Final Results - Year Ended 29 February 2000
European Motor Hldgs PLC
27 April 2000
EUROPEAN MOTOR HOLDINGS plc ('EMH')
Preliminary results for the year ended 29 February 2000
Key points:
* Profit before taxation excluding profit on disposal of businesses:
for the year ended 29 February 2000 £7.7 million
for the 12 months ended 31 March 1999 £7.1 million (unaudited)
for the 11 months ended 28 February 1999 £5.3 million
* Gearing reduced from 23% to 16%
* Earnings per share 9.6 pence
* Dividend total of 6.1 pence per share
* Uncertainty surrounding new car pricing continues
Commenting on these results, chief executive Richard Palmer said:
'I believe that the figures for this year demonstrate an excellent
achievement. Whilst the results for the second half were not as robust as
those for the first, it was nevertheless a very good performance in the
difficult conditions that prevailed in the period. We have managed to perform
well in these circumstances because of the strength of the brands that your
Board has chosen to represent, the excellent relationships between our
dealerships and their customers, and strong management. In March 2000, our
Motor Retail Division was more profitable than in the same month last year,
notwithstanding the uncertainties surrounding new car pricing and the
consequential impact on new car volumes and margins. However, since 10 April,
when the report of the Competition Commission was published, sales of new cars
have slowed down further because customers appear to be convinced that new car
prices will be reduced. If manufacturers do reduce prices, I believe that we
can anticipate an improved outcome for the year ahead.'
Enquiries:
Richard Palmer Chief Executive
Ann Wilson Finance Director
Morning Biddick Associates 020 7377 6677
Afternoon European Motor Holdings plc 020 8961 2525
Press enquiries Biddick Associates 020 7377 6677
EUROPEAN MOTOR HOLDINGS plc ('EMH')
Preliminary results for the year ended 29 February 2000
Chief Executive's statement
Set out below are the summarised results for the twelve months
ended 29 February 2000, the previous eleven month period ended 28
February 1999 which we reported last year following a change of
year end from March to February, and the unaudited results for the
twelve month period ended 31 March 1999 which provide more
meaningful comparable information.
12 months 12 months 11 months
ended ended ended
29 February 31 March 28 February
2000 1999 1999
(unaudited)
£m £m £m
Turnover 421.8 429.5 376.8
Motor Retail Division operating profit 9.5 9.3 7.3
Motor Services Division operating profit 0.5 0.5 0.5
Group profit before tax excluding profit
on disposal of businesses 7.7 7.1 5.3
Group profit before taxation 7.7 7.8 6.0
Dividend per share 6.1p 6.1p
Your Directors are recommending a final dividend of 3.5 pence per
share, making a total for the year of 6.1 pence. Although the
Group's profit before taxation has increased over the previous
accounting period, that was an eleven month period. With this in
mind, and given the current uncertainty that exists throughout the
sector in respect of new car pricing, we have decided to maintain
the dividend at the same level as for the previous period. This
final dividend will be paid on 1 September 2000 to shareholders on
the register at 4 August.
I believe that these results demonstrate an excellent performance.
There has been much publicity regarding the disparity between
prices in the UK and Europe on certain vehicles and the Competition
Commission's Inquiry into New Cars. As a result, we have
experienced both the importing of vehicles from Europe and the
deferral by a large number of customers of their new car purchases
in anticipation of price reductions. This has had an impact on
both new car volumes and margins in the second half of the
financial year but, whilst the performance in the second half was
not as strong as in the first, it was nevertheless a very good
result in the difficult conditions that prevailed in the period. I
believe that we have managed to perform well in these circumstances
because of the strength of the brands that your Board has chosen to
represent, the excellent relationships between our dealerships and
their customers, and strong management, particularly of used
vehicles.
The report of the Competition Commission on the supply of new cars
in the UK was published on 10 April. Over recent months,
manufacturers have generally improved the level of sales incentives
to enable us to compete more effectively with European prices but
no manufacturer has yet indicated that it intends to reduce prices
following publication of the report. We therefore remain in a
period of uncertainty, which we believe will continue to hamper
sales until price cuts are announced. However, I believe that the
uncertainties which exist will eventually be removed and that when
they are demand for new cars will be very strong.
Following publication of the report, the Government announced
proposed changes in arrangements between dealers and their
suppliers. Once these are finalised, they will need careful study
before any effect can be quantified.
