Interim Results
Panther Securities PLC
20 September 2006
CHAIRMAN'S STATEMENT
Introduction
I am pleased to report the interim figures for the six months to 30th June 2006.
Pre-tax profits amount to £1,692,000 compared to £2,785,000 for the same period
last year.
Rental income receivable amounted to £3,724,000, as against £4,505,000 for the
previous year's period.
These current year's figures are mainly lower due to the substantial property
sales in earlier years, leaving lower rents in 2006, and there were larger
profits produced on disposals in the period to June 2005.
Finance
The funds received from our property sales have not yet been reinvested and
normally one would expect to receive higher rents than the interest received on
the equivalent cash.
Under these circumstances, we have taken the opportunity to temporarily repay
£8,000,000 off our HSBC loan. This facility still allows us to redraw the funds
when we find suitable investment opportunities. We have also repaid £631,000 of
building society loans as a consequence of the two Scottish property disposals.
Currently, £40,000,000 is available to us under the HSBC facility, part of which
may be drawn without granting further security to the bank. We also had over
£5,500,000 cash at the balance sheet date.
Disposals
In February 2006 we sold two properties at auction; 22 Westburn Street,
Greenock, for £700,000 and 70 High Street, Elgin for £583,000. Together after
costs, they showed a small profit on the December 2005 revaluation. However,
they produced a good profit over the value attributed to them when we originally
acquired Eurocity Properties PLC in November 2002.
In the same month we sold virtually all of our shareholding in Hawtin PLC which
gave us a profit of approximately £480,000. Shareholders may recall that we
acquired 15% of Hawtin PLC at a cost of £1,488,000 in June 2004. A year later,
we started discussions with Hawtin's board with a view to our making an agreed
offer for the company. By November 2005, however, it was apparent and announced
that an agreement could not be reached. Shortly thereafter, we were approached
by a prospective purchaser for our holding, the sale of which was successfully
concluded in February 2006. We purchased Hawtin at 13p per share and sold at
18.25p per share - a most satisfactory result. We retain a residual holding of
623,000 shares.
Acquisitions
In March 2006, we bought a large freehold property for a total cost of £990,000.
It comprises four adjoining shops and upper parts in Queens Road,
Southend-on-Sea, close to the prime retail area and is let in its entirety to
HMV PLC.
In June 2006, we acquired a freehold double shop and upper parts at 182/184
Northdown Road, Cliftonville, Kent. It is close to some of our existing
properties and was acquired at a cost of £410,000. This is let to W H Smith PLC,
who sub-let at a profit rent.
In the same month we acquired the freehold of 25 Guildhall Street, Folkestone,
for approximately £232,000. It is sited between 21/23 and 27 Guildhall Street,
Folkestone, which are properties we have owned for some time. We are currently
carrying out a major rebuild of No 27 to provide 13 residential units in the
upper parts. We are also converting the upper part of No 23 into three
self-contained residential units, although we have not yet decided whether we
will retain and let the units, or sell them off individually.
Investments
Elektron PLC
Our investment in Elektron PLC is performing well, and Elektron recently
announced improved figures and an increased dividend. We were originally
attracted to the transaction because they became our tenants in the large
factory premises in West Molesey, which have considerable long-term potential.
Real Estates Investors PLC
We have a substantial holding in this small AIM Listed property company, and
whilst the current share price is slightly below our book value, we have every
confidence in the management of this company. We have recently sold our
investment at 30 High Street, Paisley to them for £1,100,000, with part payment
of £200,000 by way of ordinary shares, valued at 10p each. This sale is in
excess of the December 2005 Valuation and the profit will be brought into the
full year's figures.
Post Balance Sheet Events
As well as the sale of 30 High Street, Paisley mentioned above, we have also
sold 206/208 Main Street, Barrhead, for £975,000. This sale was also well over
the December 2005 Valuation, and the profit will also be included in the figures
for the year ended 31st December 2006.
Other Events
Ramsgate
In my chairman's statement for last year's accounts, I mentioned the long delays
we experienced in our efforts to obtain planning permission on our site in High
Street, Ramsgate. I am pleased to say that at last we received planning
permission for 20 flats.
MRG Systems Limited
We have long held an investment in MRG Systems Limited, a small high-tech
company, whose founding was financed by us in 1985/6. The company specialises in
teletext systems and, although successful in a very limited field, its turnover
and profits are erratic.
