables
Speciality Papers to satisfy the increasing demand from major customers and end
consumers for creditable certification of the source of fibre used in the
products they purchase.
Outlook
The three manufacturing subsidiaries will continue their drive to grow sales of
higher margin products, while developing and implementing plans to improve
profitability through operational efficiencies and business optimisation.
Cash management is under firm control in order to conserve resources. Investment
over the next two years will be prioritised on projects to minimise energy
costs, improve efficiencies and reduce our dependence on external waste water
treatment.
The recent weakening of the US$ against £Sterling and the € is expected to have
a broadly neutral effect on the Group overall resulting from our internal
currency matching policy.
The outlook for Speciality Papers will remain difficult for the foreseeable
future given the volatile nature of energy markets. Global pulp inventories
continue to decline, owing to strong demand and reduced pulp production, mostly
resulting from closures in North America. As a consequence pulp is expected to
advance on an upward trend in the current financial year. It should therefore be
anticipated that the profitability of Speciality Papers will deteriorate further
in the short term.
I am encouraged by the recent improvement in the performance of Technical Fibre
Products. An emerging portfolio of new product developments combined with a
well-managed cost base provides confidence that this improvement will continue
despite the recent weakening of the US$.
I anticipate that Converting will reverse its decline in the coming financial
year.
Despite the current slow down in consumer spending across the retail sector
development of The Paper Mill Shop brand will progress through new routes to
market.
I am very disappointed that it has been necessary to reduce this year's final
dividend payment. In due course management plans, backed by the Board's firm
resolve, will return the Group to acceptable levels of profitability, therefore
enabling our progressive dividend policy to be restored.
-6-
James Cropper PLC
Preliminary Results
Group Profit and Loss Account
for the period ended 1 April 2006
2006 2005
£'000 £'000
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Continuing operations
Turnover 64,201 64,568
Other income 247 235
Changes in inventories of finished goods and work in
progress 210 1
Raw materials and consumables used (27,720) (27,500)
Energy costs (4,139) (2,696)
Employee benefit costs (16,906) (16,316)
Depreciation and amortisation (3,715) (3,498)
Other expenses (11,709) (12,154)
Profit on sale of trade investment 116 -
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Operating profit 585 2,640
Interest expense (888) (823)
Interest income 263 136
Share of post tax loss from joint ventures (89) (114)
Amounts written off investments - (200)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(Loss)/profit before tax (129) 1,639
Taxation 27 (584)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(Loss)/profit for the period attributable to equity
holders of the company (102) 1,055
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(Loss)/earnings per share expressed in pence per share
- Basic (1.2p) 12.6p
- Diluted (1.2p) 12.6p
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dividends per share expressed in pence per share
- 2006 interim dividend paid 1.9p 1.9p
- 2006 final dividend proposed 2.2p 6.3p
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-7-
James Cropper PLC
Preliminary Results
Balance Sheets at 1 April 2006
Group Company
2006 2005 2006 2005
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Assets
Non-current assets
Intangible assets 1,316 1,292 1,316 1,292
Property, plant and equipment 23,763 24,613 1,295 1,254
Investment in subsidiaries - - 7,350 7,350
Investments in joint ventures 77 83 - -
Financial assets
- Trade investments - 195 - 195
Deferred tax assets 3,095 3,212 2,938 3,212
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
28,251 29,395 12,899 13,303
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Current assets
Inventories 8,267 7,663 - -
Trade and other receivables 13,399 13,205 28,839 26,830
Financial assets
- Derivative financial instruments 2 - 2 -
Cash and cash equivalents 1,762 88 1,087 7
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
23,430 20,956 29,928 26,837
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Liabilities
Current liabilities
Trade and other payables (7,727) (6,785) (4,516) (1,664)
Financial liabilities
- Borrowings (2,244) (1,890) (2,244) (3,121)
- Derivative financial instruments - (7) - (7)
Current tax liabilities (465) (489) (104) (227)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(10,436) (9,171) (6,864) (5,019)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net current assets 12,994 11,785 23,064 21,818
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Non-current liabilities
Financial liabilities
- Borrowings (8,113) (6,548) (8,113) (6,548)
Retirement benefit liabilities (10,315) (10,707) (10,315) (10,707)
Deferred tax liabilities (3,958) (4,289) (401) (621)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(22,386) (21,544) (18,829) (17,876)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net assets 18,859 19,636 17,134 17,245
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shareholders' equity
Ordinary share capital 2,090 2,090 2,090 2,090
Share premium 454 454 454 454
Translation reserve 10 (6) - -
Other reserves 61 100 14 23
Retained earnings 16,244 16,998 14,576 14,678
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total shareholders' equity 18,859 19,636 17,134 17,245
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-8-
James Cropper PLC
Preliminary Results
Cash flow statements for the period ended 1 April 2006
Group Company
2006 2005 2006 2005
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash flows from operating activities
Cash generated from/(used by)
operations 3,876 4,378 393 (950)
Interest received 262 125 1,623 1,971
Interest paid (854) (840) (753) (958)
Tax (paid)/received (198) 384 (76) 406
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net cash from operating activities 3,086 4,047 1,187 469
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash flow from investing activities
Investment in joint venture (67) (85) - -
Purchase of intangible assets (206) (277) (206) (277)
Purchase of property, plant and
equipment (2,683) (2,951) (214) (78)
Proceeds from sale of trade investment 311 - 311 -
Proceeds from sale of property, plant
and equipment - 5 - -
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net cash used in investing activities (2,645) (3,308) (109) (355)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash flows from financing activities
Net proceeds from issue of new bank
loan 4,000 1,600 4,000 1,600
Finance lease capital payments (96) (265) - -
Repayment of borrowings (1,843) (1,948) (1,843) (1,948)
Dividends paid to shareholders (686) (652) (686) (652)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net cash generated from/(used in)
financing activities 1,375 (1,265) 1,471 (1,000)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net increase/(decrease) in cash and
cash equivalents 1,816 (526) 2,549 (886)
Cash and cash equivalents at the start
of the period (54) 472 (1,462) (576)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash and cash equivalents at the end
of the period 1,762 (54) 1,087 (1,462)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash and cash equivalents consists of:
Cash at bank and in hand 1,762 88 1,087 7
Overdrafts included in borrowings - (142) - (1,469)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1,762 (54) 1,087 (1,462)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-9-
James Cropper PLC
Preliminary Results
Statements of recognised income and expense for the period ended 1 April 2006
Group Company
2006 2005 2006 2005
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
(Loss)/profit for the financial period (102) 1,055 580 394
Currency translation differences on foreign
currency investment 16 (6) - -
Retirement benefit liabilities - actuarial
(losses)/gains (44) 2,221 (44) 2,221
Deferred tax on actuarial (losses)/gains on
retirement benefit liabilities 13 (666) 13 (666)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total recognised (expense)/income for the
period (117) 2,604 549 1,949
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pensions
IAS 19 requires that actuaries calculate the assets and liabilities of
companies' pension schemes based on values and interest rates at their annual
balance sheet date. Surpluses or deficits revealed by these valuations are
included on the sponsoring company's balance sheets, either directly against
Reserves or via the Profit and Loss Account. Under IAS 19 pension scheme
liabilities are measured on an actuarial basis using the projected unit method.