Motor Retail Division
During the year, we have continued our divestment programme of non
core dealerships with the closure of our loss making Nissan and
Citroen businesses in York. These closures, together with the
divestments that we have made previously, have enabled us to spend
more management time concentrating on our core motor retail
businesses. With the exception of one Volkswagen business, none of
the motor dealership facilities in the Group will require a high
level of capital expenditure in the foreseeable future, as the
major investment programme on our existing businesses has now been
completed.
Our performance with our four major motor manufacturing partners is
detailed below.
BMW group
Last year, the BMW group continued to be our largest partner in
turnover terms. Our BMW businesses performed extremely well and
benefited from the first full year of the new '3' series model.
This, together with the introduction of '3' series coup, and M5,
has ensured that we have continued to benefit from the very strong
performance of BMW in the UK market.
As with our other franchises, we place great emphasis on the
results of BMW's customer satisfaction surveys. I am particularly
pleased to report that our BMW businesses continue to perform very
well in these surveys.
The announcement in March that BMW had decided to dispose of its
Rover and Land Rover brands has obviously had no effect on the year
under review. However, in looking forward, irrespective of the
long term future of the Rover and MG brands, I do not foresee a
significant negative effect on EMH as a result of this decision. We
had already agreed with Rover the closure of two of our dealerships
and these closures will go ahead irrespective of the outcome of the
current negotiations between the BMW group and the parties seeking
to acquire the businesses. Whilst the performance of our Rover
businesses has improved significantly over the prior period, the
contribution to profit before taxation is relatively small.
We made a great deal of progress in our Land Rover business during
the year. The various actions that we have taken have resulted in
a significant improvement in performance over the previous period.
In the future, we will report this franchise within our Premier
Automotive group franchises since it has been announced that by the
middle of the year it will be owned by Ford Motor Company.
Volkswagen group
As I reported to you at the interim stage, progress at our
Volkswagen businesses had been hampered by the refurbishment and
building works associated with the Volkswagen Retail Concept
('VRC') work. I am pleased to be able to report that the VRC work
has now been completed at all our Volkswagen sites except
Hammersmith, where we do not yet have a satisfactory planning
consent for the redevelopment, and we are once again making
progress with the Volkswagen franchise. The range of Volkswagen
cars available in their relevant sectors is probably the best in
the UK. In our Southern dealerships, there appears to be more
discussion by customers on European pricing and many Volkswagen
customers appear reluctant to commit to a purchase at present.
When retail customers are convinced that the various pricing issues
are resolved, I am certain that there will be great demand for
Volkswagen products.
Our Audi businesses suffered a downturn in profitability over the
last year that was caused by a number of factors. However, in the
first three months of 2000, our performance has improved year on
year. Both we and Audi have embarked on a series of new
initiatives which we are confident will have a positive effect on
the year ahead.
Daimler Chrysler group
Whilst our Mercedes-Benz vehicle volumes continue to increase, our
profitability remains impaired. In the London area, where our car
franchises are located, there remains intense competition from non
franchised importers who continue to attract customers purely on
price. Many customers are not aware that there are different
warranty terms on imported cars and that, in some cases, they have
a different specification. Our Mercedes-Benz after sales business
continues to grow, and the wider ownership experience of Mercedes
products that has resulted from the expansion of the range will
benefit us greatly when price harmonisation occurs. Our Mercedes-
Benz truck business continues to perform well in a very competitive
market.
Premier Automotive group
We have made very significant progress with our Premier Automotive
group franchises, Jaguar and Volvo.
Substantial improvements in profitability in our Jaguar businesses
have been achieved as a result of the first full year's sales of
the 'S' type, the increasing maturity of our operations resulting
in growth in the customer base and the overall competitiveness of
the Jaguar product in the market. Jaguar's future product plans are
extremely exciting and I believe that we can be very optimistic
about this marque's future and our place within it.
The increase in profitability in our Volvo businesses reported at
the interim stage has continued in the second half, giving rise to
a much improved overall performance compared with the prior period.
We work closely with our manufacturing partner to offer very
competitive prices in the challenging market which exists in the
North East of England. The market area approach is now working
very effectively in this region and we continue to benefit from the
economies and efficiencies that this brings.