Our original investment of £75,000 now has a value based on its share of its net
assets of £300,000. This is not material in relation to our total net assets.
Recently, however, the founding director and major shareholder expressed a wish
to retire. It was therefore agreed that MRG Systems Limited would purchase his
holding for cancellation out of the cash profits it had produced over the last
few years. There is of course an existing management team to continue running
the business. We are thus left owning 72% of MRG Limited, which becomes a
subsidiary, and means under current accounting rules has to be fully
consolidated in our accounts and this of itself will have an increased tax
charge on profits by virtue of it becoming a subsidiary. This distorts our
turnover and overheads but not the profit for an investment that is very, very
minor to our overall business. Once again, accounting rules distort and tax
rules punish, rather than contribute to an understanding of the accounts.
Dividends
An interim dividend of 6p per share was paid on 27th June 2006 and your board
anticipate recommending a final dividend of not less than 5p per share for the
year ending 31st December 2006.
THE SHAMBLES GETS WORSE..... my interim statement does not allow space for a
full rant on the foolishness of the system we 'hard labour' under, but my
supplement gives two stories from my past property dealings, which may have some
relevance. The first, 'The Tailor who Cried' and the second, 'The Salesman who
Died'.
OUTLOOK
Whilst it is difficult to find attractive investment opportunities for the funds
we have available, our existing portfolio seems to be producing some good
opportunities for improvement in both income and profits in due course. I also
believe there will be more interesting opportunities available to us in the near
future, because of our strong liquidity, which allows us to act quickly and
decisively in situations where vendors' cash requirements mean speed is more
important than the prices being obtained.
ANDREW S PERLOFF
CHAIRMAN'S SUPPLEMENT
The Tailor who Cried
Some 35 years ago, whilst still a young man, I had the task of dealing with a
lease renewal on a shop and upper part in Commercial Road, E1, close to
Limehouse Station. The property had been let on a 21 year full repairing and
insuring lease at a rental fixed throughout the term at £250 per annum (a long
letting at a fixed rent was not unusual at that time) and this had now expired.
I had served a termination notice, offering a new lease, but no reply was
forthcoming. The tenant thus lost his renewal rights. As the tenant had always
paid promptly, I and my partner Malcolm decided to call in to see him and
discuss the matter.
When we called the door was opened by a short (much shorter than me) old (much,
much, older than I then was) Jewish tailor, who had taken the original lease and
apparently lived upstairs. The shop consisted of a bare shop divided in half by
a large cutting table. The walls had numerous paper patterns pinned to them and
it was apparent that the property had not received a visit from a decorator
since the lease commenced. The chalk-dust covered suit worn by our tenant had
certainly seen better days.
After the tailor had regaled us with his gloomy stories of poor trade, the high
cost of materials, and how nobody wanted bespoke suits, I reduced the proposed
rent from £750 pa to £600 pa. He became more mournful, saying he would have to
give up the business and work for someone else doing alterations, so I suggested
that, if he wished, he could vacate the shop and thus stop paying rent, although
he must carry out the schedule of dilapidations for the redecoration of the
premises, which I suggested, would cost no more than £500-£600. This burden was
obviously too much for him to bear, he prostrated himself upon the cutting
table, crying loudly with profuse tears, 'I've no money, I'll go bankrupt, me
and Golda will have to live with her sister, who hates me, my wife will leave
me, I'll have to go to a hostel!'
Malcolm and I were visibly moved by this poor man's terrible plight, and wanting
to help him, I instantly agreed to waive the dilapidations and reluctantly
allowed him to stay on at the same rent until we could re-let. His tears
subsided and we left, with him thanking us, but still sobbing slightly, eyes
bright with tears. Four or five months later, the property was let at £1,000 pa
as a Chinese take-away shop and subsequently sold.
This incident would have all but been forgotten but for the fact that four or
five years later I let a room in Panther House to a small Jewish tailor.
Assuming tailoring to be a small world, I asked him if he knew my former tenant.
'Oh, yes' he replied, 'what a very, very clever man! He works from his home in
Kenton, a beautiful detached freehold that he bought for nothing in 1952. He
makes a wonderful living.'
I could not help but feel relief that his circumstances were so much better than
I had originally feared, but also slightly foolish that I had been so easily
misled. I don't know if he ever won prizes for his tailoring, but he certainly
would have been a contender for a Laurence Olivier Drama Award.