Pension liabilities are discounted at the current rate of return on an AA rated
quality corporate bond of equivalent currency and term. The pension scheme
assets are measured at fair value at the Balance Sheet date. The net of these
two figures gives the scheme surplus or deficit. As market values of the scheme
assets and the discount factors applied to the scheme liabilities will
fluctuate, this method of valuation will often lead to large variations in the
'pension balance' year on year.
IAS 19 regards a sponsoring company and its pension schemes as a single
accounting entity rather than two or more separate legal entities. The actuarial
valuation is the starting point for the creation of the IAS 19 accounting
entity. The valuation determines the net position of a pension scheme, i.e. the
difference between its assets and liabilities. On the introduction of IAS 19 the
net position, surplus or deficit, is brought onto the sponsoring company's
Balance Sheet such that Reserves are immediately adjusted by the net position
reduced by deferred tax. This obviously results in either an increase or
decrease in the net asset value of the sponsoring company. Upon valuation at
subsequent year-ends the movement in value from the previous valuation is
expressed in the following component parts:
Profit and Loss Account
Operating costs
•Current service charge, being the cost of benefits earned in the current
period shown net of employees' contributions.
•Past service costs, being the costs of benefit improvements.
•Curtailment and settlement costs.
Finance costs, being the net of
•Expected return on pension scheme assets
•Interest cost on the accrued pension scheme liabilities
Statement of Total Recognised Gains and Losses
•Actuarial gains and losses arising from variances against previous
actuarial assumptions.
-10-
James Cropper PLC
Preliminary Results
The above items are offset in the year-to-year movement by actual contributions
paid by the employer in the period. The following table shows the results of the
IAS 19 valuations.
2006 2005
IAS19 Deficit £'000 £'000
Current Service Charge (1,392) (1,551)
Finance costs (114) (330)
Future service contributions paid 1,028 1,128
-----------------------
Net impact on Profit and Loss Account (478) (753)
Past service deficit contributions paid 914 1,600
Actuarial gains or losses (44) 2,221
Opening deficit (10,707) (13,775)
-----------------------
Closing deficit (10,315) (10,707)
Deferred Taxation @ 30% 3,095 3,212
-----------------------
Net - Deficit (7,221) (7,495)
-----------------------
Actual future service pension contributions paid in the period by the Group to
its two final salary schemes in accordance with the actuaries' recommendations,
resulting from their latest 'on-going' valuations, were £1,028,000. Under IAS 19
the charge against profit in the year was £1,506,000, which was £478,000 in
excess of the future service contributions that were actually required.
2006 2005
Profit before Tax £'000 £'000
As reported (129) 1,639
Current Service Charge (1,392) (1,551)
Finance costs (114) (330)
------------------------
(1,506) (1,881)
Future service contributions paid 1,028 1,128
------------------------
Net pension adjustment (478) (753)
------------------------
Trading profit 349 2,392
------------------------
-11-
James Cropper PLC
Preliminary Results
For the year ended 1 April 2006
1. Basic earnings per share have been calculated on the loss after
taxation of £102,000 (2005: profit £1,055,000) divided by the weighted average
number of Ordinary shares in issue during the period of 8,359,114 (2005:
8,359,114).
2. The dividend will, if approved, be paid on 11 August 2006 to all
shareholders on the Register on 21 July 2006.
3. The financial information set out above does not constitute the
statutory accounts for the years ended 1 April 2006 and 2 April 2005. Statutory
accounts for 2005 have been delivered to the Registrar of Companies and those
for 2006 will be delivered following the Company's Annual General Meeting. The
auditors have reported on these accounts, their reports were unqualified and did
not contain statements under section 237 (2) or (3) of the Companies Act 1985.
4. The Annual Report and Accounts for 2006 will be posted to
shareholders by 12 July 2006 and will also be available on request from the
Company's registered office, Burneside Mills, Kendal, Cumbria LA9 6PZ.
5. The Annual General Meeting of the Company will be held at 10.30am
on Thursday 3 August 2006 at the Bryce Institute, Burneside, Kendal, Cumbria
This information is provided by RNS
The company news service from the London Stock Exchange