Auctions
Our auction businesses made a considerable improvement in their
contribution in the period. These businesses continue to provide a
valuable service to the Group in both their ability to dispose of
trade cars and the invaluable intelligence that they give us on
used car pricing trends.
Internet and e-commerce
EMH remains committed to continuing to develop its Websites
primarily in conjunction with its manufacturer partners. A
reasonable number of Group sales have emanated from enquiries via
our Websites and there is, without doubt, a very important new
distribution channel developing. Whilst our current research
indicates that only a small minority of people will actually
purchase over the Internet, we believe that a very significant
number of potential purchasers will use the Internet to gather
information about prices, specification, availability, financing
options and so on, which will enable them to be better informed
when they decide to purchase.
I believe the current surge in advertising and promoting Internet
car retailing is purely opportunistic and has been caused by the
disparity of pricing that has prevailed with respect to other EU
markets. Even if people do decide to purchase over the Internet,
they will still need to utilise the services of a dealer for
service and repair and for the disposal of their used car. The
type of modern, purpose built facilities that the Group has
invested in, together with high quality, customer friendly staff
and the services they provide, including 'e-commerce', cannot be
replicated by unproven, inexperienced Internet only operators whose
only contact will be via a screen.
Perodua
Our Perodua franchise has continued to make progress. In the year
under review, we have sold 958 Nippas in the UK. The establishment
of this entry level 'niche' franchise in the UK market is an
important building block for the future of the Group. I am
delighted to inform you that we will be launching a new car, which
fits into the segment just above the Nippa, at the British
International Motor Show at the NEC in Birmingham in October. This
additional model, called the 'Kenari', will attract new customers,
and I am certain that it will prove as reliable and durable as the
Nippa and create a further 'niche' in the UK market. Our long term
ambitions for Perodua in the UK remain high and, from the plans
which we have discussed with the manufacturer in Malaysia, we can
be confident of a long and successful partnership with Perodua.
Motor Services Division
The performance of Wilcomatic, the principal operating company
within our Motor Services Division, was much improved over the
previous period. Whilst the reported profitability shows a
marginal improvement, this masks an actual improvement of over
£200,000 which was, unfortunately, counteracted by an exchange
loss. We have historically managed our currency exposure by buying
forward to cover forecast Italian lire requirements, but the very
unusual combination of much lower sales than anticipated and the
exceptionally strong pound, has led to the requirement for a
balance sheet provision of £203,000. This does, however, provide
us with a very competitive exchange rate for the current year.
Many of the contracts to supply machines in the UK market are
handled on a European tender basis. If the equipment manufacturer
loses the tender, as Ceccato did with the BP supply agreement in
1998, our market in the UK is restricted by our inability to supply
to that organisation in the period covered by that tender. This
has had a continued impact on our sales performance.
In order to spread the sales risk away from oil companies and other
national accounts whose budgetary constraints can have a large
influence on their purchases, we have continued to concentrate on
developing our presence in the motor retail sector, which utilises
our machines for washing service customers' cars. This market is
very immature and we believe that we are capable of continuing to
expand into this area in the future.
We are continuing to examine different products and ways of doing
business with our supermarket customers and I hope to be able to
report progress to you during the course of this new year.
The management of Wilcomatic has focused on efficiency and the
delivery of high quality service. This has undoubtedly had a
positive effect on our service business, where we have made a great
deal of progress in the last twelve months. We are confident that
we can maintain our current service base and continue to become
more efficient in our service organisation.
Wilcomatic remains at the forefront of the vehicle washing
equipment industry and it will continue to progress in the year
ahead.
Financial review
Profit on ordinary activities before tax for the year ended 29
February 2000 was £7.7 million compared to £6.0 million in the
previous eleven month accounting period. The results of the two
periods are not directly comparable for several reasons. Firstly,
the year just ended is our first reporting period since the change
in the UK new vehicle registration plate system, and it therefore
contained two plate changes in March and September, whereas the
previous period contained only one plate change in August.
Secondly, we changed our financial year end in 1999 from March to
February because of the changes to the registration system and
therefore the previous accounting period was one of only eleven
months. Finally, the profit for the eleven months ended 28 February
1999 included a profit on disposal of certain businesses of
£724,000.
The Group's effective tax rate in the year ended 29 February 2000
was 32%, which was slightly higher than the 31% rate for the
previous accounting period as most of the Group's tax losses
brought forward from previous years were utilised last year.