The Salesman who Died
About 10 years after the tailor incident, I came to be letting a shop and upper
part in Upper Street, Islington.
Two Iranian exiles approached us wanting to rent the property for an antique
carpet showroom. They could not supply references, but they explained that they
had escaped from Iran with their stock of carpets, and had been experienced
traders in their own country before being forced to leave.
They offered to pay nine months' rent in advance if we were to let them have a
three month rent free period to fit out the shop. This clinched matters, as
money was tight at that time. They took over the shop and made it into a very
attractive showroom, with carpets draped all round the walls, and stacked on the
floors. We were very pleased with this letting. A year passed, and it was about
time to start collecting rent. From the outset, however, they were bad payers,
and gradually they fell further and further into arrears. They were always
pleasant to speak to, and they always had an excuse. For the sake of expedience,
I shall call them Nazir and Wazir, Wazir appearing to be the main partner.
One day when total arrears had reached six months rent, Malcolm phoned and spoke
to Nazir, saying that we were at the end of our patience, to which Nazir
pleasantly replied that he fully understood, but Wazir signed all cheques and
was at home ill. Malcolm said 'All right, I'll phone in two weeks and hopefully
he will be better and back at work. Malcolm called again after two weeks and was
told Wazir was seriously ill and in hospital, and could not receive visitors at
the moment.
After another month of hearing nothing, Malcolm phoned again and, without
waiting for an excuse, angrily began with, 'We can't wait any longer, we must
have some rent!'
Nazir cut in, 'Wazir died last week!'. That, of course, was a conversation
stopper. After humming and hawing, Malcolm expressed our deepest sympathies, and
said that we would leave matters for another month, to enable Nazir to sort
matters out. Six weeks later, we had heard no more, so we decided to call
unexpectedly at the shop to see if Nazir had 'done a runner'.
When we arrived outside the shop, all appeared exactly as normal, fully stocked
and open for trade. We walked in, and behind an antique desk at the back of the
shop sipping coffee from dainty china coffee cups were Nazir AND Wazir.
We approached Wazir and expressed surprise at his good health and liveliness
after hearing of his death from Nazir. He replied, 'Ah, yes. Thanks be to the
all merciful God. From my deathbed almighty God produced a miraculous recovery
for me. Praise be to God.'
Well, his God wasn't my God, and didn't feel able to produce any miraculous
recovery of our rent arrears. So, in due course, with rather less divine
methods, we managed to repossess and re-let the property.
However, some five years later, about 1988 or '89, at the height of the last
property boom, we sold the property at a miraculous price. So, with hindsight,
perhaps his God did produce a miracle for us - but just took a little longer to
get around to non-believers.
Over the years, I have many examples of people who, to protect their own
financial interests, will tell little 'porky pies'.
You may ask what is the relevance of these stories, and how they relate to my
dissatisfaction with Government - I will explain.
We have three main political parties, all promising to spend huge sums either
greater but never less than their opponents. These carefully thought out
policies are based on the hypothesis that numerous surveys and polls show that
when 'Joe Public' are asked whether they would like Government to spend more
money on Education, the National Health Service, the Police etc, etc, the
questioner nearly always gets the answer - YES!
But the real meaning of that answer is 'YES, but somebody else's money, NOT MY
MONEY'.
If, after answering yes to that question, a person instead was then asked to
make a donation of £250 to their local hospital and a blank cheque produced for
them to sign, I suspect that the local hospital in question would have several
additional emergency cases to deal with.
ANDREW S PERLOFF
Panther Securities P.L.C.
CONSOLIDATED INCOME STATEMENT
for the six months ended 30 June 2006
Six months Six months Year
ended ended ended
30 June 30 June 31 December
2006 2005 2005
£'000 £'000 £'000
Revenue 4,247 4,905 8,498
Cost of sales (1,165) (1,216) (2,035)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gross profit 3,082 3,689 6,463
Other income 54 52 133
Administrative expenses (1,026) (870) (2,061)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2,110 2,871 4,535
Profit on the disposal of
investment properties 171 662 1,607
Movement in fair value of
investment properties 70 0 22,537
Finance costs (1,437) (1,587) (3,281)
Investment income 323 522 877
Profit on the disposal of available
for sale investments (shares) 480 87 87
Profit on sale of subsidiary 0 66 66
Surplus of assets acquired over
consideration given 0 17 17
Share of result from associate (25) 147 104
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Profit before tax 1,692 2,785 26,549
Income tax expense (112) (512) (5,938)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Profit for the period 1,580 2,273 20,611
==============================================================================
Attributable to:
Equity holders of the parent 1,589 2,273 20,611
Minority interest (9) 0 0
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net profit for the period 1,580 2,273 20,611
==============================================================================
Earnings per share
Basic and diluted 9.3p 13.4p 121.3p
==============================================================================
Panther Securities P.L.C.
CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEET
As at 30 June 2006
30 June 30 June 31 December
2006 2005 2005
ASSETS £'000 £'000 £'000
Non-current assets
Property, plant and equipment 20 7 9
Investment property 100,170 79,119 99,881
Goodwill 13 0 0
Interests in Associate 0 407 364
Available for sale investments(shares) 1,779 3,078 3,047
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
101,982 82,611 103,301
Current assets
Inventories 152 0 0
Stock properties 9,770 9,525 9,534
Available for sale investments(shares) 424 423 410
Trade and other receivables 3,547 3,424 3,196
Cash and cash equivalents 5,594 13,715 14,546
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
19,487 27,087 27,686
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total assets 121,469 109,698 130,987
================================================================================
EQUITY AND LIABILITIES
Equity attributable to equity holders of the parent
Capital and reserves
Share capital 4,250 4,250 4,250
Share premium account 2,886 2,886 2,886
Capital redemption reserve 571 571 571
Retained earnings 59,650 42,460 59,925
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
67,357 50,167 67,632
Minority interest 116 0 0
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total equity 67,473 50,167 67,632
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Non-current liabilities
Long-term borrowings 38,009 47,635 46,562
Deferred tax liabilities 10,778 5,566 11,010
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
48,787 53,201 57,572
Current liabilities
Trade and other payables 3,988 3,703 4,350
Short-term borrowings 109 224 187
Current tax payable 1,112 2,403 1,246
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5,209 6,330 5,783
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total liabilities 53,996 59,531 63,355
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total equity and liabilities 121,469 109,698 130,987
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Panther Securities P.L.C.
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF RECOGNISED INCOME AND EXPENDITURE
for the six months ended 30 June 2006
Six months Six months Year
ended ended ended
30 June 30 June 31 December
2006 2005 2005
£'000 £'000 £'000
Movement in fair value of available for
sale investments (shares) taken to
equity 116 (35) (66)
Deferred tax relating to movement in
fair value of
available for sale investments
(shares) taken to equity (110) 12 20
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net income/ (expense) taken
directly to equity 6 (23) (46)
Profit for the period 1,580 2,273 20,611
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total recognised income and expense
for the period 1,586 2,250 20,565
================================================================================
Attributable to:
Equity holders of the parent 1,595 2,250 20,565
Minority interest (9) 0 0
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1,586 2,250 20,565
================================================================================
Panther Securities P.L.C.
CONSOLIDATED CASH FLOW STATEMENT
for the six months ended 30 June 2006
30 June 30 June 31 December
2006 2005 2005
£'000 £'000 £'000
Cash flows from operating activities
Profit before interest, investment
income and tax 2,110 2,871 4,535
Add: Depreciation charges for the year 3 3 9
Less: Provision against available for
sale investments (shares) - current
assets (13) 0 13
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Profit before working capital change 2,100 2,874 4,557
(Increase) / decrease in stock
properties (189) 230 221
(Increase) / decrease in receivables (192) 839 1,067
Increase / (decrease) in payables (636) 25 328
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash generated from operations 1,083 3,968 6,173
Interest paid (1,437) (1,754) (3,105)
Income tax paid (479) (765) (1,896)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net cash from operating activities (833) 1,449 1,172
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash from investing activities
Purchase of plant and equipment (3) (1) (9)
Purchase of investment properties (1,516) (282) (632)
Purchase of available for sale
investments (shares) - non current assets 0 (100) (100)
Purchase of available for sale
investments (shares) - current assets (1) (7) (7)
Investment in subsidiaries 0 (76) (76)
Acquisition of subsidiary - cash and
cash equivalents acquired 361 0 0
Proceeds from disposal of subsidiary 0 66 66
Proceeds from sale of investment
properties 1,469 9,637 12,707
Proceeds from disposal of available for
sale investments (shares) - non current
assets 1,749 399 399
Dividend income received 8 7 37
Interest income received 315 516 840
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2,382 10,159 13,225
Cash from financing activities
New loans net of repayments (8,631) (11,276) (12,384)
Dividends paid (1,870) (1,954) (2,804)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(10,501) (13,230) (15,188)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net (decrease) in cash and cash
equivalents (8,952) (1,622) (791)
Cash and cash equivalents at the
beginning of period 14,546 15,337 15,337
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash and cash equivalents at the end of
period 5,594 13,715 14,546
================================================================================
Panther Securities P.L.C.
NOTES TO THE INTERIM FINANCIAL REPORT
For the six months ended 30 June 2006
1. Basis of preparation of accounts
The results for the year ended 31 December 2005 have been audited whilst the
results for the six months ended 30 June 2005 and 30 June 2006 are un-audited.
The interim report is un-audited and does not constitute statutory accounts as
defined in section 240 of the Companies Act 1985. The statutory accounts for the
year ended 31 December 2005 have been delivered to the Registrar of Companies.
The auditors' opinion on these accounts was unqualified and did not contain a
statement made under s237(2) or s237(3) of the Companies Act 1985. Copies of the
report are available from the address shown in note 8.
There is no material seasonality associated with the group's activities.
To the best of the Directors' knowledge, the half yearly interim financial
report gives a true and fair view of the assets, liabilities, financial position
and profit or loss of the entity and were approved by the board on 11 September
2006.
The Interim figures are prepared on the basis of the accounting policies set out
in the last annual report to 31 December 2005.
2. Taxation
The charge for taxation comprises the following:
30 June 30 June 31 December
2006 2005 2005
£'000 £'000 £'000
Current period UK corporation tax 455 2,060 2,242
Prior period UK corporation tax 0 29 (180)
Current period deferred tax (343) (1,577) 3,876
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
112 512 5,938
================================================================================
The taxation charge is calculated by applying the Directors' best estimate of
the annual effective tax rate to the profit for the period.
3. Dividends
Amounts recognised as distributions to equity holders in the period:
30 June 30 June 31 December
2006 2005 2005
£'000 £'000 £'000
Final dividend for the year ended 31
December 2005 of 5p (2004 - 4p) per share 850 680 680
*Special interim dividend for the year ended
31 December 2005 of 10p per share 0 1,274 1,274
Interim dividend for the year ended 31
December 2006 of 6p (2005 - 5p) per share 1,020 0 850
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1,870 1,954 2,804
================================================================================
*A S Perloff waived his personal entitlement to the special 10p dividend for the
year ended 31 December 2005.
The Directors anticipate recommending a final dividend of not less than 5p per
share for the year ended 31 December 2006.
4. Earnings per ordinary share (basic and diluted)
The calculation of earnings per ordinary share is based on earnings, after
minority interests, of £1,589,000 (30 June 2005 - £2,273,000 and 31 December
2005 - £20,611,000) and on 16,998,151 (30 June 2005 and 31 December 2005 -
16,998,151) ordinary shares being the weighted average number of ordinary shares
in issue throughout the six months ended 30 June 2006.
5. Net assets per share
30 June 30 June 31 December
2006 2005 2005
Net assets per share 396p 295p 398p
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The calculation of net asset per ordinary share is based on the equity
attributable to share holders of the equity in the parent company, and on
16,998,151 (30 June 2005 and 31 December 2005 - 16,998,151) ordinary shares
being the weighted average number of ordinary shares in issue throughout the six
months ended 30 June 2006.
6. Investment Properties
30 June 30 June 31 December
2006 2005 2005
£'000 £'000 £'000
Fair value of investment property
At 1 January 99,881 87,812 87,812
Additions 1,516 282 632
Disposals (1,297) (8,975) (11,100)
Revaluation increase 70 0 22,537
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
100,170 79,119 99,881
================================================================================
7. Retained earnings
30 June 30 June 31 December
2006 2005 2005
£'000 £'000 £'000
At 1 January 59,925 42,164 42,164
Profit for the period 1,589 2,273 20,611
Movement in fair value of available for sale
investments (shares) taken to equity 116 (35) (66)
Deferred tax relating to movement in fair
value of available for sale investments
(shares) taken to equity (110) 12 20
Dividends paid (1,870) (1,954) (2,804)
59,650 42,460 59,925
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
8. Copies of this report are to be sent to all shareholders and are available
from the Company's registered office at Panther House, 38 Mount Pleasant, London
WC1X 0AP.
This information is provided by RNS
The company news service from the London Stock Exchange