During the year, we restructured our borrowings profile. An
overdraft facility of £8 million was repaid, partly by replacing it
with two new loan facilities (on similar terms to the overdraft)
totalling £4 million, and partly by payment from the Group's cash
balances. This is reflected in the Group cash flow statement as a
£4 million cash receipt from borrowings in respect of the new loans
and, within the overall cash increase, a reduction of £8 million in
overdrafts.
The principal elements of our borrowings are loans from finance
houses and leasing obligations in respect of demonstrator vehicles
and certain dealership refurbishments. Most utilised borrowings
are repayable either on demand or within the current calendar year,
although some leases in respect of fixed assets have five or ten
year terms. In addition, the Group has substantial banking
facilities largely unutilised at the balance sheet date.
We invested £3.2 million in capital expenditure (net of disposals)
in the year, principally on our facilities improvement programme.
Working capital has been reduced by £1.4 million during the year.
Payments in respect of taxation, including the first two quarterly
payments under the new payment system for corporation tax, and
dividends totalled £5.2 million. The net result of these cash
flows, together with those of £11.0 million resulting from the
year's operating profit (excluding depreciation), is a decrease in
the Group's net borrowings from £9.6 million to £7.1 million,
giving a gearing ratio at 29 February 2000 of 16% compared with 23%
at the previous year end.
As a result of both lower average interest rates and lower average
borrowings during the year, interest cover excluding new vehicle
stocking interest increased from 6.4 times to 11.1 times whilst
interest cover including new vehicle stocking interest increased
from 4.0 times to 6.1 times.
Outlook
In March 2000, our Motor Retail Division was more profitable than
it was in the same month last year, notwithstanding the
uncertainties surrounding new car pricing. The announcement by the
Secretary of State for Trade and Industry on 10 April with regard
to the Competition Commission's findings in its new car supply
Inquiry has not, as yet, prompted any motor manufacturers to reduce
their prices. Since this announcement, sales of new cars have
slowed down further and our April profitability will suffer as a
result of this. If action is taken by the manufacturers to
convince the public that UK prices are closely aligned with
European prices, I believe that we can anticipate an improved
outcome for the year ending 28 February 2001.
I should like to take this opportunity to thank our advisers and
manufacturer partners for their help and advice during the year,
and also all of our staff for their hard work and continued
commitment.
Richard Palmer
Chief Executive
EUROPEAN MOTOR HOLDINGS plc
STATEMENT OF PRELIMINARY RESULTS
CONSOLIDATED PROFIT & LOSS ACCOUNT
Year ended 11 months ended
29 February 28 February
2000 1999
Notes £'000 £'000
Turnover 1 421,804 376,805
Cost of sales (363,662) (325,639)
--------- ---------
Gross profit 58,142 51,166
Distribution costs (28,710) (26,332)
Administrative expenses (20,993) (18,399)
--------- ---------
Operating profit 2 8,439 6,435
Profit on disposal of businesses 3 - 724
Interest receivable 145 69
Interest payable (908) (1,185)
--------- ---------
Profit on ordinary activities before taxation 7,676 6,043
Tax on profit on ordinary activities (2,494) (1,887)
--------- ---------
Profit on ordinary activities after taxation 5,182 4,156
Equity minority interests (5) (4)
--------- ---------
Profit for the financial period 5,177 4,152
Dividends 4 (3,281) (3,281)
--------- ---------
Retained profit for the financial period 1,896 871
========= =========
Earnings per share 5 9.6 p 7.7 p
========= =========
Dividend per share 4 6.1 p 6.1 p
========= =========
There are no recognised gains or losses other than the profit for
the period as reported above.
CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEET
29 February 28 February
2000 1999
£'000 £'000
Tangible fixed assets 32,814 31,408
--------- ---------
Current assets
Stocks 62,597 64,129
Debtors 17,814 16,611
Cash at bank and in hand 6,390 8,220
--------- ---------
86,801 88,960
Creditors: amounts falling due within one year (73,711) (75,550)
--------- ---------
Net current assets 13,090 13,410
--------- ---------
Total assets less current liabilities 45,904 44,818
Creditors: amounts falling due after more
than one year (671) (1,113)
Provisions for liabilities and charges (698) (722)
Deferred income (946) (1,295)
--------- ---------
43,589 41,688
========= =========
Capital and reserves
Called up share capital 21,513 21,513
Share premium account 26,476 26,476
Profit and loss account (4,409) (6,305)
--------- ---------
Equity shareholders' funds 43,580 41,684
Equity minority interests 9 4
--------- ---------
43,589 41,688
========= =========
Gearing 16 % 23 %
========= =========
CONSOLIDATED CASH FLOW STATEMENT
Year ended 11 months ended
29 February 28 February
2000 1999
£'000 £'000
Net cash inflow from operating activities 12,379 12,604
Returns on investments and servicing of finance (763) (1,116)
Tax paid (1,907) (3,264)
Capital expenditure and financial investment (3,220) (5,967)
Acquisitions and disposals - 2,757
Equity dividends paid (3,281) (3,281)
--------- ---------
Net cash inflow before financing 3,208 1,733
Financing 2,957 (7,793)
--------- ---------
Increase/(decrease) in cash in the period 6,165 (6,060)
========= =========
Reconciliation of operating profit to net cash flow from operating activities
Year ended 11 months ended
29 February 28 February
2000 1999
£'000 £'000
Operating profit 8,439 6,435
Depreciation 2,548 2,613
Profit on sale of tangible fixed assets (12) (12)
Decrease/(increase) in stocks 1,532 (7,800)
(Increase)/decrease in debtors (1,203) 8,207
Increase in creditors 1,075 3,161
--------- ---------
Net cash inflow from operating activities 12,379 12,604
========= =========
Analysis of changes in net debt
At 1 March Cash flow Other non At 29 February
1999 cash changes 2000
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Cash at bank and in hand 8,220 (1,830) - 6,390
Bank overdraft (8,000) 7,995 - (5)
------- ------- ------- -------
220 6,165 - 6,385
Debt due within one year (5,075) (3,326) (21) (8,422)
Debt due after one year (60) - 21 (39)
Finance leases (4,709) 369 (722) (5,062)
-------
(2,957)
------- ------- ------- -------
Total (9,624) 3,208 (722) (7,138)
======= ======= ======= =======
NOTES TO THE STATEMENT OF PRELIMINARY RESULTS
1 Analysis of turnover:
Year ended 11 months ended
29 February 28 February
2000 1999
£'000 £'000
Motor Retail Division 407,056 361,440
Motor Services Division 10,630 11,760
Other Businesses 4,118 3,605
--------- ---------
421,804 376,805
========= =========
2 Operating profit comprises:
Year ended 11 months ended
29 February 28 February
2000 1999
£'000 £'000
Motor Retail Division 9,543 7,339
Motor Services Division 479 473
Other Businesses 157 5
Central costs (1,740) (1,382)
--------- ---------
8,439 6,435
========= =========
3 Profit on disposal of businesses in the eleven months ended 28
February 1999 relates to disposal of five businesses in separate
transactions during the period.
4 The Directors recommend a final dividend of 3.5p (1999, 3.5p) per
share, to be paid on 1 September 2000 to shareholders on the
register at 4 August 2000. An interim dividend of 2.6p (1999,
2.6p) per share was paid during the year, making a total for the
year of 6.1p (1999, 6.1p).
5 The calculation of earnings per share for the year ended 29
February 2000 is based on the profit for the financial period of
£5,177,000 (1999, £4,152,000) and on 53,784,710 (1999,
53,784,710) ordinary shares being the weighted average number of
shares in issue during the period.
6 This preliminary results statement has been prepared on the
basis of the same accounting policies as those set out in the
financial statements for the period ended 28 February 1999 except
for the adoption of FRS 12 (Provisions and Contingencies) and FRS
13 (Derivatives and Other Financial Instruments: Disclosures).
7 This preliminary results statement was approved by the Board of
Directors on 27 April 2000. The above results for the year ended
29 February 2000 have been abridged from the full Group accounts
for that year, which received an unqualified auditors' report and
which will be delivered to the Registrar of Companies shortly.
8 The above results for the period ended 28 February 1999 have been
abridged from the full Group accounts for that period, which
received an unqualified auditors' report and which have been
delivered to the Registrar of Companies.
9 The Annual Report and Financial Statements will be posted to
shareholders as soon as practicable. Further copies will be
available from the company's registered office at Abbey Road, Park
Royal, London NW10 7RY.